I’ve been waiting for Jae’s “Something in the Wine” to come out on Audiobook for awhile now, and I was intrigued at the very similar plot of Gerri Hill’s “The Roundabout”. Two people fake dating to get others off their back…what could go wrong? Or right?
As usual, Gerri Hill’s writing style and dialogue is enjoyable. The MCs aren’t particularly amazing or memorable, but I like them well enough. The narrator did a fine job. All in all, I would normally flesh out this review a bit and probably give the book 4*.
But. There’s a BIG BUT.
Virtually the entire book revolves around one of the MC being tormented by another woman in town. Megan drank too much at her 39th birthday party, and was left by her sister and friends at MaryBeth’s place. Marybeth stripped the unconscious Megan naked, took nude photos of her, and throughout the book systematically posts more and more revealing photos on Facebook in an effort to get Megan to date her. Oh yes, she also stole her bra and wore it to further torment Megan. Naturally, Megan’s sister and the ENTIRE TOWN thinks this is hilarious and follow the ongoing cyberattacks as if…oh, hell, I don’t know how to compare this crime to anything.
Megan’s sister, and even her love interest Leah, actually blame Megan for this situation. After all, they say, it’s HER FAULT FOR HAVING DRUNK TOO MUCH! Yup…blame the victim. Had she left the apartment in a short skirt and been raped, perhaps that too would have been her fault! Oh, by the way…Megan’s sister ends up falling in love with the miscreant and tells Megan about enjoying sex (with toys!) with the loser!
If this book had been written by a man, there would be protests in the streets. I really cannot understand what Gerri Hill was thinking. If we as women are to expect equality FOR women, we must expect equality FROM women. “Blame the victim” culture is NOT ACCEPTABLE. No matter how well written or narrated this book is…I hate the message. I cannot and will not accept a book that glorifies rape or victimhood just because everyone in the story agrees it’s “all in fun”. Hell, didn’t people think lynchings of blacks was “all in fun” decades ago?
The more I reflect on this book, and I hate reflecting on this abhorrent message, the more I dislike the book. What should have been a sweet story is really a mean spirited hateful story. I’m giving this book 1* and returning it to Audible. Gerri Hill owes all women…hell….all men and women….an abject apology.