I have read almost all of Anita Hughes books. They are easy reads, often light love stories which draw you in and make you like the characters. Her writing is often very descriptive when it comes to the scenery of the area she writes in, the food they are eating, what they are wearing. One thing about Highes writing is that her characters are often from money and quite spoiled. You are not usually going to read about a character that is in jeans, sneakers, and a hoodie with no makeup and a ponytail. It is always expensive outfits and luxury locations. That is kind of one of the things I like about her books though. They are so far away from my own life that it is interesting to read about another way of life.
I almost always like Hughes books. This one, however, I did not like. I recently went on Amazon and bought the Hughes books that I was missing from my collection, and this was one of them. I wanted to like it but I could not really get into it. Like her other books, this one is set in the luxury vacation spot of St. Bart's. It centers on one family, where the daughter, Olivia, is about to celebrate her twenty-fifth birthday. Olivia is privileged, you get that right away. She has been to the right schools. She manages her mother's art gallery in New York. She celebrates her birthday and Christmas in St. Bart's every year. She is there knowing her boyfriend of four years, Finn, is going to propose so a lot of the early story is her waiting for that proposal.
Suddenly, her long lost father shows up to surprise her for her birthday. Other than a few letters,she has not seen her father since she was five years old. Everyone around her is less than thrilled her father has suddenly made an appearance but Olivia is seemingly swept off her feet at being able to see her father again and get to know him.
What I liked about this book was the imagery. I liked the description of St. Bart's. The activities. The description of the food. It made me want to see it one day, just to see if it matched the book. I also liked the flashback moments between Olivia's parents, Sebastian and Hadley. I liked the sections where they met, fell in love, and Olivia's early life. I felt like you really needed that for this book so you understood Sebastian and Hadley's relationship later in the book.
What I did not like was everything else really. This is labeled a "St. Bart's Love Story" but I did not find much of a love story. The relationship between Olivia and her boyfriend, Finn, irritated me. It might have been romantic if these two were not such spoiled, immature kids. They did not look like two people who should be thinking about marriage. Their "fights" were superficial. Every couple fights, that is just life, and having those fights is strengthening the relationship. But, their fights were nothing. It was over stupid things. Olivia wants to get to know her father and Finn is upset that her entire world is not revolving around him for a few days. Give me a break. I kept wanting to yell at this guy, "If you want to marry her, support her! Get to know her father too! Stop whining that she did not want to watch you play tennis!".
Now, the love "triangle" between Hadley, Sebastian, and Felix. I really liked Felix in this book. He was my favorite character, with Hadley being my second favorite. Felix is Hadley's second husband, and Olivia's stepfather. I thought he was a great guy. He came in, helped to raise Olivia, and supported her as her "father". I felt like Felix should have had a bigger part in this book. He is kind of in the background and I would have liked to explore more about Hadley and Felix's relationship.
Now, you do read a lot about Sebastian and Hadley's relationship, and it is done in the classic Hughes style. They were kids, they were quick to fall deeply in love, they get married and have Olivia, and are still in love but it did not work out. Sebastian disappears and Hadley is left on her own to raise Olivia. Later, Sebastian is back and it throws Hadley for a loop, as it should be. Through most of this book you don't know if Sebastian is back for Hadley, or if it for Olivia. You also don't get a sense if Hadley is still in love with Sebastian or not. That left a lot of questions for me through this. It was not even a "will they, or won't they" kind of thing. It was just dropped, not explored. I liked Hadley as a character. I thought she was a little more down to earth than her spoiled daughter but Sebastian, for all the comments about him living commission to commission, he was just as spoiled and entitled as Olivia was.
Then the ending. I felt this fell flat. There was no romance in it. It just kind of ended and I was not pleased. It felt like Hughes had nowhere to go so she just ended it. This is not her usual style. Like I said, I have read almost all of her books and there is usually a romantic, beautiful ending. Not this time. I was disappointed because I felt like there were so many other way she could have ended this story which would have satisfied the reader.
Overall, not my favorite Hughes at all. I am glad I read this one now because, if I had read it back when I first started reading Anita Hughes, I likely would never have picked up another one of her books. I have one more on my "to read" pile and I am really hoping it is better than this one.