What do you think?
Rate this book
Dead Down East
Dead Down East is a fictional murder mystery. It is both detective noir and smart screwball comedy, rolled into one. Jesse Thorpe, a young private investigator operating out of Augusta, Maine, narrates the tale.
Jesse’s vacation on Great Pond is cut short when he receives a mysterious phone call from a former client, Cynthia Dumais. She begs to be rescued from an island south of Brunswick, within a mile of where William Lavoilette, the governor of Maine, had been assassinated the night before. She insists that her life is in danger, but is unwilling to provide Jesse any further information. Reluctantly, Jesse agrees to help.
Within a week, he has three separate clients, each with his, or her, own desperate need to have the murder solved. Jesse assembles a motley team of compadres, including rock band members, an eccentric psychic and his zesty girlfriend, Angele Boucher, to help him with the case. While the FBI and the Maine State Police investigate political motives, Jesse looks for the woman—Cherchez la femme—as the trail draws him through the lives, and DNA, of seven of the governor’s former mistresses.
Jesse’s vacation on Great Pond is cut short when he receives a mysterious phone call from a former client, Cynthia Dumais. She begs to be rescued from an island south of Brunswick, within a mile of where William Lavoilette, the governor of Maine, had been assassinated the night before. She insists that her life is in danger, but is unwilling to provide Jesse any further information. Reluctantly, Jesse agrees to help.
Within a week, he has three separate clients, each with his, or her, own desperate need to have the murder solved. Jesse assembles a motley team of compadres, including rock band members, an eccentric psychic and his zesty girlfriend, Angele Boucher, to help him with the case. While the FBI and the Maine State Police investigate political motives, Jesse looks for the woman—Cherchez la femme—as the trail draws him through the lives, and DNA, of seven of the governor’s former mistresses.
245 pages, Kindle Edition
Published May 25, 2016
60 people are currently reading
18 people want to read
About the author
Carl Schmidt
6 books10 followersCarl Schmidt is the author of a series of the mystery/humor novel series entitled, Jesse Thorpe Mysteries. The first four books in the series are Dead Down East, A Priestly Affair, Redbone, and Flim Flam.
Carl resides in Sedona, Arizona, but for the first 30 years of his life he lived in eleven different US states, Newfoundland, Philippines, Japan and India.
He chose Maine for the setting of his Jesse Thorpe Mystery novels because of its natural beauty and her colorful personalities.
Carl studied mathematics and physics in both Denver and Brown Universities.
Carl resides in Sedona, Arizona, but for the first 30 years of his life he lived in eleven different US states, Newfoundland, Philippines, Japan and India.
He chose Maine for the setting of his Jesse Thorpe Mystery novels because of its natural beauty and her colorful personalities.
Carl studied mathematics and physics in both Denver and Brown Universities.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
September 10, 2016
The main character of this book is private-eye Jessie Thorpe, and a relatively believable one when compared to so many private sleuths from fiction. This the first in Schmidt’s proposed series of books, is unsurprisingly based on one of Jessie’s first cases, and certainly his first murder. Jessie is a bit of a middle-class smart arse, who at the start of the book has had an interesting life but perhaps not achieved a great deal. Jesse has many skills, as a guitarist in a group, an odd job carpenter and now as a gumshoe. He is also toying with the idea of writing. Quite a lot of him is quite possibly a younger version of Carl Schmidt the author.
The book runs on a fuel of wry-witted observations from Jesse. The voice is very much confident middle-class, white, American. Jesse is definitely macho, but far from Rambo, relying on the ability to disarm with words rather than violence. Jesse has a firearm but not one that is habitually to hand. His so far unused shooter has been given the name of an ex-girlfriend. The feminisation is presumably supported, though it wasn’t instigated by him, through seeing Rhonda as a dissipater of threats rather than a projector of them. Rhonda is carried to give a bit of Dutch courage when felt necessary, and hopefully discourage harmful activity from the psychologically less restrained. Courage without gin, that is. Jessie would never drive inebriated unless absolutely unavoidable. Hopefully Jesse won’t become just another fictional private-eye happy to spray lead first and follow leads second.
The actual murder mystery is inventive, solved with mathematical logic and, it has to be said more than a reasonably likely quotient of good luck. Isn’t that nearly always the case in real life? If there is one thing we can say is generic to police everywhere, it is that why often make good traffic cops but generally hopeless detectives. It seems the cops of Maine are, at least in this story, little different.
I feared for a moment as the story veered in the direction of psychic practitioners. I can’t deny I was relieved that the case was solved in a sensibly scientific way. I notice that book two in the series is out, ‘A Priestly Affair’, and hope that it displays a normal range of modern detective skills to achieve what I assume will be another PI success.
The murder mystery, at least in this first book, was more of an anchor around which to build interesting back story and a range of secondary characters than the be all of the read. The book would have worked equally well without any murder at all. The fun here is in what is happening outside the mechanics of case solving. This isn’t much of an intense thriller, being more about the drama that flows around the murder. If I may borrow images from film/TV, this is more James Garner as Jim Rockford than Bruce Willis as John McClane. Actually, Jesse Thorpe mysteries would adapt perfectly to the TV series format. The book opens with reflections on modern classics in book and film, as Jesse and a fishing buddy with an academic background actually fish on ‘Golden Pond’.
The writing itself is good, especially where Schmidt allows space for idle chat and scene setting, rather than to the intricate plays of the case. I like reading modern fiction that doesn’t suffer the James Patterson disease of needing a spectacular at the end of each chapter. Yes, there is interest to keep the reading flowing, without a felt requirement for thirty world ending events. We get just enough of the landscape in the authors mind to build our own real feeling interpretations, to visually create our imagined or recall the real backdrop, of the State of Maine. I had no trouble feeling that I was visiting the murder scene.
Schmidt is yet another in the band of independent authors who write as well as, and better than some, lauded authors, but most of whom will never get the lucky, or ‘contacts’ enabled, breaks. For those that like reading good books from good writers rather than just good books by the fashionable few in the front shelves of book stores, I have no reservations about recommending this author. And of course, I hope Schmidt bucks overwhelming statistics to become a fiction writing success.
The book runs on a fuel of wry-witted observations from Jesse. The voice is very much confident middle-class, white, American. Jesse is definitely macho, but far from Rambo, relying on the ability to disarm with words rather than violence. Jesse has a firearm but not one that is habitually to hand. His so far unused shooter has been given the name of an ex-girlfriend. The feminisation is presumably supported, though it wasn’t instigated by him, through seeing Rhonda as a dissipater of threats rather than a projector of them. Rhonda is carried to give a bit of Dutch courage when felt necessary, and hopefully discourage harmful activity from the psychologically less restrained. Courage without gin, that is. Jessie would never drive inebriated unless absolutely unavoidable. Hopefully Jesse won’t become just another fictional private-eye happy to spray lead first and follow leads second.
The actual murder mystery is inventive, solved with mathematical logic and, it has to be said more than a reasonably likely quotient of good luck. Isn’t that nearly always the case in real life? If there is one thing we can say is generic to police everywhere, it is that why often make good traffic cops but generally hopeless detectives. It seems the cops of Maine are, at least in this story, little different.
I feared for a moment as the story veered in the direction of psychic practitioners. I can’t deny I was relieved that the case was solved in a sensibly scientific way. I notice that book two in the series is out, ‘A Priestly Affair’, and hope that it displays a normal range of modern detective skills to achieve what I assume will be another PI success.
The murder mystery, at least in this first book, was more of an anchor around which to build interesting back story and a range of secondary characters than the be all of the read. The book would have worked equally well without any murder at all. The fun here is in what is happening outside the mechanics of case solving. This isn’t much of an intense thriller, being more about the drama that flows around the murder. If I may borrow images from film/TV, this is more James Garner as Jim Rockford than Bruce Willis as John McClane. Actually, Jesse Thorpe mysteries would adapt perfectly to the TV series format. The book opens with reflections on modern classics in book and film, as Jesse and a fishing buddy with an academic background actually fish on ‘Golden Pond’.
The writing itself is good, especially where Schmidt allows space for idle chat and scene setting, rather than to the intricate plays of the case. I like reading modern fiction that doesn’t suffer the James Patterson disease of needing a spectacular at the end of each chapter. Yes, there is interest to keep the reading flowing, without a felt requirement for thirty world ending events. We get just enough of the landscape in the authors mind to build our own real feeling interpretations, to visually create our imagined or recall the real backdrop, of the State of Maine. I had no trouble feeling that I was visiting the murder scene.
Schmidt is yet another in the band of independent authors who write as well as, and better than some, lauded authors, but most of whom will never get the lucky, or ‘contacts’ enabled, breaks. For those that like reading good books from good writers rather than just good books by the fashionable few in the front shelves of book stores, I have no reservations about recommending this author. And of course, I hope Schmidt bucks overwhelming statistics to become a fiction writing success.
January 13, 2017
Characters
There is a stream of characters at the beginning but they rotate back through them so it isn’t overwhelming. Jesse is a man’s man. He fishes, has misplaced women’s negligee, and names his car/gun. He keeps cheap wine in his cupboards, likes his women a little crazy but passionate, but values people and doesn’t seem to be a judgmental person. I shook my head more than once at his antics but I didn’t dislike him - well maybe a few times but he is a charming character.
What makes him a well-rounded character is the supporting characters. His lady Angele is amusing and adds a passionate edge to the book. His band mates - all of them - add another layer. Michael and his wife added a softer edge to Jesse and are interesting characters in their own right.
Plot
This plot is not a whodunit and it is NOT about fishing. The author doesn’t give any clues and withholds all of the information needed to ‘solve the case’ until Jesse knows more. It is a crime novel that follows Jesse and his process of solving the crime. It was very methodical at times and a little wishy washy at others but overall was a solid crime plot. I did like the realistic aspects of what it took to track everything down. The level of detail that I normally dislike was necessary to show what it takes to solve a crime. Hard work, planning, some lying, and a lot of luck.
Overall
The writing and characters were enjoyable and believable. The pace of the book was steady and there were enough moments of interest to keep me vested as a reader. I prefer ‘whodunit’ books but this was a different type of mystery novel. It showed the process of figuring out who the murderer was. I actually really enjoyed all of that, and the level of detail the author brought to solving the murder. Even the interactions, although sometimes not necessary and a little lengthy, always served some sort of purpose.
The real problem I had with this book was the ending. I just sort of started laughing and saying ‘that’s absolutely ridiculous!’ and ‘you’ve got to be kidding me.’ There is no way they would just get away with it and it was such a gamble. They could have compromised EVERYTHING and to make matters worse an OFFICER OF THE LAW HELPED. Needless to say I was pissed because it was just too far out there. To make matters worse the entire writing style and power behind solving the case just sort of disintegrated into its other side - cornball comedy. The entire last 10% of the book was horrible for me.
Rating
3 stars
This was a solid 4 star book right up until the ending. Good characters, interesting mystery, and easy to read style of writing. The ending just pushed the boundary of reality in too many directions at once and became a true work of ‘fiction’ - to the point I no longer believed it was plausible.
I received a copy in exchange of an honest review. More reviews on creatingworldswithwords.wordpress.com.
There is a stream of characters at the beginning but they rotate back through them so it isn’t overwhelming. Jesse is a man’s man. He fishes, has misplaced women’s negligee, and names his car/gun. He keeps cheap wine in his cupboards, likes his women a little crazy but passionate, but values people and doesn’t seem to be a judgmental person. I shook my head more than once at his antics but I didn’t dislike him - well maybe a few times but he is a charming character.
What makes him a well-rounded character is the supporting characters. His lady Angele is amusing and adds a passionate edge to the book. His band mates - all of them - add another layer. Michael and his wife added a softer edge to Jesse and are interesting characters in their own right.
Plot
This plot is not a whodunit and it is NOT about fishing. The author doesn’t give any clues and withholds all of the information needed to ‘solve the case’ until Jesse knows more. It is a crime novel that follows Jesse and his process of solving the crime. It was very methodical at times and a little wishy washy at others but overall was a solid crime plot. I did like the realistic aspects of what it took to track everything down. The level of detail that I normally dislike was necessary to show what it takes to solve a crime. Hard work, planning, some lying, and a lot of luck.
Overall
The writing and characters were enjoyable and believable. The pace of the book was steady and there were enough moments of interest to keep me vested as a reader. I prefer ‘whodunit’ books but this was a different type of mystery novel. It showed the process of figuring out who the murderer was. I actually really enjoyed all of that, and the level of detail the author brought to solving the murder. Even the interactions, although sometimes not necessary and a little lengthy, always served some sort of purpose.
The real problem I had with this book was the ending. I just sort of started laughing and saying ‘that’s absolutely ridiculous!’ and ‘you’ve got to be kidding me.’ There is no way they would just get away with it and it was such a gamble. They could have compromised EVERYTHING and to make matters worse an OFFICER OF THE LAW HELPED. Needless to say I was pissed because it was just too far out there. To make matters worse the entire writing style and power behind solving the case just sort of disintegrated into its other side - cornball comedy. The entire last 10% of the book was horrible for me.
Rating
3 stars
This was a solid 4 star book right up until the ending. Good characters, interesting mystery, and easy to read style of writing. The ending just pushed the boundary of reality in too many directions at once and became a true work of ‘fiction’ - to the point I no longer believed it was plausible.
I received a copy in exchange of an honest review. More reviews on creatingworldswithwords.wordpress.com.
December 16, 2016
This originally appeared at The Irresponsible Reader.
---
Jesse Thorpe is a carpenter and member of a local band, who happens to be a P. I. on the side. The P. I. part doesn't seem to take up too much of his time or draw much attention to itself, few people in his life know that's one of his professions. Still, he's had a few clients, taken care of a few cases -- enough to give him some confidence in what he does. Then one day, a fishing trip is interrupted by a former client, who just found herself in the middle of circumstances surrounding the murder of her married lover. Who happens -- well, happened -- to be the Governor of Maine.
Maybe Jesse could use a little more experience.
It doesn't take long before Jesse is working for his former client and two other people to investigate the murder, while the FBI and local police are stymied. Jesse's client isn't the only one that the Governor had an affair with, and the investigation into the affairs keeps Jesse busy and turns up plenty of motives for murder. It'll take all of Jesse's creativity, and the efforts of a motley crew of clients, bandmates, his sexy girlfriend, a friendly policeman, and a lotta luck for Jesse to clear the innocent and make sure the guilty pay.
I really don't think the psychic adds anything beyond a chuckle or two, but that could just be me.
There were a few places where the book could've used some editing and proofreading -- but only one that took me out of the scene, so I'm not going to get into it. Well, there was also the repeated use of "FBI Officers" instead of "Agents," but that was easy enough to chuckle about and move on.
The first couple of chapters were difficult to wade through -- dialogue seemed to be more about short speeches than anything, and the first few people talking about the murder sounded like they were contributing to or reading a news release about it. But once Jesse gets hired and things start to happen, Schmidt settles in and the writing improves. The only complaint I have after this is that he tends to over-explain things -- especially the humor. He needs to trust himself and his readers a bit more and dial that back.
There's not much more to say, Dead Down East is a pretty good mystery with a cast of characters that I'd enjoy seeing more of. Give Jesse a shot.
Disclaimer: I received this book from the author in exchange for my honest opinion -- which influenced me not one whit, but I do appreciate it. I'm sorry that I filed it under "December Reads" and not "October Reads" like I'd said I would.
---
Jesse Thorpe is a carpenter and member of a local band, who happens to be a P. I. on the side. The P. I. part doesn't seem to take up too much of his time or draw much attention to itself, few people in his life know that's one of his professions. Still, he's had a few clients, taken care of a few cases -- enough to give him some confidence in what he does. Then one day, a fishing trip is interrupted by a former client, who just found herself in the middle of circumstances surrounding the murder of her married lover. Who happens -- well, happened -- to be the Governor of Maine.
Maybe Jesse could use a little more experience.
It doesn't take long before Jesse is working for his former client and two other people to investigate the murder, while the FBI and local police are stymied. Jesse's client isn't the only one that the Governor had an affair with, and the investigation into the affairs keeps Jesse busy and turns up plenty of motives for murder. It'll take all of Jesse's creativity, and the efforts of a motley crew of clients, bandmates, his sexy girlfriend, a friendly policeman, and a lotta luck for Jesse to clear the innocent and make sure the guilty pay.
I really don't think the psychic adds anything beyond a chuckle or two, but that could just be me.
There were a few places where the book could've used some editing and proofreading -- but only one that took me out of the scene, so I'm not going to get into it. Well, there was also the repeated use of "FBI Officers" instead of "Agents," but that was easy enough to chuckle about and move on.
The first couple of chapters were difficult to wade through -- dialogue seemed to be more about short speeches than anything, and the first few people talking about the murder sounded like they were contributing to or reading a news release about it. But once Jesse gets hired and things start to happen, Schmidt settles in and the writing improves. The only complaint I have after this is that he tends to over-explain things -- especially the humor. He needs to trust himself and his readers a bit more and dial that back.
There's not much more to say, Dead Down East is a pretty good mystery with a cast of characters that I'd enjoy seeing more of. Give Jesse a shot.
Disclaimer: I received this book from the author in exchange for my honest opinion -- which influenced me not one whit, but I do appreciate it. I'm sorry that I filed it under "December Reads" and not "October Reads" like I'd said I would.
September 11, 2016
Title – Dead Down East
Author – Carl Schmidt
Genre – Mystery, Humor
Amazon Pages 241
Rating 5 stars out of 5 Posted 9/9/2016
Jesse Thorp is a part time detective who also plays in a band with friends.
Cynthia Dumais was having an affair with the governor of Maine when she witnessed his murder.
Agnele is Jesse's attorney girlfriend.
The plot is soft core, interesting and humorous.
Jesse is a laid back New Englander who resists carrying Rhonda, his handgun, unless a dire need is perceived. Cynthia convinces Jesse that she was not involved in the Governor's death and he hides her in his home while the police and the murderers search for her.
The Governor and his wife were estranged and he had been involved in at least seven other affairs in the past five years, so Jesse had plenty to investigate.
Of course, there are side plots to hamper Jesse's investigation and threaten his safety.
Cynthia's ex-husband is a Maine State Police Trooper assigned to the Governor's security detail. He is arrested when it is determined that his gun was the murder weapon.
Finally, Jesse uncovers the reason behind the murder and forms an ingenious plot with a cast of his friends to procure evidence to expose the members of the deadly conspiracy.
Jesse and Angele are frequently romping in the bedroom, but the descriptions are vague at best. There are no graphic sexual scenes or references.
The editing and sentence structure is professional grade. Character development is thorough and the writing style is clear and concise.
On the down side: Internal thoughts should be in italics not quotation marks like dialog.
Supposedly the phone number and address of the Governor's parents was found on Wikipedia. I use Wikipedia often and have never seen any personal info of this type given. I can't imagine the site would provide this.
I enjoyed this story and recommend it for readers of soft core crime plots.
This review was provided in exchange for a free book.
Vigilant Reader Book Reviews.
Author – Carl Schmidt
Genre – Mystery, Humor
Amazon Pages 241
Rating 5 stars out of 5 Posted 9/9/2016
Jesse Thorp is a part time detective who also plays in a band with friends.
Cynthia Dumais was having an affair with the governor of Maine when she witnessed his murder.
Agnele is Jesse's attorney girlfriend.
The plot is soft core, interesting and humorous.
Jesse is a laid back New Englander who resists carrying Rhonda, his handgun, unless a dire need is perceived. Cynthia convinces Jesse that she was not involved in the Governor's death and he hides her in his home while the police and the murderers search for her.
The Governor and his wife were estranged and he had been involved in at least seven other affairs in the past five years, so Jesse had plenty to investigate.
Of course, there are side plots to hamper Jesse's investigation and threaten his safety.
Cynthia's ex-husband is a Maine State Police Trooper assigned to the Governor's security detail. He is arrested when it is determined that his gun was the murder weapon.
Finally, Jesse uncovers the reason behind the murder and forms an ingenious plot with a cast of his friends to procure evidence to expose the members of the deadly conspiracy.
Jesse and Angele are frequently romping in the bedroom, but the descriptions are vague at best. There are no graphic sexual scenes or references.
The editing and sentence structure is professional grade. Character development is thorough and the writing style is clear and concise.
On the down side: Internal thoughts should be in italics not quotation marks like dialog.
Supposedly the phone number and address of the Governor's parents was found on Wikipedia. I use Wikipedia often and have never seen any personal info of this type given. I can't imagine the site would provide this.
I enjoyed this story and recommend it for readers of soft core crime plots.
This review was provided in exchange for a free book.
Vigilant Reader Book Reviews.
August 23, 2016
Dead Down East by Carl Schmidt is a mystery readers everywhere won't be able to get enough of...especially of the main character, Jesse Thorpe. I am hoping there's going to be more books out soon. Otherwise, I will go bat crazy trying to come up with new adventures this new detective will engage. Absolutely, the most charming, hilarious, and intriguing detective noir that I have read. This is a new series, I would recommend to all.
Carl Schmidt's writing is that of a seasoned writer. Words that make me want to dig further and solve the case as well as find out more about Jesse Thorpe. Dead Down East holds murder, humor, and a mystery unlike any other. The danger is real. Plus, there are some steamy scenes. The characters will blow away readers' minds. Jesse Thorpe goes on a mission to rescue a woman who is in danger. She happens to be in the same area that someone else was recently assassinated. Jesse Thorpe goes about finding the murdering weapon, theft, has the DNA of an accomplice for the murder. If the accomplice can be found and interrogated the murder might just be within reach...but it all depends on if, when, and how. Every page is filled with action of some kind. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel.
Carl Schmidt's writing is that of a seasoned writer. Words that make me want to dig further and solve the case as well as find out more about Jesse Thorpe. Dead Down East holds murder, humor, and a mystery unlike any other. The danger is real. Plus, there are some steamy scenes. The characters will blow away readers' minds. Jesse Thorpe goes on a mission to rescue a woman who is in danger. She happens to be in the same area that someone else was recently assassinated. Jesse Thorpe goes about finding the murdering weapon, theft, has the DNA of an accomplice for the murder. If the accomplice can be found and interrogated the murder might just be within reach...but it all depends on if, when, and how. Every page is filled with action of some kind. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel.
September 19, 2016
Dead Down East” by Carl Schmidt is the first book in the “Jesse Thorpe Mystery” series. When part-time musician, part-carpenter and part-time detective, Jesse Thorpe receives a phone call from former client Cynthia Dumais, his vacation is cut short. Ms Dumais has witnessed the murder of the Governor, with whom she’s been having a illicit affair, and is seeking protection and counsel. Jesse must safeguard his client and solve the murder, all the while balancing his relationships with the band, Ms Dumais, his girlfriend Angele, and his handgun Rhonda. The characters are well developed and believable and the story flows easily. It is wonderfully written and endlessly entertaining. It’s worth reading just for the magical description of the fishing trip on the lake in the first chapter. I thoroughly recommend “Dead Down East”.
September 9, 2017
I needed a story that would take my mind off a grim and dark tale I had just read and reviewed. Thankfully, this story helped me do just that.
Sometimes we come across characters who are totally out of luck and are so lovable that you feel like empathising with them throughout. The protagonist of this story, a private investigator, is just that. The plot revolves around an affable character and his tryst with the solving of a crime case. For the whats you need to read the story.
The writing is amazing. Carl has added loads of humour through one-liners and at the same time, he has retained the flavour of suspense throughout. There were some 'wow' moments and it was worth a five star but for its ending. Notwithstanding that, the manner in which the story has been narrated is quiet gripping. What is more interesting is the fact that throughout the narration there have been no jerks. The imageries are in required quantities. This book also makes for a convenient read since it is fast paced and not too lengthy.
The protagonist is definitely lovable. Along with him, there are a few other characters who support him throughout the story. Besides them, there are many other characters and I have a bit of an issue with them because their presence ended up making me feel that the story is a fiction. They make it difficult to draw real life conclusions.
To sum up, the story is quirky, a quick read and an out and out fun whodunit story. The narration is superb and antics of the protagonist is heart touching. A must read for those who want a crime story that is not run-of-the-mill kind.
P.S - Thank you Carl for a quirky story and for lightening my mood with your writings. This review is my honest opinion after reading the story.
Sometimes we come across characters who are totally out of luck and are so lovable that you feel like empathising with them throughout. The protagonist of this story, a private investigator, is just that. The plot revolves around an affable character and his tryst with the solving of a crime case. For the whats you need to read the story.
The writing is amazing. Carl has added loads of humour through one-liners and at the same time, he has retained the flavour of suspense throughout. There were some 'wow' moments and it was worth a five star but for its ending. Notwithstanding that, the manner in which the story has been narrated is quiet gripping. What is more interesting is the fact that throughout the narration there have been no jerks. The imageries are in required quantities. This book also makes for a convenient read since it is fast paced and not too lengthy.
The protagonist is definitely lovable. Along with him, there are a few other characters who support him throughout the story. Besides them, there are many other characters and I have a bit of an issue with them because their presence ended up making me feel that the story is a fiction. They make it difficult to draw real life conclusions.
To sum up, the story is quirky, a quick read and an out and out fun whodunit story. The narration is superb and antics of the protagonist is heart touching. A must read for those who want a crime story that is not run-of-the-mill kind.
P.S - Thank you Carl for a quirky story and for lightening my mood with your writings. This review is my honest opinion after reading the story.
November 21, 2016
I was a bit leery when I started reading, concerned that it would be filled with fishing scenes, (one thing I really do not enjoy doing), but after the opening, which was written well and gave some thoughts to ponder upon, I delved into a world of politics filled with lots of secrets and suspects.
To me it seemed like Schmidt put a lot of himself into this book, from the fishing to the band, which is something I always enjoy. After reading a book like this, I want to take the writer out for drinks to see just how much of their life corresponds with the book.
The dialogue flowed really well between the characters, and his descriptions of the people and various spots in Maine, made it very easy to visualize what you were reading. The mystery itself was done wonderfully with lots of suspects, and it had me guessing until the end.
There are two things that had me reminding myself that it’s a piece of fiction, and the author can write however they want. The biggest one was where Jesse borrows a police officer’s uniform, to impersonate an officer, and the office knew about it. It’s just really hard for me to accept that, even if it was so they could catch the killer.
And the other, and this is more tongue in cheek, is having a Sauvignon Blanc with lasagna. I just can’t picture it pairing well, but that just means I’ll need to try it sometime.
To me it seemed like Schmidt put a lot of himself into this book, from the fishing to the band, which is something I always enjoy. After reading a book like this, I want to take the writer out for drinks to see just how much of their life corresponds with the book.
The dialogue flowed really well between the characters, and his descriptions of the people and various spots in Maine, made it very easy to visualize what you were reading. The mystery itself was done wonderfully with lots of suspects, and it had me guessing until the end.
There are two things that had me reminding myself that it’s a piece of fiction, and the author can write however they want. The biggest one was where Jesse borrows a police officer’s uniform, to impersonate an officer, and the office knew about it. It’s just really hard for me to accept that, even if it was so they could catch the killer.
And the other, and this is more tongue in cheek, is having a Sauvignon Blanc with lasagna. I just can’t picture it pairing well, but that just means I’ll need to try it sometime.
October 4, 2017
Jesse Thorpe is a musician, a carpenter and a private investigator. For the first 6 years of having a PI license he has had maybe 6 cases. While on a fishing trip in his native Maine he learns that William Lavoilette, the Governor of Maine has been murdered. Everyone is shocked as the governor was a well-like politican.
Suddenly, a former client calls him to come and protect her, she will explain the details when he sees her. He is to pick her up from the island where the Governor was assassinated.
A little slow to start but once it began it was a fun read.
Suddenly, a former client calls him to come and protect her, she will explain the details when he sees her. He is to pick her up from the island where the Governor was assassinated.
A little slow to start but once it began it was a fun read.
February 25, 2026
The pacing is steady yet intense, allowing the mystery to unfold naturally while keeping readers hooked. Twists are delivered with precision, and just when you think you have the answers, the story shifts, deepening the suspense.
What truly stands out is how Dead Down East balances classic mystery elements with emotional resonance. It’s not just about who committed the crime it’s about the ripple effects, the hidden pain, and the truths people try to bury.
What truly stands out is how Dead Down East balances classic mystery elements with emotional resonance. It’s not just about who committed the crime it’s about the ripple effects, the hidden pain, and the truths people try to bury.
May 10, 2017
I really enjoyed this book, Dead Down East.
I thought in my mind that it was going to be like Jessica Fletcher meets Sam Spade. However, it was not and I was completely surprised. I love the story, the mystery, the characters and their witty banter.
Our main character is Jesse Thorpe. Jesse is many things. He is a carpenter, a bass player in a local band, a fly fisherman, and a private investigator. He seems to stay busy. Jesse has lots of friends and a likable personality. Jesse is someone I would be friends with.
Jesse’s fishing vacation is cut short by a plea for help from Cynthia Dumais. Cynthia needs Jesse to pick her up and locate who killed the Governor of Maine, William Lavoilette. Jesse agrees to do this task, putting himself in physical and professional danger. Cynthia is nice enough. She is a real estate agent. However, Jesse ends up with three clients who all want the same thing, him to find who murdered the Governor. Jesse must go through the list of the Governor’s mistresses. There had to be a cliché, why not use the politician? I actually thought this was a great resource to use.
My favorite character though was Angele Boucher. I loved her wit, confidence, her ability to go with the punches. She is extremely verbal about her needs, wants and wishes. She works for a law firm and has a professional side, yet she still cracks jokes and shows her feminine side. She and Jesse have a fun, wonderful relationship.
I believe this will become one of my top mystery series. I loved the noir references and the old school sayings. The portrayal of Maine and its personalities. I loved the femme de fatale references and the way the truth came out. Jesse and his gang of friends are smart and brave. I loved the red herrings, especially the way his friends made bets on who the murderer was.
My rating for this book is 4 stars.
If you love good honest mysteries, check out this series: Jesse Thorpe Mysteries by Carl Schmidt. The second book is A Priestly Affair is now available.
If you would like to see other reviews like this one, check out BaronessBookTrove.com.
This book was given to the Baroness Book Trove for an honest review.
I thought in my mind that it was going to be like Jessica Fletcher meets Sam Spade. However, it was not and I was completely surprised. I love the story, the mystery, the characters and their witty banter.
Our main character is Jesse Thorpe. Jesse is many things. He is a carpenter, a bass player in a local band, a fly fisherman, and a private investigator. He seems to stay busy. Jesse has lots of friends and a likable personality. Jesse is someone I would be friends with.
Jesse’s fishing vacation is cut short by a plea for help from Cynthia Dumais. Cynthia needs Jesse to pick her up and locate who killed the Governor of Maine, William Lavoilette. Jesse agrees to do this task, putting himself in physical and professional danger. Cynthia is nice enough. She is a real estate agent. However, Jesse ends up with three clients who all want the same thing, him to find who murdered the Governor. Jesse must go through the list of the Governor’s mistresses. There had to be a cliché, why not use the politician? I actually thought this was a great resource to use.
My favorite character though was Angele Boucher. I loved her wit, confidence, her ability to go with the punches. She is extremely verbal about her needs, wants and wishes. She works for a law firm and has a professional side, yet she still cracks jokes and shows her feminine side. She and Jesse have a fun, wonderful relationship.
I believe this will become one of my top mystery series. I loved the noir references and the old school sayings. The portrayal of Maine and its personalities. I loved the femme de fatale references and the way the truth came out. Jesse and his gang of friends are smart and brave. I loved the red herrings, especially the way his friends made bets on who the murderer was.
My rating for this book is 4 stars.
If you love good honest mysteries, check out this series: Jesse Thorpe Mysteries by Carl Schmidt. The second book is A Priestly Affair is now available.
If you would like to see other reviews like this one, check out BaronessBookTrove.com.
This book was given to the Baroness Book Trove for an honest review.
Read
April 26, 2020Murder investigation
Mr Thorpe and friends investigates the death of the Governor of Maine, a rather diverse and interests of characters help out
Mr Thorpe and friends investigates the death of the Governor of Maine, a rather diverse and interests of characters help out
December 28, 2023
Excellent story with interesting characters. This is the third Jesse Thorpe story I've read and have enjoyed all of them. Hard-boiled detectives are definitely my cup of whiskey.
December 24, 2025
Bad Read
Don’t waste your time reading this. The author is obviously an intelligent linguist, but just doesn’t have the first clue how to write a story.
Don’t waste your time reading this. The author is obviously an intelligent linguist, but just doesn’t have the first clue how to write a story.
December 26, 2025
What I loved most was the balance: thoughtful reflection, dry humor, and genuine suspense. Nothing feels rushed or forced.
December 26, 2025
The opening chapters are beautifully written. Quiet moments, sharp dialogue, and subtle humor create a strong foundation for the mystery that follows.
December 26, 2025
There’s an old-school charm to this story, paired with modern sensibility. A very satisfying combination.
December 29, 2025
A thoughtful, atmospheric read that feels both intelligent and approachable. I’m already curious about the rest of the series.
December 30, 2025
Well-written, engaging, and quietly compelling. A mystery that stays with you even after you close the book.
December 30, 2025
Strong character work, vivid setting, and a quietly gripping plot. Everything feels purposeful.
December 31, 2025
This isn’t a loud thriller, it’s a confident, well-paced story that lets tension build naturally. The prose alone makes it worth reading.
January 2, 2026
The narrator’s voice is distinctive without being overbearing. Calm, reflective, and sharp when it needs to be.
January 2, 2026
A surprisingly warm mystery. Even when things turn dark, there’s a humanity running through the pages that keeps you grounded.
January 2, 2026
The setting is used brilliantly, not just as scenery, but as part of the story’s soul. You can feel the lake, the fog, and the quiet tension.
November 29, 2016
I'm not going to lie, I really did not want to read this book. Mostly because I thought it was going to be about fishing and no thanks. Thankfully, it wasn't about fishing. It had fishing in it but it didn't feel like I was reading about a man fishing. It was a pretty good whodunit that I didn't see coming.
Carl Schmidt did a good job with describing scenes in a way that made me feel like I was in Maine. I've always wanted to visit Maine and now I feel like I have. I thought the dialogue between all of the characters flowed easily. There wasn't too much dialogue or descriptions, there was a perfect amount that didn't take away from the story.
I was wrong about whodunit but that's not surprising because I'm usually wrong about that. I never guess right.
Carl Schmidt did a good job with describing scenes in a way that made me feel like I was in Maine. I've always wanted to visit Maine and now I feel like I have. I thought the dialogue between all of the characters flowed easily. There wasn't too much dialogue or descriptions, there was a perfect amount that didn't take away from the story.
I was wrong about whodunit but that's not surprising because I'm usually wrong about that. I never guess right.
October 20, 2016
In Dead Down East we are introduced to several characters, the main being, Jesse Thorpe. It was a well paced story and I enjoyed the plot line, however, I found the characters had to relate to. It may have been how the dialogue was presented (in large chunks) and how we were never really given a lot of information on the secondary characters to make a connection. Even through that, I was pleasantly surprised that I was wrong on 'whodunit' and would recommend this to other mystery readers.
September 29, 2016
Review coming soon
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews