Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Spike Milligan's Accordion: The Distortion of Time and Space in The Goon Show

Rate this book
“It’s all rather confusing, really” was one of the catchphrases used by Spike Milligan in his ground-breaking radio comedy program The Goon Show. In a series of mock-epics broadcast over the course of a decade, Milligan treated listeners to a cosmology governed by confusion, contradictions, fluidity and uncertainty. In The Goon Show’s universe, time and space expand and contract seemingly at will and without notice.

The worldview featured in The Goon Show looked both backward and backward, in the sense that it paralleled strategies used by schoolchildren to understand time and space; forward, in the ways it anticipated and prefigured a number of key features of postmodern thought.

Winner of the Ann Saddlemyer Award 2017 of the Canadian Association for Theatre Research.

210 pages, Hardcover

Published October 13, 2016

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
0 (0%)
4 stars
1 (100%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review
Profile Image for Andrew.
866 reviews20 followers
July 11, 2026
Spike Milligan is perhaps the man whose work, if not his persona, that I have tried to emulate the most when it comes to my own rather uninspiring efforts at creating any form of written material. His sense of humour speaks to me like no others have done, and that he was more than just a jobbing comedian or silly performer is fundamentally true as far as I'm concerned. Rick Cousins may not idolise Spike as I do, but his academic text Spike Milligan's Accordion: The Distortion of Time and Space in The Goon Show is a very worthy effort at validating the intellectual and imaginative constructs that informed and influenced his most significant contribution to performative culture. 'The Goon Show' was revolutionary and Spike should never, ever be forgotten for how important his production of most of the scripts for the 1950s BBC radio comedy. That his writing went above and beyond simple zaniness and borders on literary and dramatic mastery is at the heart of Cousins' book, and I condone almost everything he brings to the table.

From the get-go Cousins stakes his claims as to Milligan's brilliance, and he calls in some fairly powerful supporting arguments and citations to help back up his premise, as seen in the following citation:

"The Goon Show’s free-ranging approach to time and space was the by-product of an equally free-ranging approach to humour. The bizarre situations and plot twists that Milligan created led to comparisons with the works of Beckett, Ionesco, and other staples of the absurdist canon. At the time of Milligan’s death in 2002, Peter Barnes, the author of such comic plays as Red Noses, eulogized 'The Goon Show' as being “as bleak as 'Waiting for Godot' and funnier”. Contemporary views on 'The Goon Show' were also quick to point out a connection between Milligan’s alogical stream of consciousness and a broader vein of English-language literary nonsense. Writing in Books and Art in 1957, Philip Oakes felt confident enough in the existence of this connection to say that “Critics have detected the influence of Lewis Carroll, [Edward] Lear, [and] Stephen Leacock” in 'The Goon Show'."

The allusions and connections to Ionesco, Lear, Beckett, Caroll and Leacock are offered here as statements to Milligan's writing, and they are both not unknown to anyone familiar with his work, and repeated with justification and explanation by Cousins in his book. Throughout the text the author identifies ways in which Spike produced radio comedy that went beyond aspects of surrealism and absurdism, placing him alongside those mentioned previously, but also apart from them as a composer of his own unique perspective. I can't deny my devotion to Spike makes me a biased audience for this tome and what Cousins promotes, yet again and again the theses he offers are tethered to valid evidence and analysis.

Cousins does a very good job of identifying key elements of Milligan's comedic sensibilities and associated techniques in 'The Goon Show', and through this process establishing a deep comprehension of how his writing was such a unique and substantial achievement. For example, the manner in which Milligan demanded a somewhat revolutionary approach to sound effects is referenced, as per the following:

"One of Milligan’s collaborators, writer John Antrobus, expressed the opinion that The Goon Show, in fact, raised the BBC’s existing level of technical and conceptual sophistication, in the process creating “a whole new understanding of what sound effects could do on radio”.'

Milligan is also shown to have a wide-ranging desire to engage with traditions in an informed and meaningful way, whilst both utlising and challenging elements thereof:

" History, current events and literature (both the ‘classic’ and ‘popular’ varieties) are all fair game: if someone had been there, was there at the moment, or could imagine being there, Milligan could, and would, place his Goon Show characters there as well."

"The one quality which Bloodnok still possesses in ample reserve is braggadocio. This, combined with his pusillanimity and deviousness, places the ‘mature’ conception of Bloodnok in the company of stock comic military braggarts such as Il Capitano and Miles Gloriosus, while placing him squarely in Seagoon’s shadow."


One of the more interesting, and I would believe informative, perspectives Cousins brings to his study of Milligan's writing and dramaturgy is his relationship with jazz. The improvisational yet highly structured thinking that jazz demands, and that Milligan utilised as a musician, are seen by the author as a relevant conditional aspect of his writing:

"Milligan’s comedy offers strong evidence that he ‘thought in jazz’. His writing deviates from predictable patterns, using dramaturgical analogues to two devices commonly found in jazz: it uses simply-stated or fragmentary themes as points of departure for complex narrative elaborations, and it employs frequent changes of conversational rhythm. Interviewed for the Channel 4 series Heroes of Comedy, British jazz bandleader and broadcaster Humphrey Lyttelton characterized the thought processes behind Milligan’s writing in this way: “(i)t sounded spontaneous—as though, when he sat down to write the Goon scripts, he simply started with one line on the paper…representing, say, the theme of a jazz tune” (Heroes: Milligan). Speaking on the same program, Denis Norden saw things in much the same light: “it worked like jazz, in other words…it was a storyline…in which he went off in various different directions, but came back for the last eight bars”.

There are also some more scholarly thoughts offered by Cousins, including some serious discussion as to Milligan as an early postmodernist. Personally I am unsure about this claim, though this is not because I disbelieve the author. It's more about the challenging academic construct that Cousins establishes and then explains, which for a considerable time for me was not that clear. When trying to argue a point or develop his theses Cousins is at his best when he provides supporting evidence from The Goon Show in the form of citations from the scripts. They make his contentions far more accessible for the non-academic. Having said that, when seen in the following quote, the merits of Cousins' argument are there to be seen:

"aspects of this general idea are particularly important in giving a sense that Milligan’s writing in the 1950s bore a distinctly postmodern stamp. First off, Milligan’s style and sense of humour served to interrogate normative­ patterns of construction and discourse within the craft of comedy writing, as they existed when he entered the field in earnest around 1950. Second, and just as importantly, this interrogation was not the accidental by-product of an innate, inexplicable knack, but the result of Milligan’s conscious desire to be a force for change in his chosen field."

I was also glad to see the author of this book speak to Milligan's affinity with children, and how 'The Goon Show' is arguably more accessible to kids than adults. That was certainly my first experience with the comedy, and Cousins is right when he says "The extreme rarity of analepsis, prolepsis, and other temporal disjunctions in Goon Show narratives means that these narratives, for all the sophisticated use of wordplay and sound effects within them, can be easily followed by schoolchildren without any need for rearranging the event."

It was rather surprising to see Milligan's writing also connected with the perceptive understanding children can possess as defined by the oft-studied psychologist Piaget. Cousins includes the following dialogue between a child and an adult that reads like a Goon Show excerpt:

A: "Is a word strong?"
C: "No, it can’t do anything at all."
A: "Are any words strong?"
C: "Some words are strong."
A: "Which?"
C: "The word “strong” because you are saying it’s strong."
A: "Is the word “elephant” strong?"
C: "Yes, because an elephant can carry people."
A: "An elephant can, but simply the word?"
C: "No, it isn’t strong."
A: "Why not?"
C: "Because it doesn’t do anything."
A: "What?"
C: "The word."


When an author can help me to see a educational psychologst who has been the bane of teachers like me produce material that is not that far removed from a scene between Eccles and Bluebottle, well that's impressive.

Cousins does well to also raise the links between Milligan's comedic sensibilities and cartoons; he often either spoke about this himself, or others have said that 'The Goon Show' was a cartoon for radio. The references to thought bubbles and bizarre visual imagery that is then adapted into an audio image by Spike (e.g. Neddy Seagoon and Eccles climbing over each other's backs to get out of a cell) are definitely cartoonish, as are the continual explosions and theabsence any serious injury or death.

Finally, I was impressed to see Cousins bring in the Marx Brothers as a crucial influence and creative connection to 'The Goon Show'. The non-sequitors and puns in the dialogue, the exploitation of sound effects and (implied) physical 'slapstick', the subversive narratives and challenging of authority through various plots and schemes...they are all there for both the Marx Brothers and for Spike. This quote goes some of the way to support this:

"It is hard to imagine how The Marx Brothers could not have influenced Milligan, given the thematic parallels between their body of work and The Goon Show. Milligan created a rogues’ gallery of transparent grifters, scroungers, and buffoons, whose behaviour appears to have implicit or explicit sanction from the corridors of power in a world where “Caddishness, cowardice and ignorance replace virtue and heroism” (Lewis 1995: 176). This inversion of values bears a definite resemblance to the ways in which Groucho, Chico and Harpo (sometimes with the help of Zeppo) use society’s most cherished institutions as so many maypoles to cavort around. Groucho himself figured highly enough in Milligan’s estimation to have been included in one episode of The Goon Show, in a pre-recorded cameo appearance (‘1985’ recording: 6:40–6:48)"

Unfortunately, the final part of this quote, where Cousins erroneously attributes an impersonation by Peter Sellers as being the real Groucho, is one of a few occasions where Cousins is off-beam. It's not a major mistake per se, but if one is expecting a thorough academic text a simple errror such as this shoudl be avoided by a credible author.

All up Spike Milligan's Accordion: The Distortion of Time and Space in The Goon Show is at its best when Cousins writes clearly about Milligan's methodology, with specific reference to excerpts from the scripts to support his theses. When the author digs deep into more academic language and relies more on his theoretical considerations the book becomes a little obtuse.

I did enjoy what I read for the most part and this is a substantially constructed and researched study of someone who, in my opinion, has not received the appropriate level of academic inquiry. This isn't an easy read, but if you love Spike Milligan and want to learn more about hw he wrote comedy then this is a must.
Displaying 1 - 1 of 1 review