"'So that's it,' Charlie says. 'That's all you've got. You and my dad knew more about this than anyone, right? Don't you have more notes, an idea, some theory? Anything?'
Dr. Riley taps out his pipe.
'Children,' he says, and somehow, it actually sounds paternal rather than patronizing, 'you might want to start adjusting yourselves to the idea that the rest of your lives will be spent in Hell.'
Funny. I'd been thinking the same thing."
Five years ago, Abby Booth's mother went missing. Her mom was a cohost of a paranormal ghost-hunting reality TV show and had been filming a new season in a so-called haunted cave within the Arizona desert. She and her crew never made it out. Rescue teams had no idea where they went. Presumed dead, the ghost-hunting crew became one of the biggest mysteries to television, and their own families.
What truly happened? Did they get lost? Did they fall to their deaths in the dark? Did the cave collapse on them? Or did something else happen, despite the television cohosts' original drive to disprove these paranormal myths?
These questions nag at Abby. Her father had fallen into a deep depression. The lack of closure, not knowing what truly happened, has left him practically immobile. Abby has had enough. Wanting to move on from taking care of both herself and her father, Abby goes through her mom's belongings to throw away stuff that will never be used again. But what Abby discovers tucked away in her mother's things changes everything.
Dr. Prinn, her mom's cohost, has scribbled all over his own published book of theories with new, insane ideas. Written in bold on the cover is a disturbing word:
Wrong.
Abby contacts Charlie Prinn, the cohosts' son, and invites him on a spontaneous trip out to the cave. Maybe they can solve the mysteries that nobody else could. Once they have closure on what happened to their parents, they can finally move on with their lives.
But what they find stumps all of them, even their religious friend, Alex, even Charlie's scientific genius girlfriend, Selby.
What they find might just be Hell itself, and now it has broken free and destroyed the world they once knew.
"'Okay. Cool. If you have any questions, give me a call.'
'Just one. What do you think happened?'
Charlie hesitated. 'Honestly, I don't have an answer for that. I just know I'm going to find out.'"
AAAH! I want to SCREAM, this book was so insanely good.
The first page had me hooked. Caves? Oh hell yes. The ultimate darkness element and panic had me hooked from the start—total darkness making people go insane is a topic that isn't talked about enough. I thought at first that this would be a contemporary adventure story. But oh, was I wrong.
This story has it all. Science and physics. Biblical references. Paranormal features. Magic. The inexplicable. There is so much that I do not understand, but maybe I don't need to. Even the smartest of characters had their stubborn beliefs shattered by what they went through.
The best part of this book? THE PACING. Oh my god, the way each chapter bounced between timelines gave us the perfect amount of suspense two ways. Reveals happened just at the right moment—I never felt lost. And the way it created a full-circle effect was so satisfying.
These characters were so well fleshed-out. It was honestly impressive. I loved the depth to each person—Abby, Charlie, Selby, Alex, Abby's dad, Mrs. Brower, etc. Abby's father's depression was depicted so well and added to the story in surprising ways. I loved that I hated Selby. Her bitchiness grew on me, and I actually liked her by the end. I enjoyed how we get both sides of Abby and Charlie, before and after Hell. Trauma aged them significantly, and the narrative transformed with them.
I usually prefer standalones, but this story needs a sequel. It needs it. It was set up so beautifully, but left us with so many questions. There is so much more I need to know. Obviously, what happens next, but also why did this happen like this. What is the explanation? Will they be able to stop Hell, or will they learn to survive through it? We got a taste for what Hell is like—pawns of Hell, they called it—but will Abby, Charlie, and Selby actually face it again? And what about the tension between Abby and Charlie? Selby and Abby are on good terms, but there is definitely some friction there regarding Charlie. I usually love platonic stories that don't necessarily have to go further, but this book was just asking for it (on the contrary, I do highly respect that there was almost no romance, considering all of the adrenaline/trauma/grief each character had been through. Very realistic, so I applaud that.)
Yes, this story ended, but I need closure. A whole second book worth of closure. Please.
Now I have all of this pent-up energy accumulated while reading this, and I don't know what to do about it. That is a great thing as much as it is bad.
"'I think most of it was true. The devil doesn't need to tell lots of big lies. One small one is probably enough. We'll just have to figure out which one that is.'
'You believe in the devil now?' Charlie asks.
I eyed him cautiously.
'Don't you?'"