What do you think?
Rate this book


400 pages, Paperback
First published March 15, 2016
How I came to read this book:
It’s a funny story, I’m glad you asked. What happened was, I saw the cover and …
The End.
My issue with it is that it was vague in parts which were important and were potentially more intriguing. The concept of magic, first and foremost, with the chatelaines and clockwork devices and magisters and souls. It was restricted only to the plot and it wasn’t explained as broadly as I would have liked.
What was the magister’s end game? Just the euphoria of seeing his creations brought to life? Was that really it? And the rooks. Like, why rooks specifically? The lady’s scheme to bring more children to her through this academy of hers was another thing that didn’t sit well with me. I think I understand why Kat’s father sent her and her siblings, but all those other kids? If escaping war was the reason the parents were sending them there than why were there so few of them? It should have sent the kids there in droves if it was that appealing. I don’t know, this bit was too convenient.
There was an odd magic = science and science = magic theme here which wasn’t coherent.
I do appreciate the uniqueness of the story and its appeal. If this is ever made into a film I’m sure it’ll scare me shitless but as a book, eh, it didn’t have quite the effect it was meant to have.