Rating: minus 12 on a scale of minus 15 to plus 5.
This is typically terrible US military science fiction. I remember little about the book and failed to finish it. I doubt that anyone will read this, as I revise.
Before I begin I must visit the YouTube. This is made possible by Doctor Who/Never Cruel or Cowardly - Ozar, NCMI, Anark, fig tree, Just a Confused Brit, Sarah C M Paine, Red Glasgow, Tale Foundry, Keffals, Welcome to Ukraine, Postmodern Jukebox, Brigitte Empire, AllShorts, Books N Things, Vasya in the Hay, Emily Michelle, Sailing Melody, Bren Booth-Jones, Veritas et Caritas, Ro Ramdin, Kings and Generals, Tully Slings,
The New Enlightenment with Ashley, Omeleto, LuckyBlackCat, RevolutionarythOt, Belinda Strnad, Prose and Petticoats, Yanis Varoufakis, Inside Russia, Dr Fiona Hill, Welcome to Ukraine, Kyiv Independent, Jen the Librarian, The Kavernacle, Jess Owens, Owen Jones, FAFO, KernowDamo, ATP Geopolitics, Cambrian Chronicles, Munecat, ScaredKetchup, Revolutionary Communists of America,
Matriarchetype, Hoots, Mallen Baker, Lucy Lumen, The Serf Times, Roisin's Reading, Raw News and Politics, Leena Norms, Reese Waters, Turn Left, Lynn Saga, The Leftist Cooks, Puddles Pity Party, Jessie Gender, Think Ukraine, Emilie's LIterary Corner, Your True Shelf, Reads with Rachel, Fit 2B Read, Eugenia from Ukraine, Shades of Orange, Library Unbounded, Princess Weekes, Sarah Millican, Mandy, Kopke613,
The Gaze, Jay Exci, Broken Peach, Joe Webb, Operator Starsky, Silicon Curtain, JohnTheDuncan, Oceanliner Designs, Dark Brandon, Kazachka, HBomberguy, E W Baylis Toy Soldiers, Dungeons and Discourse, Paul Stanley, May, Foster on the Spectrum, NerdForge, Just in Time Worldbuilding, Veritas et Caritas, Dr Fatima, DUST, Refashioned Hippie, No Justice, Supertanskiii, Toby Rose Lonesome,
Jen the Librarian, Katie Halper, Riverboat Jack, Aid Thompsin, Tibees, Unlearning Economics, Uncivilized, Perun, Queen Penguin, Lady of the Library, Blooms & Greens by Chloe, Deerstalker Pictures, Dr Becky, Seizure Girl, TallGirl6234, Let's Talk Tabletop, Ministry of Miniatures, Parkrose Permaculture, The Slaggy Book Club, Agro Squirrel Narrates, Shakos and Sprues, Midlander Gaming,
Waterstones, Living the Skye Life, TimeGhost History, Jessica Craven, Morning Mercury, Carolina Pinglo, Haunts Wargaming, Paperback Journeys, Wanderness, Beth Stelling, Jessica Craven, Ellen Catherine, Julie reads her bookshelf, Greg Terry Experience, Charlotte McDonnell, White Cockade, Katie Montgomerie, Diane Jennings, CiCi Zhu, Ksenia Turkova, Ms Modeller, Barry's Economics. Guard the Leaf.
A member of the Village Idiot Movement whilst insulting an essayist I mention, complained to her that I list other trans creators. The Snowflake (proudly ignorant, self-important US male) no longer shocks me. A trigger warning then.
The channels which I list include archaeologist, German, cis, WOC, blond, socialist, bi, physicist, tall, queer, autist, redhaired, military historian, trans, artist, communist, married, pensioner, culture critic, Finnish, primatologist, lesbian, boater, architect, older, writer, intersex, mathematician, musician, Irish, physically challenged, asexual, political commentator, language historian, military boardgamer, sewist, miniatures modeller, cosplayer and other creators known as Women.
Almost as threatening to smug arrogance are the other BIPOC, Australian, married, anthropologist, anarchist, military modeller, ginger, Scottish, other neurodivergent, slim, hobbyist, short, philosopher, fashion historian, other LGBTQI+, book reviewer, French, science educator, miniatures collector, stout, boater and other creators recognised (outside the USA) as Human Beings.
Should the voices persist, seek emergency therapy, learn a language, perhaps English and/or repeat several times daily "I will not be a bellend today".
My feelings towards these clods parallel those of the 13 Ukrainian marines defending Snake Island when their surrender was demanded by the Russian navy. Their response, "Russian warship, go f@ck yourself". Glory to Ukraine. Glory to the Heroes. Crimea is Ukraine.
Unto the book, dear friends. I vaguely remember it. The one unusual bit is that the writer might know what a destroyer is. I wonder if a destroyer would serve a purpose if there is no space version of a submarine or small attack craft. I have given thought to that in my own world building.
I am thinking that a cruiser makes more sense as an independent unit. I only noticed ship designation because these military science fiction writers often have no clue about ship classes, their roles, their functions.
There are aliens but nothing is done with them. The book about the lone, not very capable warship as hero ship, is boring and overused. These writers never build a substantial background universe. With no developed characters, human or otherwise, the book becomes as unmemorable as the rest.
I assume that every crew person has an Anglo surname and presumed US american in lieu of personality. There are other problems but in the end, my rating described my reaction. I have since ended my Unlimited sub.
I began watching YouTube about four years ago. The number and variety of channels surprised me. The best discovery was that of Book Tube. 😍 These channels host communities of readers who are curious, courteous (in the main), lovers of all that is bookish. The environments created are far different to that of whatever Goodreads have become.
This next was made possible by YouTube Doctor Who/Never fail to be Kind -Slyfer2812,
NCMI, WhoCulture, Lily Simpson, Capital Lumber Log Yard, The Knitting Cult Lady, Kirkpattiecake, Brittany Page, Sophie Games, Legendary Tactics, Revenant Reads, Rose and Rosie, Lilly's Life, Verilybitchie, Double Down News, Simply Resilient Me, The Historian's Craft, Times Radio, Amanda and Shaye,
Gittemary Johansen, Leora Aileen, this tiny life, Noella Reacts, FAFO, Yarmak, Inside Russia, Tristan and the Classics, Ukraine Calling, Katia Pavlov Art, Reads with Rachel, Suris, The Shitty Book Club, Cindy's Villa, Joe Blogs, YourbestieMisha, Off JaWagon, DIEM25, Plant based Bride, Mercado Media, Honest Government Ads, Brianna Sarovski, Sally's Economics, Dark Side of Russia, Sarah Todd Hammer,
Emma Thorne, Ukraine Calling, Told in Stone, Unfiltered Stories, Paul Warburg, Operator Starsky, The Russian Dude, Sanctioned Ivan, Malling Film, Anka Daily News, Liz Webster, Professor Gerdes Explains, AllShorts, ScaredKetchup, The Gaze, Supertanskiii, Yankee Farm Wife, Admiral Sea Bass, twinshangout kenya, Read with Susmitha, The Ritual Kitchen with Laura May, Board Game Sanctuary,
More Perfect Union, The DiceKeep, Between the Lines, Feral Historian, BaldBookGeek, Kozak Siromaha, JmmyTheGiant, RFU News, Feral Historian, Business Basics, Patrick(H)Willem, EarleWrites, The Military Show, Ellie Dashwood, Jack in the Books, danainspired, Tizzy Ent, What Rae Reads, Marianne Williamson, Aisha rae, Unlearning Economics, Roomies Digest, Gina Stanyer Books, 7th Sons, Gary's Economics,
Amanda Rae, New Buckenham Historical Wargamers, Diane Jennings, Book Furnace, ThatDaneshGuy, Keith Edwards, Noella reacts, aidan knight, Aid Thompsin, PPR Global, Willow Talks Books, Upon Reflection, Real Vintage Dolls House, Then & Now, History with Kayleigh, Planarwalker, Claire Fenby-Warren,
Bean Thinking, Larry & Paul, Gutsick Gibbon, Ember Green, Mom on the Spectrum, kgb detected, YuGopnik, Anti-Social Studies, Ancient Americas, Hoots, Council of Geeks, Sophie Games, Caerhle Irey, Book and Hearth, Cruising Alba, Boat Time, Jake Broe, Leena Norms, No Justice, Jessie Gender, Biracial Voices,
Anna from Ukraine, Silicon Curtain, Samantha Lux, Steve Shives, LydLoves, Jordaline Reads, Tennessee Brando, The Serf Times, Chris Norlund, Soggyrice3, Jen's Reading Life, gemma dyer, Fiona Tanya, captured in Words, ConeOfArc, Queer Eye Australia, Raw News and Politics, AllShorts, JustAli, NowHere Channel, Chris and Shell, Cruising Crafts, Well Deck Diaries, Caerhl Irey, Alyssa and the Books,
Ana Fern, Amie's Literary Empire, Dropkick Murphys, Nomadic Crobot, Bobbing Along, Dead Domain, Anti-Social Studies, WokeGardener, SolarpunkAlana, roughhouserosie, Claire Fenby-Warren, Just in Time Worldbuilding, Anna Cramling, Arbitrarium Games, Words in Time, JuLingo, Armoured Archivist, Artur Rehi, Asturia Quartet, Duo Vagari, Sally's Economics,
Enter the Book, Autistic AF, Back from Burnout, Nerdy Kathi, Gaelic with Jason, Irish Medieval History, Bernadette Banner, Jack Edwards, Ellen Catherine, Business Basics, Andrew Watson, Shannon Makes, I Draper, Boylei Hobby Time, JammiDodger, Abby Cox, Snappy Dragon, PPR Global, Strange Lucidity, Engineering Knits, Rebecca Watson, Rachel Maksy, Plaid Cymru, Amodelwhosread,
Maggie Mae Fish, Books From My Bookshelf, Turn Left, NYTN, A Brush with Bekah, Revolutionary Communist Party, Planet Critical.
Consider treating this as a hostile site. 🤔
Goodreads do not encourage discourse. As example, I wrote my last original review and received my last comment storm with Powers of the Earth. That book was a sorry, pathetic salute to the psychotic January 6, 2021 hero. The plot was glorification of a rich twat wanting to not pay taxes on his inheritance enlisting the military to overthrow the US government. I found the book dangerous and disturbing.
The writer is Travis Corcoran who self-described as libertarian (now anarcho capitalist without the millions) and advocate for the return of chattel slavery (popular stance in the US, already implemented in prison labour with ongoing legislative drives to extend the practice), veteran, employee of an unnamed US agency, supporter of Putin (popular stance among many in the USA and government).
The writer and six fellow patriots took exception. There followed a year long demand for a response to comments, among them was noted my narcissistic personality as I declined to engage, judgement of intelligence, strange interpretations of History, etc.
The layers of irony were painful.
I had hoped that, I might also have answers to Etruscan origins. I did not. Such is life.
The final comment was delivered by Claes Rees Jr aka cgr710 now ka Clayton R Jesse Jr (who seems no longer to self-identify as a Nazi).
He declared that They had "won" (?), after referencing the contents of my last message to a Goodreads friend. I discovered that They had launched a year long flood of anti-working class, racist, misogynistic and ableist comments against apparently every female creator which I listed (some in my name and it continues still).
They failed to impress the historian, midteen boater or her mother, mathematician, science educator or other women.
They did increase the world's overabundance of ugliness and delivered an accurate self-portrait of the Snowflake (vicious, arrogantly ignorant US baby-man) to a multinational audience.
It seems this was Victory. Goodreads provide refreshing reader exchanges ??
There are a number of safer, more useful reader sites to which BookTubers may direct you.
Ominous music begins. 😊 Few BookTubers address the issue of the comment gangs. They are not one-off but loosely organised groups of free speechers, seemingly US membership led or inspired. They seem fairly widespread across Romance and Speculative fiction.
Their activity is not limited to nasty comments. They include the doxxing, stalking, threatening and I myself have been target of a hacking attempt. Amazon have never acknowledged these incidents nor disciplined members, punished writers when involved with same or dismissed sociopathic employee enablers.
My ultimate harassment from Amazon/KIndle was the giving over of my very limited message history to these disturbed persons. This made possible a request through Pine Gap Centre for Australian Security to interrogate the one friend whom I occasionally messaged.
The attempt at my personal history failed, though it left two outraged customers. Only after we shared this experience did Amazon become concerned. Suddenly all lurkers whom I had not previously been Allowed to remove disappeared, my page format and options were returned to normal, etc. No apology, no explanation. I would suggest that Amazon explore new customer service practices. 🙂
A seventh ex-employee of EBay was sentenced for harassment of a couple whose small ecommerce site was deemed unkind to EBay. The couple were awarded millions and that ex-employee had been Chief of EBay Global Security or something like.
The above all occurred before the present immunity awarded to US data firms.
I suggest a few precautions. Remove personal information from profile and avoid messaging. Remove lurkers, those who never post. Those friends are likely monitors for gangs or employee created dummies, not admirers.
Given Amazon's cavalier attitude towards customer data and safety, the screenshots of the odd, ugly and threatening are truly invaluable. For Goodreads, these should be sufficient.
Kindle are the more dangerous. Do Not use Kindle Files, Calendar, Email or Contacts. My 15 minute test email was removed with some small difficulty and password changed immediately after. Some six months later, I received a Kindle message that They were unable to Sign Into my email (?).
Do Not "purchase" Kindle ebooks. You own only the device and your "purchased" titles may be removed at Amazon's whim. I am embarrassed to admit that I unfortunately misjudged corporate behaviour before having already purchased several hundred titles.
There are BookTubers to direct you to alternative vendors of ebooks and devices. They also discuss alternatives to e-book purchase.
Silk searches should obviously be innocuous and non-critical.
The national culture actually thrives on violence and attack on the non-conforming individual. The normalisation of rape, forced sterilisation and other torture by US Border Patrol, has for decades been known and reported.
Obama (the wonderful), Trump (proud white supremacist) and Biden (decades long leader of legislative attacks on the working class, BIPOC and women) have each ignored the practice.
Border Patrol have causally admitted in televised interviews that They do not even keep records of deaths occurring in custody. There was no national upheaval, scandal or outrage.
The extent, depth and indifference to US cruelty is that which Conservative and Reform have only dreamed. These are the predominant segment of Anglophone Goodreads and are US patriots.
I discovered a quote by US President Lyndon Johnson. "Tell the lowest white man that he is superior to the best black man and he will never notice you picking his pocket. Hell, give a poor white man someone to look down on, he'll empty his pockets for you."
Sadly something similar seems applicable to Britain. Ominous music ends. 😊
Be safe and may we all find Good Reading. 🤗
Some of my favourite channels.
NCMI, Bobbing Along, Ben and Emily, The Leftist Cooks, AllShorts, Mrs Betty Bowers, Some More News, EarleWrites, Books with Chloe, Zoe Baker, Juice Media, Philosophy Tube, Christy Anne Jones, Atun Shei Films, Dr Becky, Art by Annamarie, Viva La Dirt League, Lady knight the brave, Art Deco, Media Death Cult,
Fundie Fridays, TVP News, Serena Skybourne, Spacedock, NFKRZ, A clockwork Reader, Kris Atomic, Cruising Crafts, Cruising the Cut, Ship Happens, Cruising Alba, Jean's Thoughts, Roomies Digest, Maggie Mae Fish, Scotland History Tours, 16 Feet, 6UPTabletop Gaming, A Brush with Beka, A Time of Eagles, A Very Casual Librarian, SciFi Scavenger,
The Brothers Gwynne, What Vivi did next, 2Cellos, Sunny Book Nook, Erin Janda Creative, We're in Hell, Ben and Emily, Adult Wednesday Addams -2 seasons, Ryan McBeth, Think That Through, Sort of Interesting, Activist Witch, aidan knight, The Mindful Narrowboat, The Paranormal Scholar, The Great War, Julie Nolke,
Grace McGuire, Austin McConnell, Sort of Interesting, Winging it on a Budget, OrangeRiver, Adelaide Beeman-White, Kady 2.0, Maiorianus, Real Time History, Kings and Generals, Black Lodge Games, Blackboot Official, Girls and Tanks, Bardcore, Aliensrock, allie_202, Lindsey Stirling, Squire, Ukraine Matters, Eleanor Morton, Smack the Pony,
Rowan J Coleman, Books with Chloe, Scallydandling About the Books, Jabzy, Mandy, Books with Emily Fox, Boat Time, Brandon Fisichella, Stevie Emerson, Vlad Vexler, Novara Media, Alice Cappelle, Natasha's Adventures, Lady of the Library, Petrik Leo, Fran Blanche, Tibees, Whitenoiz,
The Lorna Jane Adventures, The Shades of Orange, Battle Order, Jake Broe, Alex Fleev, Alt Shift X, Engineering with Rosie, Lucy Darling, Hej Sokoly, Depressed Russian, Crecganford, Then & Now, Russian Dude, Amie's Literary Empire, Luciana Orlandi, SciFi Odyssey, DW News, Zoe Bee, Historia Civilis, LIbrary Ladder, Swell Entertainment, OliviaReadsaLatte, Gingers are Black, Alyssa Matesic.
I wish you a lovely morning, a lazy afternoon, a relaxing evening, an exciting night and may we all continue learning.
Hope springs constantly, as well as eternally.
William Wallace