I started reading Lunula with the notion that it would be vastly different than what it turned out to be. Given the description, I expected it to be more of a face off between the witch and the warlock, one where she is training for magical combat of some kind. The thing is, the summary given for this really doesn't aptly explain it at all. What it explains is maybe the first 50 pages of the story, and then everything after that is grossly unrepresented. This worked out simply because the actual story was much better to me than the one that was described, and I was happily surprised to find this out.
Wynn, the witch, is kind of a pushover. I would figure that someone who has known her entire life that someone would be after her to steal her power would try and do something to at least protect herself. That's not the case at all. She never bothers to try and exercise her abilities and make them better, which irked me. Again, if her life is in danger, why not try and give herself as much of a fighting chance as possible? I can speculate about this, although I think that perhaps just because she's meant to be the cliché sensitive, caring, empathetic woman that she would never dream of doing something offensive. My personal character isn't like that, so it's a bit hard for me to grasp, but for her it does seem characteristic. I really enjoyed that she at least used her magic quite a bit, and was competent enough to handle numerous missions before the one Queen Alexandria entrusts to her. And she did serve to be quite useful to others, most notably Gethin and his army (even if it was just being a nurse and making them smell nice).
Gethin was actually the best character to me. I'm kind of tired of female protagonists always doing the martyr thing, it seems to be more and more common especially in YA. And usually the male protagonists are super duper sexy and studly and beautiful and the female cannot control herself around his ridiculous good looks. That isn't an issue in Lunula, and I absolutely loved it. Most of his descriptions surround him just being dark, which I liked and thought consistent. Dark eyes, dark hair, dark powers, etc. I wasn't constantly bombarded with ridiculously long passages about how gorgeous he was, so I found that I was actually able to focus more on his character. And I found that I liked him quite a bit. He was a bit stoic, but as described in the book he was most likely forced to be that way after having to shoulder so much responsibility at such a young age. He was good to his men, and to his brothers. I had hoped that a bit more brotherly interaction would be involved, but I was satisfied with what there was. It seems that good nature ran in that family, since Gavin and Erik were both enjoyable and I liked their scenes.
As for the elves, it was an interesting break from tradition. In most all stories having to do with elves, they are portrayed as wise and calm, not rash and arrogant. Lunula is just the opposite. They still have the same traits as in other stories, like longer life spans, better coordination and uniform beauty it seems. However, they think all humans are vile and idiotic and therefore treat them with very little respect. It seemed pretty bigoted to me, which again is so different than an elf's usual portrayal that I really enjoyed the change. It was refreshing.
One thing I want to comment on as well is the elf traitor. I won't give anything away, but I got annoyed with the book as I was reading because I felt the traitor was so obvious. I really hate in stories when something is so painfully obvious and none of the supposedly clever characters figure it out. Again, Lunula proved me wrong in this regard, because they do figure it out. I was so happy. SO HAPPY. You mean we're not going to dumb down the characters just to make the plot more dramatic? Can this be? Ah, so refreshing. I sat back and enjoyed that for a moment before I continued on with it. A protagonist actually deserved to be a protagonist by figuring out who the bad guy was. Such a feat.
The one thing that really brought me down though was the ending. I'm not a fan of abrupt endings, because I feel like after spending 250+ pages to explain the story, the ending should have some depth to it. I had to reread the last few pages several times to make sure I hadn't missed anything, and even still I'm not totally sure what happened in the epilogue. I'm tempted to email the author and ask her, actually. Yet in the span of five and a half pages on my Nook, it's over. It truly happened way too fast, and I sort of feel like my reading experience isn't complete. I'm missing something to put this novel to rest.
That being said, I really truly loved this story, enough that I would read it from start to finish again. Some descriptions were a bit confusing (the elf dress being the first that comes to mind) but overall I really loved the descriptions of the settings and people and things. The ice castle was extremely vivid in my mind, as was Gethin's camp that Wynn stumbles into. It was beautiful and I, someone that usually breezes through long descriptions, found myself rereading bits of it because I liked the way it was explained. I already mentioned that I loved the characters, and I would like to state it again. Gethin was by far my favorite, but I really enjoyed all the characters, especially his army men. Queen Alexandria was a strange and interesting person who I was fascinated with. The elf king (Lycus, I think?) was brash and impulsive, and I found him entertaining to read about as well.
Of course, the entire issue with the lunula (I didn't know what it was until I read the story, either) was clever. I liked that there was folklore created in this world to go along with the characters and devices, and that plays perfectly with the lunula and its power, as well as the witch and the warlock. The way it was explained to me as the reader was well done, too. A puppet show to explain how the warlock would kill the witch? Awesome. Super awesome.
4 stars. I give 4 instead of 5 because I really do want more explanation for the ending.