I found this book a little difficult to get into, but once I did, I wanted to find out what was going to happen. I didn't like the main character, Sarah, much in the beginning. She seemed quite cold at first, but then, as I met her father and realized how much he dictated her life, including her choice of career, I understood her a little more. Also, as the mother of an attorney, I understood her callousness, colored by stress, when she was in law school, since I went through that stress, vicariously, with my own son.
I enjoyed the descriptions of the small southern town and the tight-knit community that already had a verdict, signed, sealed and delivered, against Sarah's hometown friend, JoBeth, who'd been accused of murdering her children.
JoBeth herself is a pile of contradictions, not just in terms of the murder accusations, but also in terms of her relationship with everyone in the town. The entire situation unfolds in an interesting way, but I found myself being able to predict what was going to happen.
The one thing that stuck in my craw was why in the world would Sarah "fall" for the attorney Al, with whom she was working on JoBeth's trial? He comes across as an arrogant, pompous, self-centered egotist who doesn't care whom he steps on to get what he wants, and Sarah's no exception. One day, she'll look back and put Al into the #MeToo category. What she ever saw in him is beyond me, especially since he fits into the same category as her controlling father.
I liked the development of Sarah's mother, who was a real character, someone you'd expect to meet in real life, someone who has flaws but also tried to solve every problem that comes along, even though she knows she cannot. I also felt compassion for Sarah when her childhood canine companion had medical problems. The men, for the most part, are slime and remain the root of all evil in this book, and the women do not triumph; rather, they're victims.
I give this book between three and four stars. It has many interesting plot twists and turns, lots of foreshadowing, but also many things that could be obvious to an observant reader.