What would you do when you get discovered... not for your voice.. but for your guitar playing?
I was on the hunt again for a new manga, and I came across this one. I love manga about music, so I was eager to read this one. However, after reading... I am not too sure. I will finish this series because it is only 2 volumes, but if it was more I would probably have stopped reading with this one.
Don't get me wrong, there were good moments. The art at times was just beautiful. The characters were likeable at times. I loved that, even though she wouldn't be singing her songs, she gets the chance to be in a band playing her guitar and her songs. I loved seeing the band get together and try various things and get closer. I had a laugh at the manager and her fierce determination (though she was also a bitch at times). I loved getting more backstory on Kaname (and her family). Then there is the girl with the rasta-ish hair and her love for our giraffe girl. :P
But I also didn't like a ton of things. Like Kaname and her gloomy and depressing attitude (she is a great guitar player, she needs to see that). Which wasn't always her fault as people were just acting plain shitty. Like the lead girl singer and how she often treats Kaname like she is the worst and just a piece of poo that needs to be removed (like with the nickname or being blunt about Kaname's singing) but then the next time pours over her in love? Or the manager who just acts like a bitch (but maybe means it nice and just doesn't know how to act like that)? Or how her uncle just kicked her out of her job without remorse (though we do see that he was sad, but I wished he had shown that as now he came over as a dick)? Or how people laugh at her? Or that backstory taking place in school? So yeah, I can imagine that she feels down and depressed. But still, there were also instances when there was just no reason for her to act like that. Like when she just ran away and disappeared after the live, I get that it was too much, but it still felt pretty eh for various reasons. I also wished she would stand up for herself. Come on girl, tell these girls how you feel. Tell that lead girl that you feel shitty because of her.
I liked that the title of the manga popped up in the story. OK, the actual song title is Rocket Girl, but our angry lead singer girl saw it as Rock it Girl. :P
While the art was pretty nice, and at times even gorgeous, at other times it was just beyond weird. Kaname has some really intriguing facial expressions. And not just her, but also others, but with Kaname being the main focus it was mostly her.
So a very hit/miss manga. There were moments I enjoyed, but also plenty times I didn't enjoy it. Again, I will keep reading, just one more volume. However, not now. Someday soon.
When its like the first volume of a manga i dont rly know how to rate it bc it doesn't really get to anything but this was cute and funny. It was a nice little read.
Kaname tiene un gran don para escribir canciones, para tocar la guitarra, pero en cuanto comienza a cantar, podemos notar que el don musical no abarca este campo, eso no impide que una productora musical, Maggie, quiera reclutarla como guitarrista para la nueva banda femenina que está formando.
Cuatro chicas con personalidades distintas deberán probar su suerte para debutar y posicionarse como banda, suena imposible cuando su guitarrista, Kaname, y su cantante, Seira; no puede conseguir llevarse bien, a pesar de ser un gran complemento para la otra. Sus diferencias y dinámica puede ser lo que catapulte la banda al éxito, u ocasione que esta se separe.
Opinión Personal:
Consideraría este un manga para pasar un buen rato, porque no es aquel donde profundicen tanto en la historia de las protagonistas, e incluso en la historia que se está contando, ya que hay varios saltos del tiempo.
Me hubiera gustado saber más sobre la historia de Kaname y Seira, creo que ambas tenían mucho potencial para abarcar más de sus historias, e incluso para conectar más entre ellas, ya que la música y su inspiración por esta viene por parte de otra persona quien no pudo acompañarlas hasta su debut.
A pesar de que su relación es un punto importante para la historia, no hay mucho trasfondo sobre esta, solamente existe, eso no des merita la gran pareja (visual y trop de personalidades) que hacen.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Una historia linda y buenos dibujos, pero la manera en que se desarrolló esta historia no me gustó. Son 2 tomos en los que se pudo plantear un buen desenlace pero no se hizo y eso hace que a pesar de tener 12 capítulos la historia se vea incompleta. Me hubiese gustado ver más a fondo la relación de Kaname y Seira.
This was ok….My biggest issue with this is how many characters there are. There’s way too many people for a two volume series to give them enough depth. I just don’t care about any of them. I will probably finish this because it’s so short. The art is fantastic.