What do you think?
Rate this book
Quaker Midwife Mystery #2
Called to Justice
When Hannah Breed confides to midwife Rose Carroll that she's pregnant out of wedlock, Rose promises to help her through the pregnancy and figure out a way to break the news to her family. But that night, amid the noise and revelry of the Independence Day fireworks, Hannah is found shot dead.
After a former slave and fellow Quaker is accused of the murder, Rose delves into the crime, convinced of the man's innocence. An ill-mannered mill manager, an Irish immigrant, and the victim's young boyfriend come under suspicion even as Rose's future with her handsome doctor suitor becomes unsure. Rose continues to deliver babies and listen to secrets, finally focusing in on the culprit only to be threatened herself.
After a former slave and fellow Quaker is accused of the murder, Rose delves into the crime, convinced of the man's innocence. An ill-mannered mill manager, an Irish immigrant, and the victim's young boyfriend come under suspicion even as Rose's future with her handsome doctor suitor becomes unsure. Rose continues to deliver babies and listen to secrets, finally focusing in on the culprit only to be threatened herself.
300 pages, Paperback
First published April 8, 2017
22 people are currently reading
570 people want to read
About the author
Edith Maxwell
47 books583 followersEdith Maxwell is an Agatha-winning mystery author who writes the Local Foods Foods Mysteries as well as the historical Quaker Midwife Mysteries, featuring a Quaker midwife sleuth in 1888.
As Maddie Day, she writes the Country Store Mysteries set in southern Indiana, and the Cozy
Capers Book Group Mysteries.
Her short stories have appeared in twenty juried anthologies and magazines. She is active in Mystery Writers of America and Sisters in Crime.
Edith, a fourth-generation Californian, has two grown sons and lives in an antique house north of Boston with her beau, their energizer kitten, a small organic garden, and some impressive garden statuary. She worked as a software technical writer for almost two decades but now writes fiction full time.
As Maddie Day, she writes the Country Store Mysteries set in southern Indiana, and the Cozy
Capers Book Group Mysteries.
Her short stories have appeared in twenty juried anthologies and magazines. She is active in Mystery Writers of America and Sisters in Crime.
Edith, a fourth-generation Californian, has two grown sons and lives in an antique house north of Boston with her beau, their energizer kitten, a small organic garden, and some impressive garden statuary. She worked as a software technical writer for almost two decades but now writes fiction full time.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 87 reviews
June 18, 2019
The second in this historical Quaker Midwife series. It is set in a New England factory town in 1888 depicting life in the area. Historical details, the Quaker faith, and birthing details are accurate. The birthing data may bother some. I have not read the first but I had no trouble understanding narrative.
Rose Carroll is attending the July 4th celebration when an unmarried Quaker, Hannah informs her that she is pregnant. She refuses to name the father saying they cannot marry.
That evening during the fireworks display, Hannah is shot. A former slave and Quaker is arrested for the murder Rose feels he is not guilty and begins to search for a different answer. Rose has plenty to keep her busy. She is chaperoning her niece, Faith, attending several births, and continuing her affair with Dr. David Dodge. The ending will surprise you. I recommend this book.
Disclosure: I received a free copy from Midnight Ink through NetGalley for an honest review. I would like to thank them for this opportunity to read and review the book. The opinions expressed are my own.
Rose Carroll is attending the July 4th celebration when an unmarried Quaker, Hannah informs her that she is pregnant. She refuses to name the father saying they cannot marry.
That evening during the fireworks display, Hannah is shot. A former slave and Quaker is arrested for the murder Rose feels he is not guilty and begins to search for a different answer. Rose has plenty to keep her busy. She is chaperoning her niece, Faith, attending several births, and continuing her affair with Dr. David Dodge. The ending will surprise you. I recommend this book.
Disclosure: I received a free copy from Midnight Ink through NetGalley for an honest review. I would like to thank them for this opportunity to read and review the book. The opinions expressed are my own.
April 14, 2017
It’s the fourth of July, and Rose Carroll is taking the day off from her midwife duties to enjoy the holiday when an older teen, Hannah, approaches her and confesses that she is pregnant. Rose doesn’t know what to do to help Hannah, but she promises to try. Unfortunately, while enjoying the fireworks that night, Rose responds to a commotion in the crowd to find that Hannah has been shot. When a fellow Quaker accused of the crime, Rose sets out to figure out what really happened. Can she do it?
I enjoyed the first trip to 1888 with Rose, and this book was a wonderful return visit. The story starts strongly but gets a bit distracted by sub-plots as the book went along. Of course, those sub-plots were also strong, so I wanted to keep reading. The new characters made strong suspects, and it was nice to get to know the returning characters better. The time is really another character, and I felt transported back to the time period.
NOTE: I received an ARC of this book.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
I enjoyed the first trip to 1888 with Rose, and this book was a wonderful return visit. The story starts strongly but gets a bit distracted by sub-plots as the book went along. Of course, those sub-plots were also strong, so I wanted to keep reading. The new characters made strong suspects, and it was nice to get to know the returning characters better. The time is really another character, and I felt transported back to the time period.
NOTE: I received an ARC of this book.
Read my full review at Carstairs Considers.
April 13, 2017
Dollycas’s Thoughts
In her follow up to Delivering the Truth Edith Maxwell takes us back to Amesbury, Massachusetts in 1888 just in time for the Independence Day celebration. Rose Carroll is enjoying the fireworks with her beau David Dodge when gunshots ring out and a young woman in found dead. A former slave and Friend becomes the prime suspect leading Rose to delve into the investigation herself. She finds her life in danger the closer she gets to learning the truth. Just when she needs him most her relationship with Doctor Dodge gets rocky and Rose tries to remain strong. There are several lives in danger as this midwife strives to keep everyone safe.
Rose has become a very comfortable character for me. She is smart, caring and kind to everyone she meets. She carries a calmness about her, something that is very important in her work as a midwife. She also keeps her wits about her when things get out of control. She is true to herself and her beliefs. The author captures the history of the time very well. She draws on her Quaker roots to give us real sense of Quaker lifestyle.
The characters Ms. Maxwell surrounds Rose with are quite varied. From very wealthy to factory workers and even a former slave. All are very fleshed out and believable. As Rose connects with them we become aware of their true colors. Some we can quickly eliminate as suspects and others need further scrutiny.
The plot entwines the characters together in many ways making the mystery a tough one to solve. The story gives us a complex mystery with a perfect flow that builds to an exciting climax. Suspense was ratcheted up quite high as the ending played out. I absolutely loved this story.
A wonderful mystery you can get lost in. Travel back with Rose and the people of Amesbury. A perfect escape!
In her follow up to Delivering the Truth Edith Maxwell takes us back to Amesbury, Massachusetts in 1888 just in time for the Independence Day celebration. Rose Carroll is enjoying the fireworks with her beau David Dodge when gunshots ring out and a young woman in found dead. A former slave and Friend becomes the prime suspect leading Rose to delve into the investigation herself. She finds her life in danger the closer she gets to learning the truth. Just when she needs him most her relationship with Doctor Dodge gets rocky and Rose tries to remain strong. There are several lives in danger as this midwife strives to keep everyone safe.
Rose has become a very comfortable character for me. She is smart, caring and kind to everyone she meets. She carries a calmness about her, something that is very important in her work as a midwife. She also keeps her wits about her when things get out of control. She is true to herself and her beliefs. The author captures the history of the time very well. She draws on her Quaker roots to give us real sense of Quaker lifestyle.
The characters Ms. Maxwell surrounds Rose with are quite varied. From very wealthy to factory workers and even a former slave. All are very fleshed out and believable. As Rose connects with them we become aware of their true colors. Some we can quickly eliminate as suspects and others need further scrutiny.
The plot entwines the characters together in many ways making the mystery a tough one to solve. The story gives us a complex mystery with a perfect flow that builds to an exciting climax. Suspense was ratcheted up quite high as the ending played out. I absolutely loved this story.
A wonderful mystery you can get lost in. Travel back with Rose and the people of Amesbury. A perfect escape!
April 7, 2017
Called to Justice by Edith Maxwell is the second book in A Quaker Midwife Mystery series. Rose Carroll is a Quaker midwife in Amesbury, Massachusetts. Rose is watching the Fourth of July parade when she is approached by Hannah Breed, a seventeen-year-old mill worker. Hannah confides in Rose that she is pregnant, but she is unwilling to reveal the identity of the father. Rose agrees to help the young woman. Later that evening, Rose is enjoying the fireworks display with her beau, Dr. David Dodge. There are men shooting off guns nearby and soon screams ring out. David and Rose run over to find Hannah on the ground (someone took advantage of the chaos). When the police arrive, the manager of the Hamilton Mill, Lester Colby, makes sure to point fingers at Akwasi Ayensu, an African-American Quaker and local businessman. Rose is astounded that anyone would accuse Akwasi and is further incensed when he is arrested for the crime. Rose knows that Akwasi would not harm a soul and sets out to find the true culprit of the crime. In the meantime, Rose approaches John Whittier to hire counsel for Akwasi. Rose has to work in a little sleuthing in between her midwifery duties. Rose’s relationship with David is going along splendidly until his mother decides to interfere (she does not approve of Rose). This causes a rift between the pair that hopefully can be repaired. With Akwasi soon going to trial, Rose needs to step up her game if she is to find the real killer. The villain will not go easily, and Rose soon finds her life in peril.
Called to Justice is an interesting historical mystery novel. I liked the time period, the lovely setting, and the Rose’s occupation. I do wish, though, that the story had been written in the third person to make it easier to read. With the story being written in the first person, I found it harder to read the Quaker dialogue. I thought that the dialogue was stilted and old fashioned which suits the novel, but it hard to get through (in the beginning). The book is well-written, and I liked the mention of historical figures like Louisa May Alcott, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and Susan B. Anthony. There are also some appealing details that help set the time. Mail is delivered twice a day which aided communication between people living in different towns as well as businesses. Also, the telephone was just starting to be installed in homes. While Called to Justice is the second book in A Quaker Midwife Mystery series, it can be read alone. The author provides all the necessary background details on Rose, her family, friends, and life. The mystery was intriguing but not overly complex. Most readers will be able to discern the identity of the killer before the reveal. The relationship between Rose and David did not dominate the book. It was nice, light and romantic which I appreciated.
Called to Justice is an interesting historical mystery novel. I liked the time period, the lovely setting, and the Rose’s occupation. I do wish, though, that the story had been written in the third person to make it easier to read. With the story being written in the first person, I found it harder to read the Quaker dialogue. I thought that the dialogue was stilted and old fashioned which suits the novel, but it hard to get through (in the beginning). The book is well-written, and I liked the mention of historical figures like Louisa May Alcott, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and Susan B. Anthony. There are also some appealing details that help set the time. Mail is delivered twice a day which aided communication between people living in different towns as well as businesses. Also, the telephone was just starting to be installed in homes. While Called to Justice is the second book in A Quaker Midwife Mystery series, it can be read alone. The author provides all the necessary background details on Rose, her family, friends, and life. The mystery was intriguing but not overly complex. Most readers will be able to discern the identity of the killer before the reveal. The relationship between Rose and David did not dominate the book. It was nice, light and romantic which I appreciated.
Read
February 23, 2017Called to Justice by Edith Maxwell is a well paced mystery that's light on the midwifery aspect of storytelling. I love how there is an emphasis on good writing as the author deftly moves the story along with good plotting and lovely language. I also love how the author educates the reader about the Quaker faith.
Recommend.
Review written after downloading a galley from Net Galley.
Recommend.
Review written after downloading a galley from Net Galley.
May 19, 2017
Another tour de force by Edith Maxwell. CALLED TO JUSTICE is a brilliantly written, historically accurate tale of a Midwife in Amesbury, Massachusetts, in the late 1800's. Although fictional, there are many real historical figures such as John Greenleaf Whittier, noted poet and Quaker, who play ongoing roles in this delightful series.
May 28, 2023
I am really enjoying this series! It's another cozy mystery involving a number of characters who are Quakers and also characters who work with them or otherwise interact with them. The setting is historical, taking place in the 1800s when women were treated very differently. The character development is intriguing to me. In particular, I am enjoying the romantic angles as well as the conflicts that result from the romances. Jealousy is very much alive in this story! I will definitely read the next book in the series.
December 7, 2016
I’m warmed by a feeling that all’s right with the world, after a practically non-stop reading of Edith Maxwell’s CALLED TO JUSTICE. So many problems intertwine in the usually quiet town of Amesbury, MA, as midwife Rose Carroll works to bring newborns into safe, loving homes. The Quaker traditions of speaking truth to power and being quiet in worship but far from quiet in the face of injustice mean that Rose cannot look away when Friend Akwasi Ayensu is falsely accused of murder. The plot is complex, and tries the limits of Rose’s ability to find stillness and “discern the best path forward” and look for the good in everyone. Inspiring woman!
Historical references give a sense of time, with assistance from the poet John Greenleaf Whittier and a meeting with journalist Lucy Larcom, whom I had to look up and am glad I did.
Learning a bit of history adds an extra layer of enjoyment, even in smaller details; telephones are a wonderful invention, but twice-daily mail delivery helped those without phones, and I hadn’t even thought about how life was improved by screen doors.
Problems with babies, troubles with romance, complexity despite a search for simplicity, but in the words of a brave and caring French-speaking patient, “All’s Good That Ends Good” in this totally satisfying book.
Historical references give a sense of time, with assistance from the poet John Greenleaf Whittier and a meeting with journalist Lucy Larcom, whom I had to look up and am glad I did.
Learning a bit of history adds an extra layer of enjoyment, even in smaller details; telephones are a wonderful invention, but twice-daily mail delivery helped those without phones, and I hadn’t even thought about how life was improved by screen doors.
Problems with babies, troubles with romance, complexity despite a search for simplicity, but in the words of a brave and caring French-speaking patient, “All’s Good That Ends Good” in this totally satisfying book.
March 16, 2017
Midwife Rose Carroll is enjoying the 1888 Independence Day evenng fireworks with her beau David Dodge when teenaged Quaker mill girl Hannah Breed is found shot dead. Former slave and a fellow Quaker Akwasi Ayensu is accused of the murder. Rose is convinced of his innocence and does her own sleuthing. An ill-mannered mill manager, an Irish immigrant mill girl, and Hannah's young boyfriend come under suspicion even as Rose’s future with her handsome doctor suitor becomes unsure. Rose’s Quaker faith and thirst for justice make her a persistent sleuth and champion for those falsely accused. The author provides rich historical details of living in 1888 Amesbury Massachusetts. I received an e-ARC via Netgalley and Midnight Ink.
October 8, 2019
1888 Independence Day, and Quaker midwife Rose Carroll is at the evening's fireworks display when a young female is shot. When a fellow Quaker and former slave is accused Rose investigates.
An enjoyable mystery, with a little romance, and a well-written story.
A NetGalley Book
An enjoyable mystery, with a little romance, and a well-written story.
A NetGalley Book
April 25, 2017
Called to Justice is as much historical fiction as it is cozy mystery, and I found both aspects of the story to be riveting. A young, unmarried woman confides in Rose that she is expecting a child, and then ends up being murdered during the Independence Day fireworks celebration. Determined to find justice for the girl and her unborn child, Rose manages to squeeze in a little investigating, between birthing babies and checking on the well-being of her clientele of local women waiting to deliver.
There was a lot of attention to detail and historical accuracy where the births in the story were concerned. See what author Edith Maxwell has to say about midwives and the birthing process on my blog.
There was a lot of attention to detail and historical accuracy where the births in the story were concerned. See what author Edith Maxwell has to say about midwives and the birthing process on my blog.
June 11, 2017
Rose is a Quaker midwife, in love with a non Quaker. Hannah confides in Rose that she is pregnant out of wedlock. That night during the 4th of July fireworks Hannah is found shot dead. A former slave and fellow Quaker is accused of the murder Rose starts trying to prove him innocent. Rose continues to deliver babies while looking at the ill-mannered mill manager, Irish immigrant and Hannah's boyfriend to figure out who did it.
February 6, 2018
Another appealing entry in this well-researched, well-written series. Rose Carroll is a terrific character, and the times and setting are portrayed so clearly that I feel I'm walking the streets of 1888 Amesbury, Mass with her. Maxwell makes writing look easy -- and certainly makes the reading easy!
April 7, 2025
Loved it !
My first time with the author and I loved it.
A well written story that centers around a midwife helping to solve a mystery.
My first time with the author and I loved it.
A well written story that centers around a midwife helping to solve a mystery.
November 10, 2016
1888, Amesbury, Massachusetts, and Quaker midwife Rose Carroll finds herself busy attending pregnant women, delivering babies, and helping afterward, when she finds herself deep into another mystery.
A young woman mill worker is shot during the July 4th celebration and a fellow member of the Society of Friends, a former slave, has been arrested on circumstantial evidence.
Rose feels ‘called to justice’ to help her fellow Quaker, and begins to understand some of the darker currents in her north eastern Massachusetts town. Her mood grows darker when her future mother in law refuses to accept her, and when her mentor suffers a stroke, the darkness seems almost unbearable.
Return those many years ago and join Rose in her quest for justice for her Quaker friend and openings for herself in solving what could be life changing circumstances.
CALLED TO JUSTICE will grab your interest and you’ll easily find yourself walking those small town 19th century streets with Rose in this well researched, authentic mystery.
A young woman mill worker is shot during the July 4th celebration and a fellow member of the Society of Friends, a former slave, has been arrested on circumstantial evidence.
Rose feels ‘called to justice’ to help her fellow Quaker, and begins to understand some of the darker currents in her north eastern Massachusetts town. Her mood grows darker when her future mother in law refuses to accept her, and when her mentor suffers a stroke, the darkness seems almost unbearable.
Return those many years ago and join Rose in her quest for justice for her Quaker friend and openings for herself in solving what could be life changing circumstances.
CALLED TO JUSTICE will grab your interest and you’ll easily find yourself walking those small town 19th century streets with Rose in this well researched, authentic mystery.
June 5, 2017
I didn't realize when I picked up this book that it was the second book in a series. Maybe reading book number one might have helped me appreciate this novel. There was so much wrong with the way the story was constructed. The story began on an interesting note but it quickly went down hill.
The first thing that began upsetting me about this story which I really wanted to like ( I love midwife stories) was that the time period felt modern. It did NOT feel Victorian what so ever. The second thing that was off was the romance between the midwife and her boyfriend. There didn't seem to be a reason why they would be dating. Those two cultures just don't mix especially in Victorian days. It just didn't compute. Then there was the detective aspect of her being a Quaker. That also didn't fit.
I love midwife stories and that part was interesting but that was about about it. I wish I knew what provokes people to give such stories as this one 5 stars. I certainly can't fathom what keeps them engaged.
The first thing that began upsetting me about this story which I really wanted to like ( I love midwife stories) was that the time period felt modern. It did NOT feel Victorian what so ever. The second thing that was off was the romance between the midwife and her boyfriend. There didn't seem to be a reason why they would be dating. Those two cultures just don't mix especially in Victorian days. It just didn't compute. Then there was the detective aspect of her being a Quaker. That also didn't fit.
I love midwife stories and that part was interesting but that was about about it. I wish I knew what provokes people to give such stories as this one 5 stars. I certainly can't fathom what keeps them engaged.
December 9, 2016
Quaker midwife Rose Carroll is enjoying the 1888 Independence Day evening fireworks with her beau when a teenaged Quaker mill girl is found shot dead. After a former slave and fellow Quaker is accused of the murder, Rose delves into the crime, convinced of the man's innocence. An ill-mannered mill manager, an Irish immigrant, and the victim's young boyfriend come under suspicion even as Rose's future with her handsome doctor suitor becomes unsure. Rose continues to deliver babies and listen to secrets, finally figuring out one criminal—only to be threatened by the murderer, with three lives at stake. Can she rescue herself, a baby, and her elderly midwifery teacher in time?
This is a murder mystery with a twist, I never read the first instalment, but with the Quaker background it gives the story a slightly different spin, with murder, prejudice and many secrets there is lots going on the story, with lots of mixed characters that keep the book interesting.
This is a murder mystery with a twist, I never read the first instalment, but with the Quaker background it gives the story a slightly different spin, with murder, prejudice and many secrets there is lots going on the story, with lots of mixed characters that keep the book interesting.
March 21, 2019
I really enjoyed this laid back Quaker mystery. I believe a first in Quaker genre for me. Since this was a galley proof from NetGalley I had not read the first book in the series, a mistake that I will remedy.
Rose Carrell is a younger midwife that seems to stumble into mysteries as a sideline to her full-time midwife practice. This time a young girl that works at the local mill confides to Rose that she is with child and unmarried. Shortly thereafter she is murdered and a local African is blamed for the murder.
There are lots of twists and turns that somehow always involve Rose, some hair raising moments as well.
I liked the background of the Quaker lifestyle and was somewhat distracted for awhile by the Thees and Thous, but soon it didn’t bother me anymore.
If real life didn’t interfere so much I could have finished it much earlier
I received an eversion of this book from NetGalley and I am now giving my review. Don’t miss this little mystery, maybe start with the first one.
Rose Carrell is a younger midwife that seems to stumble into mysteries as a sideline to her full-time midwife practice. This time a young girl that works at the local mill confides to Rose that she is with child and unmarried. Shortly thereafter she is murdered and a local African is blamed for the murder.
There are lots of twists and turns that somehow always involve Rose, some hair raising moments as well.
I liked the background of the Quaker lifestyle and was somewhat distracted for awhile by the Thees and Thous, but soon it didn’t bother me anymore.
If real life didn’t interfere so much I could have finished it much earlier
I received an eversion of this book from NetGalley and I am now giving my review. Don’t miss this little mystery, maybe start with the first one.
July 4, 2017
I would like to thank Midnight Ink for providing me with a free electronic ARC of this book, via Netgalley, in exchange for an open and honest review.
This is the second book in the ‘A Quaker Midwife’ series, and I was lucky enough to get to read the first one, due to a suggestion by the author herself. I enjoyed it so much - you can see my review for ‘Delivering the Truth’ here that I have been hanging out for this the second book.
I found ‘Called to Justice just as good’ as the first book ‘Delivering the truth’. It picks up the life of Rose the Quaker midwife a few months after the first book finishes and, although it does refer to a couple of things from the first book, it could be read and enjoyed as a stand-alone story if desired.
For me it had just that right amount of mystery, historical everyday life and the personal life comings and goings of Rose herself within her home, work and faith. Although not a Quaker myself (for those who haven’t read my other stuff, I’m Pagan and proud) I love learning and hearing of how it is depicted within this series. I am going to trust that Ms Maxwell has researched it well (she says she has and I believe her) and so it is as true to form as can be. It just adds a nice touch of harmony within one’s own faith without overpowering the book with religion… if that makes sense?
As to the mystery side of it? Perfect. I, as is my bane, guessed the who and why early on, but found there were enough red herrings to make me doubt myself all the way until near the end. Which, to me, makes a great mystery book. Thinking you know who did it early on and then doubting yourself as information unfolds. You simply MUST keep reading to see if you are right or wrong. ;-) And what I also love about Ms Maxwell’s writing style of this book is there is just the right amount of padding. Some cosy crimes and mystery books stuff their stories full of so much padding and red herrings you really get tired and lose any desire to find out who really did it. There is just too much stuff to wade through. Not with ‘A Quaker Midwife’ series - so far the two books have both contained just the right amount of padding, red herrings and interesting story telling to make this a totally enjoyable book.
Would I recommend this book to others?
Yes I would. Lovers of cosy crimes/ mysteries will enjoy it; lovers of historical crime fiction will love it. It can be enjoyed with the first book in the series or, as I’ve said, happily stand on its own as an entertaining read. Though, being a lover of reading a series in order, I would recommend people read ‘Delivering the Truth’ first.
Would I buy this book for myself?
Yes I would. If you haven’t guessed I’m thoroughly enjoying the series and the second book was as good as the first. I could happily see the ‘A Quaker Midwife’ series on my electronic bookshelves. They are not a read once sort of book. I could easily see myself rereading it again in the future and still getting enjoyment from it.
In summary: An excellent second book in ‘A Quaker Midwife’ series, but could easily be read as a stand-alone too.
This is the second book in the ‘A Quaker Midwife’ series, and I was lucky enough to get to read the first one, due to a suggestion by the author herself. I enjoyed it so much - you can see my review for ‘Delivering the Truth’ here that I have been hanging out for this the second book.
I found ‘Called to Justice just as good’ as the first book ‘Delivering the truth’. It picks up the life of Rose the Quaker midwife a few months after the first book finishes and, although it does refer to a couple of things from the first book, it could be read and enjoyed as a stand-alone story if desired.
For me it had just that right amount of mystery, historical everyday life and the personal life comings and goings of Rose herself within her home, work and faith. Although not a Quaker myself (for those who haven’t read my other stuff, I’m Pagan and proud) I love learning and hearing of how it is depicted within this series. I am going to trust that Ms Maxwell has researched it well (she says she has and I believe her) and so it is as true to form as can be. It just adds a nice touch of harmony within one’s own faith without overpowering the book with religion… if that makes sense?
As to the mystery side of it? Perfect. I, as is my bane, guessed the who and why early on, but found there were enough red herrings to make me doubt myself all the way until near the end. Which, to me, makes a great mystery book. Thinking you know who did it early on and then doubting yourself as information unfolds. You simply MUST keep reading to see if you are right or wrong. ;-) And what I also love about Ms Maxwell’s writing style of this book is there is just the right amount of padding. Some cosy crimes and mystery books stuff their stories full of so much padding and red herrings you really get tired and lose any desire to find out who really did it. There is just too much stuff to wade through. Not with ‘A Quaker Midwife’ series - so far the two books have both contained just the right amount of padding, red herrings and interesting story telling to make this a totally enjoyable book.
Would I recommend this book to others?
Yes I would. Lovers of cosy crimes/ mysteries will enjoy it; lovers of historical crime fiction will love it. It can be enjoyed with the first book in the series or, as I’ve said, happily stand on its own as an entertaining read. Though, being a lover of reading a series in order, I would recommend people read ‘Delivering the Truth’ first.
Would I buy this book for myself?
Yes I would. If you haven’t guessed I’m thoroughly enjoying the series and the second book was as good as the first. I could happily see the ‘A Quaker Midwife’ series on my electronic bookshelves. They are not a read once sort of book. I could easily see myself rereading it again in the future and still getting enjoyment from it.
In summary: An excellent second book in ‘A Quaker Midwife’ series, but could easily be read as a stand-alone too.
November 14, 2019
I did not think I was a fan of historical mysteries until I met Edith Maxwell's Rose Carrol. My problem with historicals is author's tend to overwhelm a reader with their in depth research. Also at times the effort to produce a normal voice for the period results in almost incomprehensible dialogue.
Not so with the Quaker Midwife series. Rose does speak with the flavor of late 19th Century English.
Others in the novel reveal social standing and education though dialogue --not dialect-- a subtle welcome part of Maxwell's style.
Book 2 may be read as a stand alone. The references to events in Delivering the Truth are logical as in mentioning the aftermath of the fire from book one. Relationships introduced in book one continue to develop especially Rose's romance with David Dodge. Her friendship with Bertie remains strong, as does the professional relationship with Kevin.
The book opens with an Independence Day Celebration in Amesbury MA. in 1888. Rose's viewing of the parade are interrupted by Hannah Breed, a fellow Quaker, and mill girl with her niece Faith. Hannah seeks her out as a she is pregnant, and unwed, and distraught. Sadly, she is the victim who calls to justice.. she is murdered within 24 hours of speaking to Rose. Maxwell then introduces the theme of racism. An African American who is a former slave and is now a successful craftsman is accused, jailed, and seems to be on the way to a certain trial. Will Rose be able to convince others of this injustice?
The passages regarding midwifery are equally fascinating. Here Maxwell shares the perils of 19th Century medicine. She explicitly describes the facts surrounding a birth when the mother has gonorrhea. Another life threatening birth involves antepartum hemorrhage, a scene that left me
reading late into the night. All this work for $2.00 a birth, a fee that would translate to $54.00 in 2019 dollars; the low fees seem to be another way that Maxwell shows Rose's Quaker values.
A seasoned reader of mysteries may deduce the perpetrator fairly easily. This is not the point. Immersing oneself in another time by seeing a world through the eyes of a curious, independent young woman is the point. I look forward to reading more of Rose's adventures.
Highly recommended
Not so with the Quaker Midwife series. Rose does speak with the flavor of late 19th Century English.
Others in the novel reveal social standing and education though dialogue --not dialect-- a subtle welcome part of Maxwell's style.
Book 2 may be read as a stand alone. The references to events in Delivering the Truth are logical as in mentioning the aftermath of the fire from book one. Relationships introduced in book one continue to develop especially Rose's romance with David Dodge. Her friendship with Bertie remains strong, as does the professional relationship with Kevin.
The book opens with an Independence Day Celebration in Amesbury MA. in 1888. Rose's viewing of the parade are interrupted by Hannah Breed, a fellow Quaker, and mill girl with her niece Faith. Hannah seeks her out as a she is pregnant, and unwed, and distraught. Sadly, she is the victim who calls to justice.. she is murdered within 24 hours of speaking to Rose. Maxwell then introduces the theme of racism. An African American who is a former slave and is now a successful craftsman is accused, jailed, and seems to be on the way to a certain trial. Will Rose be able to convince others of this injustice?
The passages regarding midwifery are equally fascinating. Here Maxwell shares the perils of 19th Century medicine. She explicitly describes the facts surrounding a birth when the mother has gonorrhea. Another life threatening birth involves antepartum hemorrhage, a scene that left me
reading late into the night. All this work for $2.00 a birth, a fee that would translate to $54.00 in 2019 dollars; the low fees seem to be another way that Maxwell shows Rose's Quaker values.
A seasoned reader of mysteries may deduce the perpetrator fairly easily. This is not the point. Immersing oneself in another time by seeing a world through the eyes of a curious, independent young woman is the point. I look forward to reading more of Rose's adventures.
Highly recommended
May 31, 2017
"Death. Betrayal. Sickness. Thievery. Rape." .... In a Quaker Midwife Mystery series ??
Trust. Love. Commitment. Friendship. Life. .... In a Quaker Midwife Mystery series ??
Absolutely !!! Called to Justice by Edith Maxwell has that and a whole lot more.
The main character, Rose, is a Quaker and a midwife and a friend to everyone. Rose is a very good listener and will do whatever she can to help someone.....even if it could be dangerous.
While enjoying a day of celebration Rose vows to help Hannah, a young girl who works at the factory with her niece. Hannah had informed Rose that she was with child but wouldn't say who the father was. Before Rose can gather more information from the young girl, Hannah is shot during the firework display. At the time, no one comes forward to say who shot her. Rose not only wants to solve Hannah's murder but also find out who the father of the unborn child is.
As Rose continues her midwife responsibilities she is able to do some investigating as well. When a Friend is accused of Hannah's murder, Rose knows that the authorities have the wrong person. She also learns that another girl who works at the factory and lives in the boardinghouse where Hannah lived is accusing the deceased as having stolen items from her.
On top of ALL that, David has asked her to marry him and she has accepted. But before they can even celebrate, David's mother expressed her feelings about their engagement and it isn't nice at all !!
With all that information, Rose is more determined to solve Hannah's murder. Will she be able to free her innocent friend from jail ? Can she do this without putting her own life in jeopardy ?
No matter how much stuff gets thrown at Rose, she is always able to handle it. Pick up your copy of Called to Justice and see how she does it.
June 20, 2017
The reader is transported to Amesbury, Massachusetts in 1888. Oh my, what an eye opening book this was and makes me realize how much we take every day conveniences and medical, technological, and social advances for granted! The author brings the life of a midwife to full view in an era before technology, modern medicine and hospitals. The perils that can befall the newborn and new mothers alike are treated with compassion and grace. I found myself hoping for the best in each birth the protagonist, Rose Carroll, attended and my heart stopped when things didn’t go as expected. The author also gives the reader a charming peek into the Quaker’s lifestyle along with an uglier look at the bigotry and prejudices against other races and against women during that time period. I think it’s a good reminder, despite all the political and social upheaval our country is experiencing, that we have made great strides in becoming a better nation, a better people.
Edith expertly weaves the historical details and social mindset of the late 1800’s into a good mystery that keeps a reader guessing about who would have wanted to kill the unwed, pregnant teen. Rose Carroll is a believable protagonist as she searches for justice, not only for the murdered girl but for the wrongly accused man. I enjoyed Rose’s character very much — she is a good role model not only for the 1800’s but for current day too! She isn’t afraid to defy conventional customs governing young ladies and instead focuses on doing what she knows to be the right thing to do. All in all, CALLED TO JUSTICE is a fascinating read with a satisfying mystery!
I was provided a copy with the hopes I would review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Edith expertly weaves the historical details and social mindset of the late 1800’s into a good mystery that keeps a reader guessing about who would have wanted to kill the unwed, pregnant teen. Rose Carroll is a believable protagonist as she searches for justice, not only for the murdered girl but for the wrongly accused man. I enjoyed Rose’s character very much — she is a good role model not only for the 1800’s but for current day too! She isn’t afraid to defy conventional customs governing young ladies and instead focuses on doing what she knows to be the right thing to do. All in all, CALLED TO JUSTICE is a fascinating read with a satisfying mystery!
I was provided a copy with the hopes I would review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
May 13, 2017
Rose Carroll is a Quaker midwife in Amesbury, Massachusetts and on Independence Day Hannah Breed comes to Rose and confides to her that she is pregnant out of wedlock. Rose is not sure what to do to help her right then, but promises Hannah that she will help her. Later that night amidst the fireworks Hannah is found shot dead.
Another Quaker, a former slave is accused of the murder, and arrested. Rose once again envolves herself in the investigation as she is confident that her fellow Quaker is innocent. Is it the victim's young boyfriend or the rude mill manager?
Rose continues to deliver babies and go about her midwife duties and listen in on the secrets of the town. She also talks with the town constable and tries to find out what evidence he has or does not have.
Her future with Dr. David Dodge seems to be unsure, will they be able to work it out and what about his parents? Will they ever except her?
Rose continues to work on who could have shot Hannah and in the end gets involved in things that threaten her and her neice's life. Later the murderer follows Rose and things become touch and go.
I enjoy the story of Rose and her Quaker life and her growing love for David. The historical accuracy of the series has been great and keeps the book moving right along.
Another Quaker, a former slave is accused of the murder, and arrested. Rose once again envolves herself in the investigation as she is confident that her fellow Quaker is innocent. Is it the victim's young boyfriend or the rude mill manager?
Rose continues to deliver babies and go about her midwife duties and listen in on the secrets of the town. She also talks with the town constable and tries to find out what evidence he has or does not have.
Her future with Dr. David Dodge seems to be unsure, will they be able to work it out and what about his parents? Will they ever except her?
Rose continues to work on who could have shot Hannah and in the end gets involved in things that threaten her and her neice's life. Later the murderer follows Rose and things become touch and go.
I enjoy the story of Rose and her Quaker life and her growing love for David. The historical accuracy of the series has been great and keeps the book moving right along.
June 1, 2017
As I enjoyed the first Quaker Midwife book so much, I was more than happy to discover this next one - and it does not disappoint.
Rose Carroll is not without her faults and strains at times to practice what her religion preaches but, more than anything, her strong sense of right and wrong shines throughout these tales. It was comforting to be re-acquainted with her friends and family in this brand new and well planned mystery.
Whilst her midwifery career continues to flourish in the community of Amesbury, Rose gets to meet and know more of the inhabitants. When a fellow Quaker is wrongly accused of murder and thrown in jail, she once again darkens the door of the local police station and the unwelcome greeting from the resident detective with each bit of information she can glean about his current case. This is, again, a well planned and thought out mystery with several red herrings, suspects aplenty and other unknown crimes included in the mix.
A thoroughly satisfying read which increases my liking for Edith Maxwell's novels and I look forward to tackling the third which I note is in the works!
I received an arc via NetGalley in exchange for my honest and unbiased review.
Rose Carroll is not without her faults and strains at times to practice what her religion preaches but, more than anything, her strong sense of right and wrong shines throughout these tales. It was comforting to be re-acquainted with her friends and family in this brand new and well planned mystery.
Whilst her midwifery career continues to flourish in the community of Amesbury, Rose gets to meet and know more of the inhabitants. When a fellow Quaker is wrongly accused of murder and thrown in jail, she once again darkens the door of the local police station and the unwelcome greeting from the resident detective with each bit of information she can glean about his current case. This is, again, a well planned and thought out mystery with several red herrings, suspects aplenty and other unknown crimes included in the mix.
A thoroughly satisfying read which increases my liking for Edith Maxwell's novels and I look forward to tackling the third which I note is in the works!
I received an arc via NetGalley in exchange for my honest and unbiased review.
December 20, 2016
We are back with Rose in an 1880’s Quaker Village of Amesbury, MA, and she is still the midwife, and David is still in the picture.
We meet injustice face on when a man of color is accused of murder, but who did commit the crime. Rose is sure that this gentle man did not, but a young mill girl is murdered at the Fourth of July Celebration, and she has just let Rose in on a secret.
The author does a great job of making me believe I’m am attending the deliveries, riding a horse to the beach, or just going about my daily life. While we go about everyday life, we are also tuning into what is going on and who the real murderer is, and you are going to change from one culprit to another, and then back again, but will you be right?
Another great look into American history in old New England, with a big of suspense and mystery added in.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Midnight Ink, and was not required to give a positive review.
We meet injustice face on when a man of color is accused of murder, but who did commit the crime. Rose is sure that this gentle man did not, but a young mill girl is murdered at the Fourth of July Celebration, and she has just let Rose in on a secret.
The author does a great job of making me believe I’m am attending the deliveries, riding a horse to the beach, or just going about my daily life. While we go about everyday life, we are also tuning into what is going on and who the real murderer is, and you are going to change from one culprit to another, and then back again, but will you be right?
Another great look into American history in old New England, with a big of suspense and mystery added in.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Midnight Ink, and was not required to give a positive review.
March 22, 2020
A few months ago I read 4 of the 5 books in the Quaker Midwife series by Edith Maxwell (my library doesn’t have Turning the Tide yet). I won one of the books in a contest, but didn’t think I would like the series as I am not a religious person. I am so glad I won the book because it’s a fantastic series that I would not have otherwise read. You are pulled into the story right away. The characters are introduced in a way it’s easy to keep track of who’s who, and they develop over time in the series. They are books about blending and merging of people with differences – in a way, it’s about how people should get along. The plots are intriguing and will keep you guessing. Once you pick one up, you just want to keep reading it and not stop. I would recommend these books to everyone, regardless of your religious beliefs, or lack thereof.
December 3, 2020
I like this installment significantly more than I liked the previous one. I think it was easier to follow and I already knew and loved the characters. I also will say that I had no real idea of who could have “done it“. I’m really starting to like rose a lot and I’m kind of rooting for her and David. I really learn a lot about the Quakers and their approach to life and society in these books. I’m not really sure that there are a whole lot of them anymore and I could be wrong about that. But I really admire the principles that they stood for. It’s very interesting to read about interactions between Rose and her faith and the greater world. It was also interesting to see reactions to race in a historical context. I’m looking forward to reading the next novel in the series. I really think I’m going to enjoy it
August 16, 2022
The Quaker contemplative faith is at the heart of this mystery set in the 19th century New England. The protagonist, Rose, reveals the story in first person with thees and thous. She upholds women's rights and fights racial prejudice while conducting her midwifery skills. Well-researched historical references and a sweet courtship add believability and spice to this cozy murder mystery.
Domestic life and the time-consuming drudgery of maintaining food preparations, cleaning, and laundry in the 1800s weren't shown as part of Rose's life, but the author did attempt to suspend our realities through other supportive women characters providing repast and sending Rose's brother-in-law and his children away for the summer.
I guessed who the killer was early on, but again the author wove a great story and made you keep reading to be sure.
Domestic life and the time-consuming drudgery of maintaining food preparations, cleaning, and laundry in the 1800s weren't shown as part of Rose's life, but the author did attempt to suspend our realities through other supportive women characters providing repast and sending Rose's brother-in-law and his children away for the summer.
I guessed who the killer was early on, but again the author wove a great story and made you keep reading to be sure.
July 13, 2019
Called to Justice was an OK mystery. There is only one murder to solve (unlike the first volume of the series, Delivering the Truth), but there are other issues Rose et al. must deal with (i.e. racism and racial profiling). The culprit wasn't a total surprise, but Maxwell did an admirable job of trying to throw in a red herring .
The midwifery details were still excellent (much like Delivering) and Rose's work continues to play a part in the story (i.e. the reader is not just simply told that Rose visited with patients and then move on to the investigation, but rather Maxwell continues to write about patient visits in the plot). Additionally, the information about the Quaker religion and lifestyle were much more smoothly incorporated into the story than in Delivering; I can only think of one awkward moment where David (Rose's gentleman friend) clunkily asks Rose to clarify what First Day is. David should already know what Quakers call the days of the week because if he is attentive to Rose, he should have picked that up by now.
The midwifery details were still excellent (much like Delivering) and Rose's work continues to play a part in the story (i.e. the reader is not just simply told that Rose visited with patients and then move on to the investigation, but rather Maxwell continues to write about patient visits in the plot). Additionally, the information about the Quaker religion and lifestyle were much more smoothly incorporated into the story than in Delivering; I can only think of one awkward moment where David (Rose's gentleman friend) clunkily asks Rose to clarify what First Day is. David should already know what Quakers call the days of the week because if he is attentive to Rose, he should have picked that up by now.
February 3, 2022
I felt that this was more of a drama about the MC's life when a murder happens to take place around her. She is emotionally invested in finding out who the murderer is, but it didn't feel like a true murder mystery since the vast majority of the story was not about finding the murderer, it was about everything else going on in Rose's life. I enjoyed the view into midwifery in that time period, but the language of the time definitely slowed me down; perhaps in that sense, I'm not the ideal reader so take that comment with a grain of salt if thee likes old timey language. It took quite a while for me to really get into the story. Overall, I think it was well written and the characters were developed well, it just wasn't my cup of tea.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 87 reviews