Blackhawk: Far Star Legends 1 pans in on a dusty, backwater town, then further into what is described very similarly to an ol' West waterin' hole. There's the classic "Fist Full of Dollars" gunfight, in which our hero (I won't use the term protagonist here, because it's very clear that Blackhawk is designed from the ground up to be a HERO with a capital H) guns down four drunken soldiers in self-defense.
That's the point the book had me.
"Space western?" I said to myself, thankfully with no one around to hear me ramble, "Oooooohhh, I fucking love these."
I read on eagerly.
Unfortunately, although the book continued to engage me, the western vibe was lost slowly but surely throughout the course of the book. I'd have gladly read three hundred pages about Blackhawk in that pseudo-western town, stuck between the Rohos and the Baxters.
For a while there it transitioned into something very Dune-like (Why the swords? What practical purpose?), then later on into some very light Military Sci-Fi. Fortunately for me, Dune is my favorite book of all time, and Military Sci-Fi is one of my guilty pleasures when it's not filled with political pulpit projectile vomiting... and this isn't. At all.
Blackhawk the character begins the book as a drunken wastrel in a tavern drinking away his memories. He has his gunfight with the Militia-jerks, is imprisoned, and meets the warlord Lucerne - WHO IS A GOOD MAN. LISTEN! YOU! LUCERNE IS GOOD! HONORABLE! BUT NOT TOO HONORABLE! JUST HONORABLE ENOUGH! ...and somehow Blackhawk notices this. Lucerne here is Duke Leto Atreides, let's be honest. There may be character development in further books that take him away from this, but in THIS book, he's Cap'n America. Even his prison is nice and humane, and everyone knows you can judge a society by how it treats it's prisoners.
Our HERO consents to work for Lucerne, is betrayed and captured, and taken prisoner by Ghana - Lucerne's rival warlord. Who's prison observed to be not nearly as nice, which leads to what I believe to be Blackhawk's most cold-blooded line in the book. Don't fret though - we're not on Geidi Prime just yet, not until we meet the man backing Ghana, Carteria. He's the Harkonnen.
The problem here, once again, is the author not quite trusting his reader - hell, for all I know this is a young-adult series, and I, being neither young nor an adult, am as far from the target audience as possible. But I doubt it. We are given information about a character or event, then, in the next paragraph, it is explained to us what the information we were just given implies.
Example:
'Blackhawk took a bite of the bread, chewing quickly and swallowing before he answered. “I think what you say is true…you’d like to know who is backing Ghana…” He looked over and stared intently at Lucerne. “…but I’d also guess you are really hoping to entice Ghana into breaking the truce…or gaining some information you can use to justify your own attack, a casus bellum of some kind.”
It was Lucerne’s turn to stare wordlessly for a few seconds. He was a man who hid his thoughts well, but now they were on his face to be read. He was impressed.
“You are an insightful man. And very correct. I cannot allow another three months of inactivity…and I cannot launch an unprovoked surprise attack.” He paused. “So, we must make something happen by other means, Mr. Blackhawk. We must find a way to engineer a resumption of hostilities as quickly as possible.”
Blackhawk took another bite of the bread. He was seeing Lucerne more clearly, and his esteem was growing. The men he’d seen in his life he’d have called good were few in number…and almost without exception they were weak fools. Their motivations might have been positive, but they were idealistic, believing what they needed to believe to sustain their outlooks. And, eventually, they were all destroyed by the nature of a universe they refused to see for what it was.'
Allan, Jay (2016-04-25). Blackhawk: Far Stars Legends I (Kindle Locations 708-718). System 7 Publishing. Kindle Edition.
If I had my druthers the last paragraph would've ended after "and his esteem was growing". The rest can be inferred from what little we already know about Blackhawk. This is a common problem with authors, and it really stands out in this book due to the competent writing around it.
We are beaten over the head until we're bloody with the fact that PEOPLE DIE IN WAR. We're not all gonna make it home, boys!
It gets tiring, to be honest, even in the midst of a book as entertaining as this one. Don't get me wrong, it's better than the Jingoistic piss-fests of certain Tombstone-esque Military Sci-Fi authors, but still... it grates on you after the first few times.
Also, the dialogue ping-pongs between really great, and kinda cringy. There's a scene in Ghana's prison where I thought to myself (not yet being aware that this is a prequel and there's an entire series already written after this) "Ah, the author's coming into the voice of this character nicely", when Blackhawk's internal dialog started becoming much more informal than his dialogue with the Gray Rebels. And then, later on in the book, Blackhawk's internal dialog once again becomes very formal and stilted towards the melodramatic. The opposite would be explained by his backsliding to his natural state as a human killing machine (tm), but becoming more formal as your personality devolves into savagery just makes no sense to me. Further exacerbating matters, at that point in the book EVERYONE'S dialogue becomes formal and melodramatic, robbing Blackhawk and most other characters of a distinctive voice.
Now, I'm going to relate to you the greatest tragedy of the book - Bulg Trax.
He heard the sound at the door, a loud clumsy knock. He’d know that sound anywhere. “Enter,” he said, turning around to face Bulg Trax. The soldier wasn’t just large, he wasn’t just strong and powerful. He was a colossus, a veritable mountain of a man. And he was Carteria’s creature, body and soul.
...
...
Bulg Trax was like a force of nature in combat, and Carteria had worked his henchmen into a near-frenzy. Failure was unthinkable to the huge soldier, and he would remember Carteria’s words, the sound of the Marshal’s voice calling him ‘old friend.’ Bulg Trax would obliterate anyone who came near the treasure convoy…and he would die, along with the thousand men under his command, before he would relinquish a single ducat.
Allan, Jay. Blackhawk: Far Stars Legends I (Kindle Locations 2721-2724). System 7 Publishing. Kindle Edition.
When I read that, I made a note to myself which read: "I want to know RIGHT NOW why Bulg Trax is so loyal... maybe later?"
But no, not later. Never. Never ever is a specific reason given as to why Trax would follow Carteria to the very gates of hell. I was hoping for a cool story, or maybe a very slight softening of Carteria. But I got nothing... this wouldn't be a big deal to anybody else, I'd imagine, but for some reason I was immediately fascinated with Bulg Trax: The man who followed a monster.
Don't let me put you off, however. This book is overall very enjoyable - there were several times while reading I thought to myself
"That's a very clever way to do that - good on the author."
At one point Captain Sand, who was until recently the warden of the desert prison, (I KNOW! I KNOW!) jumped to a conclusion that, while completely wrong, was both reasonable and moved the plot forward. I would've clapped, but I'd have dropped the book.
There was a point about halfway through the book when I thought to myself - "Awesome - I just figured out how the good guys are going to win."
I was dead wrong. Couldn't have BEEN more wrong, actually, and I was super happy with that. (Rarely am I happy with being wrong.) Not only did what I predict not come to pass, what I thought was going to be a deus ex machina turned out to be a major complication for our heroes.
Jay Allan is full of surprises. Good surprises.
This book is worth a read if you've heard anything I've referenced, and liked it.
Dune, Tri-Gun, Firefly, Non-Political Military Sci-Fi - Hell, if you liked Star Wars, The Man With No Name, and Captain America all at once at any time in your life, I'd say give it a go.