You are probably dying to ask me…What are you doing reading a romance published in 1991? Isn’t it terribly outdated?
Well, I read it because the audiobook came HIGHLY recommended by friends and I put a lot of stock in friend recommendations. And yes, it’s a bit outdated – there are no cell phones, no internet and the police procedure is a bit iffy (we know better now that an FBI agent shouldn’t be consorting with the sister of a suspect) but the book is old enough that it doesn’t feel weird, if that makes any sense.
Carnal Innocence is the story of a small town in Mississippi with a serial killer in its midst. I’m not much for books set in small towns –in general, most authors paint them too idyllic – but I was charmed by this one. Probably because Ms. Roberts didn’t portrayed only the good (charming characters, great atmosphere, neighbors supporting one another) but also the bad (race tensions) and the ugly. And with a serial killer on the loose, there’s a lot of ugly going on.
Caroline arrives at Innocence after spending some time in the hospital. All her life, she has been a good little girl who does what her Mommy wants but after some therapy, she realizes that she needs to change if she wants to be happy. Her first encounter with Tucker Longstreet wasn’t promising and like her, I didn’t like him at all. Unlike most romance heroes, Tucker is portrayed as an easy going guy who’s favorite thing to do is to take a nap. In the first few chapters, his family is described in all its infamy - they are the richest people in town but there’s an alcoholic older brother, lazy but charming Tucker and a twice divorced younger sister who loves the gentlemen a little too much.
At the beginning, one of Tucker’s affairs comes to life and I was a bit outraged that he would date women from a different social strata. Didn’t he realize that some of these women wanted more? Then, I realized that I was being patronizing: these women knew Tucker way better than me and decided to date him. Why should he bear the burden of their expectations? He didn’t owe them marriage anymore than a poor guy would, especially when he hadn’t made any promises. As the story continued, I felt like the heroine: against my better judgment, I couldn’t help but be charmed by Tucker – that Southern accent in the audiobook really helped. He was funny, handsome and charismatic, a lover of poetry with a big heart and with most depth than most people realize.
The mystery is excellent with a lot of layers. It’s about family feuds and madness. I won’t go into details because I don’t want to give you any spoilers but it was very well done. I figured out who was the murderer before the denouement, but even I was a bit shocked.
Please note that race tensions are an aspect of the story and some characters use the N word. It didn’t bother me because it made sense in the story but I want to mention it in case some readers are offended by the use of the word.
The unabridged audiobook narrated by Tom Stechschulte was simply scrumptious – I think already mentioned the deliciousness that was Tucker’s accent. Even with the glowing recommendations, two things made avoid this audiobook for while: the length and the cover. The unabridged version is almost 18 hrs. but once you get started, you get caught up in the narrative and start enjoying every time Tucker tells a story about his ancestors. You also forget about the scary cover!
Overall, an excellent romantic suspense novel with great characters and ambiance. Completely recommended!