The interest of this book lies mainly in the personality of the author and the qualifications which his own history and experience have given him as a critic of Cromwell's career. An American of the old "knickerbocker" families, who has taken an active part in Republican politics, who has been a dashing cavalry leader in war, and a prominent official of the Government in peace, who was at that time in the front of the great Presidential contest in the United States, has opportunities for judging the career of the Protector from a practical experience such as none of the previous biographers (and hardly Mr. Morley himself) have possessed.
The views of an American of distinction who has had large experience both of war and of administration, when he undertakes an estimate of the great Puritan soldier and statesman, cannot but have a lively interest for the English reader.
Mr. Roosevelt's general estimate of Cromwell is that of profound admiration for his genius and character, whilst he is very far from sharing the blind idolatry of Carlyle and sundry of his followers. He judges Oliver to have been a consummate soldier, indeed a man born with an unerring genius for war, who in that sphere had hardly any known deficiency or fault. As a statesman, he credits him with noble aims and great sagacity, but marred by serious perversities and blunders. He holds him to have been, until the Protectorate, a pure and self-denying patriot, but to have been tempted, in the last few years of his life, by the sense of unlimited power, to give too much rein to a temper of arbitrary violence. Mr. Roosevelt holds by democratic principles of constitutional and popular Government. And hence, whilst ranking Cromwell far above tyrants of the Napoleonic mould, he cannot place him on the level of those great founders of nations of which Washington remains the purest type.
Mr. Roosevelt is clearly right in rejecting Carlyle's paradox that Cromwell represented " the last of all our Heroisms." The English Commonwealth, he says, was "the first modern, and not the last mediaeval, movement," and was the precursor of the English Revolution of 1688, of the American Revolution of 1776, and of the American Civil War of 1861. Mr. Roosevelt should not forget his own Dutch ancestors of 1581, nor the French Revolution of 1789. They all hang together, in spite of broad differences in circumstances and in men. Mr. Roosevelt's estimate of the conditions which led to the Civil War is clear and accurate ; it does not depart from that of our best modern authorities.
The most interesting part of Mr. Roosevelt's volume is his account of Cromwell's military career, of tactics in that age, and of the principal battles. Our author describes the Cromwellian method of a close charge of heavy cavalry in mass, kept always under rigid control, backed by adequate reserves, and capable of most rapid change of formation and point of attack, in the spirit of a cavalry leader who has seen regular war, and carefully studied not only the American wars of 1774 and 1863, but also the lessons of our own South African campaigns. He shows us, with all the point of a man who has done it himself, how rough horsemen and raw townsmen can be drilled into disciplined soldiers in one or two years of active service. His accounts of Edgehill, Marston and Naseby, slight as they are, are interesting as descriptions presented to us by a practical soldier.
Mr. Roosevelt, as a man versed in the currents of democratic parties, entirely seizes the difficulties that met Cromwell when in supreme power. On the whole, he does justice to the Protector's public spirit and wisdom; he arraigns not only Oliver's errors of judgment, but his rectitude of purpose. He tells us that "with the sense of power came the overmastering desire to seize and wield it.
Theodore Roosevelt, Jr., also known as T.R., and to the public (but never to friends and family) as Teddy, was the twenty-sixth President of the United States, and a leader of the Republican Party and of the Progressive Movement.
He became the youngest President in United States history at the age of 42. He served in many roles including Governor of New York, historian, naturalist, explorer, author, and soldier (posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor in 2001 for his role at the Battle of San Juan Hill in the Spanish-American War).
Roosevelt is most famous for his personality: his energy, his vast range of interests and achievements, his model of masculinity, and his "cowboy" persona.
I will, perhaps, read this book again some day. I thoroughly enjoyed it; while I am, by my own admission, a very slow reader, I blazed through this book in three days. Roosevelt's take on Cromwell is even-handed, acknowledging the brilliance of a man limited by the thoughts of his time - thoughts which, unfortunately, impinged upon the man's own brilliance. Roosevelt does not try to sugar-coat Cromwell's failings or offer any cobbled-together justification for him, but the author and historian does put the events in the setting of their contemporary paradigm. But shortcomings aside, Cromwell was and still remains a man among men, a masterful spirit, whose impulsive yet sincere desire for the good of his nation deserves more respect than is yet given.
Fascinating overview of Cromwell's life and times by a great statesman of another era and country. TR sees Cromwell charitably as a forerunner of the puritans who initiated the American Revolution, while downplaying his genocidal radicalism as typical of his age. Roosevelt defends Cromwell as sincere in his piety yet worldly. He makes less effort to appreciate the sincerity and good faith of the Crown and others who sought to escape the religious fanaticism whose evils he readily admits. The defense of Cromwell is based far to heavily on incidental and slender associations with constitutional liberties, such as occasional expressions of religious tolerance for political allies and his friendship with Milton.
Compelling and engaging narrative. 5 stars for the narrative, 3.5 stars for the analysis - which is generally balanced but certainly a bit anachronistic and influenced by Whig historiography.