1998, Harlequin, secret-baby, small-town romance with a slam-bang beginning
For the past six months, 25-year-old Melody (“Mel”) Evans has worked as the administrative assistant to the American ambassador in a Middle Eastern country. Until the government is suddenly overthrown by a violent, terrorist coup. Trapped in the embassy as a prisoner of the terrorists, she is convinced that she will be dead within hours, when Navy SEAL Team Ten's Alpha Squad rescues her and the two other American captives.
From the first moment that Harlan ("Cowboy") Jones encounters Melody, he feels a lightning-bolt of emotional connection to her that he has never felt toward any other woman before—especially not a woman he has helped to rescue. Upping the intensity even more is the fact that Melody obviously feels the same way about him. She also trusts him utterly, and her trust is clearly well placed. Cowboy plays a major role in getting her safely out of the war-torn country.
Immediately after the rescue operation ends, Melody and Cowboy spend six sex-drenched days together, only leaving their hotel room for dinner every night. During all of their passionate encounters, they are careful to use a condom, except for one wild, mile-high-club encounter on a flight to Paris. At the end of their torrid six days, Cowboy is summoned from his temporary leave for a new high-risk assignment. He has no intention writing off Mel as just another meaningless fling, but before he can ask her to stay in close touch with him, she solemnly informs him that, from her perspective, a fling is all that it has been between them, merely the predictable result of an overload of hormones and adrenaline. Cowboy is crushed when she declares she has no desire to ever see him again.
Seven months later, back in Mel’s hometown, the fictional small burg, Appleton, Massachusetts, Melody is in the third trimester of a difficult pregnancy. From the very first month, she has been enduring thrice-daily nausea, overwhelming exhaustion, and such severe dizziness that she occasionally collapses in a dead faint. She has been living in the huge, Victorian house that she grew up in with her older, divorced sister, Brittany, and working part-time on the election campaign of a local politician. She never expected to hear from Cowboy again until, out of the blue, she receives a call from him. He wants to come see her, but she firmly lets him know that her decision about their potential for a committed relationship has not changed, and she does not tell him that she is pregnant.
Cowboy has not forgotten Mel all these months apart. In fact, his sense of attachment to her is so strong, his fellow SEALs have teased him about taking vows of celibacy, because he has not so much as looked at another woman since Melody. After Mel shuts him down on the phone, he is determined to talk to her in person, because he is convinced if they are physically near each other, the sparks will reignite between them, and she will want to resume their affair. He manages to get an extended leave and shows up on her doorstep, much to Mel’s dismay. But faced with Mel’s burgeoning belly, poor Cowboy is in far shock more than she. When he learns she is seven months along, there is no doubt in his mind that the baby is his, and that it was conceived on that risqué plane ride to Paris. Determined to do right by Mel and his unborn child, he proposes marriage, even though the very idea of becoming a husband and father terrifies him more than any SEAL mission he has ever been on.
Unlike the first two books in this series, all of the SEAL-team action-adventure occurs at the beginning of this novel rather than at the end. For me, personally, that section of the story is, hands down, the best part of this book. During that terrifying escape, Mel displays enormous bravery, adaptability and endurance, which makes it clear that she is a worthy partner for the highly skilled, courageous and honorable Cowboy. They have a great deal of mutual respect for each other, and the emotional connection between the two of them is explosively intense. Unfortunately, once we arrive at the small-town portion of this story, Mel stubbornly persists in rejecting Cowboy while insisting that her ideal man is “everyday and average.” This plotting choice morphs Mel from a highly sympathetic, fascinating, active protagonist into a frustratingly passive, risk-averse one. This is an inexplicable attitude, because it flies in the face of the reasonably expected function of action-adventure in a romantic-suspense plot.
In virtually every romance novel in which the protagonists are strangers who are embroiled in perilous adventures together, in the process they become the equivalent of “foxhole buddies,” an unbreakable, lifetime bond, which is created when people face and overcome terrible danger together. In the process, the deepest and most heroic layers of their personalities are revealed, which is definitely true for both Mel and Cowboy. When you add on top of that, the fact that they have an enormous amount of sexual compatibility, either of them rejecting each other would need to be massively well motivated such that the one doing the rejecting does not look like a complete jerk—something that is sadly lacking in this story. After the beyond-amazing connection Mel has experienced with Cowboy, for her to insist that he is no good for her, or her for him, is analogous in this romance novel to the protagonist of a paranormal novel insisting, right up until the end of the story, that magic doesn’t exist.
There are several additional subplots which occur in Appleton which allow Cowboy to display some of his manifold, superhero, SEAL abilities, even though this small town is not filled with murderous villains and impossible odds stacked against him, as is the case with the treacherously evil, backwater, southern town that is the setting of Forever Blue, Book 2 of this series.
If judged as an ordinary, non-action-adventure, small-town romance, there are some cute subplots in the Appleton portion of this novel which involve some likeable subcharacters. In particular, there is a two-hankie plot involving Andy Marshall, a feisty, 12-year-old foster child who lives next door to Mel and her older, divorced sister, Brittany, who is a nurse who works at the local hospital. And Brittany, herself, provides a crucial, matchmaker function as a means to push Mel from her stubborn rejection of Cowboy, as well as being a major factor in the HEA ending of the Andy subplot.
The few, brief scenes in which fellow members of the Alpha Squad have cameo appearances are also entertaining. These SEALs include: Captain Joe "Cat" Catalanotto, Lieutenant Carter "Blue" McCoy, Senior Chief Daryl "Harvard" Becker, Luke “Lucky” O'Donlon, Wesley "Wes" Skelly, and Bobby Taylor.
Mel and Cowboy’s HEA, which is an essential part of every romance novel, is well motivated and quite lovely. There is also a brief epilogue that shows them living out their HEA, which is always desirable in a romance novel.
It's not essential to read the (as of 2022) 13 books in Brockmann's Tall, Dark and Dangerous series in order, but it greatly adds to one's enjoyment to do so. Each book sets up the book that immediately follows it, introducing the SEAL who will be the hero of the next book, along with pertinent backstory, for the first 11 books, which were originally published under Silhouette Intimate Moments, the Harlequin romantic-suspense imprint. In the case of this book, Harvard is frequently present in significant ways, and he is the protagonist of the next book in this series, Harvard’s Education. The last two books in this series, written many years after #11, are slightly different in that regard. In particular, the hero of #13 King’s Ransom is an important subcharacter in #3 Frisco’s Kid. This is the order in which this series was originally released:
1) Prince Joe, June 1996
2) Forever Blue, October 1996
3) Frisco's Kid, January 1997
4) Everyday, Average Jones, August 1998
5) Harvard's Education, October 1998
6) It Came Upon a Midnight Clear, December 1998 (Note: the 2010 audiobook is titled Hawken's Heart)
7) The Admiral's Bride, November 1999
8) Identity: Unknown, January 2000
9) Get Lucky, March 2000
10) Taylor's Temptation, July 2001
11) Night Watch, September 2003
12) SEAL Camp, May, 2018
13) King’s Ransom, December, 2020
I rate this book as follows:
Heroine: 5 stars beginning, 2 stars middle, 4 stars end of the book
Hero: 5 stars
Romance Plot: 5 stars beginning, 2 stars middle, 4 stars end of the book
Action-Adventure Plot: 5 stars
Subplot Orphan Andy: 5 stars
Subplot Cowboy and Harvard: 5 stars
Overall: 4 stars