Alright, so this book left me feeling pretty confused, but interested enough in the characters to move forward and read Osterkamp's The Standout. When I finished reading Promises, Promises, I was confused enough by the abrupt ending that I went ahead and read The Standout before leaving my review for Promises, Promises. Hindsight, maybe I should have written the review for Promises before moving on. However, since this book is supposed to be a lead in to The Standout, a small portion of my review is going to focus on how the two books tie together.
Overall, I enjoyed Osterkamp's style of writing. I didn't notice any glaring editorial mistakes and the writing flowed well, although the timeline could be very jarring. You would be in one place on one day, suddenly in an event that happened the next day, before finding yourself in an event that happened many years ago. The characters were well developed and likable and the relationships in the story had some very interesting issues. Osterkamp fit quite a good bit of story into the short pages of this book, which I commend her for.
Here is the biggest issue that I had, especially after I read The Standout - there is no feasible reason I can see for this back story??? I assumed that the short story would tie in to the main story somehow, but even the main characters that carry from one story to the next don't feel like the same characters in both books. In The Standout, Robin is famous for being on a reality show called The Holdout - her fame (or infamy) is never noted at all in Promises, Promises. Robin's entire personality seems to do a 180 between the two books, leaving me very confused about what happened to the quiet, sightly introverted Robin that is portrayed in Promises, Promises. Tristan and Hunter, two of the main characters in Promises don't show up at all in The Standout.
You are left with unanswered questions at the end of Promises, Promises; what happened to the couple that disappeared in the cairns? Was Tristan truly involved or not? Did Tristan and Hunter get married, or did Hunter give in to the belief that Tristan was a murderer? These are major issues that were brought up in Promises that I have yet to find the answers to. Additionally, while this is listed as a led in to The Standout, after I finished both books I found out that there was at least one more book that came before The Standout, leaving me terribly confused about the entire timeline of this series. I don't know if you should read Promises, and then The Holdout before reading The Standout, since I haven't read The Holdout. There is also another book about Robin, called The Next Breath, and I have no idea where that one fits into the timeline, either.
So, I tried to go back and rate this book simply off of what I read, in the hopes that the author gives us a story that wraps this one up.