Where to begin? Hmmm. Why not at the beginning?
Cover: a color illustration of sisters Maybonne and Marlys in giant form, picking up a house and yard outlined in fire. I think they might have tails in the form fiery walkways leading to the entrances of two other houses, one on each side of them and ending as smoke coming out of the chimneys.
There is a night sky, the colorful title "Come Over, Come Over," dotted above with giant stars. A big green field punctuated with tufts of grass. Marlys says "surprise." Marlys and Maybonne both wear glasses and their signature prints (Maybonne flowers, Marlys stripes at a slight diagonal) and smile as mischievous as ever.
"Come Over, Come Over," a daunting, but irresistible invitation.
Endpaper: in a soft-cover book I am not sure it is called endpaper, but on the inside of the front and back covers and their opposing pages is a kind of endpaper, no longer in color, cluttered with cartoon flowers. (The whole rest of the book is just black lines and shading, no color).
Title page: on the right, and on the left hand side, Maybonne and Marlys again. Maybonne is looking at herself in a mirror wearing a dress that has the same cartoon floral pattern as the endpaper and she says, "Who am I?" Marlys says, "My sister!", which right away gets to the heart of this book. Maybonne and Marlys alone, together, against the world of adults, who are inaccessible at best. Maybonne and Marlys aren't always friends, but they are a consistently grounding force in each other's lives even when they're fighting.
Dedication: "This book is dedicated to Robert Roth and the city of Chicago." I'm not sure I've seen a book dedicated to a city before. Robert Roth of the Chicago Reader picked up Barry's comics and started printing them when she had just graduated from college. I guess he started her career as a comic artist.
Opposite the dedication, on the right hand page, Maybonne and Marlys lie in bed together. Again, the three houses from the cover are here, strangely but brilliantly placed in their dark (shaded with Barry's great little lines) room, at the foot of the bed, the alarm going off. Marlys reaches toward Maybonne with perhaps the slightest bit of hesitation. "Psst, Maybonne," Marly's says. "What?" "You asleep?" "No." "Me niether." This one graphic captures the tenderness, strong as a bull, egg-shell fragile, of their intimacy, never forced, never sugary, often fraught, and always felt with some small note of affection, even in their worst moments.
Chapters: I am not sure whether to call these chapters or stories. This book is a collection of connected segments, each with a title. I'll tell you the first five.
1) Ugliful
2) Perfect Art
3) Staying Over
4) Flatness
5) Beyond The Earth (Visit The Planet of Marlys!)
Each story builds on the emotional content of the ones that come before it, and yet, also washes it away.
Barry writes about such tough and painful stuff with so much compassion and humor and musical perfection, and the trauma is real, but so is the joy, which Marlys and Maybonne manage to find in unlikely places. The pleasure of a particular moment or inexplicable feelings of relief and joy manage to wash over the hard stuff in a way that is so true to childhood experience. There is one story in which Maybonne has lost her best friend and can't stand school and feels her life is over, her despair is so tangible, and then it shifts, there is some small shift and she comes back to the present and fights to find something in the world to care for.
I wonder if I would have appreciated this book as a kid. I don't know if I would have related to their particular experiences. Certainly I would have related to Marly's isolation and frustration with school and a lot of not-so-nice kids and so many absurd adults.
There is something of the magic of poetry in here and I think it has to do with precision and maybe eccentricity.
Well, and there you have it, my review of "Come Over, Come Over." Except on the very back of the book is another color comic (didn't I say only the front was in color? Well, the back is too.) And it's great. Maybonne and Marlys bickering about what and who this book is about. If there were a word for utterly charming and completely awkward, that is the word I would use here.
The end.