What do you think?
Rate this book
Miss Darcy's Companion: A Pride and Prejudice Variation
Miss Georgiana Darcy is in need of a companion, and she would much rather not have Mrs Younge. The recently bereaved Miss Elizabeth Bennet is in need of a position. When she accepts the one Mr Darcy offers, she finds herself in his near-constant company and gets to know him at his best. Not as he would present himself to strangers in some remote corner of Hertfordshire, but as his nearest and dearest know him. An excellent brother, landlord, master. A wonderful man, noble, kind – and impossibly handsome. So who falls in love first? What of Mr Wickham and his dastardly ploys? And how is a lady’s companion ever to have a future with one who could marry into the best houses in the land?(2023 cover. Storyline unchanged)
238 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 10, 2016
151 people are currently reading
263 people want to read
About the author
Joana Starnes
21 books250 followersJoana Starnes lives in the south of England with her family. She swapped several hats over the years – physician, lecturer, clinical data analyst – but feels most comfortable in a bonnet. She has been living in Georgian England for decades in her imagination, and plans to continue in that vein till she lays hands on a time machine. She loves to look for glimpses of Pemberley and Jane Austen’s world, and to write about Regency England and Mr Darcy falling in love with Elizabeth Bennet over and over and over again.
She is the author of ten Austen-inspired novels and a contributor to the Quill Ink Anthologies. Joana’s novels are all available on Amazon in Kindle Unlimited and in paperback, and some have also been released in Audible.
You can connect with Joana on: Goodreads ; Facebook ; Twitter ; Instagram ; Website and at Austen Variations or visit Joana’s Facebook page All Roads Lead to Pemberley for places and details that have inspired her novels.
She is the author of ten Austen-inspired novels and a contributor to the Quill Ink Anthologies. Joana’s novels are all available on Amazon in Kindle Unlimited and in paperback, and some have also been released in Audible.
You can connect with Joana on: Goodreads ; Facebook ; Twitter ; Instagram ; Website and at Austen Variations or visit Joana’s Facebook page All Roads Lead to Pemberley for places and details that have inspired her novels.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 103 reviews
December 30, 2018
Georgiana Darcy is thrown into company with Miss Bennet while G.’s brother, Fitzwilliam, and her cousin, Richard, make their annual trek to Kent…not knowing that Richard’s older brother’s wife, Lady Stretton, and her three children are also visiting at Malvern House, the home of Lord and Lady Malvern. Cousin, Amelia Fitzwilliam was to be her sole company, as she is of Georgiana’s age and of an open disposition akin to her brother, Richard. Upon returning Darcy reflects that he might not have left her there if he had known of Lady Stretton’s plans to also visit. (That Lady reminded me of Aunt Reed while her son, Hartfield, has an uncanny resemblance in his misbehaviors to Jane Eyre’s cousin, John Reed, in that novel.) A short time later we find Georgiana pleading with her two guardians to hire Miss Bennet as her companion rather than Mrs. Younge. Despite some misgivings due to the age and lack of experience on Miss Bennet’s part she is hired. Soon Georgiana and Miss Bennet are sent back to Pemberley while Darcy addresses business in town.
When Darcy does join the two young ladies in the country he finds two things: Georgiana is relaxed, happy and very obviously has developed a warm friendship with Miss Bennet. The other thing he finds is that Miss Bennet is not afraid to speak her mind. But they soon come to an understanding and he finds himself enjoying evenings playing a game of chess or even debating a book with Miss Bennet as well as enjoying watching his sister and her interact. Imagine his puzzlement when, after a Christmas Ball during which he and Richard come upon the two hiding out near the orangery, spying on the ball and then being coaxed into a dance, Elizabeth seems to withdraw from his company, turning down games of chess and presenting a much more reserved mien while in his presence.
We the readers find ODC have much angst as each cannot fathom ever overcoming the gulf between their positions in society to satisfy newly discovered feelings of attachment between them. Darcy soon departs for London to debate with himself how to reconcile those disturbances to his peace while Elizabeth makes plans for the near future to join Jane and her new husband at their estate, Netherfield, near her old home.
Joana Starnes has a talent in relating the feelings of love to us. She doesn’t find it necessary to write graphic sexual details but every nuance of the heart is laid bare with words of tenderness, longing, mind-boggling depths of yearning that it brings me to dewy-eyed sighs of appreciation for her art.
Georgiana rates much more page time in this book. She has her opinions and relates them to Darcy. She also is not afraid to correct miscalculations he has made. A vicar, Mr. Bradden, and his sister show an interest in our Elizabeth. We read of Wickham again, along with a Miss Fenton’s aid, plying his deceit in searching for that pot of gold, a dowry earned through seduction. Can Elizabeth, who knows nothing about his history with Darcy, intuit his intentions and his true character? Your heart will cry for ODG when Elizabeth’s quick thinking and reputation saving actions paint a picture completely opposite in Darcy’s mind.
I loved this story and guarantee that it is one that I will read over and over again. Elizabeth is not immune to suffering the pangs of unrequited love in this variation…but Darcy does have his moments of longing also. Do read this story!
All of Joana Starnes’ books have rated 5 stars for me. I look forward to her next release.
12/23/18: I began "reading" this story for the second time listening to it on Audible as I do my morning walks. 12/29/18: finished listening to this story today - loved it all over again.
When Darcy does join the two young ladies in the country he finds two things: Georgiana is relaxed, happy and very obviously has developed a warm friendship with Miss Bennet. The other thing he finds is that Miss Bennet is not afraid to speak her mind. But they soon come to an understanding and he finds himself enjoying evenings playing a game of chess or even debating a book with Miss Bennet as well as enjoying watching his sister and her interact. Imagine his puzzlement when, after a Christmas Ball during which he and Richard come upon the two hiding out near the orangery, spying on the ball and then being coaxed into a dance, Elizabeth seems to withdraw from his company, turning down games of chess and presenting a much more reserved mien while in his presence.
We the readers find ODC have much angst as each cannot fathom ever overcoming the gulf between their positions in society to satisfy newly discovered feelings of attachment between them. Darcy soon departs for London to debate with himself how to reconcile those disturbances to his peace while Elizabeth makes plans for the near future to join Jane and her new husband at their estate, Netherfield, near her old home.
Joana Starnes has a talent in relating the feelings of love to us. She doesn’t find it necessary to write graphic sexual details but every nuance of the heart is laid bare with words of tenderness, longing, mind-boggling depths of yearning that it brings me to dewy-eyed sighs of appreciation for her art.
Georgiana rates much more page time in this book. She has her opinions and relates them to Darcy. She also is not afraid to correct miscalculations he has made. A vicar, Mr. Bradden, and his sister show an interest in our Elizabeth. We read of Wickham again, along with a Miss Fenton’s aid, plying his deceit in searching for that pot of gold, a dowry earned through seduction. Can Elizabeth, who knows nothing about his history with Darcy, intuit his intentions and his true character? Your heart will cry for ODG when Elizabeth’s quick thinking and reputation saving actions paint a picture completely opposite in Darcy’s mind.
I loved this story and guarantee that it is one that I will read over and over again. Elizabeth is not immune to suffering the pangs of unrequited love in this variation…but Darcy does have his moments of longing also. Do read this story!
All of Joana Starnes’ books have rated 5 stars for me. I look forward to her next release.
12/23/18: I began "reading" this story for the second time listening to it on Audible as I do my morning walks. 12/29/18: finished listening to this story today - loved it all over again.
June 19, 2016
This is yet another gem from Joana Starnes! When I really, really love a book it's just about impossible to put it down, and I read this all in one sitting.
The book is cleverly divided into two sections. Part One, "Darcy," is the beginning of the tale from Darcy's point of view, though still written in third person. At the urging of his cousin, Colonel Fitzwilliam, he hires Miss Elizabeth Bennet as companion to Georgiana. Step by step, it becomes obvious that the threesome of Darcy, Elizabeth and Georgiana have become a family unit. It also becomes obvious to the reader, through various hints, that Elizabeth has fallen deeply in love with her employer but that he doesn't have a clue. It becomes equally obvious that Darcy loves her but hasn't realized it himself. A turning point in their relationship occurs as this section ends. Part Two, "Elizabeth," picks up the story where Part One left off, but now the perspective is limited to Elizabeth's until close to the end. By the time we reach the book's climax and a horrible misunderstanding related to the despicable Wickham, the tale shifts back and forth between the two.
I can't begin to convey how powerfully this story engages the reader's emotions. Elizabeth is in such an awkward position. Even more than in the original Pride and Prejudice, she is too far beneath Darcy's social strata to ever hope that he might develop feelings for her, but she can't bring herself to go away, knowing she would never see him again. When Darcy suddenly leaves Pemberley, she is bereft. Wickham enters the story, he is charm personified, of course, and he insinuates himself back into Pemberley very credibly.
The plot is perfectly constructed, the characters are well drawn, the writing is flawless, and the entire book packs a whopping emotional punch. JAFF doesn't get any better than this!
The book is cleverly divided into two sections. Part One, "Darcy," is the beginning of the tale from Darcy's point of view, though still written in third person. At the urging of his cousin, Colonel Fitzwilliam, he hires Miss Elizabeth Bennet as companion to Georgiana. Step by step, it becomes obvious that the threesome of Darcy, Elizabeth and Georgiana have become a family unit. It also becomes obvious to the reader, through various hints, that Elizabeth has fallen deeply in love with her employer but that he doesn't have a clue. It becomes equally obvious that Darcy loves her but hasn't realized it himself. A turning point in their relationship occurs as this section ends. Part Two, "Elizabeth," picks up the story where Part One left off, but now the perspective is limited to Elizabeth's until close to the end. By the time we reach the book's climax and a horrible misunderstanding related to the despicable Wickham, the tale shifts back and forth between the two.
I can't begin to convey how powerfully this story engages the reader's emotions. Elizabeth is in such an awkward position. Even more than in the original Pride and Prejudice, she is too far beneath Darcy's social strata to ever hope that he might develop feelings for her, but she can't bring herself to go away, knowing she would never see him again. When Darcy suddenly leaves Pemberley, she is bereft. Wickham enters the story, he is charm personified, of course, and he insinuates himself back into Pemberley very credibly.
The plot is perfectly constructed, the characters are well drawn, the writing is flawless, and the entire book packs a whopping emotional punch. JAFF doesn't get any better than this!
June 27, 2017
In this P&P what if we are asked to imagine what would happen had Mr. Bennet shuffled off his mortal coil long before Mr. Bingley ever heard of Hertfordshire. And the eldest Miss Bennets went to live in London and Lizzy went into service. First she is working as an undergoverness for Col. Fitzwilliam's witchy sister in law. Then Georgiana begs Darcy to hire Lizzy as her companion and Mrs. Younge gets the thanks but no thanks and Lizzy is off to Pemberley with the Darcys.
Once there she quickly finds herself falling in love with Fitzwilliam Darcy and since she knows as far as she has fallen in her social standing there is no hope of his reciprocating her feelings and even if he did he would never act upon them. So she throws herself into caring for Georgiana while all but snubbing Mr. Darcy. And of course Darcy is falling in love with the darling Miss Bennet but his better judgment, his family's expectations, the inferiority of her birth, his rank and circumstance have him running off to London to avoid her. This opens the door for Wickham to do the voodoo that he do so well and he is soon a frequent caller at Pemberley. Luckily Mrs. Reynolds warns Lizzy that Mr. Wickham has turned out very wild. But Mr. Darcy misinterprets the whole thing and thinking he is warning Lizzy off Wickham while she thinks he is warning her against him. So we have some more gross misunderstanding to get through before we can all live HEA.
My pet peeve: the use of the word Pray as an adverb. Pray was used so much I started to feel like I was at a tent revival. I used the search feature on my Kindle and it is used 82 times. That averages out to once every 3 pages.
Again it doesn't take a month and half to read this book, I was enticed away and finally forced myself to clean up all my 1/2 read titles.
Once there she quickly finds herself falling in love with Fitzwilliam Darcy and since she knows as far as she has fallen in her social standing there is no hope of his reciprocating her feelings and even if he did he would never act upon them. So she throws herself into caring for Georgiana while all but snubbing Mr. Darcy. And of course Darcy is falling in love with the darling Miss Bennet but his better judgment, his family's expectations, the inferiority of her birth, his rank and circumstance have him running off to London to avoid her. This opens the door for Wickham to do the voodoo that he do so well and he is soon a frequent caller at Pemberley. Luckily Mrs. Reynolds warns Lizzy that Mr. Wickham has turned out very wild. But Mr. Darcy misinterprets the whole thing and thinking he is warning Lizzy off Wickham while she thinks he is warning her against him. So we have some more gross misunderstanding to get through before we can all live HEA.
My pet peeve: the use of the word Pray as an adverb. Pray was used so much I started to feel like I was at a tent revival. I used the search feature on my Kindle and it is used 82 times. That averages out to once every 3 pages.
Again it doesn't take a month and half to read this book, I was enticed away and finally forced myself to clean up all my 1/2 read titles.
May 13, 2019
Always a fan of Joana Starnes' books! I read this latest over a few nights. The first few chapters were a bit slow while setting the scene--despite the fact we find our beloved Lizzy Bennet in reduced circumstances or the scenes of how she came to be the governess of a mini-tyrant to paid companion of Miss Darcy. But once the story arrives at Pemberley (about Chapter 6), I found myself absolutely invested and finished the rest in one night. Lots of heart pounding action, tender moments of retrospection, hope, and angst. I was whole heartedly satisfied and thought "Miss Darcy's Companion" a delightful read. If you are new to this writer, I must recommend some of my favorites:
"The Falmouth Connection" and
"The Unthinkable Triangle." I look forward to Joana Starnes next work!
"The Falmouth Connection" and
"The Unthinkable Triangle." I look forward to Joana Starnes next work!
October 15, 2016
What If Elizabeth Worked for Mr. Darcy?
TYPE OF AUSTENESQUE NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
TIME FRAME: Several months before Mr. Bingley signs a lease for Netherfield Park
MAIN CHARACTERS: Elizabeth Bennet, Mr. Darcy, and Georgiana Darcy
SYNOPSIS: What if there was no Ramsgate, no overheard insult, and no surprise encounter in Kent? What if Darcy first met Elizabeth Bennet as a nursemaid/stand-in governess for his cousin’s children? And what if Georgiana expressly wished for Darcy to hire Elizabeth as her companion? With her father passed away and Longbourn taken over by the odious Mr. Collins, Elizabeth happily accepts this position, even though she has no experience. Will she find her new employer to be haughty and high-handed? Or will she see him as kind and generous?
WHAT I LOVED:
- Harmony and Happiness at Pemberley: This story takes us to Pemberley and stays there for nearly all of the book, with only slight mentions and visits to Netherfield and Rosings. I loved the focus on Pemberley and sense of idyllic contentment that pervaded this variation as we witnessed Elizabeth, Darcy, and Georgiana find pleasure, peace, and companionship in each other’s company with no interference. Pemberley is such a lovely setting for romance to blossom and I loved seeing the happiness and easy camaraderie between this trio.
- Woven Into Canon: With no Ramsgate, no Mr. Bennet, and no extended visit to Meryton, you may wonder if any of the same events will take place in this variation. Will there be a first proposal? Will Wickham cause any harm? I loved how, even though this story started so drastically different with altered situations for many characters, Joana Starnes found unique and clever ways to tie her variation to Jane Austen’s original canon. Especially her in regards to our favorite foils – Caroline Bingley and Mr. Wickham!
- Tempered Reserve: In many of Joana Starnes’s variations she delivers healthy doses of anguish and heartache to poor Mr. Darcy. But in this variation, the shoe is on the other foot! Mr. Darcy, being proper and honorable, does not give much romantic thought to his sister’s charming and lively companion and is quite slow to recognize his feelings. But Elizabeth, seeing Mr. Darcy in this different perspective, cannot help but admire him and think him “the best of men.” And her admiration easily leads to affection – an affection she tries to suppress and conceal because she knows there is no hope. I really enjoyed seeing Ms. Starnes explore these more reserved and private feelings of yearning and turmoil from Elizabeth’s perspective. AndI loved how she couldn’t resist giving Darcy a bit of torture and agony (which made us love him even more!).
- Georgiana: It is lovely to see Georgiana blossom in this variation. She has her shy reserve, but learns maturity and confidence with Elizabeth as her dear friend and companion. I enjoyed seeing Georgiana grow, think for herself, and become more assertive. Definitely some admirable development for her character!
- New Original Characters: Since we stay mostly at Pemberley, we don’t see much of the Bennets, de Bourghs, and the Bingleys. Instead we are introduced to several new original characters fashioned by Joana Starnes. These characters were well-constructed and interesting as they propelled the plot in various ways. (Note: I loved the helpful New Characters List in the front of the book!)
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
That now I will have an even harder time deciding which story by Joana Starnes is my favorite!
CONCLUSION:
Sensitive, poignant, and gloriously impassioned – skilled storyteller Joana Starnes gifts readers another stellar Pride and Prejudice variation that will once again inspire them to fall deeply and irrevocably in love with Mr. Darcy! While this story might have a little more quiet reserve and suppressed passion, I think it is just as beautiful and stirring! Another brilliant read from Joana Starnes!
TYPE OF AUSTENESQUE NOVEL: Pride and Prejudice Variation
TIME FRAME: Several months before Mr. Bingley signs a lease for Netherfield Park
MAIN CHARACTERS: Elizabeth Bennet, Mr. Darcy, and Georgiana Darcy
SYNOPSIS: What if there was no Ramsgate, no overheard insult, and no surprise encounter in Kent? What if Darcy first met Elizabeth Bennet as a nursemaid/stand-in governess for his cousin’s children? And what if Georgiana expressly wished for Darcy to hire Elizabeth as her companion? With her father passed away and Longbourn taken over by the odious Mr. Collins, Elizabeth happily accepts this position, even though she has no experience. Will she find her new employer to be haughty and high-handed? Or will she see him as kind and generous?
WHAT I LOVED:
- Harmony and Happiness at Pemberley: This story takes us to Pemberley and stays there for nearly all of the book, with only slight mentions and visits to Netherfield and Rosings. I loved the focus on Pemberley and sense of idyllic contentment that pervaded this variation as we witnessed Elizabeth, Darcy, and Georgiana find pleasure, peace, and companionship in each other’s company with no interference. Pemberley is such a lovely setting for romance to blossom and I loved seeing the happiness and easy camaraderie between this trio.
- Woven Into Canon: With no Ramsgate, no Mr. Bennet, and no extended visit to Meryton, you may wonder if any of the same events will take place in this variation. Will there be a first proposal? Will Wickham cause any harm? I loved how, even though this story started so drastically different with altered situations for many characters, Joana Starnes found unique and clever ways to tie her variation to Jane Austen’s original canon. Especially her in regards to our favorite foils – Caroline Bingley and Mr. Wickham!
- Tempered Reserve: In many of Joana Starnes’s variations she delivers healthy doses of anguish and heartache to poor Mr. Darcy. But in this variation, the shoe is on the other foot! Mr. Darcy, being proper and honorable, does not give much romantic thought to his sister’s charming and lively companion and is quite slow to recognize his feelings. But Elizabeth, seeing Mr. Darcy in this different perspective, cannot help but admire him and think him “the best of men.” And her admiration easily leads to affection – an affection she tries to suppress and conceal because she knows there is no hope. I really enjoyed seeing Ms. Starnes explore these more reserved and private feelings of yearning and turmoil from Elizabeth’s perspective. AndI loved how she couldn’t resist giving Darcy a bit of torture and agony (which made us love him even more!).
- Georgiana: It is lovely to see Georgiana blossom in this variation. She has her shy reserve, but learns maturity and confidence with Elizabeth as her dear friend and companion. I enjoyed seeing Georgiana grow, think for herself, and become more assertive. Definitely some admirable development for her character!
- New Original Characters: Since we stay mostly at Pemberley, we don’t see much of the Bennets, de Bourghs, and the Bingleys. Instead we are introduced to several new original characters fashioned by Joana Starnes. These characters were well-constructed and interesting as they propelled the plot in various ways. (Note: I loved the helpful New Characters List in the front of the book!)
WHAT I WASN’T TOO FOND OF:
That now I will have an even harder time deciding which story by Joana Starnes is my favorite!
CONCLUSION:
Sensitive, poignant, and gloriously impassioned – skilled storyteller Joana Starnes gifts readers another stellar Pride and Prejudice variation that will once again inspire them to fall deeply and irrevocably in love with Mr. Darcy! While this story might have a little more quiet reserve and suppressed passion, I think it is just as beautiful and stirring! Another brilliant read from Joana Starnes!
September 30, 2016
Loved this HEA, worthy of 5 swoon points
The journey to the HEA for ODC was long and difficult. There were several twists in this story that changed everything. First, while Elizabeth was in Kent, the Colonel was not able to mention Darcy’s involvement in separating Jane and Mr. Bingley. Second, Darcy was not able to make his proposal due to an express arriving from Longbourn. And lastly, Ramsgate never happened.
The Bennet family realized their worst nightmare with the death of their beloved father. Mr. Collins was excessively cruel in securing his inheritance in a hasty manner that forced the women of Longbourn to leave his presence. Elizabeth and Jane went to live with the Gardiners. Elizabeth secured a temporary position with the Fitzwilliam family filling in for their governess. From there Georgiana requested her as a companion instead of Mrs. Younge, who she just didn’t feel right about and could not like her.
Wickham was the same cruel, conniving and cunning snake that he always was. He still made his attempt to get at Georgiana’s dowry; however, since he didn’t have Mrs. Younge, he was forced to use a different accomplice. It was very creative how the author spun this new situation.
Elizabeth was thrust into the society of the Fitzwilliam/Darcy families as she lived and worked with Georgiana. They spent a lot of time together and she soon fell under the spell of Mr. Darcy. There were parts of this that reminded me of Jane Eyre and how she sketched and drew pictures of the master of the house and secretly loved him. All the prejudice Elizabeth experienced in P&P was not present and didn’t taint Elizabeth’s picture of Mr. Darcy [landlord, master, brother, and she saw the true man].
Darcy’s journey to his HEA was also difficult as he came to misunderstand everything about Elizabeth Bennet and that created such drama between them. And, it gave us our hero moments where he raced after her and placed her on his horse. Yeah, you could hear the collective swoon from readers.
Georgiana grew up right before our eyes. She wasn’t influenced and beaten down by the conniving Mrs. Younge. When the compromise attempt was thwarted by Elizabeth, she realized that her naïveté nearly ruined them all. She was able to stand tall, as the daughter of the House of Darcy, and admirably rose to the occasion. She was pretty cool.
The house of Bennet was barely mentioned and we didn’t have to spend much time with them. As soon as Darcy could get out of their presence, he did. However, he bore it admirably. Thank goodness Pemberley was a good distance away, even with good roads.
***SPOILER*** ****End Spoiler****
The journey to the HEA for ODC was long and difficult. There were several twists in this story that changed everything. First, while Elizabeth was in Kent, the Colonel was not able to mention Darcy’s involvement in separating Jane and Mr. Bingley. Second, Darcy was not able to make his proposal due to an express arriving from Longbourn. And lastly, Ramsgate never happened.
The Bennet family realized their worst nightmare with the death of their beloved father. Mr. Collins was excessively cruel in securing his inheritance in a hasty manner that forced the women of Longbourn to leave his presence. Elizabeth and Jane went to live with the Gardiners. Elizabeth secured a temporary position with the Fitzwilliam family filling in for their governess. From there Georgiana requested her as a companion instead of Mrs. Younge, who she just didn’t feel right about and could not like her.
Wickham was the same cruel, conniving and cunning snake that he always was. He still made his attempt to get at Georgiana’s dowry; however, since he didn’t have Mrs. Younge, he was forced to use a different accomplice. It was very creative how the author spun this new situation.
Elizabeth was thrust into the society of the Fitzwilliam/Darcy families as she lived and worked with Georgiana. They spent a lot of time together and she soon fell under the spell of Mr. Darcy. There were parts of this that reminded me of Jane Eyre and how she sketched and drew pictures of the master of the house and secretly loved him. All the prejudice Elizabeth experienced in P&P was not present and didn’t taint Elizabeth’s picture of Mr. Darcy [landlord, master, brother, and she saw the true man].
Darcy’s journey to his HEA was also difficult as he came to misunderstand everything about Elizabeth Bennet and that created such drama between them. And, it gave us our hero moments where he raced after her and placed her on his horse. Yeah, you could hear the collective swoon from readers.
Georgiana grew up right before our eyes. She wasn’t influenced and beaten down by the conniving Mrs. Younge. When the compromise attempt was thwarted by Elizabeth, she realized that her naïveté nearly ruined them all. She was able to stand tall, as the daughter of the House of Darcy, and admirably rose to the occasion. She was pretty cool.
The house of Bennet was barely mentioned and we didn’t have to spend much time with them. As soon as Darcy could get out of their presence, he did. However, he bore it admirably. Thank goodness Pemberley was a good distance away, even with good roads.
***SPOILER*** ****End Spoiler****
June 2, 2016
https://frompemberleytomilton.wordpre...
Joana Starnes is one of those authors whose new releases I’m always impatient to read, so it is no surprise that I could not resist to read Miss Darcy’s Companion nonstop shortly after its release date, and guess what? I loved it! But of course, that is also no surprise as Mrs. Starnes has become one of those authors whose books I always love to read.
In this variation Mr. Bennet dies and Mr. Collins loses no time in sending his cousins to the hedgerows. Or that is where they would have been were it not for their uncles assistance and Elizabeth’s resilient character. Being thrown out of her house, Elizabeth seeks employment as a governess and her employer is none other than Col. Fitzwilliam’s sister in law, Lady Stretton.
This is the point where the book starts and we soon realize that Lady Stretton is a snobbish, insupportable person who treats others as inferior beings. So, it comes as no surprise that when Georgiana Darcy requests her guardians to hire Miss Bennet as her companion instead of Mrs. Younge, and they acquiesce, Elizabeth finds herself in the position of Miss Darcy’s Companion.
Joana Starnes starts this book by teasing us! She places Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy in the same house, in close proximity, and we spend the entire first chapter eagerly waiting for them to meet, but that pleasure is delayed, and we only see them together when the position as Miss Darcy’s Companion is proposed to her.
From there, the book continues with a structure that I personally like very much. The first chapters will focus on the day to day activities at Pemberley and the interactions between all characters. The authors knowledge of all things regency is transmitted in these first chapters, and it is also during this first part of the book that we, as readers, get to know the characters and that they get to know each other. We are given the pleasure to see Elizabeth falling in love with Mr. Darcy by getting to know his true character, we see her pining for him (yes, yes, yes), and we see Mr. Darcy unknowingly falling in love with Elizabeth.
After this pleasurable peaceful time, the twists and angst appear. And even though this is a lighter book compared to others Mrs. Starnes has written before, we do have action, suspense, fear and angst, or this would not be a Joana Starnes book.
I could point out numerous scenes I loved in the book, but what I loved the most about it was Mr. Darcy. The character remained true to the original, and Joana Starnes created what I call the perfect imperfect Darcy! He was still proud, stern and firm, yet charming all the same.
He was portrayed in this book exactly as I imagine Mr. Darcy to be, and that is something that doesn’t occur that frequently. I loved Mr. Darcy’s reactions towards unpleasant situations and his attitudes. The entire scene after he sees Elizabeth leaving the inn was just heart breaking. The carriage ride that follows was one of those scenes that pulled me into the book and made me read fervently! There was so much emotion present in that scene, his jealousy and anger so adoringly painful, that I knew I was reading a Joana Starnes book. Scenes like this are the reason I still love reading JAFF and they are a boost to my addiction and love for Mr. Darcy.
Another detail that I enjoyed in this book were the letters from Mr. Wickham and Miss Bingley. They were clearly an added value, and it was interesting to see how Mr. Wickham applied to the Kympton Parsonage after having accepted the money instead of it. This is something we rarely see in JAFF novels, and Mrs. Starnes did a beautiful job in including it through a letter.
There wasn’t anything I disliked in this book, and I would only add a few more self-conscious scenes between Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth to make it absolutely perfect.
As always, Mrs. Starnes has wrote a book that cannot be missed by any JAFF reader! If you haven’t read this book yet, I highly recommend it.
Joana Starnes is one of those authors whose new releases I’m always impatient to read, so it is no surprise that I could not resist to read Miss Darcy’s Companion nonstop shortly after its release date, and guess what? I loved it! But of course, that is also no surprise as Mrs. Starnes has become one of those authors whose books I always love to read.
In this variation Mr. Bennet dies and Mr. Collins loses no time in sending his cousins to the hedgerows. Or that is where they would have been were it not for their uncles assistance and Elizabeth’s resilient character. Being thrown out of her house, Elizabeth seeks employment as a governess and her employer is none other than Col. Fitzwilliam’s sister in law, Lady Stretton.
This is the point where the book starts and we soon realize that Lady Stretton is a snobbish, insupportable person who treats others as inferior beings. So, it comes as no surprise that when Georgiana Darcy requests her guardians to hire Miss Bennet as her companion instead of Mrs. Younge, and they acquiesce, Elizabeth finds herself in the position of Miss Darcy’s Companion.
Joana Starnes starts this book by teasing us! She places Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy in the same house, in close proximity, and we spend the entire first chapter eagerly waiting for them to meet, but that pleasure is delayed, and we only see them together when the position as Miss Darcy’s Companion is proposed to her.
From there, the book continues with a structure that I personally like very much. The first chapters will focus on the day to day activities at Pemberley and the interactions between all characters. The authors knowledge of all things regency is transmitted in these first chapters, and it is also during this first part of the book that we, as readers, get to know the characters and that they get to know each other. We are given the pleasure to see Elizabeth falling in love with Mr. Darcy by getting to know his true character, we see her pining for him (yes, yes, yes), and we see Mr. Darcy unknowingly falling in love with Elizabeth.
After this pleasurable peaceful time, the twists and angst appear. And even though this is a lighter book compared to others Mrs. Starnes has written before, we do have action, suspense, fear and angst, or this would not be a Joana Starnes book.
I could point out numerous scenes I loved in the book, but what I loved the most about it was Mr. Darcy. The character remained true to the original, and Joana Starnes created what I call the perfect imperfect Darcy! He was still proud, stern and firm, yet charming all the same.
He was portrayed in this book exactly as I imagine Mr. Darcy to be, and that is something that doesn’t occur that frequently. I loved Mr. Darcy’s reactions towards unpleasant situations and his attitudes. The entire scene after he sees Elizabeth leaving the inn was just heart breaking. The carriage ride that follows was one of those scenes that pulled me into the book and made me read fervently! There was so much emotion present in that scene, his jealousy and anger so adoringly painful, that I knew I was reading a Joana Starnes book. Scenes like this are the reason I still love reading JAFF and they are a boost to my addiction and love for Mr. Darcy.
Another detail that I enjoyed in this book were the letters from Mr. Wickham and Miss Bingley. They were clearly an added value, and it was interesting to see how Mr. Wickham applied to the Kympton Parsonage after having accepted the money instead of it. This is something we rarely see in JAFF novels, and Mrs. Starnes did a beautiful job in including it through a letter.
There wasn’t anything I disliked in this book, and I would only add a few more self-conscious scenes between Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth to make it absolutely perfect.
As always, Mrs. Starnes has wrote a book that cannot be missed by any JAFF reader! If you haven’t read this book yet, I highly recommend it.
May 24, 2016
Dear reader,
Those familiar with P&P know of the unrequited love on Darcy's part for Elizabeth.
We are all too aware of how ardently he loves her,of his disastrous proposal and the poor reception he receives from Elizabeth.
But,did you ever think,dear reader,of what would happen if the roles were reversed?
If it was Elizabeth who found herself unconsciously falling in love with our dearest Mr Darcy?
She,the one to ride the emotional roller coaster of seeing him each day,conversing with him on a host of common subjects, debating and verbally jousting with him in her own unique manner,to have it all lead to naught?
Can you imagine the pain,anguish and sheer desperation suffered by one who is close to their loved one,but heartbreakingly,remains so far away?
Yes,dear reader,such are some of the emotions you will encounter as you travel the path on this beautifully crafted, heartrending,yet ultimately fulfilling journey with Darcy and Elizabeth.
You will find yourself so absorbed in this tale that you will hear yourself loudly exclaim and protest at words spoken in haste,woeful misunderstandings,and actions undertaken with devastating consequences.
This is a fantastic read,one that is utterly compelling,one that speaks to your heart, one that is sprinkled with such descriptive words that their sheer eloquence will serve to take your breath away.
Needless to say,I loved it!
I cannot recommend this tale highly enough and urge all Austen lovers to treat themselves to this delightful,literary gem.
I trust you will not be disappointed!
My sincere thanks to Ms Starnes for penning this delicious distraction!
Enjoy!!
Those familiar with P&P know of the unrequited love on Darcy's part for Elizabeth.
We are all too aware of how ardently he loves her,of his disastrous proposal and the poor reception he receives from Elizabeth.
But,did you ever think,dear reader,of what would happen if the roles were reversed?
If it was Elizabeth who found herself unconsciously falling in love with our dearest Mr Darcy?
She,the one to ride the emotional roller coaster of seeing him each day,conversing with him on a host of common subjects, debating and verbally jousting with him in her own unique manner,to have it all lead to naught?
Can you imagine the pain,anguish and sheer desperation suffered by one who is close to their loved one,but heartbreakingly,remains so far away?
Yes,dear reader,such are some of the emotions you will encounter as you travel the path on this beautifully crafted, heartrending,yet ultimately fulfilling journey with Darcy and Elizabeth.
You will find yourself so absorbed in this tale that you will hear yourself loudly exclaim and protest at words spoken in haste,woeful misunderstandings,and actions undertaken with devastating consequences.
This is a fantastic read,one that is utterly compelling,one that speaks to your heart, one that is sprinkled with such descriptive words that their sheer eloquence will serve to take your breath away.
Needless to say,I loved it!
I cannot recommend this tale highly enough and urge all Austen lovers to treat themselves to this delightful,literary gem.
I trust you will not be disappointed!
My sincere thanks to Ms Starnes for penning this delicious distraction!
Enjoy!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 15, 2020
This review was first posted on Babblings of a Bookworm: http://babblingsofabookworm.blogspot....
One of the main ways to change the story of Pride & Prejudice is for Mr Bennet to die. The Bennet ladies were woefully protected financially as Mr Bennet had never saved and the Longbourn estate was entailed to Mr Bennet’s cousin Mr Collins, as the Bennets had no sons. If Mr Bennet had died before any of his daughters had married, what would have happened to them? The girls and Mrs Bennet would have had two routes open to them – to live with whichever of their family or friends would take them in, or to earn a living in the only acceptable way for gentlewomen; governess or companion, though this would come with a drop in status. In Joana Starnes’ ‘Miss Darcy’s Companion’, Miss Elizabeth Bennet is in this situation. The elder two Miss Bennets have gone to live with their Uncle in London, Mr Gardiner, while Mrs Bennet and the three youngest Bennet sisters remain in Meryton with Mr and Mrs Phillips.
Miss Elizabeth has chosen to lighten the load on her uncle by taking the post of interim governess to the children of Lady Stretton, who is Colonel Fitzwilliam’s sister-in-law. In this role, Elizabeth has made the acquaintance of Miss Darcy, who has been staying with the family while Mr Darcy made his annual visit to Rosings Park, and Miss Darcy has taken a real fancy to the young lady who is so kind to her young cousins. Elizabeth’s role is temporary, which is just as well, as although her charges, two girls, are very sweet children, their mother is horrible, and their brother a spoilt little beast. Georgiana has come to value Elizabeth’s friendship and pleads with her brother that he consider offering Elizabeth the role of companion in preference to Mrs Younge, who Georgiana has taken a dislike to.
Darcy is unsure of the wisdom of this course, as Miss Bennet is young and inexperienced, but, persuaded by the Colonel and Georgiana, and by the urging of feelings of pity and sympathy he agrees to employ Miss Bennet.
“Truly, Fitzwilliam, have we set out to choose a companion for Georgiana or to rescue Miss Bennet from your sister’s clutches?”
“The two are not necessarily mutually exclusive,” Fitzwilliam observed.’
However, Miss Bennet is a surprisingly good fit in the Darcy household, after some initial hiccups. Miss Darcy’s confidence builds and she spends many happy hours with her new friend. Mr Darcy also begins to enjoy Miss Bennet’s company, finding that she has a keen mind and offers him an excellent challenge in chess. Then news comes from Miss Bingley, whose brother is causing her distress by his attentions to the eldest Miss Bennet, who is visiting her mother in Meryton. Darcy is worried – partly at whether Miss Bingley’s assertions are true and that her brother is being taken in, and partly at the thought that, if Miss Bennet’s sister marries one of Darcy’s friends, she can hardly continue as Georgiana’s paid companion. This thought occurs to more than one of the party.
‘Their daily get-together for refreshment, in the house or elsewhere, had always been a pleasure, but not so today. Georgiana was still ill at ease when Darcy excused himself and left the parlour in reasonably high dudgeon with his reckless friend and Bingley’s attorney, and as for Miss Bennet, she was very sombre and subdued.’
Miss Bingley’s letter continues to affect the interactions of those at Pemberley, which annoys Darcy very much:
‘It vexed him greatly that she might have been to blame for depriving him of the enjoyment of a rewarding conversation or a challenging game of chess, and equally so for making his sister’s companion tread on eggshells in a house where she had previously felt nearly as carefree as in her former home.”
Is this the only reason why Miss Bennet’s manner has changed? Why is Darcy so cross at the thought of having to find a new companion for his sister? And with a different companion for Miss Darcy, will she be targeted by impecunious boyhood friends of her brother, or is she safe?
I am a big fan of Joana Starnes’ stories and this one was just wonderful, full of romantic moments and hints of feelings unsuspected by the other characters and even in some cases by the characters who are having the feelings! The story is presented predominantly from Darcy’s viewpoint for the first half and Elizabeth’s in the latter half and it was very entertaining to see the misunderstandings of feelings, though this meant that the exquisite agony that this author usually puts characters through isn’t seen as overtly here for quite a portion of the book, more hinted at. Darcy is more oblivious than he is usually presented in variations, and while this was quite loveable, it makes him slightly less of a romantic figure than we are used to at first. However, as the book progresses we get to see despairing feelings from more than one character, which was very satisfying. There was also a reference to an aria that relates to hidden love which I thought was very evocative - it's not directly in the text, but the words are right at the beginning of the book and the aria comes later:
'My lips dare not reveal my love
But bright and eager eyes might show the raging fire
My eyes will speak for me'
... Sigh!
This was a lovely, romantic read and I would recommend it without hesitation. There are no sex scenes or distressing themes so it’d be suitable for all historical romance readers looking for an escape for a few hours. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and I’d rate it as a five star read.
*I was provided an e-book of this story by the author for my honest review.
One of the main ways to change the story of Pride & Prejudice is for Mr Bennet to die. The Bennet ladies were woefully protected financially as Mr Bennet had never saved and the Longbourn estate was entailed to Mr Bennet’s cousin Mr Collins, as the Bennets had no sons. If Mr Bennet had died before any of his daughters had married, what would have happened to them? The girls and Mrs Bennet would have had two routes open to them – to live with whichever of their family or friends would take them in, or to earn a living in the only acceptable way for gentlewomen; governess or companion, though this would come with a drop in status. In Joana Starnes’ ‘Miss Darcy’s Companion’, Miss Elizabeth Bennet is in this situation. The elder two Miss Bennets have gone to live with their Uncle in London, Mr Gardiner, while Mrs Bennet and the three youngest Bennet sisters remain in Meryton with Mr and Mrs Phillips.
Miss Elizabeth has chosen to lighten the load on her uncle by taking the post of interim governess to the children of Lady Stretton, who is Colonel Fitzwilliam’s sister-in-law. In this role, Elizabeth has made the acquaintance of Miss Darcy, who has been staying with the family while Mr Darcy made his annual visit to Rosings Park, and Miss Darcy has taken a real fancy to the young lady who is so kind to her young cousins. Elizabeth’s role is temporary, which is just as well, as although her charges, two girls, are very sweet children, their mother is horrible, and their brother a spoilt little beast. Georgiana has come to value Elizabeth’s friendship and pleads with her brother that he consider offering Elizabeth the role of companion in preference to Mrs Younge, who Georgiana has taken a dislike to.
Darcy is unsure of the wisdom of this course, as Miss Bennet is young and inexperienced, but, persuaded by the Colonel and Georgiana, and by the urging of feelings of pity and sympathy he agrees to employ Miss Bennet.
“Truly, Fitzwilliam, have we set out to choose a companion for Georgiana or to rescue Miss Bennet from your sister’s clutches?”
“The two are not necessarily mutually exclusive,” Fitzwilliam observed.’
However, Miss Bennet is a surprisingly good fit in the Darcy household, after some initial hiccups. Miss Darcy’s confidence builds and she spends many happy hours with her new friend. Mr Darcy also begins to enjoy Miss Bennet’s company, finding that she has a keen mind and offers him an excellent challenge in chess. Then news comes from Miss Bingley, whose brother is causing her distress by his attentions to the eldest Miss Bennet, who is visiting her mother in Meryton. Darcy is worried – partly at whether Miss Bingley’s assertions are true and that her brother is being taken in, and partly at the thought that, if Miss Bennet’s sister marries one of Darcy’s friends, she can hardly continue as Georgiana’s paid companion. This thought occurs to more than one of the party.
‘Their daily get-together for refreshment, in the house or elsewhere, had always been a pleasure, but not so today. Georgiana was still ill at ease when Darcy excused himself and left the parlour in reasonably high dudgeon with his reckless friend and Bingley’s attorney, and as for Miss Bennet, she was very sombre and subdued.’
Miss Bingley’s letter continues to affect the interactions of those at Pemberley, which annoys Darcy very much:
‘It vexed him greatly that she might have been to blame for depriving him of the enjoyment of a rewarding conversation or a challenging game of chess, and equally so for making his sister’s companion tread on eggshells in a house where she had previously felt nearly as carefree as in her former home.”
Is this the only reason why Miss Bennet’s manner has changed? Why is Darcy so cross at the thought of having to find a new companion for his sister? And with a different companion for Miss Darcy, will she be targeted by impecunious boyhood friends of her brother, or is she safe?
I am a big fan of Joana Starnes’ stories and this one was just wonderful, full of romantic moments and hints of feelings unsuspected by the other characters and even in some cases by the characters who are having the feelings! The story is presented predominantly from Darcy’s viewpoint for the first half and Elizabeth’s in the latter half and it was very entertaining to see the misunderstandings of feelings, though this meant that the exquisite agony that this author usually puts characters through isn’t seen as overtly here for quite a portion of the book, more hinted at. Darcy is more oblivious than he is usually presented in variations, and while this was quite loveable, it makes him slightly less of a romantic figure than we are used to at first. However, as the book progresses we get to see despairing feelings from more than one character, which was very satisfying. There was also a reference to an aria that relates to hidden love which I thought was very evocative - it's not directly in the text, but the words are right at the beginning of the book and the aria comes later:
'My lips dare not reveal my love
But bright and eager eyes might show the raging fire
My eyes will speak for me'
... Sigh!
This was a lovely, romantic read and I would recommend it without hesitation. There are no sex scenes or distressing themes so it’d be suitable for all historical romance readers looking for an escape for a few hours. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and I’d rate it as a five star read.
*I was provided an e-book of this story by the author for my honest review.
July 11, 2016
"Memories of an intangible perfection, that pierced her heart." Ms. Starnes, you have pierced my heart with this beautiful story.
For me this story was poignant, sweet, funny and extremely engaging. Even my husband noticed, as he said I had that small smile on face which tells him I am thoroughly enjoying a book. The premise of Miss Elizabeth Bennet being the companion to Miss Darcy delighted me. This may have changed the dynamics of the story from canon but the characters were held true in essentials.
The first chapter alone captured my attention and I had to chuckle when Miss Elizabeth gently admonishes young Lord Hartfield by saying, "Perhaps. But a gentleman should practise from an early age to navigate the triteness of civil conversation." As Darcy is present, "A brief smile fluttered on Darcy's lips. He might have grown to bear the drawing rooms of the 'ton' more cheerfully, had his own nanny exposed similar views." Isn't that the truth!
Another scene later on at Pemberley brought tears to my eyes and a constriction in my throat for Miss Elizabeth's pain as she explains to Darcy her tears over a book. I was so moved by this and the late night harp playing by Elizabeth. Oh yes, Ms. Starnes certainly tugs on our heart strings.
But don't think there is all smooth sailing. Wickham is a sly fox and Miss Bingley does her part to try and cause dissension. There are other not so honourable characters as well. Mr. Bingley was more decisive which I loved and the Colonel well who can ever complain about him!
I highly recommend this book to all but a word of warning, it's difficult to participate in dinner conversation when you just want to get back to reading this book!
For me this story was poignant, sweet, funny and extremely engaging. Even my husband noticed, as he said I had that small smile on face which tells him I am thoroughly enjoying a book. The premise of Miss Elizabeth Bennet being the companion to Miss Darcy delighted me. This may have changed the dynamics of the story from canon but the characters were held true in essentials.
The first chapter alone captured my attention and I had to chuckle when Miss Elizabeth gently admonishes young Lord Hartfield by saying, "Perhaps. But a gentleman should practise from an early age to navigate the triteness of civil conversation." As Darcy is present, "A brief smile fluttered on Darcy's lips. He might have grown to bear the drawing rooms of the 'ton' more cheerfully, had his own nanny exposed similar views." Isn't that the truth!
Another scene later on at Pemberley brought tears to my eyes and a constriction in my throat for Miss Elizabeth's pain as she explains to Darcy her tears over a book. I was so moved by this and the late night harp playing by Elizabeth. Oh yes, Ms. Starnes certainly tugs on our heart strings.
But don't think there is all smooth sailing. Wickham is a sly fox and Miss Bingley does her part to try and cause dissension. There are other not so honourable characters as well. Mr. Bingley was more decisive which I loved and the Colonel well who can ever complain about him!
I highly recommend this book to all but a word of warning, it's difficult to participate in dinner conversation when you just want to get back to reading this book!
June 20, 2021
This book really touched my heart. It contains some very emotional moments. I will have to add it to my list of tearjerkers. Ms. Starnes has a way with words. As an amateur photographer, I appreciated her detail when Lizzy and Georgiana were sketching by the lake. I could imagine myself there doing the following with my camera, rather than a sketchbook.
Quote —“Georgiana said once she had concluded her tale of determined treks around the lake to find and sketch the best view of Pemberley reflected in the waters.“
There was a moment for Darcy that hit me in the chest, when he reflected — “He could have done without this tonight. Acknowledging that he was lonely. That the house was too quiet and his bedchamber cold and unappealing. Discovering that he envied Bingley, a sentiment never experienced before.” Poor Darcy.
Elizabeth feels a man like Darcy could never offer for her. Instead, knowing she must leave someday, she will only ever have memories of him and a few mementos of him. Poor Elizabeth.
ODC make some errors in understanding, but thankfully, they achieve their happy ending. Bingley is a pleasant surprise. I never saw that coming! Very well written variation. I highly recommend it.
June 19, 2021 - Audiobook
Another excellent narration by Stevie Zimmerman.
Quote —“Georgiana said once she had concluded her tale of determined treks around the lake to find and sketch the best view of Pemberley reflected in the waters.“
There was a moment for Darcy that hit me in the chest, when he reflected — “He could have done without this tonight. Acknowledging that he was lonely. That the house was too quiet and his bedchamber cold and unappealing. Discovering that he envied Bingley, a sentiment never experienced before.” Poor Darcy.
Elizabeth feels a man like Darcy could never offer for her. Instead, knowing she must leave someday, she will only ever have memories of him and a few mementos of him. Poor Elizabeth.
ODC make some errors in understanding, but thankfully, they achieve their happy ending. Bingley is a pleasant surprise. I never saw that coming! Very well written variation. I highly recommend it.
June 19, 2021 - Audiobook
Another excellent narration by Stevie Zimmerman.
August 29, 2017
I must say that the ending felt a little rushed, I mean, after all their drama, everything seemed too easily resolved. But I will not complain, the story is wonderful and full of sentiment. Probably my favourite book of Joana Starnes. A well deserved 5 stars!
May 12, 2017
Fantastic
I can't believe I have never heard of this before, because it is absolutely excellent. The same Elizabeth and Darcy but in very different circumstances. Such a fresh and promising variation that never attempts to use the same tired plot devices that we all have read a thousand times, it still stays true to characters without ever being more than slightly 'canon'. I cannot recommend this enough.
I can't believe I have never heard of this before, because it is absolutely excellent. The same Elizabeth and Darcy but in very different circumstances. Such a fresh and promising variation that never attempts to use the same tired plot devices that we all have read a thousand times, it still stays true to characters without ever being more than slightly 'canon'. I cannot recommend this enough.
July 11, 2021
Lizzy as a companion
Mr. Bennet dies and Lizzy needs to work to supplement the money situation. She ends up as a companion to Georgiana. Fairly classic Cinderella story. The writing is compelling. The emotions in the story are real. Enough so i shed a tear or two
My only complaint is a spoiler so feel free to just read the book and know you will be happy you did!
My complaint is Wickham is free to continue his evil if he wants to. As a romance the book rocks. But reading the story gives us characters we believe in. How can anyone assume a Happily Ever After if Wickham is free to return and cause trouble?
So for me the HEA I flawed given how the Darcys are often his target.
Mr. Bennet dies and Lizzy needs to work to supplement the money situation. She ends up as a companion to Georgiana. Fairly classic Cinderella story. The writing is compelling. The emotions in the story are real. Enough so i shed a tear or two
My only complaint is a spoiler so feel free to just read the book and know you will be happy you did!
My complaint is Wickham is free to continue his evil if he wants to. As a romance the book rocks. But reading the story gives us characters we believe in. How can anyone assume a Happily Ever After if Wickham is free to return and cause trouble?
So for me the HEA I flawed given how the Darcys are often his target.
Read
November 3, 2017Miss Darcy’s Companion is a Pride and Prejudice variation by Joana Starnes, and it imagines Elizabeth Bennet as a temporary governess for Colonel Fitzwilliam’s nieces and nephew, which is how she meets Mr. Darcy. The Darcys and Richard feel bad for how Lady Stretton treats Elizabeth, and Darcy thinks about how he would feel if his sister, Georgiana, were in her shoes: the daughter of a gentleman thrown out of her home upon the death of her father.
Convinced by Richard that Georgiana needs a companion closer to her age and that, despite her lack of experience, Elizabeth’s liveliness will do her a world of good, Darcy agrees to hire Elizabeth as Georgiana’s companion — and the three settle into a comfortable friendship at Pemberley. That is until Elizabeth becomes withdrawn, and Darcy realizes he wants the love and passion he witnesses between his friend Bingley and his new wife, Elizabeth’s sister Jane. Forced to distance himself from Pemberley to get his feelings under control and make a life-changing decision, Darcy must rush back to Pemberley when a ghost from his past arrives and destroys his hopes for happiness.
In Miss Darcy’s Companion, Starnes puts Darcy and Elizabeth in entirely new situations with entirely different misunderstandings but stays true to Jane Austen’s characters, namely Darcy’s pride and Elizabeth’s impertinence. She also portrays a Darcy whose true character is known almost immediately by Elizabeth, and a more solemn Elizabeth who is more difficult for Darcy to figure out. I really enjoyed seeing Georgiana blossom under Elizabeth’s watchful eye and Richard relentlessly tease his cousin. There also were plenty of original characters to liven the plot, from the obnoxiously arrogant Lady Stretton to the vicar’s sweet sister, Miss Bradden, to Fitzwilliam’s charming nieces Margaret and Hetty.
Miss Darcy’s Companion is the third Pride and Prejudice variation I’ve read by Starnes, and it’s another winner. (Check out my reviews of The Subsequent Proposal and The Unthinkable Triangle.) Starnes has quickly become one of my favorite authors of Austen-inspired fiction. She never lets me down with her beautiful writing style, tenderly drawn characters, and imaginative plots.
Review posted on Diary of an Eccentric
Convinced by Richard that Georgiana needs a companion closer to her age and that, despite her lack of experience, Elizabeth’s liveliness will do her a world of good, Darcy agrees to hire Elizabeth as Georgiana’s companion — and the three settle into a comfortable friendship at Pemberley. That is until Elizabeth becomes withdrawn, and Darcy realizes he wants the love and passion he witnesses between his friend Bingley and his new wife, Elizabeth’s sister Jane. Forced to distance himself from Pemberley to get his feelings under control and make a life-changing decision, Darcy must rush back to Pemberley when a ghost from his past arrives and destroys his hopes for happiness.
In Miss Darcy’s Companion, Starnes puts Darcy and Elizabeth in entirely new situations with entirely different misunderstandings but stays true to Jane Austen’s characters, namely Darcy’s pride and Elizabeth’s impertinence. She also portrays a Darcy whose true character is known almost immediately by Elizabeth, and a more solemn Elizabeth who is more difficult for Darcy to figure out. I really enjoyed seeing Georgiana blossom under Elizabeth’s watchful eye and Richard relentlessly tease his cousin. There also were plenty of original characters to liven the plot, from the obnoxiously arrogant Lady Stretton to the vicar’s sweet sister, Miss Bradden, to Fitzwilliam’s charming nieces Margaret and Hetty.
Miss Darcy’s Companion is the third Pride and Prejudice variation I’ve read by Starnes, and it’s another winner. (Check out my reviews of The Subsequent Proposal and The Unthinkable Triangle.) Starnes has quickly become one of my favorite authors of Austen-inspired fiction. She never lets me down with her beautiful writing style, tenderly drawn characters, and imaginative plots.
Review posted on Diary of an Eccentric
May 14, 2016
A Wonderful, Deeply Emotional Book
This is a truly outstanding variation of Pride and Prejudice. There's only a few minor slips in editing, but the book is so outstanding I hardly noticed.
For some reason I love books in which Lizzy is either a companion or friend to Georgiana. Here she becomes a companion to Georgiana and is mostly in Pemberly after her father dies unexpectedly and her family is quickly removed from Longbourne by Mr. Collins whom she had rejected. He is still unmarried. Events occur differently and Lizzy's family is mostly in the background.
How well Joanna deals with the problems of a paid companion who is not quite a servant and not family while having to be with family. The death of her father and removal from her estate and acceptance of paid employment lowered Lizzy in the eyes of many snobs in society. Georgiana loved Lizzy and regarded her more as a friend while she and Darcy were attracted to each other but uncomfortable with their growing feelings because of snobby family and friends. This Lizzy is more accomplished than in P&J with more musical, artistic, and language ability.
Caroline tried to make trouble in a letter to Georgiana, but this version of Darcy was forceful in keeping Caroline out of his life. I like the more forceful version of Bingley whose response to Caroline was to marry Jane Bennet shortly after meeting her, and their love match and blissful happiness made Darcy look more critically at marriages of convenience.
It became more challenging and awkward for Elizabeth and Darcy to be in one another's company while he was glad to see Georgiana so happy and more outgoing. When Darcy went away to get away from his love, George Wickham made his appearance with the help of deceptive neighbors. Mrs. Reynolds explained to Lizzy the real wild nature of Mr. Wickham so she has the challenge of trying to keep him apart from Georgiana and Pemberly while Wickham uses neighbors to try to get to Georgiana and remove her from Lizzy long enough to compromise the naive girl. Darcy returns and he and Lizzy misunderstand each other when he sees her leaving an inn where Lizzy caught Georgiana alone with him and promptly removed her charge before she could get away herself. Then comes the heart rending climax with Lizzy and Darcy misunderstanding one another and Lizzy trying to flee. What does Darcy do? Oh, he is ever so romantic.
Lizzy's mother and sisters are in the background here. Her mother is silly, but she is not pushing her or any other daughters toward Mr. Collins. He seems to be still unmarried and disliked, as well as lacking in Christian principles. I could not put this outstanding book down. You will fall in love with this Mr. Darcy and Lizzy. There is also deeper social distinctions and real depth of social understanding and emotions. Do not miss this book. It is great to have a book where Lizzy and Darcy can fall in love without Caroline or other admirers fawning and pawing him. Lizzy had a worthy admirer here but her feelings for Darcy were too deep though seemingly hopeless.
This is a truly outstanding variation of Pride and Prejudice. There's only a few minor slips in editing, but the book is so outstanding I hardly noticed.
For some reason I love books in which Lizzy is either a companion or friend to Georgiana. Here she becomes a companion to Georgiana and is mostly in Pemberly after her father dies unexpectedly and her family is quickly removed from Longbourne by Mr. Collins whom she had rejected. He is still unmarried. Events occur differently and Lizzy's family is mostly in the background.
How well Joanna deals with the problems of a paid companion who is not quite a servant and not family while having to be with family. The death of her father and removal from her estate and acceptance of paid employment lowered Lizzy in the eyes of many snobs in society. Georgiana loved Lizzy and regarded her more as a friend while she and Darcy were attracted to each other but uncomfortable with their growing feelings because of snobby family and friends. This Lizzy is more accomplished than in P&J with more musical, artistic, and language ability.
Caroline tried to make trouble in a letter to Georgiana, but this version of Darcy was forceful in keeping Caroline out of his life. I like the more forceful version of Bingley whose response to Caroline was to marry Jane Bennet shortly after meeting her, and their love match and blissful happiness made Darcy look more critically at marriages of convenience.
It became more challenging and awkward for Elizabeth and Darcy to be in one another's company while he was glad to see Georgiana so happy and more outgoing. When Darcy went away to get away from his love, George Wickham made his appearance with the help of deceptive neighbors. Mrs. Reynolds explained to Lizzy the real wild nature of Mr. Wickham so she has the challenge of trying to keep him apart from Georgiana and Pemberly while Wickham uses neighbors to try to get to Georgiana and remove her from Lizzy long enough to compromise the naive girl. Darcy returns and he and Lizzy misunderstand each other when he sees her leaving an inn where Lizzy caught Georgiana alone with him and promptly removed her charge before she could get away herself. Then comes the heart rending climax with Lizzy and Darcy misunderstanding one another and Lizzy trying to flee. What does Darcy do? Oh, he is ever so romantic.
Lizzy's mother and sisters are in the background here. Her mother is silly, but she is not pushing her or any other daughters toward Mr. Collins. He seems to be still unmarried and disliked, as well as lacking in Christian principles. I could not put this outstanding book down. You will fall in love with this Mr. Darcy and Lizzy. There is also deeper social distinctions and real depth of social understanding and emotions. Do not miss this book. It is great to have a book where Lizzy and Darcy can fall in love without Caroline or other admirers fawning and pawing him. Lizzy had a worthy admirer here but her feelings for Darcy were too deep though seemingly hopeless.
August 15, 2025
updated review - despite having this on my Goodreads I somehow never connected it with the book I’ve been trying to find to reread for literal YEARS 😂 sue me I’m dumb. all I could remember was that Elizabeth was working for Darcy and was watching a dance around Christmas time, and that it was a really really really good book HAHA
I’m so glad I rediscovered this with the help of a fellow austenite, it’s truly a phenomenal read. Joana Starnes never fails to disappoint!!
the character development is just *chefs kiss*, the tension between Elizabeth and Darcy, the scene where he rushes after her on his horse in the pouring rain and then brings her home AAAAAAA
the only thing I would’ve loved to see is a longer epilogue. once the conflict was resolved it moved very quickly into the conclusion of the book and I would’ve liked to see the slowburn drawn out just a little more. we never get Elizabeth’s direct perspective again once she’s woken up and is frantic for her sketchbook - it focuses mainly on Darcy or on third person. I would’ve loved to see her mental thought process after the proposal and marriage
and darn it I wanted to see Darcy get the Dufoe book 😭 it could’ve been such a sweet addition as a wedding gift, but alas.
nevertheless that doesn’t detract from the 5 star recommendation, I would give it more if I could! I fear this is about to start me on a Joana Starnes reread 😂
PG-13
I’m so glad I rediscovered this with the help of a fellow austenite, it’s truly a phenomenal read. Joana Starnes never fails to disappoint!!
the character development is just *chefs kiss*, the tension between Elizabeth and Darcy, the scene where he rushes after her on his horse in the pouring rain and then brings her home AAAAAAA
the only thing I would’ve loved to see is a longer epilogue. once the conflict was resolved it moved very quickly into the conclusion of the book and I would’ve liked to see the slowburn drawn out just a little more. we never get Elizabeth’s direct perspective again once she’s woken up and is frantic for her sketchbook - it focuses mainly on Darcy or on third person. I would’ve loved to see her mental thought process after the proposal and marriage
and darn it I wanted to see Darcy get the Dufoe book 😭 it could’ve been such a sweet addition as a wedding gift, but alas.
nevertheless that doesn’t detract from the 5 star recommendation, I would give it more if I could! I fear this is about to start me on a Joana Starnes reread 😂
PG-13
May 14, 2016
Story content ends at 91% followed by promos
I have always loved this author's work. I believe I've purchased all her books to date and so I did not hesitate to do the same, again. This time I regret the decision, not because it isn't well written and engaging, as it is, but perhaps that's the reason. The story held my interest all day, through the disparaging relatives, the deceptions, the misunderstandings, etc. Well done, Ms Starnes. So, why only three stars? Simple: By nature of the genre, a HEA is a virtual guarantee so the suspense is thereby mitigated but a romance reader needs some reassurance. This book ends- abruptly. HEA, the end. No resolution to the difficulties elaborated, no celebration, no reactions at all. Sadly, I thought we had another 10% to read, but instead I was greeted with 15-20 pages of promotion material for other books by the author. And this concludes the "Public Service" portion of this review. Thought you should know.
I have always loved this author's work. I believe I've purchased all her books to date and so I did not hesitate to do the same, again. This time I regret the decision, not because it isn't well written and engaging, as it is, but perhaps that's the reason. The story held my interest all day, through the disparaging relatives, the deceptions, the misunderstandings, etc. Well done, Ms Starnes. So, why only three stars? Simple: By nature of the genre, a HEA is a virtual guarantee so the suspense is thereby mitigated but a romance reader needs some reassurance. This book ends- abruptly. HEA, the end. No resolution to the difficulties elaborated, no celebration, no reactions at all. Sadly, I thought we had another 10% to read, but instead I was greeted with 15-20 pages of promotion material for other books by the author. And this concludes the "Public Service" portion of this review. Thought you should know.
January 26, 2018
A lovely, emotional, romantic and thrilling read that I thoroughly enjoyed. Even brought me to tears, when Elizabeth told Jane her secret, I love to be moved...
Mr Bennet has passed and Elizabeth is working for lady Stretton as a governess in the house of the Darcy's aunt. Georgiana is visiting for the summer and wants Elizabeth to be her companion. After some persuasion, Darcy agrees.
There are several unexpected twists to this story and one of those are that Elizabeth developed feelings for Mr Darcy early on. That does not necessarily make their road to HEA any easier as Darcy still has his doubts about her suitability, when he finally realise he is in love. There are misunderstandings and they are very cleverly done.
Wickham makes havoc and Georgiana is his target.
Bingley shows a bit of a backbone and makes his own decisions which I found to be both refreshing and funny...
Heartily recommend this book.
Mr Bennet has passed and Elizabeth is working for lady Stretton as a governess in the house of the Darcy's aunt. Georgiana is visiting for the summer and wants Elizabeth to be her companion. After some persuasion, Darcy agrees.
There are several unexpected twists to this story and one of those are that Elizabeth developed feelings for Mr Darcy early on. That does not necessarily make their road to HEA any easier as Darcy still has his doubts about her suitability, when he finally realise he is in love. There are misunderstandings and they are very cleverly done.
Wickham makes havoc and Georgiana is his target.
Bingley shows a bit of a backbone and makes his own decisions which I found to be both refreshing and funny...
Heartily recommend this book.
December 5, 2017
I loved this story! In a turn of events following the death of mr Bennet, Elizabeth ends up working as Miss Darcy's companion. Very soon after, Darcy, Elizabeth and Georgina become a very close little family and there is a lot of fun times to be had.... but...
Obviously, it cannot all be plain sailing! Elizabeth begins to develop feelings for her employer, he has never been happier but does not associate this with any particular regard for Elizabeth. A serious misunderstanding threatens to separate them forever!
I love Joana Starnes books. There is so much attention to detail and consideration to the thoughts and feelings of the characters that as a reader I feel I know the characters and am a part of what's going on. Funny, romantic and heart breaking, this is a brilliant story!!
Obviously, it cannot all be plain sailing! Elizabeth begins to develop feelings for her employer, he has never been happier but does not associate this with any particular regard for Elizabeth. A serious misunderstanding threatens to separate them forever!
I love Joana Starnes books. There is so much attention to detail and consideration to the thoughts and feelings of the characters that as a reader I feel I know the characters and am a part of what's going on. Funny, romantic and heart breaking, this is a brilliant story!!
September 20, 2017
Elizabeth is hired to be Georgiana's companion and comes to know Darcy in his own comfortable environment. She quickly falls in love with him but knows her position as a paid employee will never make her equal to him. Then you throw in Bingley and Janes love in the mix along with troublesome Wickham and you get an interesting tale. I loved getting to know Darcy from Elizabeth's view in this novel and the friendship with her and Georgiana was beautiful as well. An enjoyable read!
October 31, 2016
It didn't hit my top ten list to get a 5 but it was very well written. What I really liked about this story is that the entire story really only involved three players. We get to see a bit of Fitzwilliam of course, who as always, is Darcy's right hand man. We also see a bit of Jane and Bingley and there are scenes with members of the Fitzwilliam side of the family as well as a few new acquaintances, so don't get me wrong, the other characters are there, but the bulk of the story revolves around Elizabeth and Georgiana with Darcy interwoven into their budding relationship. The story was well written and enjoyable and I found myself devouring the book in anticipation. Oddly enough, what bothers me about Joana Starnes books is also what makes them so wonderful. Its always this slow, almost tortuous build-up of Elizabeth and Darcy finally coming together. The build up is seamless and captivating, but I often feel a void for 50-60% of the book waiting for them to finally realize they love each other. More often than not, Darcy is always aware that he loves Elizabeth and we get to participate in this constant foreplay between them for most to all of the book until the climax of them finally coming together. In this particular version, Elizabeth comes to love Darcy first but Darcy doesn't come to realize his feelings until later on. The. So for me, thought excellently written, the first half of the book lacked passion. One other thing that bothered me was this version of Elizabeth. Where is my pertinent, headstrong Elizabeth??!! There were moments of her but more often than not we see a timid, head down and looking away Elizabeth. Not my favorite version of her. Still a great read and a great author to go to for Pride and Prejudice variations.
October 19, 2016
I really liked this one. I haven't read too many of these E as working girl stories where Mr Darcy did not know her beforehand. I liked the new-to-me angle. My only wish was to have more info at the end as to how they coped with everyone else. It seems that they were a scandal but that was it.
Reread: Loved this one. I agree with what I said in the first reading. It was left that our couple would be permanently shunned from society. Not the best ending but so well written and Darcy was adorable. :)
Reread: Loved this one. I agree with what I said in the first reading. It was left that our couple would be permanently shunned from society. Not the best ending but so well written and Darcy was adorable. :)
March 18, 2022
Joana Starnes is one of my favorite authors! She really has an amazing way to really connect and with her readers. I was emotionally engaged right from the start and loved the romance that was a nice slow and steady build up. I think this author really understands our Austen's beloved characters and does such a nice job to give us alternative stories while staying true to their characters! I only wish the ending would have been a bit more developed. This, and any book by this author is a must read if you love Elizabeth and Darcy stories! Great book!!!
July 4, 2021
Read this as an ebook first and loved it.
The audiobook is even better (thank you Stevie Zimmerman)!
Joana Starnes is a gifted story teller. The balance of Elizabeth's character and her position in life following her father's death is a great contrast with Darcy's reserve. Yet his reserve slowly dissipates as Elizabeth's affect on Pemberley and Georgiana takes hold.
Yet he struggles with his pride and duty (as usual).
The audiobook is even better (thank you Stevie Zimmerman)!
Joana Starnes is a gifted story teller. The balance of Elizabeth's character and her position in life following her father's death is a great contrast with Darcy's reserve. Yet his reserve slowly dissipates as Elizabeth's affect on Pemberley and Georgiana takes hold.
Yet he struggles with his pride and duty (as usual).
August 28, 2016
Another wonderful offering from Joana Starnes. A unique view with a Lizzy of reduced circumstances. Couldn't put it down!
July 17, 2016
Virtually perfect. Unable to provide feedback more due to conflict of interest.
December 27, 2019
Entertaining, a quick read, but I often felt like I had read this before. Maybe it was posted on a blog somewhere. Still a great story.
July 2, 2020
I didn't enjoy this one as much as The Unthinkable Triangle, as the circumstances were less believeable.
Obviously it is entirely conceivable that Elizabeth Bennet might have been forced to seek a post as lady's companion if Mr Bennet had died, and I enjoyed her being Georgiana's companion and learning to love Darcy and see his true nature by being in his home, and loving him before he notices her, that was a nice twist.
The issue for me was that once Jane married Bingley, the idea that Elizabeth would still consider herself so far beneath Darcy rang false. Clearly she only stays on in her position as she loves Darcy and Georgiana and Pemberley, not from necessity, so why is there still so much hand wringing from Darcy and Elizabeth about her station in life? It felt like the obstacles were non-existent at that point and the drama felt forced.
Also I'm still nitpicking at the overuse of the unnecessary phrase 'truth be told', which Starnes really likes and which yanks me out of the story every time it comes up. But that's just an editing issue.
Really, this is an enjoyable book and leagues ahead of many other Austen variations I have read, staying largely true to the original characters and with no glaring historical inaccuracies or sex before marriage. While I enjoyed The Unthinkable Triangle far more than this one, I will definitely read more Starnes books.
Obviously it is entirely conceivable that Elizabeth Bennet might have been forced to seek a post as lady's companion if Mr Bennet had died, and I enjoyed her being Georgiana's companion and learning to love Darcy and see his true nature by being in his home, and loving him before he notices her, that was a nice twist.
The issue for me was that once Jane married Bingley, the idea that Elizabeth would still consider herself so far beneath Darcy rang false. Clearly she only stays on in her position as she loves Darcy and Georgiana and Pemberley, not from necessity, so why is there still so much hand wringing from Darcy and Elizabeth about her station in life? It felt like the obstacles were non-existent at that point and the drama felt forced.
Also I'm still nitpicking at the overuse of the unnecessary phrase 'truth be told', which Starnes really likes and which yanks me out of the story every time it comes up. But that's just an editing issue.
Really, this is an enjoyable book and leagues ahead of many other Austen variations I have read, staying largely true to the original characters and with no glaring historical inaccuracies or sex before marriage. While I enjoyed The Unthinkable Triangle far more than this one, I will definitely read more Starnes books.
July 1, 2016
I won Miss Darcy's Companion in a giveaway on the Austen Authors website and I am so glad I did. Joana gave me a unique take on Pride & Prejudice while still staying mostly in the time frame of it. I was a little confused for the first half of the 1st chapter but after that it was smooth sailing (Tip if you want to avoid my confusion look at the list of new characters in the back of the book first). I'll warn all you Jane fans out there that she isn't in here much but I didn't mind one bit. Without Jane we get to see a friendship and sisterly affection blossom between Elizabeth and Georgina.
I always found it funny when I would find the ways Joana would just slightly change some of the lines from P&P to fit the story and they where some of my favorite lines. I'll give you an example of what you will be getting if you read this amazing book.
"The ivy grows slowly day by day, and all through the night. Tendrils sprout, unfurl and reach to take hold. No noticeable difference from one day to the next, yet a time comes when one can see it has covered the entire wall, clinging so firmly that it leaves visible damage if torn off."
Thank you Joana for writing such an amazing book and giving me a chance to enjoy it.
I always found it funny when I would find the ways Joana would just slightly change some of the lines from P&P to fit the story and they where some of my favorite lines. I'll give you an example of what you will be getting if you read this amazing book.
"The ivy grows slowly day by day, and all through the night. Tendrils sprout, unfurl and reach to take hold. No noticeable difference from one day to the next, yet a time comes when one can see it has covered the entire wall, clinging so firmly that it leaves visible damage if torn off."
Thank you Joana for writing such an amazing book and giving me a chance to enjoy it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 103 reviews