Inaccurate capitalistic book about unsustainable industrial farming that lacks proper animal welfare.
From the very beginning, the tone is strikingly cold and product-driven. The opening line frames a farm simply as “a place for producing products.” That might sound straightforward, but it reduces farming to a purely capitalistic endeavor, stripping away the deeper relationship between humans, land, and animals. For a children’s book, that’s a troubling foundation.
The presentation of animals also feels impersonal and, at times, misleading. Chickens are described as “cage free,” but there’s no mention of what that actually means (and it certainly doesn’t equal pasture-raised or humane conditions). Both cows and chickens are depicted eating grain rather than grazing naturally on grass—again reinforcing an industrialized picture of farming rather than a sustainable or accurate one. The animals themselves come across as commodities rather than living beings with needs and instincts.
On the crop side, the book promotes outdated, unsustainable methods like plowing and monocropping without addressing the environmental consequences. Worse, some of the information is simply incorrect. For example, the text suggests pumpkins “grow in the fall,” when in reality, they are planted earlier in the season and harvested in the fall. Mistakes like this are confusing for children and undermine the book’s credibility.
Overall, Farm Animals misses an opportunity to teach children about the beauty, complexity, and responsibility of farming. Instead, it presents a narrow, money-focused, and at times inaccurate view. Families looking for a more holistic and truthful introduction to farm life may want to explore other titles that highlight sustainability, animal welfare, and the rhythms of nature rather than the bottom line.