Forever a Hero is the third book in the Carsons of Mustang Creek series, and having read the previous two novels because I've been a fan of Ms. Miller's for decades, I must admit that this was my least favorite among them for a number of reasons, and I can only give it 2.5 stars.
Forever a Hero focuses on the youngest of the Carson brothers, Mace, a Wyoming vintner, who owns and operates the small but highly regarded Mountain Winery. As the novel opens, he's driving back to the ranch in the pouring rain and watches the car ahead of him fishtail and nearly slide off the muddy edge of the road where there's a 50-foot drop. He manages to free the driver seconds before the car drops down the incline, landing upside down in Mustang Creek below, where it soon bursts into flames. The damsel in distress is Kelly Wright, who is in Mustang Creek on business for her company--she's there to convince Mace to sell the winery to her employer, CGI, and she recognizes Mace immediately, although he doesn't recognize her. Ten years earlier, he rescued her from a crazed attacker on her college campus, testified at his trial and helped send him to prison for a decade.
While Mace has no intention of selling the winery he so loves, Kelly, a city born and bred career woman who is all business, all the time, and has one failed marriage behind her, is nevertheless attracted to Mace, and could use a fling.
Mace, like his brothers before him, clearly wants more than that from Kelly. Sadly, although Ms. Miller tries to develop the chemistry between these two characters, this reader just didn't feel it at all. The novel is well-written, and the words were there on the page, but I didn't see any real depth to their relationship, which, in the course of this novel, happens in one week. While I enjoyed the witty banter between these two, I didn't particularly like Kelly's character, and aside from her looks, didn't quite get what Mace saw in her that attracted him so easily. Every time Mace tried to draw her in, all she talked about was business, and never missed an opportunity to try to sweeten the deal and convince Mace to sell in the hope that her landing the winery would mean a promotion and stock options at her company. Even when she discovers that her boss, Dina, is leaving the company, and that Dina's replacement is going to be Kelly ex-husband, Alan, she still cannot stop trying to close this deal--her attempts became more than a little tiresome, and really bogged down this novel.
Also, since the sex between these two was more perfunctory than explicit, and although it's mentioned that Mace is a talented lover, all of the author's attempts to go for the sizzle and create some serious heat between Mace and Kelly ended up feeling rather flat. Kelly's previous marriage ended because her husband wanted children almost immediately after their wedding, and Kelly didn't want to give up her career. Throughout much of the novel, she's still unsure about whether or not she wants children, but it's clear that Mace does.
When Kelly learns that her former attacker has been released from prison, having served his sentence, and when she gets a text message purportedly from him, I hoped the drama of him possibly coming after her or Mace would amp up the action and suspense--it didn't. Yes, Mace and everyone else on the ranch go into protective mode, but what should have been an action-packed manhunt for Kelly's attacker simply wasn't.
While the theme of the novel, career-minded city gal meets Wyoming cowboy/vintner was an intriguing, if somewhat familiar trope, the novel seemed over-long, bogged down by business minutia, and the romance and suspense were underwhelming. Yes, there's an HEA ending, but despite Ms. Miller's attempts to inject real feeling into this novel, it's my least favorite in this series, and possibly my least favorite of all her novels.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced reader copy of this book and received no compensation for doing so. The opinions expressed are my own.