This book is terrible, read something else.
That being said, Daredevil is one of my favorite marvel characters, nonetheless is quite difficult to find a good story of him. This story is really boring, almost as bad as Andy Diggles Shadowland. I have not read yet the Marc Waid run before reading this one, but from the reviews I’ve read here in Goodreads, it does not seem to be needed to understand what is happening here.
It really shows how Charles Soule, the writer, does not understand Daredevil, in the art department Ron Garney makes some decent covers with really bad interiors, far from what he had done in other titles such as ultimate comics Captain America, Wolverine, and Thor, here he seems to have taken some influence from the recent work of John Romita Jr, which seems rushed and lazy, Matt mills does an interesting job with the colors and effects in the book, which almost save this rushed approach by Ron Garney.
The biggest problems with the story are that there are no stakes in here, and almost nothing happens, I couln´t care less about Matt who has returned to NY, nor the people he works with in the DA´s office or Blindspot, his new protegee a Chinese illegal immigrant, nor about of the people in the tenfinger´s church who are in danger. Besides Matt I don’t know any of these and I don’t care about them at all, and Soule does not give me any reason to do so.
So Tenfingers is the leader of a cult that is named after him. The church of the Tenfingers is attended by what at the beginning seem to be criminals, former criminals and illegal immigrants, its not clear why Soule selects this three groups and not others, does he consider the three of them the similar? or what is he trying to achieve by having those groups together? By the end the group seems to have changed and is now formed by families of chinatown. Tenfingers promises salvation and power, but it is never clear what he means by that. Tenfingers seems to have superpowers and he also provides some of his followers with superhuman fighting skills, but when he refers to power, he seems to be talking about something else which is never explained. Tenfingers stole some magic from the legendary criminal organization named the hand, by the end these guys of the han summon a demon called the fist. (what is next in daredevil? A new bad guy called the elbow? A different criminal syndicate by the name of the forearm maybe? ).
In the middle of the story Tenfingers approaches Matt Murdok in his new job, he explains “I had a vision where by forming a new religion I will be able to save people, do you see” What is Matt´s answer? “I don’t see, I am blind”. This line is totally useless. What is Soule trying to achieve with it? And why did Tenfingers approached Matt? There is no reason for this since now no one knows that Matt and Daredevil are one and the same. And this is another useless point. They are tying to make this whole “no one knows who daredevil is “ an interesting subject, but it is not. Its just another Deus ex machine to have the character as it was in the beginning, avoiding growth. A terrible bad decision by marvel, it was really interesting seeing Matt trying to avoid being recognized as Daredevil, and how that got him new problems. I know that the whole identity revealed thing could not last very long, but the fact is that it was almost 10 years since Bendis revealed that Matt and Daredevil are the same person, and it still felt like there could be some interesting stories to be told. Also the new seed could’ve been Daredevil quiting the whole Matt persona, and trying to become a full time vigilante with limited resources, and chased by the police for his methods. I think that something like that was needed before going back to basics.
I’ve haven’t read a story where Matt´s catholicism takes the centerstage, and I think there is a good reason why, yes every now and then he has searched for comfort in a church, and I think that it could make an interesting story, but this is certainly not the one. For every super hero there is a philosophical debate of wether or not use the skills they have for certain pourpuses, here Soule skips the struggle and concludes that Matt thinks that he is the cosen one, elected by god to achieve his will, and whoever gets in the way, is against the will of god. Talk about humility. This simplistic approach towards Matt´s election to become a superhero seems quite out of character. Matt got his powers through an accident where he also lost his sight, he is well aware of the accident that caused him this, after that, Matt was trained by stick, a man from Eastern traditions who taught him how to master his skills, then Matt became a lawyer and worked on some really complex cases, at the same time he became a vigilante, and had to deal with some really strange stuff while battling alongside Spiderman, captain America and other heroes. Matt is a vast tapestry of traditions and knowledge that does not seem to fit this “chosen by god” statement which seems good for a Crusade. Matt lives in a universe where this kinds of superpowers are not that unusual, and almost all the time have scientific explanation (in the scientific terms of that universe), even more so, there are other persons who use these kids of powers to achieve opposite goals than Matt´s, Before this, Matt´s decision to fight crime is so that no one would suffer what he had to go through when he was a kid after losing his father when the mafia killed him, every now and then he looks for relief in a church, but he knows well that he is fighting through means which his church may not approve. Matt´s fight has never been centered in religion, and to say it has shows how Soule does not understand the great possibilities and background this character has.