Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Best in Show

Rate this book
Solitary mystery writer Julian Wilkes doesn’t want a pet, but his sister persuades him to visit Lingwood Animal Rescue, where he is immediately taken with a large ginger tabby cat. Before he can settle into the joys of cat ownership, however, he discovers something very unusual about his new companion.

Macavity Birch is cursed. By day he is a large tabby cat. At night he can be himself—a human male with ginger hair and oddly yellow eyes. He didn’t mean to end up in the animal rescue, but he never meant any harm when playing the prank that resulted in his curse, either. Happily, Julian adopts him. But while exploring his host’s home, he discovers the diary of a long-dead relative.

Unfortunately, not all of Mac’s ancestors are dead and buried. His great-great-great-grandmother is very much alive, and she’s a powerful witch who doesn’t take kindly to the sharing of family secrets. When Mac reveals himself to Julian in order to save him from bigger trouble, he achieves just the opposite, plunging Julian deeper into a magical mystery with him.

87 pages, Kindle Edition

First published July 27, 2016

7 people are currently reading
148 people want to read

About the author

Kelly Jensen

38 books238 followers
If aliens ever do land on Earth, Kelly will not be prepared, despite having read over a hundred stories of the apocalypse. Still, she will pack her precious books into a box and carry them with her as she strives to survive. It’s what bibliophiles do.

Kelly is the author of twelve novels–including the Chaos Station series, co-written with Jenn Burke–and several novellas and short stories. Some of what she writes is speculative in nature, but mostly it’s just about a guy losing his socks and/or burning dinner. Because life isn’t all conquering aliens and mountain peaks. Sometimes finding a happy ever after is all the adventure we need.

Newsletter: http://eepurl.com/czGhYz

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
21 (9%)
4 stars
107 (49%)
3 stars
74 (34%)
2 stars
12 (5%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 68 reviews
Profile Image for Teal.
609 reviews252 followers
October 25, 2019
*** 3.5 stars ***

This was a treat. All you need to do is buy into the premise of "kitty shifters" and curse-casting witches, then sit back and let this funny, tart-sweet little story whisk you along.

Julian's personal life and career have both been on hold since a traumatic breakup two years ago. But though he's sad and a bit lost, he's no victim; I loved that he's perfectly capable of standing up for himself -- and his cat -- when provoked.

Mac is a fun-loving young guy whose delight in pranks isn't shared by those who suffer the consequences of said pranks. The events of the story are basically his wake-up call to that fact:

“It seemed funny at the time, and then it just wasn’t. It was stupid. Which is the actual, true story of my life.”


Things get a little bit (more) outlandish as the story goes along. But I thought the author kept the tone consistently bright and smart and funny, without lapsing into sappiness or cute overload. And if you're a cat person, the insights into cat-think are highly entertaining.
Profile Image for Len Evans Jr.
1,503 reviews222 followers
October 31, 2018
I loved, loved, loved and loved this book! First off this book sorta kinda fits the season. Sorta kinda cuz there is a cat involved, though not a black one... and there are some witches as well as a mouse in it. This book was so much fun, it is kinda fluffy, mostly light-hearted and with so sexy times at the end. I just love Julian, and Mac especially but that is just cuz I have a thing for gingers. Only think I could ask for is more stories set in this town of witches and shifters. Overall, this sorta short read was so much fun and completely enjoyable!
Profile Image for BWT.
2,251 reviews244 followers
July 23, 2016
Julian Wilkes writes mysteries and a little romantic suspense, but since his last breakup he's been a bit blocked. When his sister persuades (read: harangues) Julian into adopting a pet he decides on a large ginger tabby cat.

Macavity "Mac" Birch's pranks have gotten him into hot water before, but this time he's gone too far. Left for five days at Lingwood Animal Rescue, Mac's just happy he's been "rescued" before the little bit of magic he inherited from the woman his family calls "Aunt Clare" disappears and the staff figure out he isn't really fixed.

Clare Lingwood is actually Mac's great-great-great-grandmother, a witch, incredibly long-lived, and enormously protective of the family's secrets. She deals swiftly, and sometimes harshly, with anyone who may expose any of their secrets. When Mac finds out Julian's latest project is actually the journal of a witch, specifically Clare's sister Madeleine, he's desperate to try and get Julian to forget about writing about the Lingwood family, even if it means exposing their biggest secret.

He did have a sensitivity to magic, though. He could feel it writhing through every page of the book. He was holding the journal of a witch. Of Clare’s sister Madeleine.
Where had Julian found it?
More importantly, what did he plan to do with it?
This was so not good. The whole reason Mac had been cursed was because he’d done something that might expose Lingwood family secrets. It hadn’t—and he still thought Clare had overreacted—but if she found out about this journal, if she knew Julian had read it, frog spells would be the least of their worries.

While this is cute overall, I would have really liked to see more chemistry between Mac and Julian. I also felt like the story had some wasted potential where it rushed through some plot points I was interested in in favor of focusing on others I wasn't.

All in all though it's a cute, quick read with some humor.

Advanced Review Galley copy of Best in Show provided by Dreamspinner Press in exchange of an honest review.

This review has been cross-posted at Gay Book Reviews.
Profile Image for Christi Snow.
Author 69 books738 followers
July 27, 2016
My Review:
Yes, I'll admit it...I'm a cat person and could totally see either of my cats as cat shifters and that made me love this book even more. Mac is a cat shifter and has been able to shift into his cat form since he turned 13. But recently, he offended his witch relative and she's made it so he can only shift into his human form during the dark of night. A twist of fate meant Mac ended up in the animal shelter which is where Julian found him.

Julian is an introverted author. His sister thinks that a pet may make him more socially adaptable (i.e. a dog will get him out of the house and maybe interacting with PEOPLE). Instead he adopts a cat and begins an even more odd relationship...one with a standoffish cat...really, is there any other kind? But what he doesn't realize is that his cat turns into a man at night...although that would explain the food and beer he can't remember consuming.

This was a totally fun read. I loved Mac and the stress of his situation, and I absolutely fell in love with Julian and the nurturing, caring soul he has. I loved how he would talk to Mac and really considers and worries about keeping the cat happy. Julian may be introverted, but he's lonely and really wants the companionship.

There's an interesting twist to the story with the witches and the journal that Julian bought for inspiration for his latest novel. I would have LOVED to have delved deeper into all this...seriously, this book would have worked wonderfully as a full length book going into all they mystery and lore there. But as it is it was a really fun read that kept me smiling throughout. I love the idea of a housecat shifter.

I received a complimentary copy of this book in return for an honest review.
Profile Image for Aeren.
510 reviews29 followers
September 29, 2016
Hay poco romance, y de ser sincera, parece casi metido en el final con calzador, pero la idea del chico convertido en gatazo a rayas es super mona.
Profile Image for Ami.
6,245 reviews489 followers
August 1, 2016
3.5 stars

Okay, I will admit it. That tabby cat on the cover was my biggest reason to impulsively buy this novella. What can I say, I can be such a sucker for cats. Of course, I am also familiar with Kelly Jensen's previous stories, so it's not like I buying this cat in the bag (*teehee*)

Well, I thought it was cute. I was exceptionally amused with the reason why Mac was cursed (). I enjoyed Mac and Julian interaction, including when Mac became that grumpy cat who refused to purr (*grin*).

What annoyed me about this novella was the Aunt character though. I thought she was kind of a bi*ch for me. I was ready to slap her and I was unsatisfied that she pretty much got what she wanted easily just because she was a witch. HMPH!!

All in all, it was good/easy reading in between novels. Plus there is a cat on the cover. That's always a winning point (ahahaha)
Profile Image for Diverse.
1,179 reviews53 followers
July 31, 2016
4.5 Stars

This was so freaking adorable! Julien is a lonely writer in a serious rut. He hasn’t written a thing in three years after a break up leaves everything inside him stale. His sister pushes him to adopt a dog, he ends up adopting a cat and that’s where the magic begins… literally!

This love story has a twist. In this world witches are absolutely real and living next door. Mac isn’t your normal house cat and the irony that he and Julien become paired is awesome.

Fate, magic and love. Three things this sweet novella has that work brilliantly together. Kelly Jensen has written an angst free, exciting and fun story that you’ll absolutely fall in love with! Who doesn't love a big dose of magic and fantasy with their reality? Bravo!!
Profile Image for Simon.
1,489 reviews8 followers
March 6, 2019
Oh, sweet and lighthearted fun. They were so shy with each other and thinking the other too good/sweet for them... adorable.
Profile Image for Marge.
986 reviews3 followers
August 11, 2016
A fun story with characters and a shifter I really liked. I would love to read a sequel where Julian gets his writing mojo back and Mac finds a career. And where their relationship deepens, of course!
Profile Image for Donald.
472 reviews14 followers
June 24, 2017
A cute story...I so related to Julian. I am not a fan of cats, but if a ginger tabby showed up at my door, I might reconsider that opinion! I would love having a Mac in my life!!! A sweet story of discovery, acceptance, and possible love...I still want to know if Julian was able to follow through...
Profile Image for Joyfully Jay.
9,089 reviews518 followers
July 27, 2016
A Joyfully Jay review.

3.75 stars


’ll admit, I was drawn to this one by the “stuck in cat form” aspect, as well as the atypical shifter angle, and in this area I think the story does well. Jensen does a good job bringing out Mac’s kitty side. He starts off with kind of an aloof self interest (oh so common in cats), until he gets to know Julian and sees what a sweet guy he is. And when Mac is stuck in cat form, he is just so feline and all his little behaviors reminded me so much of my cats. There is some light playfulness here as Mac is forced to sneak around Julian’s house in human form when he changes at night and as he deals with being forced back into a cat every morning. I also liked watching how these guys interact when Mac is in cat form and is trying to communicate with Julian. Mac reveals the truth to Julian fairly early on, so the tension there ends pretty early in the book. But I think it works since we still see Mac stuck in his curse as the guys try to navigate their new friendship and fledgling relationship.

So from the shifter side and the connection between the guys, I think the story works. But the larger plot regarding Mac’s family secrets and the journal it didn’t all come together for me. I guess I was expecting more magic, more mystery, and more intensity here and things remain pretty low key. Mac is freaked out that Julian has this journal, but the secrets that are revealed are nothing that seems to warrant that level of anxiety. There also really isn’t any mystery uncovering; Julian just reads the story and learns the truth. I just felt like there was a lot of potential to this part of the storyline, but as it was, things fell kind of flat and I am not sure it added much to the overall story.

Read Jay’s review in its entirety here.



Profile Image for Mari  Cardenas.
2,293 reviews28 followers
July 26, 2016
*** Copy provided to Bayou Book Junkie in exchange for a fair and honest review. ***

Julian is forced by his sister to go to the Lingwood Animal Rescue Center to adopt a dog to force him to interact with other, but when they get there Julian feels compelled to adopt a big, ginger tabby cat named Marmalade instead, even if he has no clue why.

Once they're home and are settling into life together, some weird things start happening and Julian starts to feel like he might be losing his mind.

Macavity "Mac" Birch is cursed, he is a cat shifter, so he's been able to change into a cat ever since he was thirteen, but now due to one of his pranks gone wrong, his 'Aunt' punished him by only being able to change back into a human at night. He never intended to end up at the Rescue Center or to be adopted by Julian, but now that he is, well, he'll make the most of it.

When Mac discovers a diary from one of his ancestors in possession of Julian, he starts to fear what his 'Aunt' might do his new friend if, or rather when, she find out he has it.

This was a very cute read! Julian was sweet and oblivious, and I really liked that he took things in stride, once he stopped freaking that he was going insane that is. Mac was lovable, both as a cat and as a human, he was a bit immature, but he showed great character growth once he realized some of the things he'd done wrong and tried to make them right. I just loved them together, too. They were fun and while very different, they helped each other be the best version of themselves they could be.

The writing was really good, the progression was great and the mystery was very interesting and kept my interest. My only complaint is that I felt the ending was a bit abrupt, but other than that, this was a very enjoyable read! Recommendable!

Rating: 4 Stars!!!
Profile Image for Melissa Mendoza.
2,598 reviews54 followers
August 9, 2016
"Mac reached for Julian's cheek, and when he didn't jerk away, pressed the back of his hand to the warm skin. He didn't know what to say. Maybe words weren't necessary."

3.5 Here Kitty stars!! Quirky and different, but refreshingly cute!

Julian is a mystery writer, who spends most of his time alone. His sister convinces him to go to an animal rescue shelter to get a pet. While there he falls for an adorable orange cat and adopts him. Once home, he notices there's something different about his new pet. Macavity is living a curse, during the day he's the adorable orange cat but at night he turns back into his human form. While exploring his new home Mac finds a journal from a dead great-great-great grandmother, who just so happens to be a very powerful witch. Not happy that Mac has shown Julian who he really is, she causes even more problems for the both of them....

I'm not usually a shifter fan, but I thought the blurb was interesting. And while I was entertained by the book overall, I just couldn't really get into the story. Not that the story was horrible, I just never connected to Mac and Julian as a couple. There were definitely parts that I chuckled and found myself invested, but other times, I just wasn't into it. Overall a pretty cute book, but definitely different!

me alphabookclub
ARC provided by author in exchange for an honest review. Reviewed by Melissa from Alpha Book Club description
Profile Image for Serena Yates.
Author 104 books769 followers
July 2, 2017
Written with a great deal of humor, this is a hilarious story about a lonely mystery writer named Julian and the pet he is “forced” to get by his sister. Only, the big tabby cat by the name of Mac is actually a cursed man on the run from his family. As suspected, trouble follows these to anywhere they turn, and the magical mystery they have to solve is quite intriguing.

Mac is delightfully catlike in his behaviors during the day. When he changes into a man at night, he discovers that the diary Julian is researching for his next book belonged to one of Mac’s ancestors – and Mac panics. His family secrets are not to be shared, but what is he supposed to do? He hadn’t originally planned to stay with Julian, only needed a human to rescue him from the pet shelter, but Julian charms him with his guileless naivete and Mac is tempted to stay – something he has never had to deal with before.

Julian is lonely and not a people person at all. I loved the first scene where his sister drags him into a pet shelter so he can pick out a puppy. Except Julian sees Mac and decides he wants a cat instead, much to his sister’s consternation. But Julian can be as stubborn as any feline – and it’s a good thing he is since he and Mac turn out to be perfectly suited as “partners in crime”. Julian is excellent at solving mysteries, but this one may just be too much for him…

If you like your romances with a sprinkle of magic, a touch of mystery, and a large helping of humor, if you want to see two total strangers figure out who they really are and how they might fit together as a couple, and if you’re looking for a very entertaining read, then you will probably like this novella.


NOTE: This book was provided by Dreamspinner Press for the purpose of a review.
Profile Image for Elliot Cooper.
Author 15 books63 followers
July 31, 2016
Very cute story! A bit of a romantic comedy, but not over-the-top with the awkwardly humorous moments. I love that the conflicts between the MCs were resolved like adults. Awkward adults. But adults who aren't too afraid to talk about things (even if there's hesitance).

Head-canoned Mac as Eddie Redmayne.

Really liked the characters and the interesting shifter and witch lore. Would like to see stories about Mac's family (maybe his siblings). :)
Profile Image for Terri.
2,882 reviews58 followers
November 1, 2018
This will be a very short and enthusiastic review, because these guys are just so freakin' CUTE (TWO cinnamon rolls!) and the plot has some scare to it and the ebook is $0.99 so don't just sit there, go get it!
Profile Image for Teresa.
3,946 reviews41 followers
August 14, 2019
Adorable

This was absolutely adorable! My only complaint is that it wasn’t longer because I really loved the characters and want to see more of their lives going forward. However it was perfect in itself.
Profile Image for Amy Spector.
Author 32 books125 followers
Want to read
June 29, 2016
I'm not sure why this makes me so happy, but it does!
Profile Image for Lola.
1,993 reviews275 followers
October 6, 2018
I really liked the premise of this book and that's mostly the reason I bought this one. And after reading and enjoying two of this authors other books already I bought this one and hoped I would enjoy this one too. Best in Show is a fun short read about a mystery writer who adopts a cat, who actually turns out to be a shapeshifting human.

This was a very fun and enjoyable story. I really liked the story and the whole premise with Mac being stuck in cat form and Julian adopting him and thinking he was a normal cat. And then the shock when he finds out he isn't a cat. It also was fun to read about a shape shifter who turned into a normal house cat. I thought it was a fun twist on the standard shifters and it made for an unique story too. Seeing Mac's point of view as a cat was well done too.

My main complaint about this book is that it was too short. It was such a fun read and I just wanted it to be longer. There were some parts at the ending that felt a tad rushed, but the first half or so was well paced. The romance also developed a bit quickly and I would've liked to get a better feel for both main characters.

Having said that I did like both main characters. Mac was a bit mischievous, but eventually also realized that not all of his pranks were funny and he did have a soft side as well. Julian had a bit of a hard break-up and has lost his way after that and Mac and a diary he finds change that. It was nice how we got a bit of a feel for their personalities, although I would've liked to read a bit more about them.

There are a few side characters, most noticeably Mac's aunt and Julian's sister, who both play an important role in this story. They aren't the most likeable of characters, but are important for the story. And Julian's sister did seem to care about Julian, even tough she was a bit pushy.

The romance develops a bit quickly, but I did like these two together. I just would've liked to see a bit more of them and them together. There is a bit of heat towards the end and a bit of a happy for now ending.

We learn a bit about how magic works, that there are witches and shifters and a bit of history of the town involving some of the witches. The diary plays an important role in that part of the story. I just wish this part was delved into a bit more as it felt like there was room to work this concept out a bit more and learn more about the world.

To summarize: this was a fun and short read. I liked the premise with mac being cursed and stuck in his cat skin and then getting adopted by Julian who thinks he is a real cat. There were some great scenes and I enjoyed reading it, but it was a bit on the short side. I liked how we got a feel for the main characters, but would've liked to get to know them a bit better. The romance felt a bit rushed and I didn't fully felt their chemistry. I liked reading about these characters and there also is an interesting plot line surrounding the town and the witches. The end felt a bit rushed and like some parts could be explored and developed a bit more, but I had fun reading this. If you're looking for a short and fun read with an unique take on the paranormal romance genre, I would recommend this book.
Profile Image for Penumbra.
1,198 reviews20 followers
November 2, 2016
Best in Show is a cat shifter story. The MCs are Julian Wilkes, a mystery writer, and Macavity ‘Mac’ Birch, a cursed male witch, who lives his life as a cat by day, and human at night. The story is told in third person through both MCs povs.


Profile Image for Lena Grey.
1,615 reviews25 followers
April 22, 2021
ulian, of 'Best in Show' by Kelly Jensen, doesn't want a dog. However, his sister, Alicia, worrying about how lonely he is, finally talks him into, at least, going to the pound to look at the dogs there for adoption. Alicia reasons that having a dog for companionship will be good for Julian's dismal mental state and will get him out of the house when he has to walk the dog which might lead to him making new friends, possibly leading to a relationship. Julian isn't impressed with any of the dogs but one cat, a big, orange male attracts his attention and seems to be begging Julian to take him home. Little does he know how this pet adoption is going to change his life.

Mac Birch, aka big orange male cat shifter, is being taught a lesson by his aunt, who is also a witch, about playing practical jokes - specifically, his latest prank in which he entered himself in a cat show and won 'Best In Show’. Mac is very grateful to Julian for adopting him and bringing him home. At night, when according to the curse is free to be a person, he roams around Julian's house, helping himself to food and beer. From his snooping, Mac learns that Julian is a writer and is in possession of a diary that belonged to his ancestors, containing the real answer to an old murder mystery.

Julian almost has a heart attack when he finds a naked man in his house and his cat is nowhere to be seen. Mac makes things worse by not telling Julian, who has become quite attached to his cat, the truth. Mac even pretends to help him look for the cat digging himself in even deeper. Julian has treated Mac, in cat form, with nothing but kindness and generosity showing what kind of person he is. Even with Mac being an 'intruder' Julian doesn't kick him out, but is worried about where he will go with no money and no clothes! Julian lends him clothes of his own and allows him to stay for a few days until he can get on his feet. Julian's compassion strikes a note in Mac's heart, making him think, for once, about someone else's feelings other than his own. Just when it seems that things can't get more complicated, Mac's aunt who is actually his great-great-great grandmother, pays them a visit. She has discovered that Julian has her sister's journal and she wants it back. She's also willing and able to use her magic to play dirty if they won't hand it over.

This is a quick, light read with funny characters in an odd situation. There's also an untraditional love match between a man and a cat/man that evokes some unusual circumstances and solutions. Magic always complicates things and in this case, gives both Mac and Julian a unique perspective. I would like to have seen more 'magic' between Julian and Mac; more chemistry would have enhanced the story. Although they are adorable, it seems more like a convenience than a real meeting of the hearts. If you enjoy stories with witches, magic, cat shifters, and a lesson about being too self-centered, you may like this book. Thanks, Kelly! Mac reminds me of my own big, male orange cat that I adore.
Profile Image for Deirdre.
1,571 reviews16 followers
February 4, 2019
OMG! I had no idea that this was a shifter book. What a wonderful surprise! And Kelly Jensen pulled it off with such ease. I purchased the book nearly two years ago and had completely forgotten its premise. This is how I like to read a book, determining I want to some time ago - then letting it marinate, in this case the result is an entertaining novella about an uncommon shifter - the regular house cat. Though Marmalade is far from your average house pet, though he did have that catitude we who are owned by cats come to know and love.

His adopter, as reluctant as he was felt a kinship to the big (ginger) red tabby. Julian found himself talking to his new housemate. Making sure the big red stripper kitty was comfortable. His darn sister was right! Julian didn't realize how lonely and isolated he'd become. But with a new pet & an interesting subject to resume his writing career, Julian was feeling decidedly chipper.

Until strange things began to happen around the house, whenever he was asleep or left home. Julian's shock upon learning that Marmalade, a Cat is actually a skin shifter who has been living with him is priceless! As was when he learned Witches and curses existed too. Mac the Cat shifter is a reknown prankster among his family. He is a great main character that will put a smile on your face.
Profile Image for Allison.
1,862 reviews13 followers
June 29, 2017
This really shouldn't have worked for me, but it totally did! I don't tend to like sweet/silly books, but I loved this. I don't care much for shifter stories, but this was so not the average shifter story that it worked perfectly. I'm a dog person, through and through, but I loved Mac's cat perspective.

This is definitely something to read when you want/need to smile and feel all the mushy feels. Absolutely adorable!
Profile Image for Nessa.
1,858 reviews21 followers
February 6, 2019
This was such an adorably, humorously, precious story. Mac is rescued from a shelter (in his cat form) by Julian, who has no clue that his new cat is also a human who is cursed by his, so called, aunt. This book tickled my funny bone and it came with a little bit of mystery and passion as well. It's very well written and evenly paced. I totally enjoyed this story, and would definitely recommend it. =)
Profile Image for Lisa.
526 reviews5 followers
March 6, 2021
This was a cute and sweet cat shifter story with witches, a curse, a clueless author, an interfering sister, and hilarious moments :) This was my first book by this author and I really enjoyed her writing style. It's told from Mac and Julian's POV and it's so funny that Julian is clueless about his big orange tabby cat that he adopted from a shelter. It's a fun novella that's warm, sweet, and low-angst. I'm excited to read more books by her :)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 68 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.