What do you think?
Rate this book
The Amish Matchmaker #4
A Love for Leah
The Widow's Second Chance
Widow Leah Yoder married for love once. Now that she's come home to Seven Poplars, she wants a marriage of convenience that will provide a longed-for family without dishonoring the memory of her late husband. A steady, serious older man would be ideal—someone completely unlike handsome, fun-loving Thomas Stutzman. She and the aspiring organic farmer agree to court to prove that this time, the matchmaker has made a mistake! But as their friendship deepens, will Leah settle for what she thought she needed, or put fear aside for a second chance at happiness?
Widow Leah Yoder married for love once. Now that she's come home to Seven Poplars, she wants a marriage of convenience that will provide a longed-for family without dishonoring the memory of her late husband. A steady, serious older man would be ideal—someone completely unlike handsome, fun-loving Thomas Stutzman. She and the aspiring organic farmer agree to court to prove that this time, the matchmaker has made a mistake! But as their friendship deepens, will Leah settle for what she thought she needed, or put fear aside for a second chance at happiness?
224 pages, Mass Market Paperback
Published January 17, 2017
28 people are currently reading
143 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews
July 26, 2018
She looked away, her cheeks warm, but she didn't protest when Thomas took her hand and kissed the back of it. "I'll take care of you, you know," he said quietly. He raised her hand to his face and pressed it against his chin.
Leah comes back to Delaware from Brazil. She was serving in Brazil as a missionary with her husband. Her husband and baby died of a fever in Brazil.
Now that she has mourned for a year, she is looking for a new husband. And she knows EXACTLY what she's looking for.
"First, he must be Amish, of strong faith and respected in the community. I would prefer a mature man, a middle-aged widower, someone who may already have children. How old doesn't matter, so long as he isn't too old to father children. ... I've been the wife of a young man. I married for love. I'll never have that again, and I know that. ... "I only ask for a husband who isn't lazy and will be a good example for our children. He must know how much I want more children. ... I could not bear it if I never rocked another baby in my arms or woke to see my precious child's shining face becoming in wonder at the new day ... So you see, it might be best if my husband-to-be already has children. I can adapt to any personality, but he must be someone who will welcome children and not treat them harshly."
"Or treat you harshly," Sara suggested.
Leah shrugged. "I can accept whatever the Lord sends me. I'll be a good and dutiful wife, so long as he knows that my children must come first. ... What I want is a marriage of convenience, a union entered into for the purpose of forming a solid family. I'm not afraid of hard work, and I'll be the best wife and helpmate I can. But I need a sensible man, a practical man who doesn't expect more than I can give. ... Because part of me died in Brazil, Sara. All I can do is go on with what I have left. ... Offer me no lighthearted, carefree noodleheads. I'm seeking a sober and steady husband, one with gray in his hair, who knows what it is to suffer loss. Can you find me such a man?"
Of course, the matchmaker completely disregards Leah's wishes and sets her up with Thomas.
The book opens with Thomas proposing marriage to Ellie and getting turned down. He is considered 'fast' in the Amish community. This means he's enjoyed some light, chaste kissing. Ummmmm... he's dated a lot of 'girls.' He's never married. I don't feel like this is because he is rakish or wild at all, just fun-loving and not very serious. There's not any mean-spiritedness in him or badness.
Both he and Leah balk at getting paired up, but agree to 'date' for six weeks.
Let's break this down. Hmmmm, I'm not sure where to start.
ONE: THE EVIL PATRIARCHY It's fucking disgusting. I would go crazy.
The main, most egregious offense is that Leah - a grown woman, a widow, a world-traveler, and a mother - is treated by the Amish society as a child. She can't see Thomas without a chaperone. She can't travel anywhere alone with him. She must be monitored at all times. Her riding a horse is 'unseemly.'
Thomas even says this about her:
As much as he enjoyed being with Leah - and she was always fun - she had a way of making him uneasy. She was so outspoken... so experienced. Not like other Amish girls he knew. He wondered if she'd ever be able to return to the quiet life in Seven Poplars or any other Old Order community after her life in the English world. Pity the man who did marry her. It wasn't natural, a woman knowing more than her husband.
Uh, no. Any man would be fucking lucky to get such a smart, knowledgeable wife who had experiences outside of the Amish (and even the American) community. Because of the patriarchy, Leah's experiences don't make her more valued and sought after as a wife - they damage her and make her less worthy. Because the man has to be in charge, has to be smarter, has to be more knowledgeable and experienced than the woman or he has an identity crisis. Pathetic. Truly pathetic. I was really wondering how Leah got through this novel without stabbing anyone.
And the Amish community is SO nosy, SO busybody, SO judgmental, and SO interfering in this book it is ridiculous. They could drive a saint to murder. Everywhere Leah goes, people offer her an opinion on what she should do, what she should wear, whom she should marry, when she should marry, why she should marry, what types of men she is specifically allowed and not allowed to marry... JFC. I can't see why she'd want to stay in this community. She keeps waxing poetic about it, talking about how kind and caring the community is, but I would be running out of there at high speed. She's scolded and reprimanded and berated ALL THE TIME and it's 'for her own good' and everyone has an opinion on what her life should be and what she should be doing. It's sick.
As a side note, one of the side plots in this book is Jakob pursing Ellie. I have to say it is really gross. Ellie is almost violently opposed to 'dating' Jakob. She avoids him whenever possible, she shrinks away from him, she makes it as clear as possible she wants nothing to do with him. Miller acts like this is funny and that all it will take is 'patient pursuit' on Jakob's part to 'win Ellie over.' Um, no the fuck it won't. If a woman LITERALLY turns around and walks away every time she sees you coming, shrinks away from you if you are in a closed space with her, loudly and vocally refuses your advances... Yeah, I think she's not interested. Please leave her alone.
"I'm not giving up on the pretty little schoolteacher," Jakob replied, still watching Ellie retreat. "She had me from the first time I laid eyes on her. She's going to be my wife. She just doesn't know it yet."
I know Jakob is Amish and has never seen Beauty and the Beast, but this is almost quoting Gaston verbatim. Not a good look. Not the attitude you're going for. Please stop.
Thomas, even though he has a complex about Leah being smarter and more worldly than him, doesn't hesitate to step in a do stuff that needs doing.
Some Amish men were uncomfortable with women's work, but not Thomas. She liked that about him; he reminded her of her father, who had not been above grabbing a dishcloth and helping wash dishes after supper.
He washes dishes, opens jars for her. I mean, the problem is that you have no idea if any of this is going to continue happening after the wedding day.
2.) Good writing. This isn't a badly written romance novels. Some romance novels just seem churned out - the author doesn't bother putting any personality or real psychology into the characters.
That's not the case here.
Miller is aware of herself and of reality. Often she will make the characters engage in bullshit and then call them on their own bullshit.
Even though I don't enjoy the book - I think it's filled with disgusting patriarchy, and the fact that it is taking place in modern times with this attitude sickens me - I have to say Miller is a competent author and the book is easy to read and get into. If I were someone who jonesed on Amish Christian romance, I would find this very pleasing.
I would recommend this to people to enjoy Amish Christian Romance, along with A Groom for Greta.
3.) Heroine. I like that Leah is a smart, competent, experienced woman. Usually heroines in Amish Christian Romance are extremely sheltered 'virgins' who have never left their small village. Not so here. Not only is Leah smarter than Thomas, she's lived abroad - in Brazil, raised a child (she died), been married... It's rare to find a heroine who is smarter, more experienced, and more worldly than the hero. Not just in Amish Christian romance, unfortunately. In any romance. It's automatically assumed that the man will have the upperhand - have more life experience, more sexual experience, be smarter and tougher than the woman. ANY romance. Even modern, contemporary ones. The more you examine it, the sicker it gets.
So I was shocked at Miller taking a chance here, especially in this subgenre. It doesn't always play out well - Leah has internalized misogyny and actively wishes for a husband who is distant, cold, possibly abusive, and controlling... and she allows the Amish community to boss her around, cow her, and treat her like a child - but kudos to Miller for at least nodding to the idea that a heroine knows what she's doing and a hero doesn't.
4.) HERO Thomas is a kind, rather goofy guy who isn't very serious and likes 'partying' (his idea of partying: fast food, bowling). He likes dating women. I don't feel like he is a cad at all, Amish 'girls' have fun dating him but don't seem interested in marrying him.
He's unmotivated and rather at loose ends. Leah helps him firm up what he wants to do in life and gives him the impetus to move on it. I feel like he is a kind guy if not the brightest or the most ambitious. I actually don't like ambitious men, and I enjoyed his laid-back, easygoing personality and his joie de vivre. His mellowness contrasts nicely with how tightly Leah is wound and how many issues she has involving the death of her husband and daughter.
5.) Inclusion One thing I can say for books is that the Amish characters display tolerance for people who may not receive such tolerance in the outside world. Characters with Down syndrome are thought of as 'God's chosen' and are never seen as a burden or taunted. There are two characters with dwarfism in here, they are regular members of the community and treated just like everyone else. Fat characters are described in glowing terms, not demonized or made to feel shame and inferiority because they are fat. And marriage is a requirement by the community (in these books), and everyone is on the marriage market. Being fat or being a dwarf or being ____ is not a huge issue like it is in other books, and it certainly doesn't mean someone is 'doomed to be single' or is 'sad and alone' due to their physical traits.
As for ANTI-inclusion, of course Amish Christian fiction is a bastion of whiteness. There is rarely RARELY a POC character in Amish Christian fiction. However, there is a black woman in this book - she's a side side side character, but she IS there. Thought I'd note it since I think it's the first time I've seen a POC character in an Amish Christian fiction.
I mean, of course Leah was living with POC in Brazil, but they were painted as basically 'jungle-living savages' who 'needed Jesus' and definitely weren't seen as equal with the Amish MCs.
MENTIONS OF GOD: ~71
HOW'S THE SEX, CARMEN?
No sex, this is Christian fiction. One hand-hold, one hand-kiss, four light kisses, one bundling scene! you don't see that everyday, one foot massage (he massages her feet). That's about it. Actually quite sexual compared to some Amish Christian Romances I've read.
TL;DR - Even though this book is not to my taste - the patriarchy in here is so disgusting - I think a fan of Amish Christian Romance would enjoy this. Like A Groom for Greta, this book adds flavor and personality to its characters, and Miller doesn't just cobble something together with no spark. I also think Leah and Thomas are complementary to each other.
ROMANCE CATEGORIES:
Contemporary Romance
Inspirational Romance
Virgin Hero Romance - Paired with a non-virgin heroine! I feel like this is worth noting, it's so rare
Non-Virgin Heroine
Widow Heroine
Amish Romance
He's a Blacksmith (he hates it), Carpenter, Organic Farmer. She's a... Nothing, her whole identity as a woman in the patriarchy is so-and-so's wife, so-and-so's mother.
Leah comes back to Delaware from Brazil. She was serving in Brazil as a missionary with her husband. Her husband and baby died of a fever in Brazil.
Now that she has mourned for a year, she is looking for a new husband. And she knows EXACTLY what she's looking for.
"First, he must be Amish, of strong faith and respected in the community. I would prefer a mature man, a middle-aged widower, someone who may already have children. How old doesn't matter, so long as he isn't too old to father children. ... I've been the wife of a young man. I married for love. I'll never have that again, and I know that. ... "I only ask for a husband who isn't lazy and will be a good example for our children. He must know how much I want more children. ... I could not bear it if I never rocked another baby in my arms or woke to see my precious child's shining face becoming in wonder at the new day ... So you see, it might be best if my husband-to-be already has children. I can adapt to any personality, but he must be someone who will welcome children and not treat them harshly."
"Or treat you harshly," Sara suggested.
Leah shrugged. "I can accept whatever the Lord sends me. I'll be a good and dutiful wife, so long as he knows that my children must come first. ... What I want is a marriage of convenience, a union entered into for the purpose of forming a solid family. I'm not afraid of hard work, and I'll be the best wife and helpmate I can. But I need a sensible man, a practical man who doesn't expect more than I can give. ... Because part of me died in Brazil, Sara. All I can do is go on with what I have left. ... Offer me no lighthearted, carefree noodleheads. I'm seeking a sober and steady husband, one with gray in his hair, who knows what it is to suffer loss. Can you find me such a man?"
Of course, the matchmaker completely disregards Leah's wishes and sets her up with Thomas.
The book opens with Thomas proposing marriage to Ellie and getting turned down. He is considered 'fast' in the Amish community. This means he's enjoyed some light, chaste kissing. Ummmmm... he's dated a lot of 'girls.' He's never married. I don't feel like this is because he is rakish or wild at all, just fun-loving and not very serious. There's not any mean-spiritedness in him or badness.
Both he and Leah balk at getting paired up, but agree to 'date' for six weeks.
Let's break this down. Hmmmm, I'm not sure where to start.
ONE: THE EVIL PATRIARCHY It's fucking disgusting. I would go crazy.
The main, most egregious offense is that Leah - a grown woman, a widow, a world-traveler, and a mother - is treated by the Amish society as a child. She can't see Thomas without a chaperone. She can't travel anywhere alone with him. She must be monitored at all times. Her riding a horse is 'unseemly.'
Thomas even says this about her:
As much as he enjoyed being with Leah - and she was always fun - she had a way of making him uneasy. She was so outspoken... so experienced. Not like other Amish girls he knew. He wondered if she'd ever be able to return to the quiet life in Seven Poplars or any other Old Order community after her life in the English world. Pity the man who did marry her. It wasn't natural, a woman knowing more than her husband.
Uh, no. Any man would be fucking lucky to get such a smart, knowledgeable wife who had experiences outside of the Amish (and even the American) community. Because of the patriarchy, Leah's experiences don't make her more valued and sought after as a wife - they damage her and make her less worthy. Because the man has to be in charge, has to be smarter, has to be more knowledgeable and experienced than the woman or he has an identity crisis. Pathetic. Truly pathetic. I was really wondering how Leah got through this novel without stabbing anyone.
And the Amish community is SO nosy, SO busybody, SO judgmental, and SO interfering in this book it is ridiculous. They could drive a saint to murder. Everywhere Leah goes, people offer her an opinion on what she should do, what she should wear, whom she should marry, when she should marry, why she should marry, what types of men she is specifically allowed and not allowed to marry... JFC. I can't see why she'd want to stay in this community. She keeps waxing poetic about it, talking about how kind and caring the community is, but I would be running out of there at high speed. She's scolded and reprimanded and berated ALL THE TIME and it's 'for her own good' and everyone has an opinion on what her life should be and what she should be doing. It's sick.
As a side note, one of the side plots in this book is Jakob pursing Ellie. I have to say it is really gross. Ellie is almost violently opposed to 'dating' Jakob. She avoids him whenever possible, she shrinks away from him, she makes it as clear as possible she wants nothing to do with him. Miller acts like this is funny and that all it will take is 'patient pursuit' on Jakob's part to 'win Ellie over.' Um, no the fuck it won't. If a woman LITERALLY turns around and walks away every time she sees you coming, shrinks away from you if you are in a closed space with her, loudly and vocally refuses your advances... Yeah, I think she's not interested. Please leave her alone.
"I'm not giving up on the pretty little schoolteacher," Jakob replied, still watching Ellie retreat. "She had me from the first time I laid eyes on her. She's going to be my wife. She just doesn't know it yet."
I know Jakob is Amish and has never seen Beauty and the Beast, but this is almost quoting Gaston verbatim. Not a good look. Not the attitude you're going for. Please stop.
Thomas, even though he has a complex about Leah being smarter and more worldly than him, doesn't hesitate to step in a do stuff that needs doing.
Some Amish men were uncomfortable with women's work, but not Thomas. She liked that about him; he reminded her of her father, who had not been above grabbing a dishcloth and helping wash dishes after supper.
He washes dishes, opens jars for her. I mean, the problem is that you have no idea if any of this is going to continue happening after the wedding day.
2.) Good writing. This isn't a badly written romance novels. Some romance novels just seem churned out - the author doesn't bother putting any personality or real psychology into the characters.
That's not the case here.
Miller is aware of herself and of reality. Often she will make the characters engage in bullshit and then call them on their own bullshit.
Even though I don't enjoy the book - I think it's filled with disgusting patriarchy, and the fact that it is taking place in modern times with this attitude sickens me - I have to say Miller is a competent author and the book is easy to read and get into. If I were someone who jonesed on Amish Christian romance, I would find this very pleasing.
I would recommend this to people to enjoy Amish Christian Romance, along with A Groom for Greta.
3.) Heroine. I like that Leah is a smart, competent, experienced woman. Usually heroines in Amish Christian Romance are extremely sheltered 'virgins' who have never left their small village. Not so here. Not only is Leah smarter than Thomas, she's lived abroad - in Brazil, raised a child (she died), been married... It's rare to find a heroine who is smarter, more experienced, and more worldly than the hero. Not just in Amish Christian romance, unfortunately. In any romance. It's automatically assumed that the man will have the upperhand - have more life experience, more sexual experience, be smarter and tougher than the woman. ANY romance. Even modern, contemporary ones. The more you examine it, the sicker it gets.
So I was shocked at Miller taking a chance here, especially in this subgenre. It doesn't always play out well - Leah has internalized misogyny and actively wishes for a husband who is distant, cold, possibly abusive, and controlling... and she allows the Amish community to boss her around, cow her, and treat her like a child - but kudos to Miller for at least nodding to the idea that a heroine knows what she's doing and a hero doesn't.
4.) HERO Thomas is a kind, rather goofy guy who isn't very serious and likes 'partying' (his idea of partying: fast food, bowling). He likes dating women. I don't feel like he is a cad at all, Amish 'girls' have fun dating him but don't seem interested in marrying him.
He's unmotivated and rather at loose ends. Leah helps him firm up what he wants to do in life and gives him the impetus to move on it. I feel like he is a kind guy if not the brightest or the most ambitious. I actually don't like ambitious men, and I enjoyed his laid-back, easygoing personality and his joie de vivre. His mellowness contrasts nicely with how tightly Leah is wound and how many issues she has involving the death of her husband and daughter.
5.) Inclusion One thing I can say for books is that the Amish characters display tolerance for people who may not receive such tolerance in the outside world. Characters with Down syndrome are thought of as 'God's chosen' and are never seen as a burden or taunted. There are two characters with dwarfism in here, they are regular members of the community and treated just like everyone else. Fat characters are described in glowing terms, not demonized or made to feel shame and inferiority because they are fat. And marriage is a requirement by the community (in these books), and everyone is on the marriage market. Being fat or being a dwarf or being ____ is not a huge issue like it is in other books, and it certainly doesn't mean someone is 'doomed to be single' or is 'sad and alone' due to their physical traits.
As for ANTI-inclusion, of course Amish Christian fiction is a bastion of whiteness. There is rarely RARELY a POC character in Amish Christian fiction. However, there is a black woman in this book - she's a side side side character, but she IS there. Thought I'd note it since I think it's the first time I've seen a POC character in an Amish Christian fiction.
I mean, of course Leah was living with POC in Brazil, but they were painted as basically 'jungle-living savages' who 'needed Jesus' and definitely weren't seen as equal with the Amish MCs.
MENTIONS OF GOD: ~71
HOW'S THE SEX, CARMEN?
No sex, this is Christian fiction. One hand-hold, one hand-kiss, four light kisses, one bundling scene! you don't see that everyday, one foot massage (he massages her feet). That's about it. Actually quite sexual compared to some Amish Christian Romances I've read.
TL;DR - Even though this book is not to my taste - the patriarchy in here is so disgusting - I think a fan of Amish Christian Romance would enjoy this. Like A Groom for Greta, this book adds flavor and personality to its characters, and Miller doesn't just cobble something together with no spark. I also think Leah and Thomas are complementary to each other.
ROMANCE CATEGORIES:
Contemporary Romance
Inspirational Romance
Virgin Hero Romance - Paired with a non-virgin heroine! I feel like this is worth noting, it's so rare
Non-Virgin Heroine
Widow Heroine
Amish Romance
He's a Blacksmith (he hates it), Carpenter, Organic Farmer. She's a... Nothing, her whole identity as a woman in the patriarchy is so-and-so's wife, so-and-so's mother.
November 20, 2019
..
I usually enjoy reaching Amish fiction. This was the second one of the series entitled 'Amish of Pontotoc'. They inspire romance, faith, and a positive message. Most of the characters carried over from the first book, but this one focuses on Lea, Jamie, and Peter. I definitely enjoyed this book better than the first one.
Drebbles excerpt: "Although Leah Gingrich has left the Amish faith and become Mennonite, she has remained close to her Amish family and is, in fact, helping raise her sister Hannah’s son Brandon. When a new neighbor moves in near her parents’ house, for some reason Leah immediately clashes with him even though they have a lot in common - Jamie Stolzfus is also raising his nephew. However, as much as they clash, the two are soon drawn to each other. But how can their love be if he is Amish and she is Mennonite?"
For the Amish of Pontotoc, Mississippi, faith can open minds—and hearts—to create surprising bonds for a lifetime . . .
In most books, the old Amish church leaders preached part of the services in high German, which most members didn't even understand and they discouraged members from reading the Bible, much less memorizing verses. Yet, in this series, the family spouts off scriptures incessantly, at whim. They don't offend me. It just makes me wonder if the author researched this genre thoroughly. Also, the old Amish ways are much more strict than this book leads you to believe.
Independent-minded Leah Gingerich has always been outspoken. And even though she is now a progressive Mennonite, she's rediscovering the joys of family traditions back in her Amish hometown. Yet she can't help but clash with her handsome new Amish neighbor, Jamie Stoltzfus. He's too hard-headed and old-line to see that his traumatized young nephew, Peter, needs faith and help—or that a woman who stands up to him maybe what he needs to heal . . .
This story revealed how to demonstrate faith in God in all things, even though it appeared that some were beyond their control. Religion was a huge obstacle in their world and it definitely took a toll on the relationship between Leah and Jamie.
After a devastating tragedy, Jamie moved to Pontotoc with his nephew for a fresh start. Holding fast to his beliefs is the only way he feels he can aid Peter—and himself. But somehow, Leah's freethinking ways and feisty challenges are sparking a happiness he's never felt before. Soon, Jamie can't imagine his life without her. But are their differences ultimately too great to overcome—or can love bridge their way to a future together?
There were numerous English adages bandied about that didn't seem to fit in the world of the Amish.
This installation is able to stand alone, delivers a clean and wholesome story, and against all odds, concludes with an H.E.A.
This series is currently available through the Amazon Kindle Unlimited program.
..
I usually enjoy reaching Amish fiction. This was the second one of the series entitled 'Amish of Pontotoc'. They inspire romance, faith, and a positive message. Most of the characters carried over from the first book, but this one focuses on Lea, Jamie, and Peter. I definitely enjoyed this book better than the first one.
Drebbles excerpt: "Although Leah Gingrich has left the Amish faith and become Mennonite, she has remained close to her Amish family and is, in fact, helping raise her sister Hannah’s son Brandon. When a new neighbor moves in near her parents’ house, for some reason Leah immediately clashes with him even though they have a lot in common - Jamie Stolzfus is also raising his nephew. However, as much as they clash, the two are soon drawn to each other. But how can their love be if he is Amish and she is Mennonite?"
For the Amish of Pontotoc, Mississippi, faith can open minds—and hearts—to create surprising bonds for a lifetime . . .
In most books, the old Amish church leaders preached part of the services in high German, which most members didn't even understand and they discouraged members from reading the Bible, much less memorizing verses. Yet, in this series, the family spouts off scriptures incessantly, at whim. They don't offend me. It just makes me wonder if the author researched this genre thoroughly. Also, the old Amish ways are much more strict than this book leads you to believe.
Independent-minded Leah Gingerich has always been outspoken. And even though she is now a progressive Mennonite, she's rediscovering the joys of family traditions back in her Amish hometown. Yet she can't help but clash with her handsome new Amish neighbor, Jamie Stoltzfus. He's too hard-headed and old-line to see that his traumatized young nephew, Peter, needs faith and help—or that a woman who stands up to him maybe what he needs to heal . . .
This story revealed how to demonstrate faith in God in all things, even though it appeared that some were beyond their control. Religion was a huge obstacle in their world and it definitely took a toll on the relationship between Leah and Jamie.
After a devastating tragedy, Jamie moved to Pontotoc with his nephew for a fresh start. Holding fast to his beliefs is the only way he feels he can aid Peter—and himself. But somehow, Leah's freethinking ways and feisty challenges are sparking a happiness he's never felt before. Soon, Jamie can't imagine his life without her. But are their differences ultimately too great to overcome—or can love bridge their way to a future together?
There were numerous English adages bandied about that didn't seem to fit in the world of the Amish.
This installation is able to stand alone, delivers a clean and wholesome story, and against all odds, concludes with an H.E.A.
This series is currently available through the Amazon Kindle Unlimited program.
..
January 31, 2017
I love this Amish Matchmaker series. Sara Yoder is back working her magic among the lovelorn of Seven Poplars and Thomas and Leah might be her biggest challenge yet! A serious grieving widow who can't seem to leave the past behind and a fun-loving bachelor who has been playing the field way too long. Time for them both to settle down...but with each other?! Sweet, funny and faith-filled -- the kind of romance you want to devour in one sitting.
December 4, 2016
We are back in Seven Poplars Amish community, and our Leah has returned home after loosing her husband and infant daughter. How hard it must have been for her to continue on, and we know that her faith is what leads her.
I had the feeling that she was beating herself up, and although she would embrace having more children and a husband, she doesn’t want to fall in love again. Why, because she doesn’t want the pain of loss, or because she feels she is dishonoring her late husband.
Thomas on the other hand has been living Amish, but at almost thirty has failed to make a commitment to the faith. He seems happy go lucky, and as the book opens he is being turned down from his offer of marriage, handsome Thomas, he has failed and his family think it is time to settle down and take a wife.
Thus we find these two at the Amish matchmaker, Sara, and this could be one of her first failures, and a very unlikely match. Watch as these two interact, and meet the rest of their families, I loved being reunited with Susanna and King David; these two make their family so special.
This is a fast read, mainly because you want to find out all the answers, and the only problem I had was turning the last page and still wanting more.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Love Inspired, and was not required to give a positive review.
I had the feeling that she was beating herself up, and although she would embrace having more children and a husband, she doesn’t want to fall in love again. Why, because she doesn’t want the pain of loss, or because she feels she is dishonoring her late husband.
Thomas on the other hand has been living Amish, but at almost thirty has failed to make a commitment to the faith. He seems happy go lucky, and as the book opens he is being turned down from his offer of marriage, handsome Thomas, he has failed and his family think it is time to settle down and take a wife.
Thus we find these two at the Amish matchmaker, Sara, and this could be one of her first failures, and a very unlikely match. Watch as these two interact, and meet the rest of their families, I loved being reunited with Susanna and King David; these two make their family so special.
This is a fast read, mainly because you want to find out all the answers, and the only problem I had was turning the last page and still wanting more.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Love Inspired, and was not required to give a positive review.
June 30, 2017
I enjoyed this sweet romance about practical farming people. Leah is a missionary who went to South America but her husband died there and she has returned to her Amish roots.
Other aspects of the book I like look at organic farming, which is becoming popular with the Amish as it fits their principles and they get better prices for the crops; and the value to an elderly lady of being a chaperone, if it means she gets a day trip with no work.
Enjoy. These books can be read in any order.
I downloaded an ARC from Net Galley. This is an unbiased review.
Other aspects of the book I like look at organic farming, which is becoming popular with the Amish as it fits their principles and they get better prices for the crops; and the value to an elderly lady of being a chaperone, if it means she gets a day trip with no work.
Enjoy. These books can be read in any order.
I downloaded an ARC from Net Galley. This is an unbiased review.
December 16, 2016
Leah Yoder married the first time for love. She doesn't expect, or want, to marry for love the second time. Returning home to Seven Poplars from the Amazon mission field where her husband and baby died, Leah employs the services of Amish matchmaker, Sara, to find her a suitable husband. She's looking for an older man, someone who already has children she can mother. She's NOT looking for Thomas Stutzman. Thomas is too young, too handsome and too fun-loving. When Sara matches her up with Thomas, Leah believes she's made a horrible mistake. Thomas has dated nearly every young woman in Seven Poplars and has never gotten serious with any of them. What does Sara see in him that Leah can't?
Thomas, on the other hand, is thrilled to be paired with Leah. He knows his track record doesn't look good but he's more than ready to settle down with a wife and family. When Sara challenges them to spend 6 weeks courting, Thomas thinks he can prove to Leah that he's the man for her. Leah takes the challenge to prove he's not. Who will win this battle of wills?
I definitely enjoyed this story! I've read others in the series but you don't have to read any others to like the characters in this one.
Thomas, on the other hand, is thrilled to be paired with Leah. He knows his track record doesn't look good but he's more than ready to settle down with a wife and family. When Sara challenges them to spend 6 weeks courting, Thomas thinks he can prove to Leah that he's the man for her. Leah takes the challenge to prove he's not. Who will win this battle of wills?
I definitely enjoyed this story! I've read others in the series but you don't have to read any others to like the characters in this one.
February 4, 2017
This was another delightful addition to the Amish Matchmaker series. It is filled with all of our usual secondary character's and is written with Ms Milller's usual light touch, a good bit of comedy and enough tragedy to really pluck at your heart-strings.
I have to admit that while reading this book I was torn in two different directions. This book is about a former Amish girl, Leah, that turned Mennonite for her late husband. They went on a mission to the jungle and there she lost her baby and her husband to a fever. She travels home and decides that she would like to re-marry; she wants an older widower with children so she can have a ready made family (and one or two of her own) and not take a chance on losing her heart again.
But destiny steps in when she goes to the local Amish matchmaker who disregards what Leah wants and gives her what she so desperately needs. And that is love with a wonderful man and a second chance at happiness.
I love the well drawn character's, the well thought out plot-lines, the emotional roller coaster that reading this book provided and the warmth I find every time I find myself in Seven Poplars. I can never wait for the next book to come out!
*ARC supplied by publisher.
I have to admit that while reading this book I was torn in two different directions. This book is about a former Amish girl, Leah, that turned Mennonite for her late husband. They went on a mission to the jungle and there she lost her baby and her husband to a fever. She travels home and decides that she would like to re-marry; she wants an older widower with children so she can have a ready made family (and one or two of her own) and not take a chance on losing her heart again.
But destiny steps in when she goes to the local Amish matchmaker who disregards what Leah wants and gives her what she so desperately needs. And that is love with a wonderful man and a second chance at happiness.
I love the well drawn character's, the well thought out plot-lines, the emotional roller coaster that reading this book provided and the warmth I find every time I find myself in Seven Poplars. I can never wait for the next book to come out!
*ARC supplied by publisher.
February 15, 2017
This is a book of courage, compassion, frivolity and burdens yet you have restoration of the heart with all of that. You have Leah, a widow who lost her husband and child - what a loss - a heart wrenching loss - and she has to move on from that - how do you move on from that? She takes one step at a time and it leaves scars and fears behind - then you have Thomas who was turned down on a proposal - but how can you take him seriously when he is a player - you know what I mean? Then there is a matchmaker - can they really get along? can they find something in each other to find that spark? If they find that spark can they do something about it with the scars from their past? How does GOD work in their lives each step of the way and do they listen? man is this book something else - how it just moves you - in the highest levels of your heart. I received a copy of the book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
If you would like to see more of my Christian reviews go to chriastianlybookreviewers.hotspot.com. I look forward to seeing you there.
If you would like to see more of my Christian reviews go to chriastianlybookreviewers.hotspot.com. I look forward to seeing you there.
February 8, 2017
This was a good clean read. I thought it was a might bit slow at times but it is a mindless read.
Leah was Amish and met a Mennonite man so she did not join the Church. Her missionary husband died and now a year later Leah wants to be married again. It is the Amish way. She wants to join the church and marry a nice dependable man who already has children but can give her more.
Thomas is not sure he is ready to marry but his family is pressuring him.
They both visit the Matchmaker. Do they make a good match?
Read it and find out.
Leah was Amish and met a Mennonite man so she did not join the Church. Her missionary husband died and now a year later Leah wants to be married again. It is the Amish way. She wants to join the church and marry a nice dependable man who already has children but can give her more.
Thomas is not sure he is ready to marry but his family is pressuring him.
They both visit the Matchmaker. Do they make a good match?
Read it and find out.
February 11, 2017
Emma Miller is one of my favorite Amish authors, & she didn't disappoint me w/ this story! If you've read any other books in this mini series, this is a good continuation. I'd highly recommend this book to those who like a good, clean Amish romance.
March 15, 2017
I was mesmerized by Emma Miller's 4th book in the Amish Matchmaker series. Imagining the anguish a widow who is grieving the loss of her husband and young daughter was really difficult. I have not lost a husband or daughter, but I certainly would never want to have to go through such pain. I have lost a husband through divorce however, and that includes a grief process as well. There were many emotional hurdles to overcome when I married my incredibly wonderful second husband.
I willingly joined in fellowship with another denomination with my husband even after having served as a pastor's wife previously, and the differences between the Mennonites and Amish are much greater than what I experienced in my decision-making process. I love reading Amish fiction. The characters in this story were all lovable although there was one character that was trying on Leah's nerves. I have definitely had relationships with women who interfered in other people's business as this one also another issue explored in the book.
I would like to recommend this novel to those lovers of Amish and Christian fiction.
My rating for this novel is 5 stars.
I received a copy of this book from netgalley and the publisher. A positive review was not required. All opinions expressed are my own.
I willingly joined in fellowship with another denomination with my husband even after having served as a pastor's wife previously, and the differences between the Mennonites and Amish are much greater than what I experienced in my decision-making process. I love reading Amish fiction. The characters in this story were all lovable although there was one character that was trying on Leah's nerves. I have definitely had relationships with women who interfered in other people's business as this one also another issue explored in the book.
I would like to recommend this novel to those lovers of Amish and Christian fiction.
My rating for this novel is 5 stars.
I received a copy of this book from netgalley and the publisher. A positive review was not required. All opinions expressed are my own.
March 19, 2017
Loved the book, by Emma Miller. She never disappoints me!
A tangled web of characters, and backgrounds, most of who have known each other for most of their lives.
Leah, has lost her hubby and daughter in the jungle, while serving as a missionary. Full of heartbreak, and still mourning her losses, she has decided to return to her family and Amish faith, knowing that everyone thinks she should move on, and remarry.
A CUTE story of heartbreak and happiness, and also so many misunderstandings.
I would recommend that you read the first books in the series, before reading this one. You will be glad that you did!
A tangled web of characters, and backgrounds, most of who have known each other for most of their lives.
Leah, has lost her hubby and daughter in the jungle, while serving as a missionary. Full of heartbreak, and still mourning her losses, she has decided to return to her family and Amish faith, knowing that everyone thinks she should move on, and remarry.
A CUTE story of heartbreak and happiness, and also so many misunderstandings.
I would recommend that you read the first books in the series, before reading this one. You will be glad that you did!
Read
March 16, 2017"It is great to see some familiar characters in Miller’s latest Amish Matchmaker release. While it could be read as a stand-alone, it is best to read the series in order to fully appreciate the character development and understand Sara’s role in the community. Miller also educates the reader on a little-known Amish practice known as bundling" (4 stars @ RT Book Reviews).
Miniseries:
Miniseries:
February 6, 2017
I read this on the Kindle
This is the 4th book in the Amish Matchmaker series
It a good one but did feel that Leah for all she suppose to be strong woman she let the aunt of her dead husband say things that she should have said something about or at least stand up for herself
She wants a marriage to suit her no love involved i would have thought that is one thing that should be taken in to account if you read the bible
Overall a good book
This is the 4th book in the Amish Matchmaker series
It a good one but did feel that Leah for all she suppose to be strong woman she let the aunt of her dead husband say things that she should have said something about or at least stand up for herself
She wants a marriage to suit her no love involved i would have thought that is one thing that should be taken in to account if you read the bible
Overall a good book
May 5, 2017
If you've read "Leah's Choice" you'll want to read this one, where Leah returns as a widow and decides that she wants to remarry, something Daniel made her promise just moments before he died.... Read this, but consider having a cry rag handy just in case.
June 25, 2017
A wonderful story of finding love where you least expect it. A perfect match between the main characters and the ending was fabulous. The indecisive ways of Leah and the persistence of Thomas lend to the charm of this story.
July 14, 2017
I was happy to see Leah back at home, but sad for her circumstances as to why she was back home.
September 7, 2017
Light hearted book, but very disappointed in the silly ending. A delicate subject about second loves that could have been very interesting, but was treated lightly.
October 10, 2017
This was an easy, safe read. There were some elements of the plot that bothered me, but I don't want to spoil the book for others. I will read another of this author's books.
July 30, 2018
Another great Amish story by Emma Miller. I love how real and likable the characters are (except aunt Martha). I really enjoy reading about how the Amish all come together to help each other out.
July 20, 2023
I REFUSE to read this book.
And I'm SO FURIOUSLY ANGRY at the author for what she did here, that I could spit nails. HOW DARE SHE! I mean, Leah was the *ONLY* heroine in "Hannah's Daughters" series -AND- the "Amish Matchmaker" series that chose to leave the Amish and have a different faith/lifestyle.
Well, SCREW YOU, readers. We can't have that!
Allowing people choices? No, way. Not Emma Miller.
Miller uses her insular little world where she obviously needs to play megalomaniac and control everyone, and it's crap. How petty and awful it is to make it so that if ANYONE tries to follow Elohim and not the Ordnung she'll kill their spouses and children?!? There, that's what you get for following the Call of the Lord!!!, she conveys with snotty aplomb via this absolute drivel.
This book does not exist. Period. Leah had a beautiful story (HD#4), she meets and marries an incredible man, they take up the calling of the Lord, and they go to help people in another part of the world, reaching out and sharing God's love.
THIS pile of sh!t doesn't exist. Leah's still there. She and Daniel are happy, they're having babies, they're touching lives.
I. WON'T. READ. IT.
And shame on her for doing this.
And I'm SO FURIOUSLY ANGRY at the author for what she did here, that I could spit nails. HOW DARE SHE! I mean, Leah was the *ONLY* heroine in "Hannah's Daughters" series -AND- the "Amish Matchmaker" series that chose to leave the Amish and have a different faith/lifestyle.
Well, SCREW YOU, readers. We can't have that!
Allowing people choices? No, way. Not Emma Miller.
Miller uses her insular little world where she obviously needs to play megalomaniac and control everyone, and it's crap. How petty and awful it is to make it so that if ANYONE tries to follow Elohim and not the Ordnung she'll kill their spouses and children?!? There, that's what you get for following the Call of the Lord!!!, she conveys with snotty aplomb via this absolute drivel.
This book does not exist. Period. Leah had a beautiful story (HD#4), she meets and marries an incredible man, they take up the calling of the Lord, and they go to help people in another part of the world, reaching out and sharing God's love.
THIS pile of sh!t doesn't exist. Leah's still there. She and Daniel are happy, they're having babies, they're touching lives.
I. WON'T. READ. IT.
And shame on her for doing this.
January 24, 2024
A great story of loss and finding love again.
Leah, a widow has returned back home after loosing not only her husband but also her young son. She contacts a matchmaker to find her a older man with children for a marriage of convenience .
Thomas is single again after his long time girlfriend has broken up with him after he ask her to marry him. He is needing to find a wife or else take a chance of loosing the farm his grandfather has always promised him.
The matchmaker thinks Leah and Thomas would make a great match. Will Leah agree to this even though she had requested an older man with children? Will Thomas fall for Leah?
Leah, a widow has returned back home after loosing not only her husband but also her young son. She contacts a matchmaker to find her a older man with children for a marriage of convenience .
Thomas is single again after his long time girlfriend has broken up with him after he ask her to marry him. He is needing to find a wife or else take a chance of loosing the farm his grandfather has always promised him.
The matchmaker thinks Leah and Thomas would make a great match. Will Leah agree to this even though she had requested an older man with children? Will Thomas fall for Leah?
October 3, 2021
This book in the series can stand alone.
Leah and Thomas are likeable and their journey of getting to know each other has good moments but is also fairly average with no great highs or lows until the conflict.
I think the conflict is predictable, albeit a little strong. The resolution is interesting if, like me, you've never heard of it before.
This book is a quick read as long as you are able to push through the average portions.
Mature themes: not really. No sex or violence is described. The main characters avoid alcohol.
Leah and Thomas are likeable and their journey of getting to know each other has good moments but is also fairly average with no great highs or lows until the conflict.
I think the conflict is predictable, albeit a little strong. The resolution is interesting if, like me, you've never heard of it before.
This book is a quick read as long as you are able to push through the average portions.
Mature themes: not really. No sex or violence is described. The main characters avoid alcohol.
February 20, 2022
The concept of bundling is very interesting. I've never heard of it before.
September 9, 2024
fair to fine
December 17, 2016
"A Love for Leah" is the second book I have read in the "Amish Matchmaker" series. I really enjoy these books as they are light-hearted, fun reads. Leah and Thomas are both likable characters and Thomas could be quite amusing at times. About the only complaint I have, and it's a small one, is that they almost feel like they fell in love a bit too quick. Overall, though, it was a fun read and I will continue reading more of this series.
Read
February 6, 2017
April 26, 2017
Sweet story
May 3, 2017
I really enjoy Amish books and this one is a good read. The story is well written, heart warming, and full of faith. I know you are going to love this one.
Widow Leah Yoder married the love of her life; she and her husband served as missionaries in Brazil. After the death of her husband and small child she returns to her Amish home. She is determined to start over, all she wants now is to find an elderly widower, have children, and make a new life. She hires a matchmaker but the man she chooses is nothing like what she wants.
Thomas Stutzman decides it's time to marry so he goes to the matchmaker to find a wife for him. Thomas is a young, fun loving farmer. He is drawn to the beautiful Leah. Could she really be the one he's looking for? They agree to see each other but neither sees a future for them.
A journey of two people who think they know what they want but God has a better plan than either of them have considered. God has a plan for you too. Just surrender your heart to Him and watch Him turn your life around.
Widow Leah Yoder married the love of her life; she and her husband served as missionaries in Brazil. After the death of her husband and small child she returns to her Amish home. She is determined to start over, all she wants now is to find an elderly widower, have children, and make a new life. She hires a matchmaker but the man she chooses is nothing like what she wants.
Thomas Stutzman decides it's time to marry so he goes to the matchmaker to find a wife for him. Thomas is a young, fun loving farmer. He is drawn to the beautiful Leah. Could she really be the one he's looking for? They agree to see each other but neither sees a future for them.
A journey of two people who think they know what they want but God has a better plan than either of them have considered. God has a plan for you too. Just surrender your heart to Him and watch Him turn your life around.
November 22, 2017
A Love for Leah is a heartwarming book written by Emma Miller. This is an inspirational romance book that is centered in Seven Poplars, Delaware and Sara the matchmaker. Leah who is one of Hannah's daughters, has recently moved back home after the death of her husband and baby.
Leah has decided it is time for her to remarry so she seeks out Sara the local matchmaker. Leah married for love the first so now she is seeking a marriage of convenience so she can have more babies. When Sara comes up with the perfect match for Leah, Leah disagrees and so does Thomas. Has Sara hit the proverbial nail on the head with this match? Why does Leah and Thomas agree they are not suited? As you follow this winding road will it lead to marriage ? What does Thomas do to cause Leah to call off the courtship?
I enjoyed this story immensely and the characters are amazing. We also get to keep up with the characters from previous books. The storyline is so heartwarming that you actually feel heartbroken in several places. The author writes this story with very detailed descriptions so nothing is left for the readers to wonder about. If I am not mistaken there will be another book in this series because sweet, adorable, strong-willed Ellie still has not found her match! Or has she? For a little person she has big expectations. But that is why I love her character.
I was not given an complimentary copy of this book to read and review. All opinions and statements expressed are strictly my own. I have rated this book with five stars for meeting my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others.
Congratulations to Emma Miller on once again writing and releasing an excellent book for her readers. I will be reading more books from this author in the future.
Leah has decided it is time for her to remarry so she seeks out Sara the local matchmaker. Leah married for love the first so now she is seeking a marriage of convenience so she can have more babies. When Sara comes up with the perfect match for Leah, Leah disagrees and so does Thomas. Has Sara hit the proverbial nail on the head with this match? Why does Leah and Thomas agree they are not suited? As you follow this winding road will it lead to marriage ? What does Thomas do to cause Leah to call off the courtship?
I enjoyed this story immensely and the characters are amazing. We also get to keep up with the characters from previous books. The storyline is so heartwarming that you actually feel heartbroken in several places. The author writes this story with very detailed descriptions so nothing is left for the readers to wonder about. If I am not mistaken there will be another book in this series because sweet, adorable, strong-willed Ellie still has not found her match! Or has she? For a little person she has big expectations. But that is why I love her character.
I was not given an complimentary copy of this book to read and review. All opinions and statements expressed are strictly my own. I have rated this book with five stars for meeting my expectations of a wonderful story that I can highly recommend to others.
Congratulations to Emma Miller on once again writing and releasing an excellent book for her readers. I will be reading more books from this author in the future.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 33 reviews