What do you think?
Rate this book
Farthingale #1
My Fair Lily
Ewan Cameron, estranged grandson of the Duke of Lotheil, is in London because of a deathbed promise made to his father and has no intention of staying beyond his three month obligation. Nothing can tempt him to remain, not even Lily, the beautiful bluestocking determined not only to restore relations between him and his grandfather, but to turn Ewan into a proper gentleman. Ewan, proud of his Scottish heritage, refuses to admit that Lily, a blue-eyed, English girl, has claimed his heart. It doesn’t matter that his big lump of a sheepdog is madly in love with her. Nor is it significant that Ewan can always tell Lily apart from her identical twin sister. Always.
Lily Farthingale, the scholarly twin, dreams of becoming the first female member of the Royal Society. She grabs at the chance when the elderly Duke of Lotheil approaches her with a proposition - he’ll admit her into the Royal Society, if she helps him to establish a relation with his estranged grandson, Ewan Cameron, a very rough-around-the-edges Scotsman who hates everything English. Between shootings, explosions, and Lily’s abduction, Ewan ends up falling in love with Lily in this Pygmalion-inspired story.
Lily Farthingale, the scholarly twin, dreams of becoming the first female member of the Royal Society. She grabs at the chance when the elderly Duke of Lotheil approaches her with a proposition - he’ll admit her into the Royal Society, if she helps him to establish a relation with his estranged grandson, Ewan Cameron, a very rough-around-the-edges Scotsman who hates everything English. Between shootings, explosions, and Lily’s abduction, Ewan ends up falling in love with Lily in this Pygmalion-inspired story.
292 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 13, 2014
1515 people are currently reading
1782 people want to read
About the author
Meara Platt
119 books884 followersMeara Platt is happily married to her Russell Crowe look-alike husband, and they have two terrific children. She lives in one of the many great towns on Long Island, New York, and loves it, except for the traffic. She has traveled extensively, occasionally lectures and finds time to write. Her favorite place in all the world is England’s Lake District, which may not come as a surprise since many of her stories are set in that idyllic landscape, including her Romance Writers of America Golden Heart award winning story.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 317 reviews
March 14, 2016
It is the first time that I have been introduced to Meara Platt work and, alas!, I cannot say 'Well met.' We will most definitely NOT be acquainted. I got the Farthingale series on sale and not only will I not be reading beyond the first book, I don't intend to keep them in my house. They take up too much precious space for what they are worth.
I consider myself a connoisseur of historical romance and Regency in particular. Not because I'm fussy, but because I read tons of them and as long as they are readable, I'm happy. Mind you, historical romance is not a genre for artists (although you find those too!), it is a genre for craftswomen skilful enough to tell in yet another enticing way the same story that has been told gazillions times over since Elizabeth Bennet met Mr. Darcy (it is a truth universally acknowledged).
Writing a good regency is generic; it is like cooking a dish, you mix the usual ingredients (a rake here, a spirited lady there, forced marriage, unsuspected inheritance, etc.) and then you add your own unique flavour which usually comes from the writing style, and voila! The book is ready. As long as you kind of stick to the historical setting, and your writing style is passable (alternatively, your editor is top notch) nothing could go wrong.
And yet, in case of My Fair Lily everything possible that could go wrong went even worse. The main two protagonists being rather caricatures of the usual figures (a bluestocking and a Highlander); tension between them precarious to the point of grotesque; plot - a non-plot beyond predictable, secondary characters in theory interesting, in writing (and reading) lacking authenticity, and so on and so forth.
You want to read a regency featuring a funny dog? Read The Viscount Who Loved Me (or the rest of the Bridgerton series, you will also have a loving, slightly crazy family as a bonus). You want something funny? Read Sarah MacLean. You want something saucy? Read The Cynster by Stephanie Laurens. You'd die for a bluestocking/feminist? I'd recommend: The Notorious Rake, The Devil's Delilah, Mistress, Devil's Cub, or The Ideal Bride.
Do yourself a favour, do not Platt yourself.
I consider myself a connoisseur of historical romance and Regency in particular. Not because I'm fussy, but because I read tons of them and as long as they are readable, I'm happy. Mind you, historical romance is not a genre for artists (although you find those too!), it is a genre for craftswomen skilful enough to tell in yet another enticing way the same story that has been told gazillions times over since Elizabeth Bennet met Mr. Darcy (it is a truth universally acknowledged).
Writing a good regency is generic; it is like cooking a dish, you mix the usual ingredients (a rake here, a spirited lady there, forced marriage, unsuspected inheritance, etc.) and then you add your own unique flavour which usually comes from the writing style, and voila! The book is ready. As long as you kind of stick to the historical setting, and your writing style is passable (alternatively, your editor is top notch) nothing could go wrong.
And yet, in case of My Fair Lily everything possible that could go wrong went even worse. The main two protagonists being rather caricatures of the usual figures (a bluestocking and a Highlander); tension between them precarious to the point of grotesque; plot - a non-plot beyond predictable, secondary characters in theory interesting, in writing (and reading) lacking authenticity, and so on and so forth.
You want to read a regency featuring a funny dog? Read The Viscount Who Loved Me (or the rest of the Bridgerton series, you will also have a loving, slightly crazy family as a bonus). You want something funny? Read Sarah MacLean. You want something saucy? Read The Cynster by Stephanie Laurens. You'd die for a bluestocking/feminist? I'd recommend: The Notorious Rake, The Devil's Delilah, Mistress, Devil's Cub, or The Ideal Bride.
Do yourself a favour, do not Platt yourself.
January 27, 2016
DISAPPOINTING AND INACCURATE!!
My Fair Lily starts out slow an a bit boring. But my major problem with the story is the inaccurate way it is written. I know its fiction but please the author should have stayed with some semblance of historical facts. To make the reader feel like they are in the Regency era. I read Historical Romance fiction becasue I like this period of time from the past. The story is about Ewan and his sister Meggie fulfilling there fathers dying wish to leave Scotland for 3 moths and live with the Grandfather The Duke of Lotheil in London. The Duke has disowned Ewan father and who was the Dukes eldest son. Now he has to choose which grandson will he given his the Title of Duke of Lotheil. All I can say is this is all wrong. Its called "Primogeniture" Ewan father is the eldest and Ewan is the eldest Grandson. He gets the title!! This shouldn't have been an issue in the story. There is another younger cousin Desmond who in the end of the story Ewan decides to let him take the title of the Duke of Lotheil when the grandfather dies. NO NO NO its not done that way. They can't just decided who the title passes to. I know I am on a rant but this just ruined the whole story for me. What fool would what to be a mere Laird when he could be a Duke and help his Scottish people more by having a seat in Parliament. The Highlanders needed that help. So I really didn't like the ending. The excuse was Ewan wanted to return to Scotland, well you idiot you can still run the Dukedom from Scotland.LOL This was just badly done.
To the other part of the story Lily Farthingdale, is interested in become a member of the Royal Society. Lily loves science and writing papers of her research but the Royal Society won't except anything from her. Gavin's grandfather the Duke of Lotheil heads up the Royal Society. Gavin and Lily meet when Jasper his dog runs into to her knocking her over into a muddle of mud. Jasper is always knocking Lily over into to something or another through out the story. I did like Jasper. Dogs and Children make for great characters in stories. This is how the friendship to love relationship starts between Gavin and Lily. There is very little romance between the couple because they are always getting in and out of one scrap after another. By the end of the story Gavin has been stabbed once and shot twice. Lily had been kidnapped and drugged. So you see readers there was no time for romance and courting in this story. I just really didn't like My Fair Lily, so 2 stars, becasue I didn't hate it. I would hope Meara Platt will research a little about this period of time and just look up the word Primogeniture. Its not easy at all to get out of a title and I don't think you can just give your title too whom every you wish.
My Fair Lily starts out slow an a bit boring. But my major problem with the story is the inaccurate way it is written. I know its fiction but please the author should have stayed with some semblance of historical facts. To make the reader feel like they are in the Regency era. I read Historical Romance fiction becasue I like this period of time from the past. The story is about Ewan and his sister Meggie fulfilling there fathers dying wish to leave Scotland for 3 moths and live with the Grandfather The Duke of Lotheil in London. The Duke has disowned Ewan father and who was the Dukes eldest son. Now he has to choose which grandson will he given his the Title of Duke of Lotheil. All I can say is this is all wrong. Its called "Primogeniture" Ewan father is the eldest and Ewan is the eldest Grandson. He gets the title!! This shouldn't have been an issue in the story. There is another younger cousin Desmond who in the end of the story Ewan decides to let him take the title of the Duke of Lotheil when the grandfather dies. NO NO NO its not done that way. They can't just decided who the title passes to. I know I am on a rant but this just ruined the whole story for me. What fool would what to be a mere Laird when he could be a Duke and help his Scottish people more by having a seat in Parliament. The Highlanders needed that help. So I really didn't like the ending. The excuse was Ewan wanted to return to Scotland, well you idiot you can still run the Dukedom from Scotland.LOL This was just badly done.
To the other part of the story Lily Farthingdale, is interested in become a member of the Royal Society. Lily loves science and writing papers of her research but the Royal Society won't except anything from her. Gavin's grandfather the Duke of Lotheil heads up the Royal Society. Gavin and Lily meet when Jasper his dog runs into to her knocking her over into a muddle of mud. Jasper is always knocking Lily over into to something or another through out the story. I did like Jasper. Dogs and Children make for great characters in stories. This is how the friendship to love relationship starts between Gavin and Lily. There is very little romance between the couple because they are always getting in and out of one scrap after another. By the end of the story Gavin has been stabbed once and shot twice. Lily had been kidnapped and drugged. So you see readers there was no time for romance and courting in this story. I just really didn't like My Fair Lily, so 2 stars, becasue I didn't hate it. I would hope Meara Platt will research a little about this period of time and just look up the word Primogeniture. Its not easy at all to get out of a title and I don't think you can just give your title too whom every you wish.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 5, 2019
DNF at 53%. Man, I'm on a roll these days.
I thought the prospect of having a dog in this book would be charming. Instead, it was an undertrained and undisciplined dog whose only personality feature is a propensity towards destruction.
The humans weren't much better. Lots of pining and whining. No real personalities.
I thought the prospect of having a dog in this book would be charming. Instead, it was an undertrained and undisciplined dog whose only personality feature is a propensity towards destruction.
The humans weren't much better. Lots of pining and whining. No real personalities.
March 30, 2018
Update: Chapter one ,and already I am thinking of dnfing. A woman gets knocked to the ground by a dog. And she doesn’t seem at all injured. Then the dogs owner doesn’t seem to know here and then all of a sudden her tells her that her eyes are different to her twin sisters. It doesn’t make sense or else I am missing something.
2% - the owner of the dog says 'Lass, may I ask your name?' SO he doesn't know who she is
Three pages on I read this; 'Your eyes are a more vivid blue than your sister's, and your features softer, like the soft coat on a new born lamb.'
So he DOES know her! That made no sense at all to me. Neither did the 'soft coat of a new-born lamb' reference to her features. You cannot compare texture to facial features ;) (and the new lambs I have touched have pretty hardy tough fleece)
At this point I dnf'd.
2% - the owner of the dog says 'Lass, may I ask your name?' SO he doesn't know who she is
Three pages on I read this; 'Your eyes are a more vivid blue than your sister's, and your features softer, like the soft coat on a new born lamb.'
So he DOES know her! That made no sense at all to me. Neither did the 'soft coat of a new-born lamb' reference to her features. You cannot compare texture to facial features ;) (and the new lambs I have touched have pretty hardy tough fleece)
At this point I dnf'd.
November 13, 2014
Between this and To Tempt an Earl, I've had a fairly good reading week. This book is funny, engaging, has likable characters, a semi-interesting plot, and good romance. The only drawback is that it sometimes seems like it's trying too hard to be funny...and the ending is a bit too Disney perfect with everyone changing for the better and getting along. Schmaltzy. But since you're invested by that point, it can be overlooked.
June 4, 2015
I understood what the author was trying to do, but I don’t think the story fully accomplished it.
Lily Farthingale is a self-taught scholar who’s determined to become the first female member of The Royal Society. Her biggest, but not only obstacle, is Ewan Cameron’s stubborn grandfather, whom he promised his dying father he’d try to develop a better relationship with. Ewan, as well as his loyal overgrown slobbering canine, Jasper, are both immediately taken by the fiery young Londoner, however, his plan is to stay the three months he promised and then head back to his homeland, Scotland. While preoccupied with those who openly disagree with her entry into the prestigious club, Lily soon learns that her enemies are not confined behind the club’s walls.
Although there are some likable and colorful characters, I found the development of some to be insufficient, which cripples the climax and makes the plot seem forced. I found the dialogue the be lacking at times, and the changes in some of the behavior to be unexplained, and thus, unbelievable.
The premise was actually good, just not developed in a way to make me really appreciate the story.
Lily Farthingale is a self-taught scholar who’s determined to become the first female member of The Royal Society. Her biggest, but not only obstacle, is Ewan Cameron’s stubborn grandfather, whom he promised his dying father he’d try to develop a better relationship with. Ewan, as well as his loyal overgrown slobbering canine, Jasper, are both immediately taken by the fiery young Londoner, however, his plan is to stay the three months he promised and then head back to his homeland, Scotland. While preoccupied with those who openly disagree with her entry into the prestigious club, Lily soon learns that her enemies are not confined behind the club’s walls.
Although there are some likable and colorful characters, I found the development of some to be insufficient, which cripples the climax and makes the plot seem forced. I found the dialogue the be lacking at times, and the changes in some of the behavior to be unexplained, and thus, unbelievable.
The premise was actually good, just not developed in a way to make me really appreciate the story.
October 4, 2017
It seems like I already started reading this book and maybe read it (and forgot) or at least the first chapters. Re~reading it (Chapter 1) has not encouraged me to continue. It is obviously American so timeline is already an issue as well as genre. Ms. Platt should be writing contemporary American Young Adults books and definitely NOT Regencies. The use of present day Americanisms in this genre and timeline is an insult to readers used to the style of Heyer, Balogh, Beverly, Laurens et al... The setting of a story is most important so as not to confuse the reader. For the reason I read is mostly for entertainment and to vicariously travel and experience other worlds. I do not recommend this book for any self~respecting Regency enthusiast and reader. It will only depress you.
September 26, 2018
.
This writer has a lot of potential and many will find this an interesting, if not factual read. I enjoyed the humor and engaging moments between the characters. The scenes involving the dog were too excessive for me, but some animal lovers might find that more endearing. However, some of the other scenes would have been against all societal rules of the ton at the time.
The story can stand on its own without any cliffhangers. I always appreciate that, along with an H.E.A.
This writer has a lot of potential and many will find this an interesting, if not factual read. I enjoyed the humor and engaging moments between the characters. The scenes involving the dog were too excessive for me, but some animal lovers might find that more endearing. However, some of the other scenes would have been against all societal rules of the ton at the time.
The story can stand on its own without any cliffhangers. I always appreciate that, along with an H.E.A.
October 16, 2021
Delightfully lovely. Deliciously funny. Loved the adventures. Fun story.
Will definitely be reading #2. 4☆
2nd reading: I couldn't stop laughing at Jasper's antics, especially when Lily seemed to get knocked into Ewan's body/his arms. I wish I had a dog like Jasper.
What the hell was I thinking giving 4☆ on my first reading of this book.
I must read the whole series again. A delish 5☆
Will definitely be reading #2. 4☆
2nd reading: I couldn't stop laughing at Jasper's antics, especially when Lily seemed to get knocked into Ewan's body/his arms. I wish I had a dog like Jasper.
What the hell was I thinking giving 4☆ on my first reading of this book.
I must read the whole series again. A delish 5☆
March 19, 2023
Jasper stole the show
From first meeting Jasper in the first chapter until the end, he was all I could think about. He was big and strong and had those beautiful brown eyes that you can drown in. He loved the heroine so much from the very start and I just adored him. He saved her from the bad guys and found her when she was kidnapped. I honestly don't remember a better hero than him. I don't think he was a 'Big looby' as the Laird called him. He was wonderful, caring and loving! the rest of the story was really good too but I hope Jasper gets his own book one day. He deserves it. I don't know if I ever read this author before but she had me at Jasper! I hope he makes an appearance in the next book about Lily's twin sister at least. I love sheepdogs! Especially big lovely huggable Jasper! He stole my heart!
From first meeting Jasper in the first chapter until the end, he was all I could think about. He was big and strong and had those beautiful brown eyes that you can drown in. He loved the heroine so much from the very start and I just adored him. He saved her from the bad guys and found her when she was kidnapped. I honestly don't remember a better hero than him. I don't think he was a 'Big looby' as the Laird called him. He was wonderful, caring and loving! the rest of the story was really good too but I hope Jasper gets his own book one day. He deserves it. I don't know if I ever read this author before but she had me at Jasper! I hope he makes an appearance in the next book about Lily's twin sister at least. I love sheepdogs! Especially big lovely huggable Jasper! He stole my heart!
August 19, 2018
I enjoyed the story and the characters. Some of the regency era details were a bit off, and far-fetched but still a very pleasant read.
July 16, 2017
Really -- 3.5 Stars
Series: Farthingale #1
Publication Date: 6/2/16
My Fair Lily was the first book published for Meara Platt. I enjoyed the story, but you could definitely tell it was the first book. I believe Ms. Platt is an author to watch and I will definitely read more of her books. I’m not sure why Lily was the first book in the series because in Lily, we learn that Lily’s older sisters are married, etc. – but – the last three books in the series are about how those marriages came to be. It doesn’t matter to me that it seems out of sequence, but I do wonder why.
First, the main plot or tangle of the book was just not possible during that period of time, so it took a bit of enjoyment from the story. The storyline is that Ewan Campbell, a braw Highlander, is in London to fulfill a deathbed promise made to his father. The promise is to mend a family rift with his grandfather, the Duke of Lotheil. The Duke is a manipulative, hateful old man who supposedly disinherited Ewan’s father because of who he married. The Duke is supposed to be deciding which of his grandson’s will inherit the Dukedom. That isn’t possible. If Ewan is the firstborn son of the Duke’s firstborn son, then neither Ewan nor the Duke has any choice in the matter – Ewan WILL become the Duke upon the death of his grandfather. It is the law of Primogeniture and there really isn’t any choice. Since it was the first book, I was able to overlook this point and enjoy the story anyway, but I do hope the author does a great deal of research and gets the historical stuff straight in subsequent books. Other things that bothered me – gently bred young ladies did not go anywhere without a chaperone during that time period, yet our heroine and her sister went wherever they liked unaccompanied. Yet another thing is that the Featherstone’s freely associated with the aristocracy though they were of the business class. That association just didn’t normally happen.
I loved Jasper, Ewan’s dog, but his jumping on Lily and causing her to fall to the ground or into Ewan became a bit tiresome. I did love that he ended up being a hero!
I loved the banter between Lily and Ewan – it was funny – and some of the things that Lily had to say was hilarious. Her telling of the story of Galileo’s balls was absolutely giggle-worthy.
Lilly is a twin and nobody can tell them apart – except, Ewan always knows which one is which. Lilly is very sweet and loving and comes from a wonderfully open and loving family. Everybody loves her – except the Duke of Lotheil. She is the bane of his existence because of her persistence about being admitted to the Royal Society. Yes friends, she is a scholar, a bluestocking and has a brilliant mind.
Ewan hates his grandfather and everything English, so he certainly has no intention of marrying a Sassenach – besides – Lily is so close to her family that she’d never marry and leave. So – watching them find love is a fun adventure.
I hope you’ll give this author a try.
Series: Farthingale #1
Publication Date: 6/2/16
My Fair Lily was the first book published for Meara Platt. I enjoyed the story, but you could definitely tell it was the first book. I believe Ms. Platt is an author to watch and I will definitely read more of her books. I’m not sure why Lily was the first book in the series because in Lily, we learn that Lily’s older sisters are married, etc. – but – the last three books in the series are about how those marriages came to be. It doesn’t matter to me that it seems out of sequence, but I do wonder why.
First, the main plot or tangle of the book was just not possible during that period of time, so it took a bit of enjoyment from the story. The storyline is that Ewan Campbell, a braw Highlander, is in London to fulfill a deathbed promise made to his father. The promise is to mend a family rift with his grandfather, the Duke of Lotheil. The Duke is a manipulative, hateful old man who supposedly disinherited Ewan’s father because of who he married. The Duke is supposed to be deciding which of his grandson’s will inherit the Dukedom. That isn’t possible. If Ewan is the firstborn son of the Duke’s firstborn son, then neither Ewan nor the Duke has any choice in the matter – Ewan WILL become the Duke upon the death of his grandfather. It is the law of Primogeniture and there really isn’t any choice. Since it was the first book, I was able to overlook this point and enjoy the story anyway, but I do hope the author does a great deal of research and gets the historical stuff straight in subsequent books. Other things that bothered me – gently bred young ladies did not go anywhere without a chaperone during that time period, yet our heroine and her sister went wherever they liked unaccompanied. Yet another thing is that the Featherstone’s freely associated with the aristocracy though they were of the business class. That association just didn’t normally happen.
I loved Jasper, Ewan’s dog, but his jumping on Lily and causing her to fall to the ground or into Ewan became a bit tiresome. I did love that he ended up being a hero!
I loved the banter between Lily and Ewan – it was funny – and some of the things that Lily had to say was hilarious. Her telling of the story of Galileo’s balls was absolutely giggle-worthy.
Lilly is a twin and nobody can tell them apart – except, Ewan always knows which one is which. Lilly is very sweet and loving and comes from a wonderfully open and loving family. Everybody loves her – except the Duke of Lotheil. She is the bane of his existence because of her persistence about being admitted to the Royal Society. Yes friends, she is a scholar, a bluestocking and has a brilliant mind.
Ewan hates his grandfather and everything English, so he certainly has no intention of marrying a Sassenach – besides – Lily is so close to her family that she’d never marry and leave. So – watching them find love is a fun adventure.
I hope you’ll give this author a try.
September 25, 2019
Funny, very funny. Exceedingly so at times even 😁 It can't be easy to find the right mix between humor and (historical) romance but Meara Platt has done it extremely well!
April 4, 2015
I wasn't entirely sure how I felt about this story after I finished it. I found myself rolling my eyes a few times during the story (possibly during the seventh or so time Jasper knocks Lily over to bring her into physical contact with Ewan) and I thought Ewan's protestations about marrying Lily rang false, but I understand the author needed a bit of an obstacle to keep them apart. I also thought the grandfather was a bit two-dimensional and that his redemption at the end didn't feel quite right.
And yet, I finished the book last night and immediately bought the next book in the series today. It was not the most amazing book I've ever read, but I enjoyed it. The story was engaging enough to see how it ended. I liked Lily and her obsession with baboons. I thought Ewan was fun, even if his sister cried too much.
It looks as though this is the author's debut book. The small details that kept me from rating it higher will likely iron themselves out as she writes more. I liked this book, and I liked the next one. I'll be making a note for the release of the third :)
And yet, I finished the book last night and immediately bought the next book in the series today. It was not the most amazing book I've ever read, but I enjoyed it. The story was engaging enough to see how it ended. I liked Lily and her obsession with baboons. I thought Ewan was fun, even if his sister cried too much.
It looks as though this is the author's debut book. The small details that kept me from rating it higher will likely iron themselves out as she writes more. I liked this book, and I liked the next one. I'll be making a note for the release of the third :)
April 12, 2018
3.5 stars
This story is an historical romance and as such is alright. There are a few things that didn't jive for me because of what I know about historic London. But they can be easily overlooked for a decent story. This story is decent.
One of the things that I didn't enjoy was that Lily seemed, on occasion, to be overly obtuse. Her misconceptions could have easily been cleared up with a few simple questions. Ewan is also guilty of jumping to conclusions without all the facts. This does make them seem more human, but it doesn't make them less frustrating.
The world is built nicely and the addition of some famous London entities, like the Bow st runners and the Royal Society were a nice touch.
Overall this was a quick and pleasant read with some historical leeway and decent characters.
This story is an historical romance and as such is alright. There are a few things that didn't jive for me because of what I know about historic London. But they can be easily overlooked for a decent story. This story is decent.
One of the things that I didn't enjoy was that Lily seemed, on occasion, to be overly obtuse. Her misconceptions could have easily been cleared up with a few simple questions. Ewan is also guilty of jumping to conclusions without all the facts. This does make them seem more human, but it doesn't make them less frustrating.
The world is built nicely and the addition of some famous London entities, like the Bow st runners and the Royal Society were a nice touch.
Overall this was a quick and pleasant read with some historical leeway and decent characters.
March 23, 2015
My Fair Lily is a delightful romantic romp set in the regency era! I loved reading about Lily and Ewan and witnessing their love story. The author did a fantastic job of rounding out the characters and plot in such a way that they were deeply engrossing and realistic. The story made me laugh and cry at different times. I loved the bluestocking attributes to Lily and found the rough around the edges Scottish rouge to be very charming. The two made for an interesting pairing. I cannot wait to dive into book two.
March 23, 2018
A good story based on a false premise.
This book lost me when it started discussing who would inherit the Dukedom of Lothiel! Peerages go to the eldest son of the eldest son. A dukedom would go to the eldest son and then to his eldest son who I gathered was Ewan. The only thing that could be willed away was unentailed property. Lily was a nice character and the prejudice she experienced was only too common at that time.
Unfortunately I don't think that the nice story over ones the big blunder as it changes everything!
This book lost me when it started discussing who would inherit the Dukedom of Lothiel! Peerages go to the eldest son of the eldest son. A dukedom would go to the eldest son and then to his eldest son who I gathered was Ewan. The only thing that could be willed away was unentailed property. Lily was a nice character and the prejudice she experienced was only too common at that time.
Unfortunately I don't think that the nice story over ones the big blunder as it changes everything!
July 14, 2018
While I was going to purchase it, I just realized I already had it. I was glad I forgot it, not because the book was bad but because while it was the first one published in this series, it is the 4th one in the reading order.
I saw the twins grew up in the three previous books, and now the last two books left to read are their stories.
I had some fear about Lily as she was shown in some of the stories as a little jaded, while here she is mostly stating facts.
But she was less cold even if still the perfect bluestocking, she was more humain with her flaws and her different way of approaching life. I loved her and how she was dealing with her “obligations” and her relationship with her twin. I loved her interaction with Jasper, the furry beast who can’t stand to see her clean and upright.
Ewan was so stubborn, he was near to pass up the woman created for him, because she was a damn sassenach! But I liked him, even if he is the sort to speak with his fits first and think of the consequences after, once Lily shows him the good way, he will try to right the wrong done even if it was not his doing.
I adored to see again all the Farthingale sisters and their husbands, plus the storyline adds murder attempts and kidnapping to the usual plot.
I just have a remark, I have read the free novella about George, the Farthingale Doctor, and he was a lucky one, he was rejuvenated between this book and his story, over forty here and thirty nine in If You Kiss Me, which is set a year later (not two like wrote in the book). The author should keep track of her characters and their age, as George is not the only one whose age fluctuate over the different books.
But in all, it is a very entertaining series, I can’t speak about modern expressions or out of time words, but nothing put me out of the story.
I saw the twins grew up in the three previous books, and now the last two books left to read are their stories.
I had some fear about Lily as she was shown in some of the stories as a little jaded, while here she is mostly stating facts.
But she was less cold even if still the perfect bluestocking, she was more humain with her flaws and her different way of approaching life. I loved her and how she was dealing with her “obligations” and her relationship with her twin. I loved her interaction with Jasper, the furry beast who can’t stand to see her clean and upright.
Ewan was so stubborn, he was near to pass up the woman created for him, because she was a damn sassenach! But I liked him, even if he is the sort to speak with his fits first and think of the consequences after, once Lily shows him the good way, he will try to right the wrong done even if it was not his doing.
I adored to see again all the Farthingale sisters and their husbands, plus the storyline adds murder attempts and kidnapping to the usual plot.
I just have a remark, I have read the free novella about George, the Farthingale Doctor, and he was a lucky one, he was rejuvenated between this book and his story, over forty here and thirty nine in If You Kiss Me, which is set a year later (not two like wrote in the book). The author should keep track of her characters and their age, as George is not the only one whose age fluctuate over the different books.
But in all, it is a very entertaining series, I can’t speak about modern expressions or out of time words, but nothing put me out of the story.
April 9, 2020
One of my absolute favorites. This is a new author for me. I loved her style of writing, and her main character of Lily. She loves to read, and is labeled a blue stocking. She turns out to be a heroine, in this book with many twists. The other characters certainly wove a great tale, especially the one person she is determined not to fall for. There is some heat in this book, mostly in thought, but still graphic. I am looking forward to the next book. . The author mixes, passion, dry humor, and excitement into her books. It was a five for me.
May 17, 2018
The Farthingale's are a loving family but not all of them are strictly up to speed on what they should or should not be doing! Lily, who is an authentic bluestocking loves reading, learning, attending all or mostly male lectures about science. She has been helping a friend write a paper---definitely not your typical English lady of that century--much to her Mothers despair! Lily has a twin who helps her escape from those boring social parties she is supposed to attend--they are identical twins. Almost no one can tell them apart--her uncle can--and then
A big hairy English sheepdog takes an instant liking to her when he spots her on the street. Down she goes--the dogs owner is mortified.
Lily has no idea this Scot is the grandson of one of the most prominent men around--she thinks he is a pauper or something like that. That loving dog ruins more of Lily's dresses along the way (as well as expensive household items)--Ewan-the Big Brawny Scotsman-keeps making reparations.
As loving a family as the Farthingales are--is how hateful Ewans's family is. Lily is bound and determined to fix this----
So amid shootings, stabbings and a kidnapping--will Ewen discover what his dog already knows? Lily is the only woman for him--will the dastardly grandfather relent and give up his miserable ways? Read this book to find out. You will be very glad you did!
My Fair Lily
A big hairy English sheepdog takes an instant liking to her when he spots her on the street. Down she goes--the dogs owner is mortified.
Lily has no idea this Scot is the grandson of one of the most prominent men around--she thinks he is a pauper or something like that. That loving dog ruins more of Lily's dresses along the way (as well as expensive household items)--Ewan-the Big Brawny Scotsman-keeps making reparations.
As loving a family as the Farthingales are--is how hateful Ewans's family is. Lily is bound and determined to fix this----
So amid shootings, stabbings and a kidnapping--will Ewen discover what his dog already knows? Lily is the only woman for him--will the dastardly grandfather relent and give up his miserable ways? Read this book to find out. You will be very glad you did!
My Fair Lily
October 28, 2020
Rated 3.5
May 28, 2024
Light and Easy to Read!
I went hunting in my book stash for something light and funny and found just what I needed.
This story was an absolute pleasure. Its funny, easy to read and has some of the most delightful characters who had me giggling like a schoolgirl. Oh! just what I needed right now!
I went hunting in my book stash for something light and funny and found just what I needed.
This story was an absolute pleasure. Its funny, easy to read and has some of the most delightful characters who had me giggling like a schoolgirl. Oh! just what I needed right now!
June 15, 2021
Predictable and gender stereotyped.
June 30, 2018
Reviewed by Rachel
Book provided by author
Originally posted at Romancing the Book
I’m almost sad writing this review, mainly because it means my adventure with the Farthingale sisters is basically over with.
Before I begin, I’d like to suggest, anyone who LOVES a good historical romance, i.e. Sophie Jordan or Julia Quinn, pick up this series of books ASAP!
Okay on to the review. Lily is the smart twin, the one who plans everything to a T, who is almost so comically brilliant that you can’t help but grin when you read her inner thoughts and workings, especially when it pertains to Ewan, the estranged grandson of a duke who’s decided his grandson needs a bit of….
Fluffing up, if you will.
By reading the title, I’m sure you can see where this is going, a swap on the story of My Fair Lady where the poor man is put through the ringer–by the girl, only she’s doing it not because she loves him or even wants him–it’s all for books.
A true bluestocking, Lily has only wanted one thing, to be able to be admitted into the Royal Society.
How hard can it be? Clean him up, and send him on his way.
But, as with all of the books in this series, there is violence, and she gets kidnapped, who better to rescue her than the man she rescued and helped gain entry into society?
I refuse to let these books end, they are beautifully and elegantly written. I had such a good time reading them that I’ll most likely put them in my re-read pile.
I give the last book, or technically the first, five roses that rule.
Book provided by author
Originally posted at Romancing the Book
I’m almost sad writing this review, mainly because it means my adventure with the Farthingale sisters is basically over with.
Before I begin, I’d like to suggest, anyone who LOVES a good historical romance, i.e. Sophie Jordan or Julia Quinn, pick up this series of books ASAP!
Okay on to the review. Lily is the smart twin, the one who plans everything to a T, who is almost so comically brilliant that you can’t help but grin when you read her inner thoughts and workings, especially when it pertains to Ewan, the estranged grandson of a duke who’s decided his grandson needs a bit of….
Fluffing up, if you will.
By reading the title, I’m sure you can see where this is going, a swap on the story of My Fair Lady where the poor man is put through the ringer–by the girl, only she’s doing it not because she loves him or even wants him–it’s all for books.
A true bluestocking, Lily has only wanted one thing, to be able to be admitted into the Royal Society.
How hard can it be? Clean him up, and send him on his way.
But, as with all of the books in this series, there is violence, and she gets kidnapped, who better to rescue her than the man she rescued and helped gain entry into society?
I refuse to let these books end, they are beautifully and elegantly written. I had such a good time reading them that I’ll most likely put them in my re-read pile.
I give the last book, or technically the first, five roses that rule.
July 30, 2016
My Fair Lilly ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
(Farthingale #1) Written by Meara Platt
When the Farthingales moved to fashionable Mayfair in London things were never the same. This fun loving devoted family enjoyed life and love each other deeply and without reservation. The five sisters were devoted to each other and all the family branches as well. The two youngest unmarried sisters identical twins Lilly and Dillie respectively were the biggest handful.
The day Lilly fell and crashed into Ewan Cameron, grandson of the Duke of Lotheil, was the beginning of a whirl win experience for both of them. Lilly thought this handsome Highlander a magnificent specimen of a male. Lilly was a bookworm and analyzed everything and categorized humans as well as baboons. Ewan was just fascinated by this bluestocking miss of such superior intelligence.
Since Lilly only new love from her family when she learned of the estrangement in Ewan family between his grandfather and the three grandchildren she decided to mend their fences. Farthingdales do have a tendency to be nosy and pry into other people's business.
This was a charming story of how worlds collided and love caught them both. Lilly held her own insecurities as a super intelligent lass and Ewan was a hard headed Scot. This is my first read by this wonderful author but I am on to her next Farthingale adventure.
(Farthingale #1) Written by Meara Platt
When the Farthingales moved to fashionable Mayfair in London things were never the same. This fun loving devoted family enjoyed life and love each other deeply and without reservation. The five sisters were devoted to each other and all the family branches as well. The two youngest unmarried sisters identical twins Lilly and Dillie respectively were the biggest handful.
The day Lilly fell and crashed into Ewan Cameron, grandson of the Duke of Lotheil, was the beginning of a whirl win experience for both of them. Lilly thought this handsome Highlander a magnificent specimen of a male. Lilly was a bookworm and analyzed everything and categorized humans as well as baboons. Ewan was just fascinated by this bluestocking miss of such superior intelligence.
Since Lilly only new love from her family when she learned of the estrangement in Ewan family between his grandfather and the three grandchildren she decided to mend their fences. Farthingdales do have a tendency to be nosy and pry into other people's business.
This was a charming story of how worlds collided and love caught them both. Lilly held her own insecurities as a super intelligent lass and Ewan was a hard headed Scot. This is my first read by this wonderful author but I am on to her next Farthingale adventure.
June 14, 2016
Lily a blue stocking scholarly 19 year old woman never thought she'd be attracted to a sculpted broad shoulders Scots man with a temper until she met Ewan. Ewan hates the English and returns to London for 3 months to attempt to restore his relationship with his grandfather out of a sense of duty to a promise to his dead father. Every interaction with his grandfather makes him long for his Scottish home and away from every Englishman. But he never thought he'd be attracted to a young blue stocking and an English one at that! But lily is exactly what he needs and his dog knows it! I loved her character and how Ewans dog puts her in compromising situation with him was hilarious! I loved how he fought his attraction, how he was a brute who protected those he cared about and how he wasn't what he appeared and she could see the real man. But Ewan didn't realize the harm Lily could come to and the extent of the criticism on her research which will test his feelings for her.
I would have given this novel 5 stars instead of 4 if it had been a truly clean regency era romance - shame it wasn't as the characters had such depth I was disappointed to see sir carnal appetites give it.
I would have given this novel 5 stars instead of 4 if it had been a truly clean regency era romance - shame it wasn't as the characters had such depth I was disappointed to see sir carnal appetites give it.
June 9, 2024
Fantasy
I enjoyed it despite the historical inaccuracies. Most of these romance authors nowadays just use the setting as a fantasy background, so if you read it in that spirit the books are enjoyable. All of this author’s books are basically modern tales and characters set in the Regency England fantasy but they are fun reads. One big peccadillo though - You inherited a title based on birth order and it wasn’t something you could just acquire or give away by vote. That type of basic fact should be left alone don’t you think?
I enjoyed it despite the historical inaccuracies. Most of these romance authors nowadays just use the setting as a fantasy background, so if you read it in that spirit the books are enjoyable. All of this author’s books are basically modern tales and characters set in the Regency England fantasy but they are fun reads. One big peccadillo though - You inherited a title based on birth order and it wasn’t something you could just acquire or give away by vote. That type of basic fact should be left alone don’t you think?
July 9, 2020
This was a pretty inconsistent read. The main character Lily was all over the place. Is she smart or dumb? A badass or a meek damsel in distress? I couldn't get a read on her because her characterisation was just too inconsistent. To begin with she's referred to as a smart bluestocking. But, for someone who's supposed to be smart she's amazingly dumb. Or at least naive. Like at the start when the dog knocks her down - she seems to think Ewan will be sent to jail? If it was supposed to be a joke it wasn't very clear. And she's very dense. Ewan literally does everything up to telling her who he is and she completely denies it. Plus she's very bloody judgey for someone who doesn't actually conform to societal standards. She's trying to oppose society and achieve membership to the Royal Society - but opposes anyone else ignoring propriety. For instance the following;
“You know Lady Dayne?” Lily gazed at him in surprise, wondering how and where a man such as he might have met her respectable neighbor.
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (p. 8). Kindle Edition.
Or this;
“Good day, Lily,” Mr. Cameron called out to her. She cringed at the appalling familiarity.
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (p. 34). Kindle Edition.
And of course this;
“Surely, it hasn’t escaped your notice.”
“I haven’t a clue what you’re talking about.”
“Your encounter with E.C., in front of our townhouse… on Chipping Way.”
“No, no, no!” Lily burst into laughter. “The Chipping Way bachelor’s curse is all stuff and nonsense. Besides, Mr. Cameron didn’t run into me. His dog did. And I doubt Father would consent to my marrying his dog.”
“You’re purposely being obtuse.”
“Who taught you that fancy word? Obtuse? I’m not. Really, Dillie. This is too much!”
“You can’t explain away what happened to Rose, Laurel, or Daisy.”
“More precisely, what happened to the unsuspecting bachelors who met their doom upon encountering them on our street. They were gentlemen. Gentlemen. Not clumsy heathens passing through town.” “
Mr. Cameron is obviously not a heathen. He took the trouble to replace your spectacles and the MacLaurin book.”
“He probably stole the book.” She was uncertain what to do about that.
“He knows Eloise, and she doesn’t invite just anyone into her home.”
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (pp. 32-33). Kindle Edition.
He stole the book? Seriously? Because he's a "heathen". Little harsh. She was just very critical for someone who's trying to challenge society herself. But I did enjoy her fiery spirit when it made an appearance. I mean this;
“I was about to grab a hat pin and press it to his throat. It was the only weapon I could think of. Handy things they are, too. But I wasn’t trying to draw blood or pierce his jugular vein. Do you know where the jugular vein is located? It’s the line that runs right here along the neck.”
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (p. 79). Kindle Edition.
Lol being ready to go for the jugular. But the following takes the cake;
“Is it my purse you want? Here. Take it.” “I’ll have it an’ ye as well. Think ye can get the better of m’master. This’ll teach ye.” Lily had to think quickly. She pretended to surrender, and then at the precise moment brought her knee to his privates with all the force she could muster. As he bent over with an angry yelp, she grabbed the pin from her hat and stabbed it into the hand that was holding the knife. He shrieked and dropped his knife. Lily used his momentary distraction to race from the stall.
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (p. 98). Kindle Edition.
Total badass. I did actually like Lily I just wish she wasn't such a mess. She's too inconsistent. She flips from one extreme to the other and it made it hard to like her. I could've loved a more consistent Lily. There were glimpses of it but it wasn't enough.
Ewan was mostly likable. Except for his thoughts around marriage and Lily. It got annoying to hear him umming and aahing about how he couldn't possibly marry her and how he totally didn't want to when he very clearly did.
I enjoyed the Farthingale family. It was amusing having the twins switch (even if it did seem a bit unrealistic - did no one notice there weren't two? Or that the one with and without glasses wore the same dress?) and I liked the extended family and their relationships. Particularly the sisters when they were together. Even if the additional characters were somewhat flat. I also loved Jasper and Ewan and his sister. Even Evangeline. The crying every time something happened amused me. I was kind of surprised to see this was the first in the series. There were a lot of references to past events which made me feel as if I started in the middle - I actually went and checked while reading to ensure I wasn't missing an earlier book. I do sometimes read series out of order or just one but I generally like to know that I'm doing it.
There was lots of action and an extreme amount of drama. Overall the book was fairly average. Honestly it probably only deserves 1 star. But something about it amused me. I found myself really enjoying it. It was easy to read and had some pretty funny moments. The characters were flawed and honestly, pretty flat but they were a likable bunch as well. So I'm going to round up to 2 stars - because despite numerous flaws I really enjoyed it.
In fact, the author should probably consider writing books about the other sisters, reworking this one to include that and fixing up the inconsistencies in the characters and plot and re-release. It's something of a rough gem and with a good editor could be something really special.
“You know Lady Dayne?” Lily gazed at him in surprise, wondering how and where a man such as he might have met her respectable neighbor.
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (p. 8). Kindle Edition.
Or this;
“Good day, Lily,” Mr. Cameron called out to her. She cringed at the appalling familiarity.
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (p. 34). Kindle Edition.
And of course this;
“Surely, it hasn’t escaped your notice.”
“I haven’t a clue what you’re talking about.”
“Your encounter with E.C., in front of our townhouse… on Chipping Way.”
“No, no, no!” Lily burst into laughter. “The Chipping Way bachelor’s curse is all stuff and nonsense. Besides, Mr. Cameron didn’t run into me. His dog did. And I doubt Father would consent to my marrying his dog.”
“You’re purposely being obtuse.”
“Who taught you that fancy word? Obtuse? I’m not. Really, Dillie. This is too much!”
“You can’t explain away what happened to Rose, Laurel, or Daisy.”
“More precisely, what happened to the unsuspecting bachelors who met their doom upon encountering them on our street. They were gentlemen. Gentlemen. Not clumsy heathens passing through town.” “
Mr. Cameron is obviously not a heathen. He took the trouble to replace your spectacles and the MacLaurin book.”
“He probably stole the book.” She was uncertain what to do about that.
“He knows Eloise, and she doesn’t invite just anyone into her home.”
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (pp. 32-33). Kindle Edition.
He stole the book? Seriously? Because he's a "heathen". Little harsh. She was just very critical for someone who's trying to challenge society herself. But I did enjoy her fiery spirit when it made an appearance. I mean this;
“I was about to grab a hat pin and press it to his throat. It was the only weapon I could think of. Handy things they are, too. But I wasn’t trying to draw blood or pierce his jugular vein. Do you know where the jugular vein is located? It’s the line that runs right here along the neck.”
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (p. 79). Kindle Edition.
Lol being ready to go for the jugular. But the following takes the cake;
“Is it my purse you want? Here. Take it.” “I’ll have it an’ ye as well. Think ye can get the better of m’master. This’ll teach ye.” Lily had to think quickly. She pretended to surrender, and then at the precise moment brought her knee to his privates with all the force she could muster. As he bent over with an angry yelp, she grabbed the pin from her hat and stabbed it into the hand that was holding the knife. He shrieked and dropped his knife. Lily used his momentary distraction to race from the stall.
Platt, Meara. My Fair Lily (The Farthingale Series Book 1) (p. 98). Kindle Edition.
Total badass. I did actually like Lily I just wish she wasn't such a mess. She's too inconsistent. She flips from one extreme to the other and it made it hard to like her. I could've loved a more consistent Lily. There were glimpses of it but it wasn't enough.
Ewan was mostly likable. Except for his thoughts around marriage and Lily. It got annoying to hear him umming and aahing about how he couldn't possibly marry her and how he totally didn't want to when he very clearly did.
I enjoyed the Farthingale family. It was amusing having the twins switch (even if it did seem a bit unrealistic - did no one notice there weren't two? Or that the one with and without glasses wore the same dress?) and I liked the extended family and their relationships. Particularly the sisters when they were together. Even if the additional characters were somewhat flat. I also loved Jasper and Ewan and his sister. Even Evangeline. The crying every time something happened amused me. I was kind of surprised to see this was the first in the series. There were a lot of references to past events which made me feel as if I started in the middle - I actually went and checked while reading to ensure I wasn't missing an earlier book. I do sometimes read series out of order or just one but I generally like to know that I'm doing it.
There was lots of action and an extreme amount of drama. Overall the book was fairly average. Honestly it probably only deserves 1 star. But something about it amused me. I found myself really enjoying it. It was easy to read and had some pretty funny moments. The characters were flawed and honestly, pretty flat but they were a likable bunch as well. So I'm going to round up to 2 stars - because despite numerous flaws I really enjoyed it.
In fact, the author should probably consider writing books about the other sisters, reworking this one to include that and fixing up the inconsistencies in the characters and plot and re-release. It's something of a rough gem and with a good editor could be something really special.
July 15, 2017
I've had this one on my TBR for a while. Someone from my BC posted a funny scene and it got me interested in reading it again.
This was an over the top, funny, slightly unbelievable story. There were many mistakes in the timeline, historical accuracy, etc. But the likeableness of the characters made up for all that.
It was an enjoyable book that kept me reading and laughing.
This was an over the top, funny, slightly unbelievable story. There were many mistakes in the timeline, historical accuracy, etc. But the likeableness of the characters made up for all that.
It was an enjoyable book that kept me reading and laughing.
July 6, 2015
I found the story for this book a bit lacking. It wasn't exactly dissatisfying, it was just all over the place. But the characters were enjoyable and I definitely plan on reading more by this author. 3 stars.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 317 reviews