Berit Olam: Ruth and Esther

by Tod Linafelt, Timothy Beal

Some ancient works of literature survive in fragments that appear so simple and complete it's hard to imagine them as being part of a larger narrative. Such is the case with Ruth and Esther. On first reading they appear so simple, so whole, and their meanings so completely self-evident. Yet the closer you look, the more perplexing they become. Ruth and Esther offers that close look, enabling readers to discover the uncertainties of the texts and demonstrating how these uncertainties are not problems to be solved, but rather are integral to the narrative art of these texts. In Ruth , the first part of this volume, Tod Linafelt highlights the most unresolved and perplexing aspects of Ruth. In doing so he offers an interpretation he calls "unsettling." Linafelt states that it is unsettling in the sense that he often refuses to ?settle? on a single, unequivocal meaning of a particular word, phrase, or theme. Rather he prefers to underscore the dual or even multiple meanings that the narrative so often has. Another way Ruth differs from other interpretations is that Linafelt entertains the possibility that there might be complexity or ambiguity with regard to the various characters? motivations, the presentation of God, or the book?s purpose. In this commentary, Linafelt explores the ambiguities of meaning built into the grammar, syntax, and vocabulary of the story to discover how these ambiguities carry over to the larger interpretive issues of characterization, theology, and purpose. He also lays forth an argument that the book of Ruth is intended to be read as an interlude between Judges and Samuel. The second part of this volume focuses on Esther, a story of anti-Judaism that raises strikingly contemporary questions concerning relations between sexism, ethnocentrism, and national identity. In Esther Timothy Beal guides readers into the meaning of the story using rhetorical criticism. He asks questions without assuming that there must be answers and allows for complexity, perplexity, and the importance of accidents in the text. In essence, Beal emphasizes the particular over the general and the tentative over the continuous; however, he does not altogether dismiss the importance of broader interpretations of Esther, especially those focusing on narrative structure. Chapters in Ruth are ?The Bond between Ruth and Naomi,? ?Finding Favor in Boaz?s Field,? ?An Ambiguous Encounter in the Night,? and ?Making It All Legal.? Chapters in Esther are ?Beginning with the End of Esther 1:1-22,? ?Remembering to Esther 2:1-4,? ?New Family Esther 2:5-18,? ? Esther 2:19-23,? ?Politics of Esther 3:1-15,? ?Another Esther 4:1-17,? ?Face to Esther 5:1-8,? ?Fifty Cubits for Esther 5:9-14,? ?Sleep Esther 6:1-14,? ?Coming Out Esther 7:1- 10,? ? Esther 8:1-17,? and ? Esther 9:1?10:3.?

272 pages, Hardcover

First published July 1, 1999

About the author

Tod Linafelt is professor of biblical literature in the Theology Department at Georgetown University.

Reviews

[Cameron Barham]

“With regards to the human characters and their motivations, for example, I find that far from exemplifying a simple godliness and unquestioned morality, they are a mass of conflicting desires and vested interests, each of them existing within the bounds of a societal structure that limits a person in severe ways depending on one’s gender, social class, and nationality, yet each struggling in some way to transcend or subvert those bounds.”, in “Ruth” by Tod Linafelt, p. xv