I liked this book far more than I had anticipated, perhaps because I was a bit misled by the title. “Mind-blowing ideas in neuroscience” prepared me for a bit more hyperbole, embellished speculations, and ‘Neil deGrasse Tyson-esque comparisons’ along the lines of “There are enough axons in your brain to connect the dots of stars in the Milky Way galaxy..twice!”
Happily, this bit of the title is far from representative of the thorough information provided throughout the book, information of both a historical and scientific nature, and very little of which goes for the ‘shock and awe factor’ that one would expect when it comes to ‘mind-blowing ideas’. Instead, the chapters were conveniently divided into sections focused on brain structure, function, cognition, consciousness, and much more, all the while delivering the material in a didactic yet digestible format.
The one section I intuitively disagreed with was Seth’s section on the hard problem of consciousness, namely that he thinks the analogy of science’s debate around vitalism and the origins of life is akin to the issue we face whilst studying consciousness today. Optimism is indeed our best bet to continue progress on the ‘easy problems’, but I just don’t think the hard problem is surmountable without changing some of our fundamental assumptions to bridge the categorical disjunction we face. However, I wasn’t surprised to see his view laid out here, as his TedTalk and conversations with podcasters usually discuss it in the same manner. Granted, this is just my amateur theory of mind opinion on the topic, and said section is merely one of 50 great passages in the book, passages for which all eight contributing authors did a fantastic job explaining.
This book can be read from start to finish, or easily referenced per topic depending on the section of interest. A great book for anyone looking to get an overview of neuroscience, and a mandatory read for those who study/take the topic seriously in their everyday lives!
Also, there was at least one mind-blowing fact that warrants mention. Schizophrenic people can tickle themselves!