Welcome to the grand finale to my camp marathon, round 3. This time the twitter voters went with a trip back to Tales from the Scaremaster. I read one earlier this year and found it to be very middling. It had a fair concept kinda ruined by having to literally involve a scare master which made it overly complicated.
I was interested to see if this camp entry was better so let’s see if it is. Katie Wong is at Camp Redwood where she gets an enemy in the form of Noah, a prankster with tree hugger parents. They get stuck together with kitchen duty after she sneaks out to stop one of his pranks.
They find an odd book called Tales from the Scaremaster, which tells them a story about trouble that is just starting. Then odd things happen, with the once nice counselors doing weird things like basically turning the place into a factory, making the kids work. They figure out what is going on, as the scare master may have plans up his sleeve.
This was a solid step up from Vampire Weekend. Scaremaster is heavily involved which was a shame at first but it’s used better here. Logic is still spotty but they prove to be a bigger threat as everything that happens for their gain. It’s a larger scale story which works for some creepy moments. In the other one, it was a normal plot that Mx. Master is shoved into.
Katie and Noah have good chemistry as they grow to bond as friends and there’s enough charm in here. Pacing is steady enough and writing is fair. There are these extra friends they again who are like but they just kind of randomly become important, it’s weird. The climax is a bit anti climatic, while we’re on flaws.
The camp setting is nothing too special here, it’s mostly just there. It’s more of a mild good but it did work better than the first one I read. It flows well and it was generally fun. Basic for sure, but the large scale makes it work. Nothing too special but had enough charm to make it enjoyable. I wish the series didn’t need the literal scare master but it at least used it well.
This one again has a little cliffhanger with the first part of the next book being an epilogue here, which is sneaky. Overall, not the biggest finale for our thing but not a bad one.
That ends Camp Marathon 3. Overall, this might be our most solid batch yet. We tended to get old favorites vs new stuff but it did result in mostly solid books. More ones I can remember this time, which is good. A few middling good ones but mostly solid stuff. Here’s my ranking:
A Pocket Full of Frogs
Evil at Camp Star
Clone Camp
Camp Zombie
The Dinosaur that Followed me Home
We Three
Camp Murderface
Tales too Scary to Tell at Camp
Bigfoot, Big Trouble
So yeah, mostly horror which meant fun times. I’m not leaving it at 3, I will keep doing these for as long as I can so check in next June when we do it all again. Sorry I didn’t read much outside of these, i should have more time and get out of this slump soon enough lol. Next we’ve got our ripoff round we already started on along with some misc ideas and a Fear Street trilogy review.
May as well bust out the wheel to see which ripoff series we tackle next, as we already started anyway. It would be funny if I got another camp one as a couple still have one. Well it picked Deadtime stories and with only two left (Plz put up Farie Tale and Tiny Town 2) I just flipped a online coin and looks like we have Beast of Baskerville, see ya then.