In Nicole René's debut novel, ‘How The Warrior Fell’, the first within a series of novels to come, bound between duty and honour, the daughter of a chieftain is married to the Chief of the fiercest tribe as a way to ensure peace. Lines will be broken. Blood will be shed.
*SLAMS CUP ONTO THE TABLE*
Someone pass the Holy water, because— what on God’s good name did I read?
First and foremost, fellow readers, I must warn you. This one might have your blood boiling. However...and there is a, however...It'll either be in a good way…a bad way…or a combination of the two. Me? I’m fringing somewhere on the boundary line between a bad way—or the latter.
A tab bit reminiscent of George R.R. Martin’s ‘A Game of Thrones’ and Kristen Ashley’s ‘The Golden Dynasty’, I first encountered ‘How The Warrior Fell’ on an online social writing platform called Wattpad. Due to the author’s unexpected publishing news, however, she was unable to complete the book on the platform. Nevertheless, it’s historical and being the historical junkie that I am, leapt off that ledge to buy the book.
To start— the treatment of the main female protagonist is typical behaviour most would come to find within storylines centred on warrior tribes. Admittedly, the feminist in me screamed to run for the hills as such books I often find to be glorifying said treatment despite most authors cautioning their readers by way of a warning. Still— I had to remind myself not only of the era, but the least I could do was to give it a try. After all, it had yet to be completed, however, became popular relatively fast on the platform.
Right away readers are introduced to three tribes throughout the Samaritan: Aorsi (which our main h Leawyn is of), Siraces and the fierce and most dangerous, Izayges. If you’ve not guessed as yet, our male lead, Xavier is from that tribe.
From the beginning, he was atrocious. Handsome or not, he was no Khal Drogo or Kah Dax; two characters in categories Xavier would never be a part of. Every time he said something, I cringed. Every time he laid his hand on Leawyn, I wanted to walk the green mile. Am I exaggerating? Perhaps. Though I have good reasons as such tropes(the possessive and domineering Alpha males) are often becoming the norm within books of ANY genre. It’s either their way or the highway. What’s worse? Readers are finding it attractive, regardless of sex AND era.
Now, of course, our female lead, Leawyn is extremely beautiful. Which—*coughs* is repeatedly highlighted throughout the story to the point where it’s obsessive. Furthermore, it became apparent early on to many readers(myself included) that her beauty was part of the reason why Xavier’s sole purpose seemed nothing more than to conquer Leawyn’s mind and body. Did he strive for an heir? Absolutely. After all, in such an era, no matter how good of a warrior, your time is limited. Regardless, on multiple occasions, our heroine is subjected to unspeakable forms of physical violence. Even as we’re told there’s romance(though, to call each interaction between our leads as romance blossoming, perhaps, scheduling a visit to the doctor should be made), some scenes became unbearable to read. Something else to note, just as I found the author’s constant mentioning of her female lead’s beauty to be obsessive, so does the abuse our female lead endures to the point where it overpowers the story’s supposed conflict.
The turning point in the story came when our female lead admitted to her husband that— she would rather be raped by him than raped by others. In the end, along with hating her husband, readers know that our female lead has accepted her life for what it is.
Moreover, what little semblance of human decency our male lead portrayed, would fast become overshadowed by his abusive tendencies of not wanting to appear as a weak leader. That was where the storyline frustrated me most. We are told as a child, that our male lead witnessed the horrific deaths of his parents from an unknown tribe. Not to mention, reading our male lead, Xavier, confess to Leawyn how deeply his father cared not only for his family but his mother, should’ve been reason enough for Xavier to have treated Leawyn(even if in private) with respect and care she deserved from the beginning.
Though I must confess, brief satisfaction did happen upon reading how Leawyn’s hatred began gnawing away at Xavier’s skin. Had it done much in erasing the contempt this here reader developed for him? Nope. But for the most part, it was something.
Nevertheless, a fitting comeuppance would have been for the author to have made Xavier the only one having fallen all while knowing that his wife could never love him. Cruel, but impacting.
Moving along to other characters, we've got Tristan; the brother to Xavier who is shorter in height and at first appears to be another love interest for Leawyn. Next is Tyronian. Not only is he the cousin to our male lead but is said to be matched both in height and weight to Xavier. Due to his family’s relation to the chief of the Siraces tribe, he can challenge the Siraces chief for that position. Lastly, we have our 16-year-old and the lady-in-waiting to the chiefess, the stammering yet just as beautiful as our female lead, Namoriee. An orphan who the warrior cousin, Tyronian has set his sights on.
The next book within the series follows the relationship between our secondary leads, Tyronian and Namoriee. Keeping fingers crossed, I hope for their book we have certain questions answered. For starters, where Namoriee hails from, how she came to be in their tribe and whether she's got family out there unbeknown-est to her since her colouring(including hair) is slightly different from theirs.
Next is word-building. The genre is historical yet the dialogue had me thinking that I was reading a story where the year was 2015. I DO NOT appreciate modern lingo in any historical genre UNLESS the plot calls for it as it removes the beauty of such a period. If you’re going to write a book that is historical fiction then, DO. YOUR. RESEARCH. See to it that the dialogue resonates with the tone of the story. Don’t just tell us your story is about a tribe set in the historical period, SHOW US by bringing it together full circle.
One more thing to note, not only was I disappointed that the author removed Tyronian and Namoriee’s POV chapters, but the addition of their scenes I felt somewhat was a mini preparation of what was to come for us in the next instalment.
Overall, showcasing tribes in such an era can make for a decent read depending on what one as a reader finds acceptable. For me, one of the few things that stood out was how revered horses are to the tribes. The author showed great understanding and a deep connection between man to horse and horse to its rider.