3.5/5
There were a lot of positives to this book, but for me there was one negative that I kept coming back to: I didn't like Lane.
The reality is though, that Lane is 17. She is displaying a lot of the selfishness that teenagers often possess (and a number of adults!) throughout the book. I started out liking her just fine, but as we get further into the plot and see her essentially blame Rob for her kissing Sam simply because he chose not to go to the dance with her (and he had good reason not to) I liked her less and less. I don't by any means hate her, and hope and suspect there will be redemption for her and make her character more likeable again for me throughout the continuation of the series.
I wanted to know more as a reader though about how Lane landed the role an advice columnist at the newspaper. I found it a bit odd that a seventeen year old was handing out love life and social situation advice to others when this is exactly what she struggled with herself at times, and by her own admission, had very little experience when it came to boys.
I did however, like every other character in the book. Even Sarah. In particular Rob was the highlight for me. Well rounded, well written and not full of teenage angst and anger over his situation of being a foster child. This in particular I appreciated as it is not often you will find in books a foster child without some kind of chip on their shoulder.
I worked out the Black Rose Person quite early in the process, but that's just me. I was stunned that Lane didn't tell someone in authority much earlier in the plot, but glad when she chose to. The way the mother was written in relation to this and the process thereafter was well done.
But the stand out thing for me above all else was a line right at the end of the book. Rob says to Lane a thankyou for 'Taking me as I am, not asking me to be someone I’m not. Loving me, my life, respecting who I am’. I absolutely loved this. We all want to be loved and respected in life, so to have this addressed and done in such a touching way was just great.