Ghost Stories of Shimla Hills is a chilling compilation of the supernatural events and the activities of spirits in the hills of Shimla. The book presents ghost stories as narrated by the residents of Shimla.
Firstly, I would like to share my own experience during Shimla stay through this review. Personally, I don’t endorse such things based on rationality, but most of us would agree with me on the fact that there are certain things our conscience can’t explain about. Certain experiences of people, places, and incidences lead us to the clueless blunt ends. Being a keen observer of nature and the supernatural, there are few such instances attached with my memory. I refreshed those spooky experiences once again after reading the book Ghost stories of Shimla Hills. It was the time when I was pursuing my post-graduation at Shimla University. I was staying at the hostel but sometimes visit my friends having their own accommodations in the vicinity of the university. On one such night, around 8:30 PM, I was alone en route to my friend's place, which was approximately 10-15 min distance from my hostel. My entire path was through the beautiful forest of pines, rhododendrons and ban trees. Being a suburb of Shimla, Summer hill, where the university is actually situated, witness few commuters on regular days, and it was Saturday. So, I was expecting few peoples on my way and found exactly none to accompany me after exiting the hostel. The hotels are situated at the margins of the forest, and there was a deserted road that connects those with the main road at lower Summer hill chowk. Of course, the road had streetlights, but there was a place on a curve just at a few step distance from the hostel where the streetlight never remained functional. Either it gets damaged or remains non-functional most of the time. On that day, the light was functional but not fully, and it was fluttering and making that place even scarier than it usually was. I was walking in my own thoughts, and as I crossed that curve and suddenly under the dim light of the moon filtering through the pine trees, I felt as if a shadow of the girl had crossed me very closely. It was a silhouette of a girl for sure, I reckon. Found it usual, and I crossed, ignoring the coldness of that sensation. But within few seconds, I recalled the timing, and it was almost 8:45 PM. The presence of a girl at this time and especially at this place was not so usual. Actually, for security purposes, girl’s hostels have strict timings for closing, which was almost 1 hour before this. Moreover, there was no residence beyond hostels. So at that time, the question of passing any girl from there was negligible. I returned to make her aware of the frequent presence of leopard in that area. But to my amazement, there was none! I startled for some times. I was sure of the girl, and when thought thereafter, I could recall her polo t-shirt with blue strips of irregular thickness. I am not sure if it was a supernatural experience, but a few odds forced me to give a second thought to possibilities of spookiness on that particular night. I don’t know if a girl was actually there or not, but that cold sensation of her presence will always stay with me forever. Though the book is excellent, I felt the horripilation of words as if I am one of the characters. It's a must-read.
Ghost stories always fascinated me. The terrific looks of ghost and their past life are something which makes me read ghost stories. Every culture has its own depiction of ghost and ghostly thing. You will find me reading the ghost story in free time. Shimla is one of my dream destination as it has a dreamy atmosphere. In past Shimla has been the favourite place of Britisher's as they find the environment of Shimla same as to England. As they left our country but with this they have left some stories which have now become the folklore of Shimla.
Summary:
Minakshi Chaudhary was a former journalist. She belongs to Shimla. She grew up listening spooky stories of Bhoots (Ghosts) and churail (Lady ghost) and in this book she has tried to compile some of those stories.
This book has 15 short stories, giving the various instance of Bhoots and Churails. These stories depict the culture of Shimla hills. The misty atmosphere, heritage bungalow, trees of deodar, the lifestyle of Britishers.
All the stories are based on the work of fiction. These are those stories which are coming from generation to generation and now become the folklore. The writer has gathered such stories from people and presents it in a form of the book.
In this book, you can find a story of a man who met a Churail while coming back to his home at night. A ghost of a 14-year-old-girl, who come back in this world just to seek the justice. A story of bhoot bungalow where people get thrown out of the room.
I personally love the story 'The Sanjauli Fruit seller' where a new resident of Shimla, unaware of the ghost route walk back to home and he met a fruit seller in a very odd place. Which was actually a ghost.
This book has the foreword of Ruskin Bond which gives it an incredibility.
Writing style:
Stories are written in a simple way. The language is pretty easy to understand.
My perception:
Actually, I have bought this book in the hope of getting some spine chilling horror but this book is just a collection of folklore mended with work of fiction. You can complete this book in just one day. Stories are amusing but it will not really haunt you. There is some story where you will not even able to find the conclusion. Give it a read when you want to read light horror stories.
The fear of the unknown - enhanced by the mist, darkness, patterning of raindrops and lonely paths through the woods is part of life in the hills. Hill stations do have that eerie vibe. Also, there are accounts of encounters with the supernatural at such places,15 of which have been put together in this book by author Minakshi Choudhry based upon recounting the personal experiences of people she met while researching the book.
Whether it is the Churail of Boileauganj and St. Bedes road, the eerie happenings around Lakkar Bazar, University Road and the tunnels around Shimla or the haunted roads, bauris and benches, the author has brought together the lore around the supernatural in Shimla in this book.
First published in 2005 with a foreword by Ruskin Bond, this is a light breezy read on ghosts and spirits set in the romanticised environs of Shimla.
I don't know how I feel about this book. Most of stories aren't even real, they're more close to common legends. It was great in the beginning but then it just got worse and worse, till there was no horror left in the Ghost Stories and they became normal stories.
I really enjoyed this book! Set in India, short stories of encounters with Victorian Age English ghosts. A wonderful book full of ghosts for the Autumn/Halloween season. No spoilers and I highly recommend it.
Minakshi Chaudhry, a former journalist and writer of multiple books based in Shimla provides yet another book of Ghost stories of Shimla Hills. A total of 16 short stories are based on the other side, deals with supernatural and spirits which refuse to die down. The author's earlier book, 'Ghost Stories of the Shimla Hills', published in 2005 also by Rupa and Co, became a bestseller and is in constant reprint.
In these 16 stories, the readers will encounter bhoots (ghosts) and churails (witches) who wander in the Shimla hills. These stories also tell us about the cultural and religious life of hill people. Generations of Shimlaites grew up hearing stories about bhoots and churails. These tales based on facts and experiences shared by people, have been narrated in a fictionalised way. Dark moonless nights, lonely stretches, mist enveloping hills and valleys, something howling in the faraway jungle - everything in the Shimla hills gives an appearance of these unearthly beings.
The book includes tales about the spirit of an English nurse who wanders in the wards of Lady Reading (now known as Kamla Nehru hospital in Shimla), taking care of the children in need; a theatre manager - an Englishman who died before India's Independence who was so much in love with Shimla that he did not leave even after he died and his spirit haunts the (Gaiety) theatre and roams there on dark nights.
In these stories we meet people who can talk to the spirits and who live between the two worlds - living and the dead! We also travel to the strange world of fairies, who land and take off at the lawns of Pari Mehal (a locality in Shimla) and meet members of a unique family that claims to have met ghosts just as we meet each other.
There is a touching tale of a Muslim ghost who came to Shimla hills (in Nankhari village, some 100 km from Shimla) after partition and stayed back. It plays pranks on people but as it grew old, it lost interest in teasing people and longed to go back to Lahore but could not do so.
But apart from this, all other stories are mostly bland and have a read-that-before feeling to it. They do not invoke much emotions and hardly provides a surprise in its narrative. Over all, a mixed bag of book which provide some interesting stories but does not show enough courage to take it to the next level by introducing some new concepts in the horror genre.
I picked up Ghost Stories of Shimla Hills in the right place - a bookstore in Shimla on Mall Road. Being fascinated by Shimla and horror equally, I found the title to be instantly appealing.
I began reading the stories with a lot of hope, mostly because of the Ruskin Bond foreword. Starting reading it on the toy train to Kalka, by the way. So the ambiance was perfect.
What the author Minakshi Chaudhry has done really well is to recreate the charm of Shimla. Right from the colonial Shimla to the modern one, she has explained details very well. That was definitely one factor that kept me turning the pages.
About the stories themselves, they are folklore that she has now documented as fiction tales. It was fun to read even this, as folklore is often fascinating. I loved the legends that she has chosen to portray in this book.
What I did not like though, is the writing style. There is too much telling. The stories are narrated as if they were to kids of 12, to whom everything needs to be spelled out. There is nothing left to the imagination. Ghost stories should tell you very little; they should play out in your mind more. That does not happen here. The stories do not stay with you after you finish reading them because the author has told you everything there was to tell.
Still, a good one-time read if you love the genre and Shimla. Otherwise, it lacks charm.
I had high expectations with this book but got disappointed eventually.🔴EXPECTATIONS LEADS TO DISAPPOINTMENTS🔴. At first I thought this book is going to be super boring, nothing horror in it but slowly in middle I found one or two stories which were quite thrilling other than that nothing horror in reading the book. There were total 16 stories. As the name suggests this book is about the bhoots and churails of long lived people and angrez of Shimla. The ending in each of the story was predictable. Hence, I managed to read the book without getting any chills. But, I really liked one story amongst them which was set in a hostel room where the girl met her roommate's mother's ghost, that was quite capturing for me. . The language is simple and easy plus free flowing. The cover of the book is really good. I liked the title of the story. It was a one time read. I don't think that I would like to re-read this book ever. . If you are looking for reading stuff you can read this book but if you are looking of something spooky, ah, bad choice.
A fascinating book revealing mystical ghost stories of Shimla. A good read for those who have been to Shimla and can relate to the places where apparently ghosts exist. At times a chill runs down your spine for you have been just there and you "Look Back" if you did not miss any ghosts!!!
I picked up this book late at night for the first time, expecting it would send chills down my spine, that it would be absolutely blood-curling. Rather, it is just a collection of incidents that various residents across the Shimla Hills have experienced which they attribute to supernatural beings.
A few aspects that I admire in what has brought this book to life include the perseverance shown by the author in personally collecting the anecdotes and the effort put into understanding the origin behind all that stemmed into those beliefs. However, I would add that the narration and language used are childish, almost mocking a reader's capacity sometimes. In fact, in retrospect, the literary aspect and style are quite terrible at times.
The narration is rather simple, and nothing about it stands out as frightening. Neither are the stories what one would describe as "sleep-killers" (unless, maybe, you reside in the said area). This book entails a compilation of incidents, of encounters with English witches and White ghosts by the locals. The stories are left with an open end, with no further explanations, for they all remain as what occurred — with nobody interested in risking their lives to probe further.
It felt that the collection is something I would discard as mere tricks played by the brain, though it does not fail to fascinate a reader. If churails and bhoots terrify you, this book is a perfect blood-curling pick to curl up with at midnight.
Below average book(👎). Felt that 1-2 page stories are dragged unnecessarily to 7-8 pages. Stories are not that interesting.No need to explain each and everything and the author could have left some details to the reader imagination."The grave of an English lady" and "The prince with the red rose" doesn't even qualify as ghost/horror stories. Not sure why the author considered to add these 2 stories in this book. Only 1 or 2 are worth reading. Predictable, not so scary, very normal stories not worth paying ₹.250/-. Felt the stories are more like a fiction than a folklore or a real life experience. Nothing worth mentioning. Could read once just as a time pass. There are many interesting ghost stories on other platforms like Google, reddit, YouTube. I recommend to read those instead of this book.
"Do ghosts exist? We don't know! But ghost stories do exist and these tales are real!" - This is how the preface ends, creating the perfect aura and setting the tone for some engaging reading. All stories occur at well known landmarks of Shimla and if you have ever visited there, you can very well visualize the events in your mind. The stories start with the fast paced 'Angrez Churail' which attacks you in the face right from the word go with its beautifully terrifying description of an oncoming doom. I actually found my self re-reading it several times just to see if it gives me the same tense feeling again ... and it did! One more in the same league is 'The Road to Lovers Paradise'. From then on the stories are mixed with real tales of unexplained happenings and sightings ('Roads, Bauris & Benches') from locals and tourists alike and some are collections of rumors or mostly hearsay. The author has also busted the "bad ghost" myth by adding material related to forces which have been known to actually have helped people and families ('The Bhootwallahs', 'The Ghost on the Railway Line', 'The Grave of an English Lady'). From the set of stories in this book, my favorites are 'The Premonition' and 'Enduring Love', both quite poignant in their concept and could be good candidates to be converted to movies. One thing I would have liked to know about each of these stories is the year in which they occur, though we can make out that some are based around immediately after or aorund the post-independence years. Minakshi Chaudhry's research is highly commendable it really made me wonder how she must have extracted so much information from so much of diversity. Overall a sheer delight for horror story fans and I feel a must read for the people of Shimla!
The book is good, gives a number of british ghosts stories at Shimla. For all the interested explorers it provides enough placed in Shimla to explore in this way apart from just getting excited by its natural beauty and british setup. It arouse the urge of exploring shimla more. Though the stories are more on the locally famous stories instead of personal experiences so it is more of increasing excitement instead of giving adrenaline rush which you got from stories of Sacred Evils by Ipsita Roy Chakravatry.
A fantastic book, one that gives the reader some serious chills, I enjoyed it over a week-end away in Lonavla, amidst the pouring August rains in the year 2012. The stories are fabulous and dark. Each a journey of their own.
very good book,,these are all real stories....so you can't compare them to the fabricated ones or those which are looseley based on real life stories.....
This story is about a girl who visited Shimla as she was interested in the supernatural, specifically ghosts that wander around cemeteries. This is her story. The story is taken from 'Ghost Stories Of Shimla Hills' and name of the story is 'Ghost Don' t Exist'.There she asked a lady that where was the cemetery. The lady pointed towards a narrow road. After ten minutes she had seen a house but got no answer. After sometime she saw dozen of shops in an area. She asked an old man about the cemetery near here. So he said that after walking towards the north, half an hour she would see a very old cemetery. He also asked that why she wanted to go there. She replied that the main purpose of going there was to find ghosts wandering around there. The old man replied that there were no ghosts there. Then she started walking towards the north with the help of a compass. After half an hour she saw the cemetery which was on a small hillock. The main cemetery was an enclosed area; its boundary wall was made up of stones. She saw that there were about sixty graves, well structured with a cemented path in between. Several names and names were faintly visible there. Afterwards when she was returning back she saw a mam and started having a conversation with him. But afterwards he vanished. Then she met the old man again and he said that people heading towards the cemetery always meet a guy who vanishes after you reach your destination. Piya Rai Dhamija 6th D
Chaudhary's anecdotal wanderings through the Shimla locales is a window through the ages. Although the stories recapitulate the folklore and hauntings of some of the most popular spots across the town, the book is more about the soul of the place that feels like an anachronism in modern times. The past spills over into the present, manifesting itself through ghostly sightings and apparitions that are remnants of the British Raj. Each story is based on Chaudhry's conversations with a local who apprises her of the tales behind the ghost-stories that have endured through generations. There is something about the way common people narrate these "encounters" that just cannot be gotten from conventional horror writers. There is no malevolence in them but a simple connection to the living world that hasn't been severed yet. Some of them lament the loss of simplicity of their times while the others simply don't see a reason to leave the beautiful environs of Shimla.
This book is to be read on one of those rainy evenings when the overcast sky casts an eternal twilight during the day. When the only sound is that of the raindrops pattering against the window and the breeze frazzling the curtains. When the soul is more open to the spiritual dimension and devoid of the burden of rationality.
It took me a week to finish this slim book of just 135 pages — and that’s saying something. Not because it was gripping, or horrifying, but because I kept waiting for it to get better… and it never did.
I was genuinely excited to pick this up — my first horror read, and an Indian horror book at that! I thought it would be spooky, memorable, and perfect for my next trip to the hills — something I could bring up during those classic “bhooton wali baatein” sessions with my friends.
But this book? A complete letdown.
I understand that collecting real paranormal experiences is a tough task, but the stories here were so flat. No suspense, no chills, not even the fun kind of creepy. They weren’t even childish — just painfully lame.
The only mildly redeemable story was the last one — The Lady on the Rickshaw — where a ghostly figure gives a glimpse into Shimla’s colonial past. It had a flicker of originality, but that’s about it.
Ironically, the most entertaining part of this book wasn’t a story at all — it was Ruskin Bond’s one-page foreword. It’s clever, humorous, witty and sharp.
So if you ever come across this title, do yourself a favor: read the foreword… and walk away.
Ghost Stories of Shimla Hills written by Minakshi Chaudhry has 15 shorts. They are eerie, narrating brushes of living beings with the supernatural, and offer a good range of experiences. The book makes for a quick and easy read.
But just because it has a foreword by Ruskin Bond, please don't expect wonder's from the language aspect of the book. In fact, it is quite ordinary, call it passe. In fact, The Ghost On The Railway Line contained a glaring error (page 82) that's very subcontinental and made me laugh although the protagonist's experience was meant to evoke fear. I wish the author had also requested Mr. Bond to edit her stories. Further, the stories, rather the essays had a typical construction design - it delved too long to create the preamble to the horror and then the experience itself was extremely short. It is as if Ms. Chaudhry is inspired by Saki's sudden ends with twists in his short stories, but in the process failing to capture the effects of the supernatural to the fullest extent.
Have come here after ages I feel. So much so happened that I forgot I used to love reading and mostly share my views on the books. Any how, I have decided to start and build the reading habit again so rather diving into the hard core reading I decided to start slowly and with short stories.
And so my husband recommended me this book.
I have just finished this book. Mmmm… I didn’t have much expectations because the first few stories are just basic, but some of the horror stories are really creepy, interesting, and with unexpected endings. If you are new and did not know about this book earlier like me, it is basically an amalgamation of many short horror stories and real experiences of people living in Shimla.
Though this book is quite old, but there are some stories in it which still has impact. So go for it !! You will love the experience.
Haunted Sanjhauli road in Shimla reminds me Camel back road in Mussoorie. Conifers, cemetery and ghosts. A chill ran through my spine while browsing through ghost stories in this well written book. Though about ghosts, this book is suitable for all ages. Why so? Because it is written in such a balanced way not to cause a crude horror in you despite raising every hair in your body!
I find this book as an average read for those who are not much familiar with the shimla hills. Though it is a treat to the natives as they can easily relate to the places and roads mentioned. I myself found it bit difficult to connect that much. Also the form of the ghosts reveal themself easily in a Bollywood like manner. I personally like those stories which do not present a clear picture of the spirit. Instead they should let your imagination wander here and there without giving it a shape.
"Ghost Stories of Shimla Hills" by Minakshi Chaudhry offers a captivating journey into the supernatural folklore of the Shimla region. Chaudhry's storytelling prowess brings these eerie tales to life, painting a vivid picture of the haunted landscapes and mysterious occurrences. While some stories may lack depth or originality, overall, the collection succeeds in delivering an entertaining and spine-chilling read for enthusiasts of the paranormal genre.
This book is a true masterpiece of horror and suspense. The stories start with normal conversations and then deepen into a sense of fear and that feeling for readers, "Keep reading,keep reading." The book absorbed my attention, I finished it in two 2 hour sittings, perhaps my habit or the book's magic itself. I would recommend thus book to anyone who likes spooky things ,especially children.
One of the few Horror stories book that I have read. The writing style is very narrative and I found my self in some situations (partly because I belong to Shimla and could easily connect with the places mentioned). All in all its really interesting and quick read and I recommend it to get a instant chilling experience.