Finales are hard. They can be written well with satisfactory endings. But many times, they are not. They seem rushed or have too many loose ends. Sadly, Redeemed was not a good ending, in my opinion, and this is why I think it was not.
I feel like a lot of people on Goodreads really enjoyed this last book. I tried really hard to like it, but I just couldn't.
First of all, the last book in an eight book series has a different narrator. No one asked for Jordan when we have Jonah! Granted, I actually really appreciated the twin twist. Not very many books feature identical twins, and if they do they're all wrong. Sorry guys, Fred and George Weasley are not good examples of actual twins. Haddix highlighted some of the struggles of being overlooked and mixed up as a twin, which was really relatable and very accurate. It makes me wonder if there is a set of twins in her life that she based it off of because it was written VERY well. That's probably the only thing I liked about this book, not gonna lie. (I am an identical twin so I am an EXPERT on this stuff lol)
Jordan ended up being a pretty decent character, but I'm still upset that in the LAST BOOK, our mains Jonah and Katherine did almost nothing. This is similar to The Blood of Olympus, when Percy and Annabeth didn't get povs in the FINAL PERCY JACKSON BOOK. Whatever I won't get into that.
Okay so I guess the first seven books in the series feature the gang going back in the past, so in the last one they're going to go to the future! Fun!1! I wish we could have gone to the past again, because I LOVED when they did that, but I understand why they went to the future instead.
Why were the last two books in this series so incredibly confusing?! This is a middle grade series I read mostly in elementary and middle school!! It was NEVER this confusing. Not to mention, the 'final battle' and resolution was poorly explained and full of deus ex machinas. Nothing made sense!! If you asked me anything about how the paradoxes and multiple dimensions were resolved, I wouldn't be able to tell you.
I thought Kevin/Sam Chase/Second Chance was done four books ago, so I was a little surprised when he came back. His plot line wasn't so bad, but the fact that even his thirteen year old self was able to predict the actions of Jordan and Mr. Rathbone before any of it happened just because he was some mega-genius was unrealistic, plot service, and a complete deus ex machina. I found it very hard to believe that he knew the secret to aging/un-aging at thirteen.
Also who even was Mr. Rathbone? Where did he come from? Why did Haddix add some new random villain in the last book? That didn't seem cohesive to me.
Also, let's not forget that these kids are young middle schoolers. Katherine can still fit into and shop at Justice. What's with all the stupid pairing off?? We do not need this much romance! It's kind of weird to me. They're still kids! I thought Angela and Hadley all of a sudden 'being in love' and adopting baby Gary and Hodge was super weird. When did they even meet?
Overall, this book felt very different from the previous titles in many alienating ways. I loved this series to death as a kid. This series sparked my love for reading in fourth grade, and I can probably cite it as one of the first things that made me realize how much I love history. Maybe it inspired my love for history. So I'll give it that. The beginning of this series is so near and dear to my heart. I'll probably just ignore the existence of Redeemed because it disappointed me. Still, great series overall, thank you Margaret Peterson Haddix!!