Books that humanize the topic of illegal immigration have become more commonplace in YA over the past couple of years, which is a much appreciated trend especially given the recent election cycle.
In Something in Between, Melissa de La Cruz introduces readers to Jasmine, an accomplished high school senior living in Southern California. While Jasmine has dreams of attending elite colleges, the discovery that she’s an undocumented immigrant seems like it’s about to derail that plan…
I've read a number of YA books discussing the odyssey of undocumented immigrants over the years, and I was struck by just how relatable Jasmine's journey felt. While I'm sure part of it could be attributed to the fact that Jasmine - like me! - is from Southern California (more or less), the majority of the relatability was due to the fact that de la Cruz has done a remarkable job of charting and humanizing a disorientating, complicated journey.
Because Jasmine makes that discovery that she's an undocumented immigrant in the worst possible way: she's about to accept a prestigious scholarship, but has to decline because it would shine too much attention to her status. By not accepting the scholarship, Jasmine is also opening the door to the idea that she may not even have a future in this country, as well.
While the stakes for Jasmine's journey didn't necessarily felt as urgent as Alma's in Dream Things True, De la Cruz does a wonderful job of reiterating to the reader that Jasmine's core journey isn't just that of an undocumented immigrant. Though it's very much occupying the bulk of her thoughts, Jasmine still has very normal teenaged struggles, including family drama, romance issues and friendship struggles.
And that's really the crux of this book. It's a reminder that even though there are many who would like the undocumented immigrant issue to become a broad, faceless issue where those who are caught up in the struggle are very much viewed as the other, there actually is a face, a story and a dream behind each of these stories. De la Cruz is essentially reminding us the importance of not othering these individuals, a reminder that is sure to resonate deeply with all readers.
My one issue with the book though, was with the romance. While Royce was undoubtedly charming, the entire situation just felt a tad too convenient, given the timing and the situation. Because of course, Royce's father was a politician who had the capacity to help Jasmine's situation. It's a bit clichéd, but does help drive a few important points forward.
*Minor spoilers ahead*
While I'll acknowledge that Jasmine's accomplishments don't necessarily merit the consideration that normally comes with the sponsorship for a private bill, I do absolutely understand why de la Cruz chose to have Jasmine have access to an easier, happier ending.
There are too many who view undocumented immigrants as something to be feared and/or a topic of strong debate, and de la Cruz shows readers that more often than not, those who are undocumented and seeking access to citizenship only want the same quality of life that many of us take for granted. It's a bit of a broad lesson, but a much appreciated one.