Rooted in thousands of pages of Access to Information documents and dozens of interviews carried out throughout Latin America, Blood of Extraction examines the increasing presence of Canadian mining companies in Latin America and the environmental and human rights abuses that have occurred as a result. By following the money, Gordon and Webber illustrate the myriad ways Canadian-based multinational corporations, backed by the Canadian state, have developed extensive economic interests in Latin America over the last two decades at the expense of Latin American people and the environment.
Latin American communities affected by Canadian resource extraction are now organized into hundreds of opposition movements, from Mexico to Argentina, and the authors illustrate the strategies used by the Canadian state to silence this resistance and advance corporate interests.
The authors have conducted an extensive search through thousands of pages of Access to Information documents and interviews carried out throughout Latin America, resulting in a very pertinent and authoritative book. This book, of just over 350+ pages, is divided into four parts and countries such as Honduras, Guatemala, Columbia, Peru, Ecuador, Venezuela and the Andes are covered in-depth. Blood of Extraction may not be written for the casual reader but as a research tool I am sure it will prove invaluable to many educators as well as investors, activists and other groups desiring to act in an ethical and socially responsible way.
The best aspect of the book is the topic. It seems ripe for exposure. As Canadians, we can be a little smug about our role in the world (it helps that we're positioned next to the USA), believing we are usually, if not always, aligned on the side of good vs evil, reason vs prejudice, etc. Yet our mining companies have wreaked havoc environmentally and socially in so many disparate places in the world. And this is no small matter given that, as the authors point out, two-third's of the WORLD's mining companies are headquarters in Canada due to a variety of legal, regulatory and tax advantages.
The least appealing aspect of this book is its inaccessibility to a broader audience. It is loaded with academic jargon -- and I do mean jargon. It's hard to imagine anyone outside a scholarly audience enthusiastically turning the pages. Not a good read, in that sense.
I was also disappointed with the tone of the book. I understand and agree with the authors' antipathy to our corporate mining greed and the political, diplomatic and economic policies that facilitate their profitability without apparent concern for the welfare of vulnerable people, especially indigenous communities, around the world, and particularly Latin America, but I found they glossed over certain facts in order to support their thesis of corporate Canadian imperialistic evil-doers.
For example, they imply that Canadian companies prey solely upon the vulnerable societies of underdeveloped nations (sort of like they're the easy pickings and are thus targeted) which is not entirely accurate from what I know. After all, our mining companies also operate in the USA (e.g. copper mines in Arizona) as well as, obviously, Canada. And while some affect indigenous communities, some do not. They offer well-paying jobs, and unsurprisingly wreak environmental damage (e.g. Mount Polley spill) but rarely get attention. In other words, it's not always a "third world" issue -- the companies go where ever they can turn a profit, and will take whatever liberties the local regulators and population allow. This should not have been ignored.
Also, the authors make the point more than once about how mining as a job creator is inefficient because of the high ratio of investment dollars for each job created. That's a total red herring. Affected communities don't care how many millions are invested to create a job, all they want to know is how many jobs are created, how well they pay and how safe they are. Obviously the ratio of investment pays off for the mining companies in terms of profits. So this kind of spin on the data bothers me as an overt bias that undermines as opposed to enhances the thesis, and the authors' credibility.
I would say the same thing about the critique on Corporate Social Responsibility. Sure some of it is mere window dressing, but not all of it can be condemned as the authors seem to sweepingly generalize with comments like how CSR results in creation of "poorly-funded schools" (without the stats to support that). Just give the middling credit to the companies that build the schools and leave it at that.
These glosses all come prior to the major area of the book dealing with country profiles, so I felt wary as I read on. I don't think that's the reaction the authors would want. Nor do I want to overshadow the overall good work in the book with its careful research and its attempt to expose a problem the world, and Canadians in particular, should take greater heed of. After all, we laud the wealthy CEOs of these abusive mining companies (e.g., the largest shareholder of Mount Polley, N Murray Edwards, is considered a community leader in Alberta and co-owner of Calgary Flames; the late Peter Munk of Barrick was lauded as a "philanthropist and national champion" (Globe & Mail obit), etc.). Especially insightful is the close ties politically (both Liberal and Conservative) that allow our diplomats to play a role as corporate pitchmen. It should embarrass all Canadians.
I wish the prose weren't so dry for certain chapters but it's very informative and great analysis. Makes me want to read Trotsky's theory of uneven and combined development, Mandel, and Ellen Meiksins Wood