What do you think?
Rate this book
De vintagewinkel
Amanda Rosenbloom, eigenares van kledingboetiek Astor Place Vintage, krijgt van een oude dame een grote kist vol kleding aangeboden. Een routineklus, zo lijkt. Tot ze een ingenaaid dagboek vindt dat het leven onthult van Olive Westcott, een jonge vrouw die in 1907 vanuit de provincie naar New York verhuisde en ervan droomde kledinginkoper bij een groot warenhuis te worden. Naarmate Amanda meer leest over Olive, ontdekt ze dat haar leven en dat van Olive veel meer met elkaar verweven zijn dan ze had kunnen denken.
Met De vintagewinkel schetst Stephanie Lehmann een hartverwarmend boek geschreven dat je laat wegdromen naar het New York van 100 jaar terug, waarin ze een vooruitstrevende jonge vrouw portretteert, die tegen de normen en waarden van haar tijd durfde in te gaan.
Met De vintagewinkel schetst Stephanie Lehmann een hartverwarmend boek geschreven dat je laat wegdromen naar het New York van 100 jaar terug, waarin ze een vooruitstrevende jonge vrouw portretteert, die tegen de normen en waarden van haar tijd durfde in te gaan.
440 pages, Paperback
First published June 1, 2013
84 people are currently reading
4700 people want to read
About the author
Stephanie Lehmann
13 books77 followersMy novels are The Art of Undressing, Thoughts While Having Sex, Are you in the Mood?, and You Could Do Better. They aren't as sexy as they sound, which could be good or bad depending on your point of view.
My new novel is Astor Place Vintage, and that will be published by Simon and Schuster in 2013. It's about a woman who works in a department store in 1907 Manhattan and a woman who owns a vintage clothing store on the Lower East Side in 2007.
I'm currently building a website for the book at http://www.AstorPlaceVintage.com with lots of photographs and historical information I wasn't able to use for the novel but loved to learn about.
My new novel is Astor Place Vintage, and that will be published by Simon and Schuster in 2013. It's about a woman who works in a department store in 1907 Manhattan and a woman who owns a vintage clothing store on the Lower East Side in 2007.
I'm currently building a website for the book at http://www.AstorPlaceVintage.com with lots of photographs and historical information I wasn't able to use for the novel but loved to learn about.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 543 reviews
January 10, 2014
Ugh. Where to begin with this one? I was actually really looking forward to reading Astor Place Vintage. I thought the idea of a woman being connected to history through the merchandise in her vintage clothing store seemed pretty cool and unique. This was one I just couldn’t wait till Christmas to ask for, so I bit the bullet and ordered it in August. All the banners and ads for it on Goodreads probably added to my sense of excitement and urgency.
The problem is, this book was, despite all my enthusiasm, hard to dredge through. It was seriously painful at times. Here’s my list of Pros and Cons for this book:
Pros:
1.) I finished it. More than I can say for the Last Summer, by Judith Kinghorn
2.) Some of the historical details were interesting. Stephanie Lehmann obviously did extensive research.
3.) The ending came together neatly and tied up loose ends with both storylines.
Cons:
1.) I didn’t like any of the characters. Seriously. I had no pity for stupid Amanda, who was bitching and moaning about how she has “wasted her thirties” on a married man. He is MARRIED. You are the OTHER WOMAN. He will NEVER LEAVE HIS WIFE FOR YOU. And the fact that she allowed for him to pay for her expenses and jewelry and such came across as very “kept woman” and hookerish. And Olive I had trouble connecting with as well. She was the now-stereotypical historical book character who is only interested in a Career, Not Marriage. She was very awkward with her beliefs. The worst part is, even none of the secondary characters did anything for me.
2.) Insert Wacky Best Friend Who Is Into Unconventional Sciences/Spirituality Here. So sick of that cliché, too.
3.) I HATE pseudo-fantasy elements in works of otherwise realistic fiction! When Amanda first finds the journal, she starts seeing flashes of colors behind her and feels another presence. I assume the author wanted us to think it was Olive’s ghost? And then the author went over the top and had Amanda suffer from over-the-top, fantastical dreams that were “so real,” which predictably all included Olive. Yawn. (And why was Amanda naked in all of them? That was weird.)
4.) There was information overload in the first half of the book. Above, I did praise the author for doing her research, but I feel like she included TOO MANY DETAILS for the 1906/1907 bits. There was too much frivolous minutiae about the early twentieth century that I felt was inserted by Lehmann saying, “HEY GUYS! GUYS! I DON’T KNOW IF YOU KNOW THIS, BUT THIS PART OF THE STORY TAKES PLACE IN THE PAST! LOOK AT ALL THIS RESEARCH I DID! I FOUND FACTS, GUYS!” And I love historical fiction, but even I felt overwhelmed by all the details. Lehmann really needed to do some serious detail-pruning for Olive’s side of the story.
5.) There was too much about sex. Not even sexy-sex, which might have been fine. There was just way too much about Olive naively wondering about sex, menstruation, conception, “rubber bags,” childbirth, whatever, that it got to be repetitive and boring. I guess the point was to illustrate the how Victorian morals inhibited turn-of-the-century girls like Olive to learn/feel comfortable about their sexuality, but still, this was way too much. It stopped being interesting way early on in the story, but kept getting dragged out throughout the whole thing.
6.) I hate how the author used bipolar disorder as just a catchall "crazy" state of mind that somehow excused Jeff from having an affair, and explained away his wife's irrational behavior without really delving into it properly. It just seemed as if the author tacked on this particular disorder because it's taboo "bad enough" that it totally made everything okay without much explanation. And I found that incredibly tacky.
7.) Meh. I don’t even feel like thinking about this book anymore. I felt a great sense of relief when I finished it, which just isn’t the right emotion. This short list will have to do.
The problem is, this book was, despite all my enthusiasm, hard to dredge through. It was seriously painful at times. Here’s my list of Pros and Cons for this book:
Pros:
1.) I finished it. More than I can say for the Last Summer, by Judith Kinghorn
2.) Some of the historical details were interesting. Stephanie Lehmann obviously did extensive research.
3.) The ending came together neatly and tied up loose ends with both storylines.
Cons:
1.) I didn’t like any of the characters. Seriously. I had no pity for stupid Amanda, who was bitching and moaning about how she has “wasted her thirties” on a married man. He is MARRIED. You are the OTHER WOMAN. He will NEVER LEAVE HIS WIFE FOR YOU. And the fact that she allowed for him to pay for her expenses and jewelry and such came across as very “kept woman” and hookerish. And Olive I had trouble connecting with as well. She was the now-stereotypical historical book character who is only interested in a Career, Not Marriage. She was very awkward with her beliefs. The worst part is, even none of the secondary characters did anything for me.
2.) Insert Wacky Best Friend Who Is Into Unconventional Sciences/Spirituality Here. So sick of that cliché, too.
3.) I HATE pseudo-fantasy elements in works of otherwise realistic fiction! When Amanda first finds the journal, she starts seeing flashes of colors behind her and feels another presence. I assume the author wanted us to think it was Olive’s ghost? And then the author went over the top and had Amanda suffer from over-the-top, fantastical dreams that were “so real,” which predictably all included Olive. Yawn. (And why was Amanda naked in all of them? That was weird.)
4.) There was information overload in the first half of the book. Above, I did praise the author for doing her research, but I feel like she included TOO MANY DETAILS for the 1906/1907 bits. There was too much frivolous minutiae about the early twentieth century that I felt was inserted by Lehmann saying, “HEY GUYS! GUYS! I DON’T KNOW IF YOU KNOW THIS, BUT THIS PART OF THE STORY TAKES PLACE IN THE PAST! LOOK AT ALL THIS RESEARCH I DID! I FOUND FACTS, GUYS!” And I love historical fiction, but even I felt overwhelmed by all the details. Lehmann really needed to do some serious detail-pruning for Olive’s side of the story.
5.) There was too much about sex. Not even sexy-sex, which might have been fine. There was just way too much about Olive naively wondering about sex, menstruation, conception, “rubber bags,” childbirth, whatever, that it got to be repetitive and boring. I guess the point was to illustrate the how Victorian morals inhibited turn-of-the-century girls like Olive to learn/feel comfortable about their sexuality, but still, this was way too much. It stopped being interesting way early on in the story, but kept getting dragged out throughout the whole thing.
6.) I hate how the author used bipolar disorder as just a catchall "crazy" state of mind that somehow excused Jeff from having an affair, and explained away his wife's irrational behavior without really delving into it properly. It just seemed as if the author tacked on this particular disorder because it's taboo "bad enough" that it totally made everything okay without much explanation. And I found that incredibly tacky.
7.) Meh. I don’t even feel like thinking about this book anymore. I felt a great sense of relief when I finished it, which just isn’t the right emotion. This short list will have to do.
September 24, 2013
Why Should You Read This Book?
The characters are the most realistic I've read in a long while. Seriously. They make decisions that you don't often see in books. They are real women with realistic dilemmas.
Do you want to be grateful to be a modern woman? Imagine using sanitary napkins connected to belts. Good gravy, no. How about not understanding what the "sex act" actually is with no way to find out? Would you like to rent an apartment or a hotel room? You'd best be accompanied by a man or it's no dice. We've come a long way baby and this novel will remind you of that.
The historical tidbits in this book are spot-on. Ms. Lehmann did her research and she did it well. I was checking Wikipedia like a mad woman to learn even more about the events that were mentioned.
I've read many books that swing back and forth from the present to a time in history. I've never read one that did it this successfully. I'm almost always in a hurry to get back to the past. Not this time. I consider that a small literary miracle.
Astor Place Vintage is an absolute delight. I think you'd agree.
The characters are the most realistic I've read in a long while. Seriously. They make decisions that you don't often see in books. They are real women with realistic dilemmas.
Do you want to be grateful to be a modern woman? Imagine using sanitary napkins connected to belts. Good gravy, no. How about not understanding what the "sex act" actually is with no way to find out? Would you like to rent an apartment or a hotel room? You'd best be accompanied by a man or it's no dice. We've come a long way baby and this novel will remind you of that.
The historical tidbits in this book are spot-on. Ms. Lehmann did her research and she did it well. I was checking Wikipedia like a mad woman to learn even more about the events that were mentioned.
I've read many books that swing back and forth from the present to a time in history. I've never read one that did it this successfully. I'm almost always in a hurry to get back to the past. Not this time. I consider that a small literary miracle.
Astor Place Vintage is an absolute delight. I think you'd agree.
October 27, 2015
I bought an ARC of this book for 50 cents at the SFPL Big Book Fair two years ago, and it's been hanging out in my apartment ever since. It's one of those books that I kept stacking hopefully in my TBR pile (see: entries #4-50 on my to-read shelf) and I finally started skimming it yesterday to see if I should keep it. Answer: NO. The writing is awfully clunky - lots of exposition in the form of "conversation" - and the characters are wooden and unbelievable. 2007 protagonist Amanda would be the most irritating person on the face of this planet if she was actually alive, given that she's a single thirty-nine-year-old woman having an affair with a married man who thinks that having his baby might be a good idea for their relationship (which she texts him at one point using "u" instead of "you," natch). 1907 protagonist Olive is unable to function socially. Her conversations with potential suitors end with put-downs that are supposed to be witty but make her sound like her dialogue was written by a seventh-grader. They're both awful.
The aspects of this book that I enjoyed were the descriptions of New York in 1907. The author is extremely blatant about shoving her research into normal conversations ("Did you hear about that murder case?" "I wondered to myself just what contraception was available." "I love it when a man can undo each hook of my corset.") which makes this a bad novel but interesting to skim. Olive is impoverished about 60 pages in and has to become a Career Woman at a fancy downtown department store. It was fun to read the descriptions of the building and the salesgirls' routines. And it was fun to read about Amanda's store, Astor Place Vintage, specifically the styles from each decade that she buys and the modifications she makes - it made me want to take up sewing. Luckily, I was able to separate those parts from the fact that Amanda is literally the worst businesswoman ever and it's unbelievable that she's able to keep her store afloat even with money from her sleazy married boyfriend. I wouldn't believe Amanda if she tried to break up with me, either. Girl is crazy.
I just saw that Khaled Hosseini has a blurb on the front of the ARC copy that I have that says he found it insightful and charming. That means he either did not read it, or he read this description of Amanda having sex (both possibilities are equally delightful): "I felt like everything everywhere and didn't want it to end."
The aspects of this book that I enjoyed were the descriptions of New York in 1907. The author is extremely blatant about shoving her research into normal conversations ("Did you hear about that murder case?" "I wondered to myself just what contraception was available." "I love it when a man can undo each hook of my corset.") which makes this a bad novel but interesting to skim. Olive is impoverished about 60 pages in and has to become a Career Woman at a fancy downtown department store. It was fun to read the descriptions of the building and the salesgirls' routines. And it was fun to read about Amanda's store, Astor Place Vintage, specifically the styles from each decade that she buys and the modifications she makes - it made me want to take up sewing. Luckily, I was able to separate those parts from the fact that Amanda is literally the worst businesswoman ever and it's unbelievable that she's able to keep her store afloat even with money from her sleazy married boyfriend. I wouldn't believe Amanda if she tried to break up with me, either. Girl is crazy.
I just saw that Khaled Hosseini has a blurb on the front of the ARC copy that I have that says he found it insightful and charming. That means he either did not read it, or he read this description of Amanda having sex (both possibilities are equally delightful): "I felt like everything everywhere and didn't want it to end."
February 15, 2016
Ugh. I picked this book up thinking that the story sounded intriguing and had so much potential. The historical plot was pretty interesting in places, though the clunky writing made it somewhat of an average read. Seeing Olive discover herself and try to follow her calling in life in early 20th century New York made me appreciate all over again just how different life was only 100 years ago.
But then there was the modern-day plot. Not only do readers have to contend with the same clunkiness in the writing, but the modern heroine, Amanda, is one of the most frustrating twits I've come across in literature. As a 39-year-old business owner who has lived independently for quite some time, one might expect her to have some maturity. And that would be your first mistake.
As it turns out, Amanda does have a passion for vintage clothing, but from what I saw in the book, she's disorganized and somewhat lackadaisical in how she runs her business. I also lost respect for her when I found out about her personal life. Amanda has spent the past six years having an affair with a married man. On top of that, pretty much the only reason Amanda's business didn't go under is because said married man pays her an allowance. So yes, Amanda is pretty much a kept woman. Oh, and her segue into the historical story comes when she gets her hands on Olive's diary - which she basically stole from a client.
Amanda drove me up a wall almost from the beginning and normally I would have tossed this book pretty quickly. However, the details of early 20th century New York intrigued me and I kept reading against my better judgment. Hence the second star.
But then there was the modern-day plot. Not only do readers have to contend with the same clunkiness in the writing, but the modern heroine, Amanda, is one of the most frustrating twits I've come across in literature. As a 39-year-old business owner who has lived independently for quite some time, one might expect her to have some maturity. And that would be your first mistake.
As it turns out, Amanda does have a passion for vintage clothing, but from what I saw in the book, she's disorganized and somewhat lackadaisical in how she runs her business. I also lost respect for her when I found out about her personal life. Amanda has spent the past six years having an affair with a married man. On top of that, pretty much the only reason Amanda's business didn't go under is because said married man pays her an allowance. So yes, Amanda is pretty much a kept woman. Oh, and her segue into the historical story comes when she gets her hands on Olive's diary - which she basically stole from a client.
Amanda drove me up a wall almost from the beginning and normally I would have tossed this book pretty quickly. However, the details of early 20th century New York intrigued me and I kept reading against my better judgment. Hence the second star.
September 1, 2013
Astor Place Vintage was a terrific read! It is interesting that I chose to read it immediately after reading "The Girl You Left Behind," by JoJo Moyes. Both books span nearly 100 years in history, traveling back in time to connect the present day with the past. I loved the references in this book to fashion, New York landmarks, and its depiction of life in New York during the early 1900s, before WWI when women were just starting to become empowered. The women who came before us sacrificed so much, and it makes me take time to remember how far we have come in the last 100 years! Lehmann's writing is wonderful, and I enjoyed all of the photos of New York landmarks, it help me to better visualize the story. Her writing reminded me a little bit of Adriana Trigiani, perhaps it is her depiction of Angelina and her Italian immigrant family, that made me think back to "The Shoemaker's Wife," which I read earlier this year. I highly recommend this book for anyone that is interested in history, fashion and the women's movement!
July 15, 2013
This was enthralling. I inhaled it over two days this weekend. I love the way the story moves back and forth between the present and the past.
I couldn't help but wonder if she's not a Maud Hart Lovelace fan. Among the characters in her book were people named Betsy, Joe and Bettina, and one family with the last name of Kelly.
I couldn't help but wonder if she's not a Maud Hart Lovelace fan. Among the characters in her book were people named Betsy, Joe and Bettina, and one family with the last name of Kelly.
Read
September 30, 2021Dnf pg. 65. One of the many books on my shelves that I had tried before & saved to try to get into later. Well it is later and I still cannot get into it-- absolutely no connection to any of the charecters. Time to give it up to my free library....
August 28, 2020
"The city used to tempt me with the promise of rescuing me from my past."
Amanda is devoted to vintage clothing and her shop "Astor Place Vintage". With the rising rents in Manhattan and the troubled economy, she's struggling to keep her little business alive, while she can't end the affair with a man who should be history.
When through a new client she finds a journal, she's happy to escape into the world of Olive Westcott.
Olive can't wait for her future to begin. She's trying to replace repressive ideas with more modern ways of thinking but soon has to deal with her comfortable life turning into an uncertain existance.
Amanda and Olive were both two inspiring young women and I really enjoyed reading about their challenges. Both were interesting characters but I did with both of them a lot. I hated how apologetic Olive got when she was a little insensitive but also treated poorly and I hated how judging Amanda was, when she was not at all in the place.
I instantly loved Amanda's fascinating new client and her grandson,
But these were two young women seperated by a century and while challenges arise for women in every era, the language, the way they talk and how each story is told should differ.
Just like Amanda I loved delving into Olive's world, I loved the portraid of New York City and I liked that past and present collided at some point but the ending came unexpectedly and was too rushed.
All in all I enjoyed reading this but it could have been better.
"Is it brave when you have no choice?"
"I suppose we always have a choice; it's just that it might not be the choice we want."
Amanda is devoted to vintage clothing and her shop "Astor Place Vintage". With the rising rents in Manhattan and the troubled economy, she's struggling to keep her little business alive, while she can't end the affair with a man who should be history.
When through a new client she finds a journal, she's happy to escape into the world of Olive Westcott.
Olive can't wait for her future to begin. She's trying to replace repressive ideas with more modern ways of thinking but soon has to deal with her comfortable life turning into an uncertain existance.
Amanda and Olive were both two inspiring young women and I really enjoyed reading about their challenges. Both were interesting characters but I did with both of them a lot. I hated how apologetic Olive got when she was a little insensitive but also treated poorly and I hated how judging Amanda was, when she was not at all in the place.
I instantly loved Amanda's fascinating new client and her grandson,
But these were two young women seperated by a century and while challenges arise for women in every era, the language, the way they talk and how each story is told should differ.
Just like Amanda I loved delving into Olive's world, I loved the portraid of New York City and I liked that past and present collided at some point but the ending came unexpectedly and was too rushed.
All in all I enjoyed reading this but it could have been better.
"Is it brave when you have no choice?"
"I suppose we always have a choice; it's just that it might not be the choice we want."
January 12, 2024
Heerlijk om als luisterboek op te zetten terwijl je ergens anders mee bezig bent. Makkelijk te volgen, hoge snelheid en mooi uitgewerkte karakters.
May 29, 2013
Amanda Rosenbloom, proprietor of Astor Place Vintage, a vintage clothing store in Manhattan, is intrigued when she finds an old journal sewn into the lining of a fur muff she has bought from an elderly woman, Mrs. Kelly. As she reads the story of Olive Westcott, a young woman in the New York City of 1907, both she and the reader find that the two women have much in common despite the 100 years that separate them. Twenty-year-old Olive is the genteel daughter of the manager of Woolworth’s flagship store in Manhattan. Groomed by the finest of finishing schools for a future as the wife of a wealthy man, Olive learns from her education that “I was far more likely to succeed in managing a business than a household.” When tragedy forces a change in her circumstances, Olive is determined to find success and happiness on her own terms rather than to take the expected route for a young woman of her background and seek the protection of a husband. Her quest introduces her to people like lovely immigrant Angelina Spinelli and her handsome brother Joe and to young women who manage to live on the meager wages paid to women employees by having affluent male “friends” who help cover their living expenses. In the 21st century Amanda encounters an unexpected business reversal and the occasion of her birthday provokes a personal crisis involving her 7-year affair with a married man and the fear that, as she approaches her 40s, a chance for a family of her own may elude her. Their stories merge in a very clever surprise ending.
Olive and Amanda tell their stories in the first person in alternating chapters. This structure worked well, as it highlighted the similarities in the challenges they faced, although I occasionally forgot which woman was speaking at a given time (my weakness, I suspect, not the author’s)! It also showed their differences, e.g., Olive’s virginity and total ignorance of the most basic information about sex versus Amanda’s modern attitudes and experience. Olive and Amanda’s comments about other people did a marvelous job of simultaneously revealing something about both the narrator and the person being commented on, such as when Amanda says about Mrs. Kelly, “Loose skin sagged under her cheekbones and jaw. Red-rimmed, glassy eyes sank deep in the sockets. What was it like to look at yourself in the mirror every day and see you’d turned into an old lady?” (Speaking from experience, Amanda, it ain’t fun.)
Astor Place Vintage is a wonderful book to take on your summer vacation, but it is more than a “beach book”. Certainly there is a well-told story---two stories actually---of women trying to find happiness and fulfillment under difficult circumstances. The writing is vivid and evocative of place and time. In addition, the book could almost serve as a travel guide to New York City buildings, as they were in 1907 and one hundred years later, showing how the city has changed and how it has stayed the same. There are even pictures of the turn-of-the-last-century buildings to enhance the travelogue. A real pleasure, well-done enough that you need not even feel guilty at your enjoyment!
Olive and Amanda tell their stories in the first person in alternating chapters. This structure worked well, as it highlighted the similarities in the challenges they faced, although I occasionally forgot which woman was speaking at a given time (my weakness, I suspect, not the author’s)! It also showed their differences, e.g., Olive’s virginity and total ignorance of the most basic information about sex versus Amanda’s modern attitudes and experience. Olive and Amanda’s comments about other people did a marvelous job of simultaneously revealing something about both the narrator and the person being commented on, such as when Amanda says about Mrs. Kelly, “Loose skin sagged under her cheekbones and jaw. Red-rimmed, glassy eyes sank deep in the sockets. What was it like to look at yourself in the mirror every day and see you’d turned into an old lady?” (Speaking from experience, Amanda, it ain’t fun.)
Astor Place Vintage is a wonderful book to take on your summer vacation, but it is more than a “beach book”. Certainly there is a well-told story---two stories actually---of women trying to find happiness and fulfillment under difficult circumstances. The writing is vivid and evocative of place and time. In addition, the book could almost serve as a travel guide to New York City buildings, as they were in 1907 and one hundred years later, showing how the city has changed and how it has stayed the same. There are even pictures of the turn-of-the-last-century buildings to enhance the travelogue. A real pleasure, well-done enough that you need not even feel guilty at your enjoyment!
July 17, 2013
Astor Place Vintage tells the stories of Amanda, a vintage clothing store owner who has discovered a diary in an antique fur muff, and Olive, the long-ago girl who once hid her diary in the lining of her muff for safekeeping. Amanda happens upon (and steals) Olive’s diary while one a clothing-buying outing for her store and begins to read it.
Amanda is a contemporary New Yorker who owns her own businesses, is afraid she's too old to have children, and evaluates every man she meets for marriageability potential. Olive, her counterpart, is woman from a well-to-do family who finds herself penniless and alone in early 1900's New York City after a family tragedy. Olive soldiers on through sexism, squalor, and seduction in pursuit of her dream: to support herself without depending on a man.
According to the book summary, reading Olive's diary is supposed to teach Amanda valuable lessons about her own life. Olive's life and Amanda's life might have occasionally intersected in subject matter, but Amanda didn't really seem to learn anything beyond some useful history. She does have a major turning point that coincides with when she reads about a major turning point in Olive's life, but Amanda's revelation is the direct result of something she learns from the present, not the past.
I grew to like Olive by the middle of the novel - when she became interestingly self-sufficient and stopped being such a cliché. Amanda was a constant disappointment. She suffers from a woe-is-me, I-wasted-my-youth-on-a-man-who-never-married-me attitude that is infinitely irritating. It's boring, overplayed, and off-putting. Hasn’t fiction had enough 30-somethnig women who want to wallow in their failure to be married? Her inability to escape a long affair with her married lover and attendant despair could have been interesting and humanizing, but it's just not.
The one plot point that really was Olive’s quest for accurate information about contraception in the early 1900’s; I found the variation of misinformation she encountered and the depth of the taboos she challenged fascinating. As a girl who grew up without a mother, Olive had never had anyone explain the facts of life to her. When she’s abruptly thrust into the lower echelons of New York society by her father’s death, these missing facts suddenly become vital rather than just interesting. Sadly, this plot line wasn’t a major focus.
This book is tied together by a number of unsurprising coincidences that shock the characters and bore the reader. Overall, this feels like two books that were chopped up and unsuccessfully mashed together. Astor Place Vintage is a fun concept that failed to put its money where its mouth is.
Amanda is a contemporary New Yorker who owns her own businesses, is afraid she's too old to have children, and evaluates every man she meets for marriageability potential. Olive, her counterpart, is woman from a well-to-do family who finds herself penniless and alone in early 1900's New York City after a family tragedy. Olive soldiers on through sexism, squalor, and seduction in pursuit of her dream: to support herself without depending on a man.
According to the book summary, reading Olive's diary is supposed to teach Amanda valuable lessons about her own life. Olive's life and Amanda's life might have occasionally intersected in subject matter, but Amanda didn't really seem to learn anything beyond some useful history. She does have a major turning point that coincides with when she reads about a major turning point in Olive's life, but Amanda's revelation is the direct result of something she learns from the present, not the past.
I grew to like Olive by the middle of the novel - when she became interestingly self-sufficient and stopped being such a cliché. Amanda was a constant disappointment. She suffers from a woe-is-me, I-wasted-my-youth-on-a-man-who-never-married-me attitude that is infinitely irritating. It's boring, overplayed, and off-putting. Hasn’t fiction had enough 30-somethnig women who want to wallow in their failure to be married? Her inability to escape a long affair with her married lover and attendant despair could have been interesting and humanizing, but it's just not.
The one plot point that really was Olive’s quest for accurate information about contraception in the early 1900’s; I found the variation of misinformation she encountered and the depth of the taboos she challenged fascinating. As a girl who grew up without a mother, Olive had never had anyone explain the facts of life to her. When she’s abruptly thrust into the lower echelons of New York society by her father’s death, these missing facts suddenly become vital rather than just interesting. Sadly, this plot line wasn’t a major focus.
This book is tied together by a number of unsurprising coincidences that shock the characters and bore the reader. Overall, this feels like two books that were chopped up and unsuccessfully mashed together. Astor Place Vintage is a fun concept that failed to put its money where its mouth is.
July 12, 2013
3.5 stars!
I really enjoyed reading both POVs and thought it worked very very very well in this novel.
As for the characters, for me, Olive was the true heroine of the book. I completely fell in love with her. She had the perfect mixture of innocence and pluck. Her character and story drew me in almost immediately. Sometimes she made decisions that I thought went against what I thought her character should be, but at the same time I found that compelling and exciting!
Olive was kind of stuck in what I like to call ‘history’s limbo’. She wasn’t a repressed woman of the Victorian era but she wasn’t quite the ‘Modern woman’ of the 1920’s. She was stuck in a very important transition period for women and I thought the author captured that dilemma spectacularly.
I didn’t really care for Amanda. I personally felt like she was way too insecure and almost too pathetic for me to like. She grew on me a more toward the end of the novel but ultimately, for me, it was a little too late. I just couldn’t say that I loved her.
Even though I can’t say that I loved Amanda, I thought she was the most real character in the novel. Olive was perfect as the ideal heroine but Amanda was real. She was in a real dilemma and had to make some real tough choices, I thought that came across well in her character. I think a lot of women can relate to her in some way or another.
One thing that I particularly loved in this novel was how the author incorporated old pictures of New York into the novel. It was fun to see how Manhattan has changed by yet how the past remains immortalized in the future in the form of buildings. I will admit, I love New York City and its rich history and I thought the author captured that same nostalgia and history that Manhattan is so famous for.
To borrow a phrase from Olive….I would have to say this novel is lovely! It was charming and entertaining at the same time. It held my interest and I really enjoyed reading it from beginning to end. No low sports in this novel, it moved along nicely. With likeable characters and an interesting story line, this novel will be sure to entertain readers and fans of historic fiction and chick lit alike!
See my full review here
I really enjoyed reading both POVs and thought it worked very very very well in this novel.
As for the characters, for me, Olive was the true heroine of the book. I completely fell in love with her. She had the perfect mixture of innocence and pluck. Her character and story drew me in almost immediately. Sometimes she made decisions that I thought went against what I thought her character should be, but at the same time I found that compelling and exciting!
Olive was kind of stuck in what I like to call ‘history’s limbo’. She wasn’t a repressed woman of the Victorian era but she wasn’t quite the ‘Modern woman’ of the 1920’s. She was stuck in a very important transition period for women and I thought the author captured that dilemma spectacularly.
I didn’t really care for Amanda. I personally felt like she was way too insecure and almost too pathetic for me to like. She grew on me a more toward the end of the novel but ultimately, for me, it was a little too late. I just couldn’t say that I loved her.
Even though I can’t say that I loved Amanda, I thought she was the most real character in the novel. Olive was perfect as the ideal heroine but Amanda was real. She was in a real dilemma and had to make some real tough choices, I thought that came across well in her character. I think a lot of women can relate to her in some way or another.
One thing that I particularly loved in this novel was how the author incorporated old pictures of New York into the novel. It was fun to see how Manhattan has changed by yet how the past remains immortalized in the future in the form of buildings. I will admit, I love New York City and its rich history and I thought the author captured that same nostalgia and history that Manhattan is so famous for.
To borrow a phrase from Olive….I would have to say this novel is lovely! It was charming and entertaining at the same time. It held my interest and I really enjoyed reading it from beginning to end. No low sports in this novel, it moved along nicely. With likeable characters and an interesting story line, this novel will be sure to entertain readers and fans of historic fiction and chick lit alike!
See my full review here
August 22, 2013
I enjoyed every page of this little gem. The reason I like this book so much is because the characters became like friends. There is a shifting narrative in APV both taking place in New York City. One character is present time, Amanda, who owns a vintage clothing store, and the other is Olive who lives in 1907 New York. With shifting narrative's I often like one over the other but not in this book. Both characters are equally absorbing and interesting and for me became like friends. While I wasn't reading the book, I actually worried about one character or the other from wherever I left off in the book. This is just a mesmerizing read that celebrates women, past and present with their failures, struggles and accomplishments.
The story goes like this: Amanda, picking up some vintage clothing, finds an old diary sewn inside a fur muff when she goes to a New York mansion to pick up some clothing from an old woman. The finding of the diary takes the reader on an adventure with Olive Wescott, a less than typical young woman who longs for more than marriage in a day when men ruled most everything. This adventure is intermingled with Amanda's life and her struggles with career and love and belonging.
I learned a lot about vintage clothing, New York architecture and the department store of the early 1900's as I enjoyed the trials and stories of Olive and Amanda. This is a book to savor this summer. It's a magical book that will transport you to the bustling city of New York today as well as New York 100 years ago. A most excellent read.
I almost forgot to add another thing I thought was cool about this book! There are vintage pictures of New York throughout. I have a vintage picture of the Flat Iron building that I adore hanging on my wall. I love the vintage pictures Stephanie Lehmann added to this book. Seeing the places while you are reading is just a great touch.
The story goes like this: Amanda, picking up some vintage clothing, finds an old diary sewn inside a fur muff when she goes to a New York mansion to pick up some clothing from an old woman. The finding of the diary takes the reader on an adventure with Olive Wescott, a less than typical young woman who longs for more than marriage in a day when men ruled most everything. This adventure is intermingled with Amanda's life and her struggles with career and love and belonging.
I learned a lot about vintage clothing, New York architecture and the department store of the early 1900's as I enjoyed the trials and stories of Olive and Amanda. This is a book to savor this summer. It's a magical book that will transport you to the bustling city of New York today as well as New York 100 years ago. A most excellent read.
I almost forgot to add another thing I thought was cool about this book! There are vintage pictures of New York throughout. I have a vintage picture of the Flat Iron building that I adore hanging on my wall. I love the vintage pictures Stephanie Lehmann added to this book. Seeing the places while you are reading is just a great touch.
April 10, 2019
This book is an old favorite of mine.
Astor Place Vintage is set in both past and present day New York City. In this book you will meet Amanda, a vintage clothing store owner and Olive, who wishes to become a buyer in a department store in the year 1907. The story goes back and forth between both women and their struggles.
Olive has to deal with women rights issues along with a life changing event that will force her to find her voice and strength. Amanda has to deal with her own questionable choice of boyfriend and what does this choice has to do with her past, also her vintage clothing store may go through a change.
Amanda starts to question some of her choices when she finds a journal, written by Olive from 1907, in the pocket of a vintage piece of clothing.
Get a picture of what New York City was like in the beginning of the 1900's, this book actually has pictures circa 1907. Meet Amanda, Olive and their friends. Find out how different but yet similar their lives were.
This author does a superb job of making the stories of these women blend together! I look forward to reading more from Stephanie Lehmann!
This review was originally posted on Fictional Reviewer
Astor Place Vintage is set in both past and present day New York City. In this book you will meet Amanda, a vintage clothing store owner and Olive, who wishes to become a buyer in a department store in the year 1907. The story goes back and forth between both women and their struggles.
Olive has to deal with women rights issues along with a life changing event that will force her to find her voice and strength. Amanda has to deal with her own questionable choice of boyfriend and what does this choice has to do with her past, also her vintage clothing store may go through a change.
Amanda starts to question some of her choices when she finds a journal, written by Olive from 1907, in the pocket of a vintage piece of clothing.
Get a picture of what New York City was like in the beginning of the 1900's, this book actually has pictures circa 1907. Meet Amanda, Olive and their friends. Find out how different but yet similar their lives were.
This author does a superb job of making the stories of these women blend together! I look forward to reading more from Stephanie Lehmann!
This review was originally posted on Fictional Reviewer
June 12, 2013
Imagine living your life as a working young woman in 1907 or in 2007. What would be the same and what would be different? Believe it or not, not much, although as this novel depicts two women from each period run into society’s strictures and mistakes of their own. This is the story of Olive Westcott, a young woman living in the earlier part of the 20th Century. She wants to be a retail seller of clothing in the worst possible way, but her father and business owners will not allow social pressures to make her dream possible. A woman could never go anywhere alone, let alone work without a male reference or supporter. She is up to the fight however, when her father no longer has that ever-present influence in her life. She proves that times are slowly changing by starting at the bottom as a salesgirl at a department store.
How do we know all this? Amanda Rosenbloom, who owns a clothing shop named per this novel’s title, finds Olive’s journal. Amanda is in a bit of a quandary herself. She’s an insomniac dating a married man. She knows her future with him is going nowhere fast but lacks the strength to end it, at least initially. As it turns out, the economy in New York City is changing as well, and Amanda finds herself being evicted so the owner can charge a more exorbitant rent to the next person. After all, New York, both in Amanda and Olive’s time, is prime territory for real estate and business. Amanda will prove to be creative and resourceful in her attempt to save her business, find a better place to live, and seek a satisfying romance.
Tall order for Olive and Amanda, yes; but Stephanie Lehmann offers the reader two females with all their strengths and weaknesses who are all the more likeable because they are so real! Lehmann also offers us through quaint, exciting and painstaking detail a thorough panorama of the architecture, interior designs, fashions in clothing, food, music, and art prominent in both time periods. This is an elegant picture of New York as it evolved over 100 years and a delight to relish equally with the story!
Astor Place Vintage is very finely written and a hugely entertaining read!
How do we know all this? Amanda Rosenbloom, who owns a clothing shop named per this novel’s title, finds Olive’s journal. Amanda is in a bit of a quandary herself. She’s an insomniac dating a married man. She knows her future with him is going nowhere fast but lacks the strength to end it, at least initially. As it turns out, the economy in New York City is changing as well, and Amanda finds herself being evicted so the owner can charge a more exorbitant rent to the next person. After all, New York, both in Amanda and Olive’s time, is prime territory for real estate and business. Amanda will prove to be creative and resourceful in her attempt to save her business, find a better place to live, and seek a satisfying romance.
Tall order for Olive and Amanda, yes; but Stephanie Lehmann offers the reader two females with all their strengths and weaknesses who are all the more likeable because they are so real! Lehmann also offers us through quaint, exciting and painstaking detail a thorough panorama of the architecture, interior designs, fashions in clothing, food, music, and art prominent in both time periods. This is an elegant picture of New York as it evolved over 100 years and a delight to relish equally with the story!
Astor Place Vintage is very finely written and a hugely entertaining read!
July 21, 2013
It’s not bad. It’s not great. It’s just eh. And at 400 pages, I want more than eh.
Astor Place Vintage is the story of two women (Amanda in 2007, Olive in 1907) told in alternating chapters, although be warned there’s no noticeable difference between their two voices. Olive sounds way too much like a modern woman, which is a major pet peeve of mine when reading historical fiction. I could see what Ms. Lehmann wanted to do with Olive, but the character’s arc is fairly flat and predictable. It didn’t go anywhere new or interesting, and the writing isn't strong enough to carry such a well-trod story.
As for Amanda, I don’t know. I wanted to like her but she was so annoying. Again, I liked what Ms. Lehmann attempted to do with the character, but the execution didn’t click.
As for the intertwining story: it kind of worked. I’m more and more jaded to the “two women separated across time but united for some reason that may or may not be clear at the start of the book” genre. Astor Place Vintage didn’t help that fatigue, especially because the connecting threads were shallow and convenient, despite the potential for a deeper, thematic connection between the two women lurking within the pages.
Finally, a warning: I found the feminist angle teeth-grindingly obnoxious. And I say this as someone who proudly identifies as a feminist. All the rah-rah women’s lib was written as hit-readers-over-the-head pronouncements with no finesse or building realizations. If I want the twee sayings and clunky rallying cries about girl power, I’ll check out Twitter. Not recommended.
Astor Place Vintage is the story of two women (Amanda in 2007, Olive in 1907) told in alternating chapters, although be warned there’s no noticeable difference between their two voices. Olive sounds way too much like a modern woman, which is a major pet peeve of mine when reading historical fiction. I could see what Ms. Lehmann wanted to do with Olive, but the character’s arc is fairly flat and predictable. It didn’t go anywhere new or interesting, and the writing isn't strong enough to carry such a well-trod story.
As for Amanda, I don’t know. I wanted to like her but she was so annoying. Again, I liked what Ms. Lehmann attempted to do with the character, but the execution didn’t click.
As for the intertwining story: it kind of worked. I’m more and more jaded to the “two women separated across time but united for some reason that may or may not be clear at the start of the book” genre. Astor Place Vintage didn’t help that fatigue, especially because the connecting threads were shallow and convenient, despite the potential for a deeper, thematic connection between the two women lurking within the pages.
Finally, a warning: I found the feminist angle teeth-grindingly obnoxious. And I say this as someone who proudly identifies as a feminist. All the rah-rah women’s lib was written as hit-readers-over-the-head pronouncements with no finesse or building realizations. If I want the twee sayings and clunky rallying cries about girl power, I’ll check out Twitter. Not recommended.
February 27, 2021
I had the distinct pleasure of reading this book as a pre-read for MainStreet BookEnds in preparation for a visit from the author. First of all Stephanie Lehmann is a really fun person who has obviously researched her work quite intensely and is very passionate about the changing roles of women at the turn of the century. The book itself is an engaging portrait of New York in two times, 1907 and 2007.
The plot switches between both time as two women's lives mirror each other in fun and engaging ways. Olive is a feisty and heroic protagonist is 1907 who must find her own way in the world while facing down the challenges she meets in a patriarchal turn of the century New York. I loved the story of Olive and the old city as well as the window both provide into another time and place for women and their roles in society.
Present day we meet Amanda who is a struggling business owner and NYC resident. A romantic at heart Amanda discovers the story of Olive in a box of old clothes we wants to buy for her vintage shop and is transported and transformed by her journey in another woman's shoes. Amanda is a flawed character but she is utterly relatable and very interesting to get to know. Definitely a great summer read that will have you thinking from the start!
The plot switches between both time as two women's lives mirror each other in fun and engaging ways. Olive is a feisty and heroic protagonist is 1907 who must find her own way in the world while facing down the challenges she meets in a patriarchal turn of the century New York. I loved the story of Olive and the old city as well as the window both provide into another time and place for women and their roles in society.
Present day we meet Amanda who is a struggling business owner and NYC resident. A romantic at heart Amanda discovers the story of Olive in a box of old clothes we wants to buy for her vintage shop and is transported and transformed by her journey in another woman's shoes. Amanda is a flawed character but she is utterly relatable and very interesting to get to know. Definitely a great summer read that will have you thinking from the start!
September 29, 2013
This was a really enjoyable read. First off, this is my neck of the woods and I knew the streets she mentioned, and could easily picture in my head Mad Sq Park, the buildings on the lower east, the basements with the cyclone fenced quadrants for storage, and I had to laugh when she visited the old Siegel-Cooper department store only to find that it's now a TJ Maxx/Bed Bath & Beyond/Marshalls. I've shopped there countless times and wondered about the building! So it was a lovely yarn, knitting together a struggling woman around my age, with the story of a woman struggling against the societal norms and conditions of 1907 New York.
The stories of Olive and Amanda had some moments where there were parallels (the debate of motherhood, money issues, men, etc.) but the story tied together loosely enough that it wasn't overbearing.
I particularly liked the ending and won't spoil it other than to say that it was left open in many ways. I like that sort of ending, because it's more realistic. Life isn't neatly tied up. There are always unanswered questions and it let me imagine Olive walking away from me as she went about her work in the store, and imagine that Amanda will continue her life in a good way too. Good read, indeed.
The stories of Olive and Amanda had some moments where there were parallels (the debate of motherhood, money issues, men, etc.) but the story tied together loosely enough that it wasn't overbearing.
I particularly liked the ending and won't spoil it other than to say that it was left open in many ways. I like that sort of ending, because it's more realistic. Life isn't neatly tied up. There are always unanswered questions and it let me imagine Olive walking away from me as she went about her work in the store, and imagine that Amanda will continue her life in a good way too. Good read, indeed.
August 22, 2013
This story is told in two voices - present day Amanda and early 1900‘s Olive. I fell in love with Olive immediately. Born into a reasonably well to do life, but in a time when women made few of their own decisions, her life takes a dramatic change. Instead of taking the easy way out, she continues to fight for her dreams to be an independent, career focused female. Amanda, on the other hand, did not sit well with me. I felt she did sometimes take the easy way out and did not warm up to her until almost the very end ot the story.
I love when an author writes in such a way that I end having very strong feelings for their characters. I found myself thinking of things I would say to both Olive and Amanda as I read about their journey. I thought Ms. Lehmann did a great job bringing both women to life. She slowly wove the story in and out to a very interesting conclusion. Her writing is detailed and entertaining.
Many thanks to Touchstone, via Netgalley, for allowing me to read this in exchange for an unbiased review.
4.5/5.0
Publish date: June 11, 2013.
I love when an author writes in such a way that I end having very strong feelings for their characters. I found myself thinking of things I would say to both Olive and Amanda as I read about their journey. I thought Ms. Lehmann did a great job bringing both women to life. She slowly wove the story in and out to a very interesting conclusion. Her writing is detailed and entertaining.
Many thanks to Touchstone, via Netgalley, for allowing me to read this in exchange for an unbiased review.
4.5/5.0
Publish date: June 11, 2013.
September 16, 2013
I found Astor Place Vintage at my local library, the parallel plot with two women separated by one hundred plus years intrigued me. I also enjoy stories set in early 20th Century New York City that centered around women and the changing times.
To say that Stephanie Lehmann's novel is a page turner is an understatement. I spent most of my Sunday huddled over this novel finding it impossible to put down until all the threads came together in the final chapter.
Lehmann has a wonderful storytelling gift. She knows how to create twists and knots in her plot, how to create characters that seem more real than the neighbors next door and then she weaves in a bit of supernatural magic. One of her themes revolves around the rights of women, then and now; with Lehmann's deft hand, we never feel like someone is preaching to us or politicizing. Instead we root for the strong women characters who falter at times but then in the end prove themselves as astute businesswomen and women we would want as friends.
To say that Stephanie Lehmann's novel is a page turner is an understatement. I spent most of my Sunday huddled over this novel finding it impossible to put down until all the threads came together in the final chapter.
Lehmann has a wonderful storytelling gift. She knows how to create twists and knots in her plot, how to create characters that seem more real than the neighbors next door and then she weaves in a bit of supernatural magic. One of her themes revolves around the rights of women, then and now; with Lehmann's deft hand, we never feel like someone is preaching to us or politicizing. Instead we root for the strong women characters who falter at times but then in the end prove themselves as astute businesswomen and women we would want as friends.
February 2, 2017
Prachtig boek! Heel mooi met de afwisseling vroeger en heden waarbij in beide levens de normen en waarden sterk naar voren komen. Doordat het verhaal zich in New York afspeelt, is dit voor mij als New York liefhebber een extra +. Interessant om een verhaal te lezen zich afspelend in 1907 en in het boek zijn ook foto's/afbeeldingen uit die tijd opgenomen.
June 25, 2020
Terrible main character in the current story who made *so* many bad decisions. However, the basic storylines were interesting enough to keep me engaged in the story to the end.
July 21, 2019
This book was really interesting, and I love all the historical notes about early 1900's NYC. (Funnily enough, the last book I had finished also talked specifically about McDougal Street and the Village, haha.) The chapters about present-day Amanda were also funny in that, just like the main character in the last book, she was also suffering from insomnia.
Overall, an enjoyable book. And I enjoyed the historical photos that came with each new section/day.
Overall, an enjoyable book. And I enjoyed the historical photos that came with each new section/day.
April 1, 2015
Astor Place Vintage is an example of why I do not totally discount Chick Lit. Chick Lit can be light weight and formulaic -- but so can other genre fiction. I have no problem reading purely for fun and relaxation. It is simply that I am not often in the mood for a standard Chick Lit plot. I am well out of my 'young/youngish & single and frustrated and looking' stage. At this point in my life it is hard for me to relate to story lines about going out with the girls and wearing designer shoes and flirting with the wrong guys. -- Astor Place Vintage was very light on that sort of thing and, much to my delight, much more of an alternative time-line history story.
Amanda Rosenbloom is the contemporary character. At age 38, she has thrown her prime years away on Jeff -- her now married high school sweetheart. Jeff is not happily married. But he is happy enough to stay with Denise and the kids and string Amanda along as the side piece. He's a nice enough guy (for a married man who cheats) -- but we all realize that he is not the right man for Amanda.
Amanda, by the way, is way cool. She runs a vintage clothing shop in Manhattan and loves nothing more than poking around looking for the ghosts of Old New York. I wish she was real and I wish I knew her. I would love her clothing and I would have her deck me out in retro threads. And she is a person who would actually participate enthusiastically in one of my favorite hobbies -- namely driving around the city and becoming obsessed with old buildings and then trying to learn their history. (Ok. So I do this in Cleveland. Not quite New York City level architecture, but we have our unknown gems.)
No really. Amanda does this! I am not just going off on a tangent here:
"Glorious as any monument from ancient Rome, the massive block-long building radiated magnificence despite the fact that Bed Bath & Beyond, T. J. Maxx and Filene's Basement now shared the rent. Wreaths, columns, balconies, and lion heads along the cornice adorned the facade. Bronze columns and lanterns flanked the front doors. Olive, Sadie, and Angelina had used the employee entrance on Eighteenth Street, but still. Here it stood. I had to remind myself that I didn't actually know those women who worked there so many years ago."
"Something up near the roof made my jaw drop. A crest, like a coat-of-arms, engraved with the letters S and C. Siegel-Cooper! I saw more of the same crests evenly spaced along the top. I'd never noticed them even though I'd walked by a zillion times. I couldn't help taking the discovery as a message to me personally. Who else in recent history had observed the inscription of the original owners up there? Who would care? I wanted to sit right down on the curb and sob. The past! Right here in our midst, and we were so utterly oblivious, going about our days worshipping the present, as if the generation of 'now' was the only one that mattered."
This book is packed full of these (to my mind anyway) clever observations from this character who is obsessed with the past. She is sleeping with her high school boyfriend at 38. She owns a vintage clothing store. And she is completely fascinated with a woman who lived 100 years before she did. This woman is Amanda's historic counterpart. Her name is Olive Westcott and she lives in the New York of the turn of the 20th century.
When Amanda purchases some used clothing for her store from an extremely elderly woman, she finds Olive's journal sewed into the lining of a fur piece. In this journal, Olive documents her own tumultuous experiences as a single woman in New York who has a desire to make her own way in the world. Olive bucks the Edwardian system and craves life as a career woman. She is curious about her (not very accurate) notions of men and sexuality but is loathe to have children. (Olive's mother died in childbirth.)
Astor Place Vintage is told in alternating chapters that chronicle Amanda and Olive's experiences in the same New York neighborhood -- but 100 years apart. Astor Place Vintage was fun to read. It was filled with interesting tid bits about the neighborhood; what changed and what remained. (I felt like the author had a great time doing the research. Again, she felt like a kindred spirit to me, based on my fascination with property research alone.) The book is well written. The fact that this comes as a bit of a 'surprise' (considering the Chick Lit Rep) is merely a manifestation of my own prejudices. I had too much fun reading it. And I have daydreamed quite a bit lately about finding some sort of old journal in a trunk filled with Downton Abbey clothing.
This was a book where I made an immediate bond with the characters. It was a book that kept me turning pages at a rapid clip. But it was also a book that, more than once or twice, made me slow down and re-read a paragraph with pleasure. In other words, Astor Place Vintage was wonderful. And not just for a Chick Lit book either!
I would recommend this one to female readers who like a little bit of romance, a little bit of historical fiction and a little bit of contemporary Sex in the City stuff. If you are also hopelessly nostalgic, this would be a first rate choice. As Amanda muses to herself on page 100:
"Abbie Hoffman, the rebel from the sixties, once said that nostalgia is a mild form of depression. It did have the potential to bring me down and make me long for something that couldn't be captured. But it could also make me feel a part of something bigger. The past doesn't just go away; it lingers on. You can actually touch and see the remains, and to the extent that these souvenirs survive, the past is present. You can't say that for the future. It's not here in any form. It can't be; it hasn't arrived yet. Once it does arrive, it's the present, but only fleetingly before it's the past. You can never hold the future in your hands."
Amanda Rosenbloom is the contemporary character. At age 38, she has thrown her prime years away on Jeff -- her now married high school sweetheart. Jeff is not happily married. But he is happy enough to stay with Denise and the kids and string Amanda along as the side piece. He's a nice enough guy (for a married man who cheats) -- but we all realize that he is not the right man for Amanda.
Amanda, by the way, is way cool. She runs a vintage clothing shop in Manhattan and loves nothing more than poking around looking for the ghosts of Old New York. I wish she was real and I wish I knew her. I would love her clothing and I would have her deck me out in retro threads. And she is a person who would actually participate enthusiastically in one of my favorite hobbies -- namely driving around the city and becoming obsessed with old buildings and then trying to learn their history. (Ok. So I do this in Cleveland. Not quite New York City level architecture, but we have our unknown gems.)
No really. Amanda does this! I am not just going off on a tangent here:
"Glorious as any monument from ancient Rome, the massive block-long building radiated magnificence despite the fact that Bed Bath & Beyond, T. J. Maxx and Filene's Basement now shared the rent. Wreaths, columns, balconies, and lion heads along the cornice adorned the facade. Bronze columns and lanterns flanked the front doors. Olive, Sadie, and Angelina had used the employee entrance on Eighteenth Street, but still. Here it stood. I had to remind myself that I didn't actually know those women who worked there so many years ago."
"Something up near the roof made my jaw drop. A crest, like a coat-of-arms, engraved with the letters S and C. Siegel-Cooper! I saw more of the same crests evenly spaced along the top. I'd never noticed them even though I'd walked by a zillion times. I couldn't help taking the discovery as a message to me personally. Who else in recent history had observed the inscription of the original owners up there? Who would care? I wanted to sit right down on the curb and sob. The past! Right here in our midst, and we were so utterly oblivious, going about our days worshipping the present, as if the generation of 'now' was the only one that mattered."
This book is packed full of these (to my mind anyway) clever observations from this character who is obsessed with the past. She is sleeping with her high school boyfriend at 38. She owns a vintage clothing store. And she is completely fascinated with a woman who lived 100 years before she did. This woman is Amanda's historic counterpart. Her name is Olive Westcott and she lives in the New York of the turn of the 20th century.
When Amanda purchases some used clothing for her store from an extremely elderly woman, she finds Olive's journal sewed into the lining of a fur piece. In this journal, Olive documents her own tumultuous experiences as a single woman in New York who has a desire to make her own way in the world. Olive bucks the Edwardian system and craves life as a career woman. She is curious about her (not very accurate) notions of men and sexuality but is loathe to have children. (Olive's mother died in childbirth.)
Astor Place Vintage is told in alternating chapters that chronicle Amanda and Olive's experiences in the same New York neighborhood -- but 100 years apart. Astor Place Vintage was fun to read. It was filled with interesting tid bits about the neighborhood; what changed and what remained. (I felt like the author had a great time doing the research. Again, she felt like a kindred spirit to me, based on my fascination with property research alone.) The book is well written. The fact that this comes as a bit of a 'surprise' (considering the Chick Lit Rep) is merely a manifestation of my own prejudices. I had too much fun reading it. And I have daydreamed quite a bit lately about finding some sort of old journal in a trunk filled with Downton Abbey clothing.
This was a book where I made an immediate bond with the characters. It was a book that kept me turning pages at a rapid clip. But it was also a book that, more than once or twice, made me slow down and re-read a paragraph with pleasure. In other words, Astor Place Vintage was wonderful. And not just for a Chick Lit book either!
I would recommend this one to female readers who like a little bit of romance, a little bit of historical fiction and a little bit of contemporary Sex in the City stuff. If you are also hopelessly nostalgic, this would be a first rate choice. As Amanda muses to herself on page 100:
"Abbie Hoffman, the rebel from the sixties, once said that nostalgia is a mild form of depression. It did have the potential to bring me down and make me long for something that couldn't be captured. But it could also make me feel a part of something bigger. The past doesn't just go away; it lingers on. You can actually touch and see the remains, and to the extent that these souvenirs survive, the past is present. You can't say that for the future. It's not here in any form. It can't be; it hasn't arrived yet. Once it does arrive, it's the present, but only fleetingly before it's the past. You can never hold the future in your hands."
February 24, 2023
Trata sobre las peripecias de una chica que desea prosperar profesionalmente en el Nueva York de principios del s. XX. Quienes adoren esa ciudad y estén interesados en el mundo de la moda y la confección de aquella época disfrutarán de lo lindo con esta novela. A mí, que no me interesaba especialmente ni lo uno ni lo otro, me ha encantado. La época, la protagonista y el trasfondo feminista me encandilaron desde el principio. La otra historia, la contemporánea, me interesó menos. Aun así, la combinación de pasado y presente no entorpece la trama demasiado.
March 29, 2017
This was a book I picked up at a book sale because I was enchanted by the cover and a title... I was less enchanted by the story. I struggled to feel any sort of attachment to the characters and often found myself rolling my eyes at them and their sort of rote decisions... I found them static and slow with little - if any - development. I think that if I was more in to stories about adult women's emotional development I would feel differently but this is not a genre that I tend to reach for.
June 11, 2021
I enjoyed the format of the book with Amanda's story and then Olive's diary. Unfortunately, the plot didn't have anything that made me care very much about the characters or the conflict. I know that I can find it difficult to connect with characters who I don't like very much. And, I definitely felt that way with Amanda. Olive's story was more interesting for me. I especially enjoyed the pictures of early 1900s New York interspersed throughout. It really made the locations come to life.
May 9, 2021
Tweeënhalf. Gaat veel over wel of niet kinderen krijgen, menstruatie, wel of niet een verhouding hebben, weinig over vintage. Interessant omdat er veel over NY begin 20ste eeuw wordt verteld. Verder niet bijzonder.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 543 reviews