Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Voluntary City: Choice, Community, and Civil Society

Rate this book
Assembling a rich history and analysis of large-scale, private and voluntary, community-based provision of social services, urban infrastructure, and community governance, this book provides suggestions on how to restore the vitality of city life. Historically, the city was considered a center of commerce, knowledge, and culture, a haven for safety and a place of opportunity. Today, however, cities are widely viewed as centers for crime, homelessness, drug wars, business failure, impoverishment, transit gridlock, illiteracy, pollution, unemployment, and other social ills. In many cities, government increasingly dominates life, consuming vast resources to cater to special-interest groups. This book reveals how the process of providing local public goods through the dynamism of freely competitive, market-based entrepreneurship is unmatched in renewing communities and strengthening the bonds of civil society.

869 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 1, 2002

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

David T. Beito

14 books12 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
21 (39%)
4 stars
23 (43%)
3 stars
8 (15%)
2 stars
1 (1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews
Profile Image for Nick.
716 reviews199 followers
May 19, 2010
A vindication of Anarcho-Capitalism. 9/10 times when someone says that Libertarianism cannot work "in the real world" I am able to flip to a chapter of this book and say "well it did".
Profile Image for Kevin Gomez.
25 reviews6 followers
March 29, 2018
Wonderful essays on the emergence of associations to take care of societal issues.
4 reviews
July 11, 2026
An incredibly important insight into Enclosure.

Enclosure version 1 (named by David Lipschitz) lasted for the past 500 years. Enclosure is fully called Enclosure of the Commons. The Commons are what we all own and the rights we all have. If you want a full understanding of Enclosure version 1 and The Commons, read "The Voluntary City" by Beito, etc.

But this guy, David Lipschitz, has invented a new term: "Enclosure version 2".

Enclosure version 1 was done by the elite, initially by Kings and other Landed Gentry (Lords and Ladies with Royal (given by Kings and Queens) titles). It allowed for 4 industrial revolutions where people became more and more expert and got awarded titles such as Bachelor (a degree), Master, Doctor, Doctorate, Professor, Expert, and many more degrees (of excellence (whose excellence?)). All these "degrees" where awarded directly or indirectly by Royal Charter, and this charter was needed to start a university or some such institution of learning; and the learning was required to create the experts that the Industrial Revolutions needed.

Enclosure version 2, which is discussed in David's book, "A User Manual for Life on Earth", presents a different possibility. Enclosure v1 was (is) about centralisation. It's about redirecting all economic activity via a centre. The centre could be the fiscus, and the fiscus could be a King's fiscus, or a government's fiscus. This allows the centrists to take their rents (also known as corruption), but this got out of control where so much money was flowing via the centre that people there started taking too much money for themselves and not leaving anything for the decentrists (taxpayer and poor people (David defines a poor person as someone who doesn't pay tax (note that a poor person is not the same as a destitute person))).

Enclosure version 2 is about lowering costs. We have already seen this, with free communications, free GPS, free phone calls, free weather reports, free satellite images, free education, all available in the palm of our hands on a "smart" device. In exchange for this freedom, you give up your right to privacy, and someone somewhere knows everything about you, in fact they know more about you than you know about yourself. On a positive note, passports and visas shouldn't be required anymore. On a negative note, we don't understand privacy anymore. But at the same time as this, costs of government goods such as electricity, water, petrol, transport, health insurance, etc are spiraling up out of control, and money supply is "easing" and is also out of control.

"A User Manual for Life on Earth" explains how we (taxpayers and poor people) can permanently get out of debt and how we can have free electricity, water, sewerage, waste, food. And why would you want that? Because you would get back your rights because all this happens decentrally at the boundary rather than in the centre.

Want to read more?

https://www.smashwords.com/books/view...
389 reviews6 followers
February 4, 2022
A bit of a slog in the second half, but excellent research and examples of voluntary organizing to solve large scale problems that many think can only be solved by coercive government. From fraternal societies like the Elks who provided life insurance and health care subsidies, to subdevelopments that provided roads (!), Utilities, and policing, there are unexpected examples from the last 300+ years. Interesting notes about the evolution of policing, from initially being privately funded dealing with mainly property disputes, to the more modern form focused on population control and compliance. Worth a read if you're interested in libertarian/market based alternatives.
Profile Image for Shane.
631 reviews19 followers
April 30, 2020
This is a fascinating collection of essays that examine how governance can and has developed in addition to or often in place of Government. There is a little speculation, but the vast majority of the essays are historical references. From the examination of Private Neighborhoods to Fraternal Societies and private law enforcement.

It was very interesting to see how many 'market failures' were solved by private means long before they ever 'failed'.
Profile Image for Zach Boyle.
28 reviews3 followers
August 14, 2019
The parts about mutual aid societies, mutual anti-crime societies, and non-profit turnpikes were new to me and stuff I had not learned from Mises.org or other sites. However overall this book is a good overview, even if some of the stuff is review.
Profile Image for Eric Harris.
23 reviews20 followers
June 27, 2018
The more I read of history and distant places, the less convinced I am that there are some good things that are inherently government activities. This book, for instance.
Profile Image for E Miller.
30 reviews
June 25, 2009
At age 32, Henry Charles was a carpenter living in what is now the North Side of Pittsburgh. On July 16, 1849, Charles dropped a cigar in his shop, starting a fire. The Allegheny City Fire department refused to extinguish the blaze because they were on strike. The fires spread to adjoining blocks and destroyed the newly constructed First Presbyterian Church. It was eventually extinguished by Allegheny City residents.

This story could either be used to extol the benefits of a free market--if the fire department was a private enterprise, surely profit would motivate its extinguishment--or more likely convince a populace that laws must prevent economics and political goals from standing in the way of a roaring blaze.

The Voluntary City, a collection of essays, tries to make the point that communities can be formed by choice, rather than run by a rigid, overbearing government entity.

MORE: http://www.newcolonist.com/br-volunta...
Profile Image for Nathan Titus.
126 reviews10 followers
April 16, 2013
Extremely well reseached, with all the xyz's of how to make a society open to all exist in the here and now laid out. While I don't agree with everything the book says, all the essays are insightful and intrigueing. Also desturbing at times: it really makes you think "so THAT'S why things are set up the way they are!" The conclusion isn't that the system is broken, but that it works perfectly at what it's meant to do. Scary stuff.
Profile Image for Sean.
9 reviews2 followers
August 14, 2012
Good for folks who want to learn the really dry, nitty gritty details of stateless societies.
Profile Image for Jon.
8 reviews
December 28, 2007
couldn't finish it, although some of it is interesting.
109 reviews2 followers
Read
April 2, 2011
Interesting book, but I just couldn't finish it.
Displaying 1 - 13 of 13 reviews