What do you think?
Rate this book
Queen Branwen #1
Between Two Fires: A Novel
Saxon barbarians threaten to destroy medieval Wales. Lady Branwen becomes Wales' last hope to unite their divided kingdoms when her father betroths her to a powerful Welsh warlord, the Hammer King. But the fledgling alliance is fraught with enemies from within and without as Branwen becomes the target of assassination attempts and courtly intrigue. A young woman in a world of fierce warriors, she seeks to assert her own authority and preserve Wales against the barbarians. But when she falls for a young hedge knight named Artagan, her world threatens to tear itself apart.
Caught between her duty to her people and her love of a man she cannot have, Branwen must choose whether to preserve her royal marriage or to follow her heart. Somehow she must save her people and remain true to herself, before Saxon invaders and a mysterious traitor try to destroy her.
Branwen's story combines elements of mystery and romance with Noce's gift for storytelling.
336 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 23, 2016
About the author
Mark Noce
3 books310 followersMark writes historical fiction with a passion, and eagerly reads everything from fantasy to literature. Born and raised in the San Francisco Bay Area, he has been an avid traveler and backpacker, particularly in Europe and North America. He earned his BA and MA from Cal Poly, San Luis Obispo, where he also met his beautiful wife. By day, he works as a Technical Writer, having spent much of his career at places like Google and Facebook. In addition to writing novels, he also writes short fiction online. When not reading or writing, he’s probably listening to U2, sailing his dad’s boat, or gardening with his family.
His debut novel, Between Two Fires and the upcoming sequel, Dark Winds Rising, are being published by St. Martin's Press and Macmillan.
His debut novel, Between Two Fires and the upcoming sequel, Dark Winds Rising, are being published by St. Martin's Press and Macmillan.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews
August 1, 2016
Despite having a strong start, this historical romance didn't work for me. While the Welsh countryside was a nice departure from the usual England that historical romances like to live in, there is not much else that I liked about this book. I felt that it had potential, but found that there were way too many conveniences.
It was almost ludicrous how many things just ended up “working out” despite no forethought or legitimate planning. And while I am not against “neat” endings this books ending was tied up so perfectly that it was practically factory sealed!
I normally love books by St.Martins Press but unfortunately this one didn't work for me. On the plus side, since I usually enjoy 80% of the books I read by this publisher, statistically speaking that means that the next book I read from them should be a five star....right?*fingers crossed*
Buy, Borrow or Bin Verdict: Bin
Check out more of my reviews here
Note: I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review.
July 14, 2016
Lady Branwen's father has promised her hand in marriage to the Hammer King to unite their divided kingdoms. However, after Lady Branwen meets her new King and leaves her home with him she immediately finds herself the target of multiple assassination attempts.
Lady Branwen is not one to sit by and become the property of a man and with her life in danger she takes her safety into her own hands and decides to leave the Hammer King. Not knowing who to trust Lady Branwen finds herself teaming up with a knight named Artagan and finds herself not only trying to save herself but her people before Saxon invaders and a mysterious traitor try to destroy her.
Between Two Fires is another novel I was a bit torn on how to rate when I was finished reading. It's not a bad read exactly but I found it really failed on what I was led on to believe the book should be. The synopsis to this one promised a historical romance and I think it fell really short of the romance side of things.
Taking place in 597 A.D. in medieval Wales this one stands out for being something a bit out of the normal in historical romances. It's a time when there are constant battles and wars and women were basically property. The setting was great in this one and made it stand out in my mind and along with an action packed plot I'm sure some will love that part of this historical read.
However, when it comes to the romance in this book I just found it extremely lacking. Lady Branwen is a strong female that wants to make her own decisions and stand alongside the men during the wars but I never gained an emotional attachment to her, she very well could have been a male telling the story most of the time. I kind of questioned maybe if it weren't the fact this one comes from a male author it just simply lost the romantic sparks that I was expecting and became an historical action read instead.
Overall, the setting and plot are great but I found the romance lacking, not enough depth to the characters personalities and emotions.
I received an advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
For more reviews please visit https://carriesbookreviews.wordpress....
Lady Branwen is not one to sit by and become the property of a man and with her life in danger she takes her safety into her own hands and decides to leave the Hammer King. Not knowing who to trust Lady Branwen finds herself teaming up with a knight named Artagan and finds herself not only trying to save herself but her people before Saxon invaders and a mysterious traitor try to destroy her.
Between Two Fires is another novel I was a bit torn on how to rate when I was finished reading. It's not a bad read exactly but I found it really failed on what I was led on to believe the book should be. The synopsis to this one promised a historical romance and I think it fell really short of the romance side of things.
Taking place in 597 A.D. in medieval Wales this one stands out for being something a bit out of the normal in historical romances. It's a time when there are constant battles and wars and women were basically property. The setting was great in this one and made it stand out in my mind and along with an action packed plot I'm sure some will love that part of this historical read.
However, when it comes to the romance in this book I just found it extremely lacking. Lady Branwen is a strong female that wants to make her own decisions and stand alongside the men during the wars but I never gained an emotional attachment to her, she very well could have been a male telling the story most of the time. I kind of questioned maybe if it weren't the fact this one comes from a male author it just simply lost the romantic sparks that I was expecting and became an historical action read instead.
Overall, the setting and plot are great but I found the romance lacking, not enough depth to the characters personalities and emotions.
I received an advance copy from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
For more reviews please visit https://carriesbookreviews.wordpress....
February 27, 2016
The time is A.D. 590s in rugged yet beautiful Wales when Saxons pillaged and Christians prayed to one God, but knew of and understood the earlier times of old tribal beliefs. In this stark setting amid castles and Roman ruins, Lady Branwen is a sixteen-year-old who seems to be destined to be a pawn in the game of power among the ruling kings.
We follow her journey from innocent, insecure girl to a young woman with a keen political mind and the ability to garner loyalty and admiration from the people she leads. Love, hate, murder, betrayal and bravery knit together to tell the story of Lady Branwen who must find the one behind the attacks on her life and survive. The enemy could be among her entourage and her closest friends.
In her story, she has Artagen, the man she loves, but who belongs to another. She has the king she's married to, but hates. She has her brother, but learns how even her kin can't be trusted. The story has been told before, but in Between Two Fires, Noce gives it a new life.
As to style, it's hard to pull off first person point of view, present tense, but in this book it was well done. It didn't affect the rhythm of the prose and it kept this reader close to the protagonist as she struggled to become an independent woman in a time when men controlled the world.
We follow her journey from innocent, insecure girl to a young woman with a keen political mind and the ability to garner loyalty and admiration from the people she leads. Love, hate, murder, betrayal and bravery knit together to tell the story of Lady Branwen who must find the one behind the attacks on her life and survive. The enemy could be among her entourage and her closest friends.
In her story, she has Artagen, the man she loves, but who belongs to another. She has the king she's married to, but hates. She has her brother, but learns how even her kin can't be trusted. The story has been told before, but in Between Two Fires, Noce gives it a new life.
As to style, it's hard to pull off first person point of view, present tense, but in this book it was well done. It didn't affect the rhythm of the prose and it kept this reader close to the protagonist as she struggled to become an independent woman in a time when men controlled the world.
February 26, 2016
Lady Branwen may often feel like a pawn, but even a pawn may stop a king in Mark Noce's Between Two Fires. The time of King Arthur may have passed, but the time of Lady Branwen has come. Branwen exudes a wisdom beyond her years and balances the traditions of the Old Tribes with the new Christian religion. She still makes plenty of mistakes, but she blossoms into a strong woman worthy of the Welsh people. The romance between her and Artagan is a bright spot in the novel. I couldn't help but want Branwen to be happy. Noce's lush descriptions transported me to the late sixth century Wales. An intriguing mystery of who wants Branwen dead weaves throughout the scenes and kept me guessing. Between Two Fires by Mark Noce combines complex political intrigue of sixth century Wales with sweet romance and a page-turning mystery.
August 23, 2016
Between Two Fires
By Mark Noce
Rating 4.5
The opening page begins with this:
To endure a dilemma is to stand between two fires. —CELTIC PROVERB
It is the year AD 597 as the story opens with 16 year old Branwen getting dressed for her wedding to a man to whom she has never met and has only heard horrific stories and rumors. She is scared and has absolutely no idea of what to expect. Just a few weeks ago she was riding her horse along the seaside lands of Dyfed and now she will soon be a Queen. A marriage of alliances and conveniences; but young Branwen only has nightmares. Branwen is spirited away from home and family before any wedding can take place by her betrothed, King Morgan, the Hammer King. Enroute she is waylaid, attacked and almost kidnapped if it had not been for the notorious hedge knight, Artagen, of the Free Cantrefs, who saved her. So begins the story of love, strife, battles, wars, intrigue, mystery, betrayal, birth and death.
I just love it!
This wasn't just a time when women were to be seen and not heard. This was a time when women were nothing more than possessions…easily donned and just as easily discarded. Queens who met with dissatisfaction or disfavor from the King either met with a deadly accident or retired to a nunnery. Marriages were not about love; but strategically planned alliances for power, protection and the giving of birth to sons. Branwen not only finds herself caught in the midst of a power struggle amongst the kingdoms of Wales; but also for the survival for all of Wales. This is pretty huge for a sixteen year old girl who is not yet quite a woman. On the eve of her 17th birthday, she is to finally wed King Moargan, the Hammer King. She is shaking and she has good reason…two failed kidnappings and an assassination attempt. Obviously, someone wants her dead; but who and why? So many twists and turns that it just makes your brain wobble.
Branwen, comes from a long line of women of the Old Tribes where women who were valued.
Women could become druidesses, rule as high chieftains, work along side the men or fight for their home and family. Women were able to express their thoughts on the most important of issues without reprisal. It was a time long forgotten…
“Father doubtlessly paced back and forth outside my mother’s solar, waiting to hear the first cries of his much-awaited son. Instead, he got me. Only once did he ever tell me of that night, and in an offhand way, while in one of his drunken reveries. He recalled the broad smile on my mother’s face the evening afterward, she belonging to the Old Tribes who prized daughters more over sons. A primitive custom, Father called it”.~ Branwen
Lord Vortigen of Dyfed, Branwen’s father, was not much of a father after her mother was killed by a Saxon raid when she was a very little girl. Branwen barely remembers her mother and her father never talks of her. However, Lord Vortigen, did teach Branwen how to play chess…the game of thinkers and of kings at a very early age. Branwen grew from a frightened almost woman to a bright, caring and strong woman of inner strength, confidence and character. I loved watching her grow and how she was able to calculate and think things through…much like the chess games she played with her father. She readily recognizes that she is a pawn amongst the more powerful and therefore can be readily disposed of at any given time. However, Branwen, is no stranger to the game of chess and she knows very well the strategies, maneuvering and patience the game requires. She is determined to win.
Artagen, is Branwen’s Knight and he is able to make any woman just swoon…even me, and I was only reading about him! I admit, a sigh or two escaped my lips. He is your bravado knight; but he has failings, too. He does love Branwen…and she him. Artagen is multi layered and complex. Maybe it comes from his lineage of the Free Cantrefs. However, I found all of the characters to be wholly developed and defined as the story progressed.
This time in early Wales history was well researched, not only in geography; but also the political unrest both in Wales and the lands surrounding Wales. It was a turbulent time with monarchies changing frequently. The the social mores, customs, beliefs and the religious beliefs of the time were well portrayed. Christianity had made its way into Wales; but there remained strong ties with some who still held on to the old ways. I was quite impressed and it brought the story so vividly to life with every single page.
“I stand between two fires. Always, always I live in the space between two all-consuming flames. Saxons try to destroy my world from without, and traitors try to destroy it from within. And all the while I must decide whether I can save my people and yet still remain true to the desires of my own heart. Between two fires, indeed.” ~Branwen
Sooo, there is no magic, no dragons or magical beasts either good or evil in the whole story. But there are castles, Knights, Kings and would-be kings, evil bad guys, Queens, dungeons and stolen kisses. There was plenty of nail biting angst, tension, intrigue, mystery, gory battles, mayhem and…Passion to keep me rereading passages and slowly turning each page. I didn't want to get to the last page. I didn't want to close the book. I didn't want it to end. But there is a door left open a crack…just maybe it will open and I can wander through.
I have received an electronic copy of this book from the publisher and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This in no way shaped or influenced my opinion of the book. I would like to thank St. Martin’s Press, Thomas Dunne Books and NetGalley for this opportunity.
By Mark Noce
Rating 4.5
The opening page begins with this:
To endure a dilemma is to stand between two fires. —CELTIC PROVERB
It is the year AD 597 as the story opens with 16 year old Branwen getting dressed for her wedding to a man to whom she has never met and has only heard horrific stories and rumors. She is scared and has absolutely no idea of what to expect. Just a few weeks ago she was riding her horse along the seaside lands of Dyfed and now she will soon be a Queen. A marriage of alliances and conveniences; but young Branwen only has nightmares. Branwen is spirited away from home and family before any wedding can take place by her betrothed, King Morgan, the Hammer King. Enroute she is waylaid, attacked and almost kidnapped if it had not been for the notorious hedge knight, Artagen, of the Free Cantrefs, who saved her. So begins the story of love, strife, battles, wars, intrigue, mystery, betrayal, birth and death.
I just love it!
This wasn't just a time when women were to be seen and not heard. This was a time when women were nothing more than possessions…easily donned and just as easily discarded. Queens who met with dissatisfaction or disfavor from the King either met with a deadly accident or retired to a nunnery. Marriages were not about love; but strategically planned alliances for power, protection and the giving of birth to sons. Branwen not only finds herself caught in the midst of a power struggle amongst the kingdoms of Wales; but also for the survival for all of Wales. This is pretty huge for a sixteen year old girl who is not yet quite a woman. On the eve of her 17th birthday, she is to finally wed King Moargan, the Hammer King. She is shaking and she has good reason…two failed kidnappings and an assassination attempt. Obviously, someone wants her dead; but who and why? So many twists and turns that it just makes your brain wobble.
Branwen, comes from a long line of women of the Old Tribes where women who were valued.
Women could become druidesses, rule as high chieftains, work along side the men or fight for their home and family. Women were able to express their thoughts on the most important of issues without reprisal. It was a time long forgotten…
“Father doubtlessly paced back and forth outside my mother’s solar, waiting to hear the first cries of his much-awaited son. Instead, he got me. Only once did he ever tell me of that night, and in an offhand way, while in one of his drunken reveries. He recalled the broad smile on my mother’s face the evening afterward, she belonging to the Old Tribes who prized daughters more over sons. A primitive custom, Father called it”.~ Branwen
Lord Vortigen of Dyfed, Branwen’s father, was not much of a father after her mother was killed by a Saxon raid when she was a very little girl. Branwen barely remembers her mother and her father never talks of her. However, Lord Vortigen, did teach Branwen how to play chess…the game of thinkers and of kings at a very early age. Branwen grew from a frightened almost woman to a bright, caring and strong woman of inner strength, confidence and character. I loved watching her grow and how she was able to calculate and think things through…much like the chess games she played with her father. She readily recognizes that she is a pawn amongst the more powerful and therefore can be readily disposed of at any given time. However, Branwen, is no stranger to the game of chess and she knows very well the strategies, maneuvering and patience the game requires. She is determined to win.
Artagen, is Branwen’s Knight and he is able to make any woman just swoon…even me, and I was only reading about him! I admit, a sigh or two escaped my lips. He is your bravado knight; but he has failings, too. He does love Branwen…and she him. Artagen is multi layered and complex. Maybe it comes from his lineage of the Free Cantrefs. However, I found all of the characters to be wholly developed and defined as the story progressed.
This time in early Wales history was well researched, not only in geography; but also the political unrest both in Wales and the lands surrounding Wales. It was a turbulent time with monarchies changing frequently. The the social mores, customs, beliefs and the religious beliefs of the time were well portrayed. Christianity had made its way into Wales; but there remained strong ties with some who still held on to the old ways. I was quite impressed and it brought the story so vividly to life with every single page.
“I stand between two fires. Always, always I live in the space between two all-consuming flames. Saxons try to destroy my world from without, and traitors try to destroy it from within. And all the while I must decide whether I can save my people and yet still remain true to the desires of my own heart. Between two fires, indeed.” ~Branwen
Sooo, there is no magic, no dragons or magical beasts either good or evil in the whole story. But there are castles, Knights, Kings and would-be kings, evil bad guys, Queens, dungeons and stolen kisses. There was plenty of nail biting angst, tension, intrigue, mystery, gory battles, mayhem and…Passion to keep me rereading passages and slowly turning each page. I didn't want to get to the last page. I didn't want to close the book. I didn't want it to end. But there is a door left open a crack…just maybe it will open and I can wander through.
I have received an electronic copy of this book from the publisher and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This in no way shaped or influenced my opinion of the book. I would like to thank St. Martin’s Press, Thomas Dunne Books and NetGalley for this opportunity.
May 8, 2018
Medieval Wales - my fav. This book started really strong, but the last half of the book was mostly romance and coincidence. Branwen was all over the place with her decisions. She mostly reacted with emotion rather than thinking things through. I loved reading about the setting, and Noce really portrays Wales and its customs well.
February 22, 2022
I don't know what to think! I'm so sorry author, I don't think writing historical fiction with female leads is your jam! I had to BURN my eyes every time you were misogynistic or just unaware of what you were doing.
I'm so sorry, this was soooo mean, but I COULD NOT deal with this book.
but hey the story was kind of good? I did like the history.
February 26, 2016
While I’m not usually a fan of stories written in first person present tense, this one works. The author immediately captures the sense of the main character trapped in the expectations of her society and place. I felt for her and looked forward to when she would inevitably show the male dominated world she had more value than just being good breeding stock.
I loved the energy in the story and the cinematic action sequences. The plot kept the story moving. The descriptions swept me away to a wonderful version of Welsh life in a time of great unrest. I could smell the wood smoke, feel the chill in the air, hear the crackle of the fires and clash of swords.
This book is promoted as an Historical Romance. I’d hesitate calling it an historical. Yes, it’s set in Wales just shy of 600 AD, but there were too many distracting anachronisms for me to call it historical. It would make a far better fantasy. But then, I’ve studied a fair bit of the Anglo-Saxon times and I suspect most people wouldn’t even pick up on the majority of the anachronisms, so it’s not a huge issue.
On the romance side, it had the perfect amount for me, which wasn’t a whole lot. Normally I shy away from romances because I’m not a fan of most stories where the focus is solely on the romantic relationship between two characters. However, this book is more of an action adventure with a little bit of romance on the side. My kind of story.
Between Two Fires will carry you away on an adventure of court intrigue, spies and assassins, and the occasional twist to keep everything moving. A light, fun read.
4.5 stars.
I loved the energy in the story and the cinematic action sequences. The plot kept the story moving. The descriptions swept me away to a wonderful version of Welsh life in a time of great unrest. I could smell the wood smoke, feel the chill in the air, hear the crackle of the fires and clash of swords.
This book is promoted as an Historical Romance. I’d hesitate calling it an historical. Yes, it’s set in Wales just shy of 600 AD, but there were too many distracting anachronisms for me to call it historical. It would make a far better fantasy. But then, I’ve studied a fair bit of the Anglo-Saxon times and I suspect most people wouldn’t even pick up on the majority of the anachronisms, so it’s not a huge issue.
On the romance side, it had the perfect amount for me, which wasn’t a whole lot. Normally I shy away from romances because I’m not a fan of most stories where the focus is solely on the romantic relationship between two characters. However, this book is more of an action adventure with a little bit of romance on the side. My kind of story.
Between Two Fires will carry you away on an adventure of court intrigue, spies and assassins, and the occasional twist to keep everything moving. A light, fun read.
4.5 stars.
September 30, 2016
I enjoyed reading the level of detail and felt thoroughly immersed in this early medieval world. Anyone who wants to read about the kind of world depicted in The Lord of The Rings, without the fantasy elements, will feel at home here on the Welsh Marches. Suspicious kings, siege wars, ambushes, rangers, warning beacons, cold stone castles, brave horses, archers, invaders, and a strong heroine all feature.
Lady Branwen is sixteen, about to be wed to a warrior she's never met in order to seal a truce in the expected way. Women were pawns of the warlords. By uniting the tribes her soon-to-be husband expects to have aid in holding off the coming Saxons. But an ambush might kill or separate them even before Branwen reaches her new lord's home at Caerleon.
To add tension and romantic suspense a daring outlaw is introduced; and gradually we see Branwen, who enjoys reading in Latin and has been taught to pray dutifully, develop a stronger sense of self and learn the skills of a warrior lord's wife.
I am impressed by the research demonstrated and look forward to reading more from this American author. An ARC was sent to me. I chose to write an unbiased review.
Lady Branwen is sixteen, about to be wed to a warrior she's never met in order to seal a truce in the expected way. Women were pawns of the warlords. By uniting the tribes her soon-to-be husband expects to have aid in holding off the coming Saxons. But an ambush might kill or separate them even before Branwen reaches her new lord's home at Caerleon.
To add tension and romantic suspense a daring outlaw is introduced; and gradually we see Branwen, who enjoys reading in Latin and has been taught to pray dutifully, develop a stronger sense of self and learn the skills of a warrior lord's wife.
I am impressed by the research demonstrated and look forward to reading more from this American author. An ARC was sent to me. I chose to write an unbiased review.
July 16, 2016
* I received this title for free from NetGalley in return for honest feedback*
When I read the description for this novel I was so excited! I love historical fiction and romance all wrapped together in a story. I was ready for love, lust, back stabbing, and devous court rumors. I commend Mark Noce for embarking on this journey, I think it takes a great deal to write about 597 AD. However, this novel missed the mark for me.
Our main character, Lady Branwen, is a young unattractive girl set to be married to the Hammer King. I thought the story started off well. There was some action to get the characters moving and start the journey to the Hammer King’s castle. Upon arrival, the action comes to a halt. I felt that Lady Branwen conveyed little emotion. She had some inner dialogue/emotion but not enough for me to feel a connection to her. When her love interest was introduced there was no indication of their feelings towards one another. Lady Branwen didn’t wonder about him before she fell asleep, or her heart didn’t skip a beat when she saw him in court.
I wasn’t looking for instant romance, but something that would have sparked that love and lust I was hoping for. The action scenes within the story also had “neat” resolutions. If Lady Branwen was being chased, an archer suddenly appeared and saved the moment! There was hardly any consequence for her actions. I decided to call it quits on this novel when I got to Part II - 598 AD. Lady Branwen is pregnant with the Hammer King’s child. In about two months, she loses the child and lots of blood, confining her to her bedchamber. The Hammer King is anxious to have an heir and made some comments about riding his Queen like a horse. In that moment, Lady Branwen decided that she can’t be with him any more. The Hammer King is a wicked man and leaves the castle with her love interest, Artagan, in tow.
I felt that her actions during this part were so abrupt. There was a little inkling to the romance that will ensue, but I was at 42% on my Kindle when I reached this point. I filed this under my “did not finish” shelf. I was disappointed to say the least. I felt that there was so much promise for this historical romance, but it didn’t pan out.
When I read the description for this novel I was so excited! I love historical fiction and romance all wrapped together in a story. I was ready for love, lust, back stabbing, and devous court rumors. I commend Mark Noce for embarking on this journey, I think it takes a great deal to write about 597 AD. However, this novel missed the mark for me.
Our main character, Lady Branwen, is a young unattractive girl set to be married to the Hammer King. I thought the story started off well. There was some action to get the characters moving and start the journey to the Hammer King’s castle. Upon arrival, the action comes to a halt. I felt that Lady Branwen conveyed little emotion. She had some inner dialogue/emotion but not enough for me to feel a connection to her. When her love interest was introduced there was no indication of their feelings towards one another. Lady Branwen didn’t wonder about him before she fell asleep, or her heart didn’t skip a beat when she saw him in court.
I wasn’t looking for instant romance, but something that would have sparked that love and lust I was hoping for. The action scenes within the story also had “neat” resolutions. If Lady Branwen was being chased, an archer suddenly appeared and saved the moment! There was hardly any consequence for her actions. I decided to call it quits on this novel when I got to Part II - 598 AD. Lady Branwen is pregnant with the Hammer King’s child. In about two months, she loses the child and lots of blood, confining her to her bedchamber. The Hammer King is anxious to have an heir and made some comments about riding his Queen like a horse. In that moment, Lady Branwen decided that she can’t be with him any more. The Hammer King is a wicked man and leaves the castle with her love interest, Artagan, in tow.
I felt that her actions during this part were so abrupt. There was a little inkling to the romance that will ensue, but I was at 42% on my Kindle when I reached this point. I filed this under my “did not finish” shelf. I was disappointed to say the least. I felt that there was so much promise for this historical romance, but it didn’t pan out.
February 5, 2016
Lady Branwen is Wales' last hope to unite divided kingdoms, but it means marrying a man she's never met. The Hammer King is a powerful warlord, and surely he will drive off the Saxon invaders and bring peace to the land again. From the beginning, Branwen's marriage is shadowed by assassination attempts and a spy within. Yet she must choose between duty and love when she falls for a hedge knight named Artagan. But can she save her people and be true to herself at the same time?
A magnificent historical romance that has renewed my love for the genre. Long ago, I became a fan of The Mists of Avalon by Marion Zimmer Bradley. It's been a long time since another medieval tale has captured me in the same way, but I found the magic again in Between Two Fires. It's masterfully written with beautiful detail and wondrous settings. The action is intense and the mystery clever.
Right from the beginning I was hooked, and it is because of the fantastic characterization. Branwen is a strong and admirable heroine. She might be young when she's married, but she has to grow up fast to survive. Artagan might come off as a flashy flirt, but there's so much more to him under it. The whole cast of characters is many layered, and they make this world even more brilliant.
I was lucky enough to win an ARC of this book in a giveaway, and I was under no obligation to review it. But when something this amazing comes along, I want to share it with the world! I cannot wait for more from Mark Noce.
A magnificent historical romance that has renewed my love for the genre. Long ago, I became a fan of The Mists of Avalon by Marion Zimmer Bradley. It's been a long time since another medieval tale has captured me in the same way, but I found the magic again in Between Two Fires. It's masterfully written with beautiful detail and wondrous settings. The action is intense and the mystery clever.
Right from the beginning I was hooked, and it is because of the fantastic characterization. Branwen is a strong and admirable heroine. She might be young when she's married, but she has to grow up fast to survive. Artagan might come off as a flashy flirt, but there's so much more to him under it. The whole cast of characters is many layered, and they make this world even more brilliant.
I was lucky enough to win an ARC of this book in a giveaway, and I was under no obligation to review it. But when something this amazing comes along, I want to share it with the world! I cannot wait for more from Mark Noce.
September 13, 2016
I entered Branwen's world as she was thinking about her impending marriage to a man she'd never met. I fell in love with her voice. A page or two later, I was already deep into her story. I'd follow Branwen anywhere. Between Two Fires, by Mark Noce, is a wonderful debut. I'm looking forward to reading more books by him.
December 24, 2017
2 stars
This book started off so well! I was hooked immediately. The author has obvious skill. He can pull you into the story with nearly effortless language.
But he can't keep telling the story past a certain point. After about the 40% mark the book just kept repeating itself in a way that got so incredibly tiresome. For example, several places he mentions that the stone castles of Wales were erected by the Romans, but the Celts had lost the knowledge of how to build them so newer fortresses are wooden. Beyond the repetition of research facts I also had issues with the repetition of plot points. The story pretty much boiled down to "Branwen gets pissed off and runs away. When she gets to her new place the Saxons Attack! Who is the spy in Branwen's camp? Someone she trusts is betraying her!" This happened over and over and I got pretty sick of Branwen not figuring it out when it was obvious from the getgo. I also got pretty sick of her getting innocent people murdered by Saxons every whipstitch because of her lack of thinking for anyone but herself. The author tries to drive home the point that she's a genius at the ancient game of Celtic Chess (which she played with her father.) But then he repeatedly has her making amateurish decisions that lack any tactical skill.
I ended up skimming the third section of the book because I couldn't deal with any more of that mess. And of course I was dead on about who the traitors were.
The other thing I need to mention is that there are several places where the author steals lines or scenes from more popular / classic novels. Sampling the hits is great if you're writing a hiphop single. It's not so awesome when you're writing a novel.
--at one point the brash Gary Stu love interest tells Branwen to "stab the Saxons with the pointy end". George RR Martin wants his line back.
--Branwen's husband is brought back from battle gravely wounded. His entire army believes him to be near death. Branwen is trained as a healer and steps in to save his life. She earns respect from all by spending a long night stitching him up and saving his life. Julie Garwood wants her scene back.
Honestly, I debated about whether or not to write this review. The book was recommended by a friend who knows the author and I am not keen on hurting his feelings with my opinions. But honestly he's a good writer. This is his first published novel. I am betting he'll have some 4- and even 5-star books coming. He has the native skill, which is something few authors possess. I'll try his subsequent work. But this one just didn't quite make the grade overall.
This book started off so well! I was hooked immediately. The author has obvious skill. He can pull you into the story with nearly effortless language.
But he can't keep telling the story past a certain point. After about the 40% mark the book just kept repeating itself in a way that got so incredibly tiresome. For example, several places he mentions that the stone castles of Wales were erected by the Romans, but the Celts had lost the knowledge of how to build them so newer fortresses are wooden. Beyond the repetition of research facts I also had issues with the repetition of plot points. The story pretty much boiled down to "Branwen gets pissed off and runs away. When she gets to her new place the Saxons Attack! Who is the spy in Branwen's camp? Someone she trusts is betraying her!" This happened over and over and I got pretty sick of Branwen not figuring it out when it was obvious from the getgo. I also got pretty sick of her getting innocent people murdered by Saxons every whipstitch because of her lack of thinking for anyone but herself. The author tries to drive home the point that she's a genius at the ancient game of Celtic Chess (which she played with her father.) But then he repeatedly has her making amateurish decisions that lack any tactical skill.
I ended up skimming the third section of the book because I couldn't deal with any more of that mess. And of course I was dead on about who the traitors were.
The other thing I need to mention is that there are several places where the author steals lines or scenes from more popular / classic novels. Sampling the hits is great if you're writing a hiphop single. It's not so awesome when you're writing a novel.
--at one point the brash Gary Stu love interest tells Branwen to "stab the Saxons with the pointy end". George RR Martin wants his line back.
--Branwen's husband is brought back from battle gravely wounded. His entire army believes him to be near death. Branwen is trained as a healer and steps in to save his life. She earns respect from all by spending a long night stitching him up and saving his life. Julie Garwood wants her scene back.
Honestly, I debated about whether or not to write this review. The book was recommended by a friend who knows the author and I am not keen on hurting his feelings with my opinions. But honestly he's a good writer. This is his first published novel. I am betting he'll have some 4- and even 5-star books coming. He has the native skill, which is something few authors possess. I'll try his subsequent work. But this one just didn't quite make the grade overall.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 17, 2019
While it was a good story there was so many parts that didn't seem logical to me. The biggest one is why Queen Branwen was so loved. I guess she healed people (although she was young and didn't really have a lot of experience doing that) but she brought so much danger that it just didn't seem plausible a whole community of people would love her so much to risk their lives. Everywhere she went people were willing to die for her. WHY? I felt nothing for her. I think maybe because the author spent a lot of time making her seem like she was a silly young girl and not much time on her being a strong and important woman. I found her very spoiled and silly. Definitely not someone to risk your life for or follow into battle.
I also didn't buy that she could marry a man when already a Queen and married to a King. I guess it didn't matter back then.
I also didn't buy that she could marry a man when already a Queen and married to a King. I guess it didn't matter back then.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 18, 2020
There were many things I really like about this novel and some things that I think could have been a little better. I love the cover and the strong female character Branwen. I also liked the overall story and characters. What confused me was that at first her husband seemed ok. He was gentle with her and made her part of a delegation. He let her sit in on a meeting and said that he wanted her to be more than a broodmare. Then everything changed and he was a completely different man. It kind of felt like he was two different people and the author just wanted to pave the way for a new love interest for Branwen. That aside, I did enjoy the story.
July 29, 2018
3.75
Interesting...this is the definition of historical fiction. There's no fantasy element what so ever (which was actually quite refreshing for me today). I liked that the mc grew with her experiences and understood how things were escalading and adapted accordingly. It felt like such a long book with everything that covered but it's actually quite small! MC romance was sweet.
Interesting...this is the definition of historical fiction. There's no fantasy element what so ever (which was actually quite refreshing for me today). I liked that the mc grew with her experiences and understood how things were escalading and adapted accordingly. It felt like such a long book with everything that covered but it's actually quite small! MC romance was sweet.
March 11, 2018
Branwen is a pawn in a king's game, the target for marriage, bearing children, assassinations, and kingdom destruction by Saxons. She's more than aware that her life isn't entirely in her own hands, so she plays like a chess master, navigating the numerous courts throughout Wales to unite the country, be with the one she truly loves, and defeat the Saxons.
I'm always eager to read books similar to Hild or Shadow on the Crown, stories that are set in medieval or ancient Britain / Europe, when countries were still torn apart in tiny little kingdoms. Bonus points for those women navigating and influencing this incredibly patriarchal and sexist time.
Noce's writing style forced me to slow down and take in every single scene word for word. I fell in love with Branwen slowly but surely, beginning as a naive yet frightened young woman and growing into the "Fairy Queen" she became to Wales by the end of the novel. I savored each moment with Artagan, and worried for his safety each time he rode off to battle. And, speaking of battles, I was *gasp* totally invested in all those battle scenes. The Welsh castles and fortresses I could picture in my head and it still blows my mind how people were able to defend themselves in those spaces. There were also a few twists here and there that I was able to predict, but the twists within the twists left such an intriguing trail of deceit that I was impressed.
I enjoyed this enough that I'm eager to see what Dark Winds Rising has in store!
I'm always eager to read books similar to Hild or Shadow on the Crown, stories that are set in medieval or ancient Britain / Europe, when countries were still torn apart in tiny little kingdoms. Bonus points for those women navigating and influencing this incredibly patriarchal and sexist time.
Noce's writing style forced me to slow down and take in every single scene word for word. I fell in love with Branwen slowly but surely, beginning as a naive yet frightened young woman and growing into the "Fairy Queen" she became to Wales by the end of the novel. I savored each moment with Artagan, and worried for his safety each time he rode off to battle. And, speaking of battles, I was *gasp* totally invested in all those battle scenes. The Welsh castles and fortresses I could picture in my head and it still blows my mind how people were able to defend themselves in those spaces. There were also a few twists here and there that I was able to predict, but the twists within the twists left such an intriguing trail of deceit that I was impressed.
I enjoyed this enough that I'm eager to see what Dark Winds Rising has in store!
August 24, 2016
Every day is a struggle for life, death, or love.
This story commences in 587 A.D. with the Welsh clans during the middle ages. The various Welsh clans have their own kingdoms and are not known for helping each other when threatened. The Saxons intend to destroy medieval Wales. Branwen, daughter of King Vorten of Dyfed is betrothed to a powerful Welsh Warlord, Morgan, the Hammer King, thereby having someone to help defend him if attacked. She is only sixteen years old, her real mother died years prior at the hands of the Saxons. King Morgan is several years older than Branwen, is a widower and has a son by his first wife. Branwen knows nothing of marriage and is afraid, but she is also a healer and Morgan becomes ill and she heals him. Morgan has a brother Malcolm who is always trying to seduce one of the maids. Branwen has a half-brother, who goes with her as her body guard, when her father betroths her to a powerful Welsh warlord, the Hammer King. But the fledgling alliance is fraught with enemies from within and without as Branwen becomes the target of assassination attempts and courtly intrigue. Towards the end of the story the reader discovers who is the party attempting to slay Branwen and why.
She is a young woman in a world of fierce warriors, who thinks like a queen, has been highly educated by a Priest who supplies many books for her, and she absorb the information as she seeks to assert her own authority and preserve Wales against the barbarians. She wants to unite all of the kingdom into one in order to defend themselves against the Saxon, who kill everyone in their path when they raid.
When King Morgan sends her as his emissary, she is attacked by a small group of Saxons and is saved by a young hedge knight named Artagan, of the Free Cantrefs Clan. They are poor and move around much of the time, but their women fight side by side with their men. Branwen gets two young maidens as her ladies in waiting and they are always there for her. The story is complicated, extremely active with wars and deaths. Branwen does much healing during her time with the Free Cantrefs and she becomes beloved by most who meet her. The story then filters around her off again on again time with Artagan.
This is a long, complicated tale full of wars, death, healing, romance, betrayal and adventure. It is a page turner and the author must have researched those times to make them come alive so well. I love the story and I was given a complimentary copy for an honest review.
This story commences in 587 A.D. with the Welsh clans during the middle ages. The various Welsh clans have their own kingdoms and are not known for helping each other when threatened. The Saxons intend to destroy medieval Wales. Branwen, daughter of King Vorten of Dyfed is betrothed to a powerful Welsh Warlord, Morgan, the Hammer King, thereby having someone to help defend him if attacked. She is only sixteen years old, her real mother died years prior at the hands of the Saxons. King Morgan is several years older than Branwen, is a widower and has a son by his first wife. Branwen knows nothing of marriage and is afraid, but she is also a healer and Morgan becomes ill and she heals him. Morgan has a brother Malcolm who is always trying to seduce one of the maids. Branwen has a half-brother, who goes with her as her body guard, when her father betroths her to a powerful Welsh warlord, the Hammer King. But the fledgling alliance is fraught with enemies from within and without as Branwen becomes the target of assassination attempts and courtly intrigue. Towards the end of the story the reader discovers who is the party attempting to slay Branwen and why.
She is a young woman in a world of fierce warriors, who thinks like a queen, has been highly educated by a Priest who supplies many books for her, and she absorb the information as she seeks to assert her own authority and preserve Wales against the barbarians. She wants to unite all of the kingdom into one in order to defend themselves against the Saxon, who kill everyone in their path when they raid.
When King Morgan sends her as his emissary, she is attacked by a small group of Saxons and is saved by a young hedge knight named Artagan, of the Free Cantrefs Clan. They are poor and move around much of the time, but their women fight side by side with their men. Branwen gets two young maidens as her ladies in waiting and they are always there for her. The story is complicated, extremely active with wars and deaths. Branwen does much healing during her time with the Free Cantrefs and she becomes beloved by most who meet her. The story then filters around her off again on again time with Artagan.
This is a long, complicated tale full of wars, death, healing, romance, betrayal and adventure. It is a page turner and the author must have researched those times to make them come alive so well. I love the story and I was given a complimentary copy for an honest review.
November 5, 2015
I love a good mystery, and I love fiction that takes place in historical times. I’m also hooked on stories set in Celtic Britain. So these are three great reasons to be delighted with Mark Noce’s debut novel, Between Two Fires.
The book opens in the year A.D. 597—post-Arthurian times, when Wales is in disarray from the invading Saxons. The Romans are gone. Arthur’s Camelot is distant history. Christianity coexists with remnants of the old Druid religion. Fragmented Wales is riddled by power struggles between kings want to be sole ruler of Wales, if it can ever be united enough to withstand the Saxons. The ambitious King Vortigen of Dyfed has decided to marry his illegitimate daughter Branwen to King Morgan of Caerleon and Caerwent, also known as the Hammer King. Illegitimate or not, it’s to Morgan’s advantage to breed sons by Branwen for the future, and it’s to Vortigen’s advantage to have his daughter strategically placed to spy on Morgan. Yes. It’s that kind of world, full of intrigue and counterplots set in motion by those who have other plans for Branwen.
At first, sixteen-year-old Branwen, smart but dutiful, is resigned to her destiny. Then several attempts on her life force her to make her own destiny, one very much at odds to the future her father had planned. Choosing love over duty, using healing skills she learned from her mother, trusting her own natural leadership, Branwen becomes a legend throughout Wales. The story is told throughout through her eyes in present tense, which gives a sense of immediacy to every scene. Subplots abound, all of them well-resolved. From the opening line (Today I will marry a man I have never met), the main story’s builds tension, and each chapter ends on a page turner.
The story takes place over a three-year period, during which Branwen evolves into a revered figure the people call Mab Ceridwen, with the love of her life by her side. I can’t tell much more of the storyline beyond this without spoilers. But this is a book to settle into, as you become immersed in history, legend, and a great love story.
I was fortunate to get an advance copy of this book for an honest review. I've also pre-ordered the book so that I can get it signed in September.
The book opens in the year A.D. 597—post-Arthurian times, when Wales is in disarray from the invading Saxons. The Romans are gone. Arthur’s Camelot is distant history. Christianity coexists with remnants of the old Druid religion. Fragmented Wales is riddled by power struggles between kings want to be sole ruler of Wales, if it can ever be united enough to withstand the Saxons. The ambitious King Vortigen of Dyfed has decided to marry his illegitimate daughter Branwen to King Morgan of Caerleon and Caerwent, also known as the Hammer King. Illegitimate or not, it’s to Morgan’s advantage to breed sons by Branwen for the future, and it’s to Vortigen’s advantage to have his daughter strategically placed to spy on Morgan. Yes. It’s that kind of world, full of intrigue and counterplots set in motion by those who have other plans for Branwen.
At first, sixteen-year-old Branwen, smart but dutiful, is resigned to her destiny. Then several attempts on her life force her to make her own destiny, one very much at odds to the future her father had planned. Choosing love over duty, using healing skills she learned from her mother, trusting her own natural leadership, Branwen becomes a legend throughout Wales. The story is told throughout through her eyes in present tense, which gives a sense of immediacy to every scene. Subplots abound, all of them well-resolved. From the opening line (Today I will marry a man I have never met), the main story’s builds tension, and each chapter ends on a page turner.
The story takes place over a three-year period, during which Branwen evolves into a revered figure the people call Mab Ceridwen, with the love of her life by her side. I can’t tell much more of the storyline beyond this without spoilers. But this is a book to settle into, as you become immersed in history, legend, and a great love story.
I was fortunate to get an advance copy of this book for an honest review. I've also pre-ordered the book so that I can get it signed in September.
February 3, 2017
I received a free copy of this book via netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
This book had a great premise, it should have been full of history, it should have been a great book that left the reader wanting more. Sadly it did not deliver. If this had not been a review book and I was reading it for a challenge I wouldn't have gotten past the first two chapters.
I know there is a lot of sexism in history but this was just too much to handle.Also the whole ugly girl gets all the guys, 4 kings and prince oh and a few other guys thrown in. Then suddenly she is pretty.Suddenly she has guts to do what is needed.
The story dragged, it went from one boring poorly written skirmish to the next, with very little in between. The parts that should have been good, the history, the politics, the battles all lacked oomph. I do not know enough about the history of this period in Wales to say whether it is true or not, but I know Lady Branwen didn't exist. (If google is telling the truth).
There was no description at all of the countryside, Wales is a beautiful place, even a little description of the countryside would have been nice, but apart from it being wooded or in doors etc there was nothing.
I really wish I could have liked this more but I was glad when the book finished.
2 out of 5 stars
This book had a great premise, it should have been full of history, it should have been a great book that left the reader wanting more. Sadly it did not deliver. If this had not been a review book and I was reading it for a challenge I wouldn't have gotten past the first two chapters.
I know there is a lot of sexism in history but this was just too much to handle.Also the whole ugly girl gets all the guys, 4 kings and prince oh and a few other guys thrown in. Then suddenly she is pretty.Suddenly she has guts to do what is needed.
The story dragged, it went from one boring poorly written skirmish to the next, with very little in between. The parts that should have been good, the history, the politics, the battles all lacked oomph. I do not know enough about the history of this period in Wales to say whether it is true or not, but I know Lady Branwen didn't exist. (If google is telling the truth).
There was no description at all of the countryside, Wales is a beautiful place, even a little description of the countryside would have been nice, but apart from it being wooded or in doors etc there was nothing.
I really wish I could have liked this more but I was glad when the book finished.
2 out of 5 stars
October 20, 2016
Originally Between Two Fires intrigued me so much, I was the first person to request a hold even before my library managed to purchase a copy. A strong female protagonist is caught up in a political intrigue, while her home country of Wales is being invaded by brutal Saxons? That sounds right up my alley! Assassins? Allegiances? Forbidden love? Sign me up! But instead of a gritty, complex historical novel I get a bodice ripper with a Christian fiction filter thrown on top. This book is about as gritty as a basket of kittens. That’s not how the Dark Ages worked!
Obviously I am the wrong audience for this book. Between Two Fires is for the people who prefer the Arthurian version of history – with its chivalry, romanticism, and the black-and-white characterization. The good guys are saintly, and the bad guys have a maniacal laugh and a pointy mustache. Seriously, you can figure them out from a mile away. If you are familiar with some common tropes in fiction, you will know the solution to the main mystery before that mystery is even introduced.
The huge red flag from the very beginning was... [more on Chika Books]
Obviously I am the wrong audience for this book. Between Two Fires is for the people who prefer the Arthurian version of history – with its chivalry, romanticism, and the black-and-white characterization. The good guys are saintly, and the bad guys have a maniacal laugh and a pointy mustache. Seriously, you can figure them out from a mile away. If you are familiar with some common tropes in fiction, you will know the solution to the main mystery before that mystery is even introduced.
The huge red flag from the very beginning was... [more on Chika Books]
October 4, 2016
Lady Branwen is being used as a pawn in a medieval game of chess. She is uniting two divided kingdoms in Wales by marrying the Hammer King, a powerful and tough Welsh warlord. Lady Branwen is just a young girl though and this is all new to her; she has little guidance. Her step-mother isn't supportive, so she barely has anyone on her side. To complicate matters further, the Saxons are constantly attacking and she has even been subjected to many assassination attempts. She knows her job is to simply produce an heir, but she can't help her desire to be more and do more. However, in medieval Wales, this is close to impossible. Enter a young knight named Artagan. She shouldn't feel something for him, but she does and now she must deal with impossible question of following her heart or knowing her place and her duty. Mark Noce's Between Two Fires is an entertaining medieval tale despite the few issues I had with it.
Read the rest of my review here: http://www.confessionsofabookaddict.c...
Read the rest of my review here: http://www.confessionsofabookaddict.c...
November 2, 2016
While reading Between Two Fires, I felt very much like I was reading a book along the lines of Queen of the Tearling, only this was set in history instead of a fantasy world. Mark Noce excels at bringing ancient Wales to full Technicolor life, and I found myself drawn into this era that I know relatively little about. Queen Branwen is a scrappy sort of heroine who isn't about to sit idly by and let society (or her husband) dictate the path her life will take. The romantic in me also enjoyed the chemistry between her and Artagan, who reminded me of a dashing sort of Robin Hood.
The dust jacket says this is only the first in an epic historical series--I'll be interested to see where Mark Noce takes the story next!
The dust jacket says this is only the first in an epic historical series--I'll be interested to see where Mark Noce takes the story next!
September 16, 2014
I love a story with a good strong female character, and Branwen grows into a force to be reckoned with over the course of this book. Equal parts historical thriller, love story, and mystery it captured my attention and took me on a thrilling adventure.
August 7, 2019
I found much to like about this novel. Branwen is a lovable character--a strong, independent young woman in a world of men who want to control her. When she meets and butts heads with the Robin Hood-esque Artagan, sparks fly. Their relationship starts and remains one of equals. I was very impressed with Mark Noce's ability to write from the perspective of a character of another gender than his own, and make it realistic. He even wrote accurately about how it feels to grow breasts. The story was well-plotted and well-paced, and it kept me turning pages and thinking about the story when I had to put the book down.
So, why not four or five stars? There were a lot of historical inaccuracies and linguistic anachronisms that had the effect of pulling me out of the story. The story is set in the years 597-99 in Wales. The problem is that back then Wales didn't exist and the word that was to become "Welsh," "wealh," was used by the Saxons for their Brittonic slaves. (If you want a historically accurate treatment of that concept, I recommend Hild by Nicola Griffith). Branwen and the other characters refer to themselves as Welsh and have a pride in a Welsh identity that would not exist for centuries.
The names of people and places are given in Modern Welsh, a language that would not develop for more than 1000 years. In the 590s, Brittonic tribes from the west coast were speaking dialects of Primitive Welsh (some linguists might even dispute that and call it Common Brittonic). All that said, I expect most readers wouldn't be bothered by this and if it was an editorial decision made so that modern readers can relate more to the story, I understand. If I did not have a background in linguistics none of this would have mattered to me.
Also problematic is the fact that the story deals with the Britons battling the Saxons under Penda of Mercia, a king who was not even born until 606. Branwen's father is Vortigen (which should be Vortigern) of Dyfed, who may have been legendary, but is said to have ruled in the year 425. There are other historical inaccuracies of that nature throughout the book.
Finally, the story is shot through with a highly romanticized view of the "ancient Celts." First of all, the people we think of as Celts wouldn't have used that term for themselves. Second of all, although I love the idea of a matriarchal, peace-loving culture driven by "Ancient Harmonies" and a kindly Mother Goddess, that is not what the tribes we collectively refer to now as the "ancient Celts" actually had. They had an intensely hierarchical warrior culture. While it's true that women could be warriors, queens and druids, the ideas of peace and love that a wise priestess who follows the "ancient ways" espouses in the story derive more from systems like Buddhism and Quakerism than the actual beliefs of Europeans in the Early Historic Period. And when the ancient poet Taliesin was referred to as a "Welsh shaman" I had to grit my teeth. There may be some similarities between poetic inspiration and shamanism, but Early Historic Britons would never know the term, let alone compare one of their poets to a shaman.
Notwithstanding the historical inaccuracies, Between Two Fires was a good story with likable characters. History buffs will enjoy it if they can suspend the disbelief born of prior knowledge, and people who enjoy vivid storytelling with strong heroines will love it. Branwen is a great role model and her relationship with Artagan an example of a healthy one. The sex scenes are tasteful and fade-to-black. For those reasons I would recommend this story to readers of all ages, and I plan to read the following books in the series.
So, why not four or five stars? There were a lot of historical inaccuracies and linguistic anachronisms that had the effect of pulling me out of the story. The story is set in the years 597-99 in Wales. The problem is that back then Wales didn't exist and the word that was to become "Welsh," "wealh," was used by the Saxons for their Brittonic slaves. (If you want a historically accurate treatment of that concept, I recommend Hild by Nicola Griffith). Branwen and the other characters refer to themselves as Welsh and have a pride in a Welsh identity that would not exist for centuries.
The names of people and places are given in Modern Welsh, a language that would not develop for more than 1000 years. In the 590s, Brittonic tribes from the west coast were speaking dialects of Primitive Welsh (some linguists might even dispute that and call it Common Brittonic). All that said, I expect most readers wouldn't be bothered by this and if it was an editorial decision made so that modern readers can relate more to the story, I understand. If I did not have a background in linguistics none of this would have mattered to me.
Also problematic is the fact that the story deals with the Britons battling the Saxons under Penda of Mercia, a king who was not even born until 606. Branwen's father is Vortigen (which should be Vortigern) of Dyfed, who may have been legendary, but is said to have ruled in the year 425. There are other historical inaccuracies of that nature throughout the book.
Finally, the story is shot through with a highly romanticized view of the "ancient Celts." First of all, the people we think of as Celts wouldn't have used that term for themselves. Second of all, although I love the idea of a matriarchal, peace-loving culture driven by "Ancient Harmonies" and a kindly Mother Goddess, that is not what the tribes we collectively refer to now as the "ancient Celts" actually had. They had an intensely hierarchical warrior culture. While it's true that women could be warriors, queens and druids, the ideas of peace and love that a wise priestess who follows the "ancient ways" espouses in the story derive more from systems like Buddhism and Quakerism than the actual beliefs of Europeans in the Early Historic Period. And when the ancient poet Taliesin was referred to as a "Welsh shaman" I had to grit my teeth. There may be some similarities between poetic inspiration and shamanism, but Early Historic Britons would never know the term, let alone compare one of their poets to a shaman.
Notwithstanding the historical inaccuracies, Between Two Fires was a good story with likable characters. History buffs will enjoy it if they can suspend the disbelief born of prior knowledge, and people who enjoy vivid storytelling with strong heroines will love it. Branwen is a great role model and her relationship with Artagan an example of a healthy one. The sex scenes are tasteful and fade-to-black. For those reasons I would recommend this story to readers of all ages, and I plan to read the following books in the series.
March 13, 2017
I had a hard time deciding between two or three stars for this book. On one hand, I enjoyed reading about a time period and setting that aren't often the focus of historical fiction (6th century Wales). On the other, loose ends in the story were wrapped up much too quickly and neatly for my liking, and I couldn't relate to the main character. This book centers on the imagined story of Branwen, a lady of the Welsh kingdom Dyfed, being wed to the Hammer King, a ruler in the south of Wales. The marriage is intended to unite two powerful kingdoms and help unite the Welsh against the threat of Saxon invasion, but Branwen's life is constantly threatened while in King Morgan's keep, and she ends up having eyes for a hedge knight named Artagan instead of for her husband. Branwen is touted for having the blood of the "Old Tribes" as well as a strategic mind, so she's able to be more vocal in the realm of politics than other women of her era. Overall, I didn't find Branwen's voice (this book is told in the first person) to be very believable as a young woman and I rolled my eyes at how she was always threatened by other women and jealous of them for finding the same man attractive that she did. Meanwhile, the 'mystery' about who was plotting against her was pretty obvious from the start and the reveal at the end of the connecting threads of the story seemed like it was trying too hard to push Branwen as this great strategic thinker when in reality the mystery was just not very complicated. Her chemistry with Artagan, the rakish knight, was pretty good, but although their relationship is a driving force in this story this book is definitely not what I would call a romance.
Overall, an interesting time period to read about and the book inspired me to look up actual historical works about Wales. I don't think I'll read the next book, though, as I just couldn't get into the characters and am not really invested in learning more about their stories.
Overall, an interesting time period to read about and the book inspired me to look up actual historical works about Wales. I don't think I'll read the next book, though, as I just couldn't get into the characters and am not really invested in learning more about their stories.
October 14, 2026
I want to put a disclaimer here and say this is probably a fine book and you'll understand why I rated it so low shortly. Contrary to popular belief, you should judge the book by its cover!
This was picked up on Audible on the recommendation of "If you like the video game Dark Souls then you'll love this". This is not the case. Please be aware that although it shares the name, this is in fact not a medieval horror set in France, it's actually a medieval Welsh romance. You're looking for "Between Two Fires" by Christopher Buehlman and not Mark Noce. Unfortunately it seems only Audible US has the audiobook version of the horror and this is why I made my error.
I finished this book waiting for the nightmarish aspect to begin but it just kept going with the will they/won't they romance. It solidified that this genre is not for me, so I'll give myself a pat on the back for trying but rest assured that this is nothing like Dark Souls.
This was picked up on Audible on the recommendation of "If you like the video game Dark Souls then you'll love this". This is not the case. Please be aware that although it shares the name, this is in fact not a medieval horror set in France, it's actually a medieval Welsh romance. You're looking for "Between Two Fires" by Christopher Buehlman and not Mark Noce. Unfortunately it seems only Audible US has the audiobook version of the horror and this is why I made my error.
I finished this book waiting for the nightmarish aspect to begin but it just kept going with the will they/won't they romance. It solidified that this genre is not for me, so I'll give myself a pat on the back for trying but rest assured that this is nothing like Dark Souls.
October 11, 2024
Just okay. I think this story would have been more poignant if it had been written by a woman. The author did a good job of voicing a woman in early medieval Wales but there was just something off about Branwen that I couldn't quite place my finger on. I enjoyed reading about the historical setting but neither Morgan nor Artagan were swoon-worthy heroes so I don't understand Branwen's total devotion to Artagan. He was a good man but I think the author should have spent more time fleshing out his personality.
April 20, 2016
Release date: August 2016 from Thomas Dunne Books
This power-packed historical novel is the first in a series...and it's going to have readers beating on the publisher's door for more.
Look, I'll be the first to tell you that historical fiction can be a real slough. In the wrong author's hands, novels set in any time period earlier than maybe 20 years ago can bog down in details...what folks wore, how they acted, the mores of their society, what their culture told them was right, how they rebelled...endless, really.
But in a strong author's hands, historical fiction is a true delight. And that's what Noce has delivered with Between Two Fires: a work that moves along briskly while providing everything they need to know to dive into the period. Never once will readers be left wondering, "What. What? Who? How did that happen?"
Part of the strength of this work comes from the depth Noce gives to the protagonist. Lady Branwen of Wales is the country's last and final hope for unification...through marriage, of course. But the fellow she weds lives up to his nickname of Hammer King.
Meanwhile, Brandwen has been watching the rogue hedge knight Artagan, rumored to be as dark as his name, Blacksword. But he is more complex than that, and might be the only person she can rely on. Her mind is set against him but her heart has other plans.
As the lady becomes a queen and then flees from her realm, Saxons invade. The romance and intrigue take on a depth that comes entirely from the well-drawn characters painted atop the historic backdrop.
There are some elements about the descriptions that are repetitive. These are fairly minor but several did throw me out of the fictional world for just a few beats. Readers of this type of work can be trusted to follow along, and hopefully the rest of the books in this series will eliminate those types of blips. Generally, this was a strong showing. I can't wait to read the rest of the series!
5 stars!
If you enjoy strong female leads, check out Beloved: A Sensual Noir Thriller.
If you prefer historical elements in your stories that blend seamlessly with a thrilling plot and a deep romance, check out Reparation: A Novel of Love, Devotion and Danger.
This power-packed historical novel is the first in a series...and it's going to have readers beating on the publisher's door for more.
Look, I'll be the first to tell you that historical fiction can be a real slough. In the wrong author's hands, novels set in any time period earlier than maybe 20 years ago can bog down in details...what folks wore, how they acted, the mores of their society, what their culture told them was right, how they rebelled...endless, really.
But in a strong author's hands, historical fiction is a true delight. And that's what Noce has delivered with Between Two Fires: a work that moves along briskly while providing everything they need to know to dive into the period. Never once will readers be left wondering, "What. What? Who? How did that happen?"
Part of the strength of this work comes from the depth Noce gives to the protagonist. Lady Branwen of Wales is the country's last and final hope for unification...through marriage, of course. But the fellow she weds lives up to his nickname of Hammer King.
Meanwhile, Brandwen has been watching the rogue hedge knight Artagan, rumored to be as dark as his name, Blacksword. But he is more complex than that, and might be the only person she can rely on. Her mind is set against him but her heart has other plans.
As the lady becomes a queen and then flees from her realm, Saxons invade. The romance and intrigue take on a depth that comes entirely from the well-drawn characters painted atop the historic backdrop.
There are some elements about the descriptions that are repetitive. These are fairly minor but several did throw me out of the fictional world for just a few beats. Readers of this type of work can be trusted to follow along, and hopefully the rest of the books in this series will eliminate those types of blips. Generally, this was a strong showing. I can't wait to read the rest of the series!
5 stars!
If you enjoy strong female leads, check out Beloved: A Sensual Noir Thriller.
If you prefer historical elements in your stories that blend seamlessly with a thrilling plot and a deep romance, check out Reparation: A Novel of Love, Devotion and Danger.
September 14, 2016
WHAT IT'S ABOUT
Saxon barbarians threaten to destroy medieval Wales. Lady Branwen becomes Wales' last hope to unite their divided kingdoms when her father betroths her to a powerful Welsh warlord, the Hammer King. But the fledgling alliance is fraught with enemies from within and without as Branwen becomes the target of assassination attempts and courtly intrigue. A young woman in a world of fierce warriors, she seeks to assert her own authority and preserve Wales against the barbarians. But when she falls for a young hedge knight named Artagan, her world threatens to tear itself apart.
Caught between her duty to her people and her love of a man she cannot have, Branwen must choose whether to preserve her royal marriage or to follow her heart. Somehow she must save her people and remain true to herself, before Saxon invaders and a mysterious traitor try to destroy her.
MY TAKE
I listened to the audiobook, and the narrator did a fabulous job.
This is quite the gritty tale. The mentality toward women of this age is a powerful theme in the book. Pawns, marriage tokens for political maneuvering, "brood mares," and the victims of the violence of warfare, left to raise the children forced upon them because of rape--if they were left alive at all.
Poor Branwen begins the story as the daughter of a jerk king married off for the political connection to another jerk king. I have little patience with political and power machinations, and her life is rife with them. Poor kid. She wants so bad to more than just a possession.
You know there's something about Artagan when he first makes his appearance and saves Branwen's life in what will be the first of many attempts on her life. As she struggles finding her place, her love grows for the young hedge knight. Together they must face many things, including the possibility of losing each other. There's also a bit of a mystery in the book.
There's a fair bit of war violence, and open door bedroom scenes. There is some detail but not what can't be skimmed over if those bother you.
Branwan's growth is a little slow in coming. I was frustrated at times with how long to took to come into her own. But when she does, she comes into it with a vengeance.
4 1/2 stars
Saxon barbarians threaten to destroy medieval Wales. Lady Branwen becomes Wales' last hope to unite their divided kingdoms when her father betroths her to a powerful Welsh warlord, the Hammer King. But the fledgling alliance is fraught with enemies from within and without as Branwen becomes the target of assassination attempts and courtly intrigue. A young woman in a world of fierce warriors, she seeks to assert her own authority and preserve Wales against the barbarians. But when she falls for a young hedge knight named Artagan, her world threatens to tear itself apart.
Caught between her duty to her people and her love of a man she cannot have, Branwen must choose whether to preserve her royal marriage or to follow her heart. Somehow she must save her people and remain true to herself, before Saxon invaders and a mysterious traitor try to destroy her.
MY TAKE
I listened to the audiobook, and the narrator did a fabulous job.
This is quite the gritty tale. The mentality toward women of this age is a powerful theme in the book. Pawns, marriage tokens for political maneuvering, "brood mares," and the victims of the violence of warfare, left to raise the children forced upon them because of rape--if they were left alive at all.
Poor Branwen begins the story as the daughter of a jerk king married off for the political connection to another jerk king. I have little patience with political and power machinations, and her life is rife with them. Poor kid. She wants so bad to more than just a possession.
You know there's something about Artagan when he first makes his appearance and saves Branwen's life in what will be the first of many attempts on her life. As she struggles finding her place, her love grows for the young hedge knight. Together they must face many things, including the possibility of losing each other. There's also a bit of a mystery in the book.
There's a fair bit of war violence, and open door bedroom scenes. There is some detail but not what can't be skimmed over if those bother you.
Branwan's growth is a little slow in coming. I was frustrated at times with how long to took to come into her own. But when she does, she comes into it with a vengeance.
4 1/2 stars
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews