I don’t know who came up with the title for this book, whether it was the author, her agent, or the publisher, but it was a brilliant choice. I never read books on etiquette and manners, but this one stopped me in my tracks based on the title alone, and since I was looking for something light to read after an excursion into the phenomenology of consciousness, this looked like it would be fun. It was fun, and the author’s humorous approach gives the book a light, breezy feeling, while providing genuinely useful information on how to navigate the rough spots in our dealings with other people.
There are chapters on handling social situations such as parties, on communicating with others clearly, using the telephone, the internet, dating, how to apologize, and more. The basic approach to criticism is to avoid direct aggression unless it is your intention to shame someone publicly, when their bad behavior does not respond to polite suggestions. In most cases you can avoid antagonizing them by playing dumb. Both you and your neighbor know perfectly well that their yappy little fleabag barks all night, but you can avoid making the owner defensive by starting off with something like, “You might not be aware of this, but….” Also, you can pad your account with some fictional details which can evoke their sympathy, since they are more likely to comply if they are sympathetic toward you. So, “You might not be aware of this, but your darling little Chewy sometimes barks all night. My daughter has a medical condition that makes her a very light sleeper, and every time she gets woken up it takes her forever to get back to sleep. Could you perhaps bring your cuddly little angel inside at night?” You can still call them inconsiderate jerks, but use your quiet voice.
The chapters on what to say during a police stop, and how to comfort a friend with a serious illness are both excellent. They made me reflect on how I would handle such situations, and how I could do a better job. The chapter on dealing with noisy and inconsiderate neighbors has some very good suggestions. Sometimes a little communal shaming can work wonders, like taping pictures in public places showing inconsiderate behavior. One time, one of my neighbors missed the recycling pickup, and just dumped her boxes and bottles into other people’s bins. Unfortunately for her, some of those boxes had her address on them, and she came back from work that evening to find them piled on her doorstep with a note that explained to passers-by what an inconsiderate jerk she was.
As I was reading there was one thing that struck me as fairly odd. Books are generally written over long periods of time, and it is understandable that the author might forget that she had already discussed something when writing about it in a different chapter. But isn’t that what editors are for? For instance, there is evidence from evolutionary psychology that humans have evolved a fine-tuned ability to keep track of who we owe favors to and who is cheating the system. It is called moralistic aggression, and it sheds some light on why we can get enraged over simple, non-threatening acts of rudeness. However, the author discusses it – not just mentions it, but explains it – four separate times in different chapters. It’s hard to understand how that didn’t get flagged as the book went through pre-production.
Amy Alkon gives advice for a living, and has a website where she answers people’s questions. Her writing style is entertaining, and she gives good advice at a time when consideration for others seems to be on the decline. I thought this book would give me a few laughs, and it did, but it also provided some good, solid advice for how to deal with all those other half-mad hairless apes called humans, whose technology has evolved faster than their emotional and psychological skills.