So I'm going to review this in two ways. First as a teen from a rural area who was only able to get books from her small town school library while school was in session and who was desperate to read and loved horror. Second as an adult who has since grown her own library to five hundred or more and had read many many books. Both masterpieces and utter trash.
My teen self would have given this book five stars. I remember LOVING it. Short chapters, short read, to the point, interesting, and employed all the innocuous high school drama tropes and characters I needed to relate with. It wasn't scary but intriguing. It wasn't horror-filled but made me yearn to read the next. So teen Amanda gives it *****
Adult Amanda can compare it to classics like War of the Worlds or Frankenstein. I can rate it against extremely well-written books like The Devil's Queen and books that really intrigued me like Sapkowski's. Adult me on these merits would give this book two stars for its entire plot of telling and not showing, for how I felt thoughts, feelings, words, and names were constantly repeated, and because character dialog and actions sometimes seemed out of character. But because my past self loved it so dearly and because it has a few pros like being a quick, easy read and being interesting enough to keep going, because it didn't drag out and bog down with information, adult Amanda gives it *** Which I don't think is all that bad.