A really pleasant experience! Give this collection a read if you get the chance. Find my short takes on each story in the collection below.
For a TL;DR: “La Clochemar”, “Strange Things Done” and “Let Slip the Sluicegates of War, Hydro-Girl” stand out as incredible pieces and most of the others are well worth the read too. I only found “Tunnels of Madness” fairly underwhelming and the message of “Equus” to be a bit of an outlier.
“La Clochemar” by Charlotte Ashley:
Love the god-like creatures, the life-clocks, the interactions of Indigenous Peoples with Europeans. Rare to see a story like this where a settler such as Suzette is accepted to this degree, but Ashley seems respectful of Indigenous names so I take it as a hopeful relationship!
“East Wind in Carrall Street” by Holly Schofield:
Very cute; reminds me of R.F. Kuang’s Babel with the wax cylinders replacing silver. Enjoyed the relationship between the kids and how they help each other forward.
“The Harpoonist” by Brent Nichols:
Been a minute since I’ve been genuinely touched by a ‘superhero’ story, but this one was pretty great. Great atmosphere too – Gastown and unions and whatnot – though tough to pinpoint this one as particularly Canadian.
“Crew 255” by Claire Humphrey:
Not the ending I’d have expected, but a nice enough story about found family I suppose. As a neurodivergent and maybe aromantic person who doesn’t really understand these things, Casimiro only getting suddenly fixed by a relationship feels like it goes against a lot of what I’ve learned – but maybe I’m missing something.
“The Curlicue Seahorse” by Chantal Boudreau:
A quaint little treasure-hunting story! Again not feeling the most Canadian, but more than anything I’d have liked some details - I loved the clockwork key, gimme a description of some of the treasure and historical artefacts and I’d have been all over this story.
“Strange Things Done” by Michal Wojcik:
Yes yes yes, love this so much! Great foreshadowing that Amery is only finding things instead of inventing them, and wonderful descriptions throughout. Not sure I understand the explanation at the end that the thing wasn’t intelligent because it didn’t survive the blast, but otherwise excellent.
“Buffalo Gals” by Colleen Anderson:
Cool idea with a nice perspective from an Indigenous constable. The killer remaining mysterious makes sense if this is part of a broader world, but I think the story itself would be a little stronger by sticking to the standard ‘oh it was the other named male character’. Kind of interesting that both Walks Through Shadows and Peter have this odd ability to see the spirits, and that ‘Gastown’ is mentioned (maybe collaborated/brainstormed with Nichols?)
“Our Chymical Séance” by Tony Pi:
Cute how much fun the author was clearly having with alternate historical place names and everything! The amber are very reminiscent at first of Stormlight’s spren and gemstones, though they go on to diverge in cool ways as well. The Holmes/Watson dynamic was fun too in its way.
“The Seven O’Clock Man” by Kate Heartfield:
Weird! But incredibly imaginative and cool! I’m struggling to grasp the overall message here (the Clock feels like a colonial system being imposed on this community, incorporating the worst aspects of Mr. Martin as well?) but the ending at least seems to be about remembering the past and keeping culture alive. A quick google also informs me that the Seven O’Clock Man is a known Canadian myth which is very cool. I’d love to revisit this one in the future.
“The Tunnels of Madness” by Harold R. Thompson:
I’d never really thought about the geopolitics of the American Civil War, so that was interesting in its way. Otherwise, this is the weakest story in the collection so far. Having the PoV character start to see the Confederates as evil only after having a gun pointed at him is pretty laughable character growth, and the twist was far from satisfying. [Plus with a title like that, I want some Cthulhu dammit.]
“Let Slip the Sluicegates of War, Hydro-Girl” by Terri Favro:
Fuck yes! Trans rep, Indigenous rep, abusers getting hanged, an unbelievably imaginative religion dedicated to electricity… This story is an absolute treat.
“Equus” by Kate Story:
This is the one story where I can feel its age (the collection was published in 2016, so the story was likely written around 2015). Although author Kate Story goes a long way to include Indigenous Peoples, she also has a lot of praise for the idea of Empire – surveying, expanding and exploring – in a way that is absent in most speculative fiction these days. This story’s fairly uncritical view of technology triumphing over nature and tradition feels jarringly out of place in this collection, let alone the genre as a whole. Narratively decent, but morally strange.
“Gold Mountain” by Karin Lowachee:
A great reminder of another dark corner of Canadian history, using the supernatural to offer commemoration to the many Chinese immigrant workers who lost their lives building the railways. It feels fitting that those very railways are all the “steampunk” aspect that this story needs. This story makes me feel even stranger about the previous one with how it celebrated the triumph of the railways.
“Komagata Maru” by Rati Mehrotra:
Another story with real, brutal history behind it. Also constantly relevant to refugee boats and immigration attempts happening on a global scale. The ending feels like a catharsis for a lot of frustration at the sad real history, and I enjoyed the triumph of imaginative hope over cruel bureaucracy.
“Bones of Bronze, Limbs Like Iron” by Rhea Rose:
A touching and hopeful finale. I’m tired and so not sure if the ideas were lost on me or if they really didn’t make much sense, but I’ll give the story the benefit of the doubt. Kind of nice to include another hopeful story about emigration without the context of colonization (mostly – granted, settling both the past and new worlds both have their own glaring ethical issues but at least there isn’t real history there?)