What do you think?
Rate this book
Lone Star Hero #1
The Loyal Heart
Robert Truax, former Second Lieutenant and Confederate officer in the Civil War, made a promise to his comrade Phillip Markham. If anything happened to Phillip, Robert would look after his beloved wife, Miranda. She was his life, his world, his everything.
399 pages, Library Binding
First published July 1, 2016
91 people are currently reading
1489 people want to read
About the author
Shelley Shepard Gray
126 books2,314 followersLibrarian Note: AKA Shelley Gray (Western Romance).
Shelley Shepard Gray has published over seventy novels. She currently writes Amish romances for Harper Collins, Kensington, and Simon & Schuster and contemporary women’s fiction for Blackstone Publishing.
Her novels have been Holt Medallion winners and Inspirational Readers Choice and Carol finalists. Shelley’s novels have appeared on both the New York Times and USA Today bestseller lists.
Her novels have been highlighted in the Philadelphia Enquirer, Washington Post, Time Magazine, and USA Today. She has also been interviewed on NPR as well as numerous regional radio stations.
Before writing romances, Shelley lived in Texas and Colorado, where she taught school and earned both her bachelor’s degree in English literature and elementary education and later obtained her master’s degree in educational administration. She currently lives in Colorado Springs and writes full time. Shelley is married, the mother of two young adults, and always has a dachshund by her side. She is an active member of her church, on Facebook and on Twitter. She also has a website, www.shelleyshepardgray.com.
t
Shelley Shepard Gray has published over seventy novels. She currently writes Amish romances for Harper Collins, Kensington, and Simon & Schuster and contemporary women’s fiction for Blackstone Publishing.
Her novels have been Holt Medallion winners and Inspirational Readers Choice and Carol finalists. Shelley’s novels have appeared on both the New York Times and USA Today bestseller lists.
Her novels have been highlighted in the Philadelphia Enquirer, Washington Post, Time Magazine, and USA Today. She has also been interviewed on NPR as well as numerous regional radio stations.
Before writing romances, Shelley lived in Texas and Colorado, where she taught school and earned both her bachelor’s degree in English literature and elementary education and later obtained her master’s degree in educational administration. She currently lives in Colorado Springs and writes full time. Shelley is married, the mother of two young adults, and always has a dachshund by her side. She is an active member of her church, on Facebook and on Twitter. She also has a website, www.shelleyshepardgray.com.
t
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 224 reviews
May 3, 2017
Rating: 3.5
This was a good story revolving around 3 honorable men who fought for the Confederacy and were then captured and spent the remainder of the war in a prison camp on an island in Lake Michigan. The 3 men promised one another as well as a fallen comrade that they would always be there for one another. Philip's beloved wife, Miranda, was his main concern before he died. When trouble befalls her, one of his comrades, Robert Truax, heads to Galveston to see if he can help her. With the other two arriving later on to assist both Robert and Miranda.
I really enjoyed the relationship between the 3 men. Their promise to always be there for one another as well as Philip's wife was important to each of them. It was evident how strong their connection was. Robert's story of becoming a self-made man from an orphaned childhood and scrabbling for everything depicted how strong and determined he was to improve himself. But he still fought lack of self-confidence and feelings that he wasn't good enough. Miranda learned that she was stronger than she thought and had more of a will to live than her grief and troubles indicated to her. I appreciated the slow growing feelings between Robert and Miranda.
There were a couple of things in this book that brought my rating down. First, I loved the reminiscences and background of the soldiers; but I found that several times the transition from one chapter to the next with background story was awkward. Second, there were a few places where I felt a scene was inserted in the chapter that really wasn't necessary to the flow of the chapter. Finally, the faith thread was very light throughout the book. I noted that the library had marked it Inspirational rather than Christian Fiction.
I do look forward to reading more of this series as I would like to find out what happens to the other men.
FAVORITE QUOTES:
"But he did say from time to time that a man can't be judged only by the region where he lives or the dialect in his speech...That was his way of reminding me that every soldier in the North wasn't a terrible person, just like every man in the south wasn't perfect either."
"Love isn't full of conditions or threaded with threats and pain."
"What does God want?...God wants us to find solace in each other. To remember to give thanks for what we have. To love the people we care about and show kindness to people we don't. He wants us to live and breathe and learn from our past....He does not want us to find retribution. That is for Him to do, not us.
This was a good story revolving around 3 honorable men who fought for the Confederacy and were then captured and spent the remainder of the war in a prison camp on an island in Lake Michigan. The 3 men promised one another as well as a fallen comrade that they would always be there for one another. Philip's beloved wife, Miranda, was his main concern before he died. When trouble befalls her, one of his comrades, Robert Truax, heads to Galveston to see if he can help her. With the other two arriving later on to assist both Robert and Miranda.
I really enjoyed the relationship between the 3 men. Their promise to always be there for one another as well as Philip's wife was important to each of them. It was evident how strong their connection was. Robert's story of becoming a self-made man from an orphaned childhood and scrabbling for everything depicted how strong and determined he was to improve himself. But he still fought lack of self-confidence and feelings that he wasn't good enough. Miranda learned that she was stronger than she thought and had more of a will to live than her grief and troubles indicated to her. I appreciated the slow growing feelings between Robert and Miranda.
There were a couple of things in this book that brought my rating down. First, I loved the reminiscences and background of the soldiers; but I found that several times the transition from one chapter to the next with background story was awkward. Second, there were a few places where I felt a scene was inserted in the chapter that really wasn't necessary to the flow of the chapter. Finally, the faith thread was very light throughout the book. I noted that the library had marked it Inspirational rather than Christian Fiction.
I do look forward to reading more of this series as I would like to find out what happens to the other men.
FAVORITE QUOTES:
"But he did say from time to time that a man can't be judged only by the region where he lives or the dialect in his speech...That was his way of reminding me that every soldier in the North wasn't a terrible person, just like every man in the south wasn't perfect either."
"Love isn't full of conditions or threaded with threats and pain."
"What does God want?...God wants us to find solace in each other. To remember to give thanks for what we have. To love the people we care about and show kindness to people we don't. He wants us to live and breathe and learn from our past....He does not want us to find retribution. That is for Him to do, not us.
August 3, 2016
Not only is Shelley Shepard Gray's new series a Texas romance but it’s a post-Civil-War-Texas romance. And as much as I love reading Civil War era fiction, I love reading about the Reconstruction years even more. The emotions and the uncertainty and the “feeling adrift” that many experienced are so intriguing to me. Everything as the South knew it changed and where there had once been hope and confidence there was suddenly very little of either. It is this very psychology that Gray portrays through her characters in The Loyal Heart.
Shelley Shepard Gray starts her newest series off with a mix of strong and memorable characters sure to delight and intrigue readers. In fact, the character I found most compelling – Ethan Kelley – is only in the present story briefly but he made such a vivid impression that I’m hoping he gets his own book later on in the series! The thread of suspense adds extra dimension and emotion to the plot of The Loyal Heart and keeps the story moving at a steady pace. The romance is quite simply delightful – blossoming from a friendship at a natural progression that made me smile and swoon interchangeably. I’m already looking forward to the next book in the series, which features a character we didn’t see much of at all in this one, and wishing February would hurry up and get here so I can read it
(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)
See my full review at Reading Is My SuperPower
Shelley Shepard Gray starts her newest series off with a mix of strong and memorable characters sure to delight and intrigue readers. In fact, the character I found most compelling – Ethan Kelley – is only in the present story briefly but he made such a vivid impression that I’m hoping he gets his own book later on in the series! The thread of suspense adds extra dimension and emotion to the plot of The Loyal Heart and keeps the story moving at a steady pace. The romance is quite simply delightful – blossoming from a friendship at a natural progression that made me smile and swoon interchangeably. I’m already looking forward to the next book in the series, which features a character we didn’t see much of at all in this one, and wishing February would hurry up and get here so I can read it
(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)
See my full review at Reading Is My SuperPower
July 1, 2019
The Loyal Heart (2016, Zondervan), first in the Lone Star Hero series by Shelley Shepard Gray, is a Christian romance set at the end of the Civil War. I requested this book from NetGalley (in exchange for an honest review) because Ms. Gray has been on my list of authors to try for some time now. I’m so glad I did, as I enjoyed the story very much!
The Heroine:
Miranda Markham is a widow. Her husband, a Confederate officer, died in a POW camp shortly before he would have been released. In order to eke out a living, Miranda has opened the mansion she inherited from her husband as a boarding house. She is struggling with grief, rumors about her husband being a traitor, and resentment from her in-laws, as well as other problems. It is almost too much for her to bear. Fortunately, she has some very faithful, upstanding servants... and a hero soon to come into the picture.
The Hero:
Robert Truaxx was a Confederate soldier stuck in a POW camp. Fortunately, he had a small, close-knit group of Confederate officers there to help keep up his spirits, and they shared a pact to look after one another once the war was over. Phillip Markham, Miranda’s husband, was in this group. After months pass, Robert stays as a guest at Miranda’s boarding house to make sure she’s doing well. He’s appalled to learn how bad her situation is, and is committed to help her get through her problems.
What I liked:
*The way Ms. Gray has written this story is, in my opinion, masterful. I am so looking forward to reading more of her works in the future. I don’t tend to read Amish fiction, but I would love to try another of her Christian novels, or one of her Westerns (as Shelley Gray).
*Miranda’s character is complex. She is beaten down, yet slowly moving forward. She is grieving, yet ready for healing. Robert, too, is an excellent character. He is very sensitive toward Miranda, but at the same time, he is very strong for her. Both characters are well-drawn, and the secondary characters are also impressive!
What I didn’t like:
*I always find grieving widows a bit hard to handle emotionally. I’ve never been there and really don’t want to be. But I found the grief to be believable without overwhelming me, so my “didn’t like” is actually almost a “like.”
I’d recommend this book to fans of Christian or historical romance. The book is a clean read, but there is some violence. I look forward to reading the second book in the series, which I’m hoping will have one of Robert’s comrades as the hero.
The Heroine:
Miranda Markham is a widow. Her husband, a Confederate officer, died in a POW camp shortly before he would have been released. In order to eke out a living, Miranda has opened the mansion she inherited from her husband as a boarding house. She is struggling with grief, rumors about her husband being a traitor, and resentment from her in-laws, as well as other problems. It is almost too much for her to bear. Fortunately, she has some very faithful, upstanding servants... and a hero soon to come into the picture.
The Hero:
Robert Truaxx was a Confederate soldier stuck in a POW camp. Fortunately, he had a small, close-knit group of Confederate officers there to help keep up his spirits, and they shared a pact to look after one another once the war was over. Phillip Markham, Miranda’s husband, was in this group. After months pass, Robert stays as a guest at Miranda’s boarding house to make sure she’s doing well. He’s appalled to learn how bad her situation is, and is committed to help her get through her problems.
What I liked:
*The way Ms. Gray has written this story is, in my opinion, masterful. I am so looking forward to reading more of her works in the future. I don’t tend to read Amish fiction, but I would love to try another of her Christian novels, or one of her Westerns (as Shelley Gray).
*Miranda’s character is complex. She is beaten down, yet slowly moving forward. She is grieving, yet ready for healing. Robert, too, is an excellent character. He is very sensitive toward Miranda, but at the same time, he is very strong for her. Both characters are well-drawn, and the secondary characters are also impressive!
What I didn’t like:
*I always find grieving widows a bit hard to handle emotionally. I’ve never been there and really don’t want to be. But I found the grief to be believable without overwhelming me, so my “didn’t like” is actually almost a “like.”
I’d recommend this book to fans of Christian or historical romance. The book is a clean read, but there is some violence. I look forward to reading the second book in the series, which I’m hoping will have one of Robert’s comrades as the hero.
August 25, 2016
Chivalry lives! I read lots of reviews describing swoon worthy moments. This is the first novel I've read that has compelled me to use that term. The Loyal Heart absolutely included swoon worthy moments. I adored the heroes in this novel. They each exhibited a no nonsense, take care of it attitude to problems. And oh boy, did main character Miranda Markham have problems.
In addition to all the swooning, I loved the way the author unfolded the story. There was a certain amount of tension or underlying current to the novel that wasn't clear initially. The story slowly built to a crescendo and then ended with a lot of action.
The setting in both Ohio and Galveston, Texas was well described and easy to visualize. I could feel the cold in Ohio and the humidity in Galveston.
I've also read the Chicago World's Fair Mystery Series. While it was good and I enjoyed each of the novels, The Loyal Heart is my new favorite by Shelley Shepard Gray. I eagerly await the next book in the series.
My gratitude to publisher TNZ and its Fiction Guild for a complimentary copy of the novel. The opinions expressed are my own.
In addition to all the swooning, I loved the way the author unfolded the story. There was a certain amount of tension or underlying current to the novel that wasn't clear initially. The story slowly built to a crescendo and then ended with a lot of action.
The setting in both Ohio and Galveston, Texas was well described and easy to visualize. I could feel the cold in Ohio and the humidity in Galveston.
I've also read the Chicago World's Fair Mystery Series. While it was good and I enjoyed each of the novels, The Loyal Heart is my new favorite by Shelley Shepard Gray. I eagerly await the next book in the series.
My gratitude to publisher TNZ and its Fiction Guild for a complimentary copy of the novel. The opinions expressed are my own.
August 15, 2016
An exciting new series (A Lone Star Hero's Love Story) by an author I adore! I love the premise of the series -- desperate men in a desperate situation making a pact to watch out for one another even after the war ends. It speaks of their honour and valour and put this reader into a bit of a tailspin 'cause there's nothing so swoony as a take charge hero who's got your back.
Gray tackles the difficult subject of depression in The Loyal Heart. Miranda has been victimized and subjected to relentless cruelty for so long that it's taken its toll. She's in a vulnerable place when Robert arrives on her doorstep. I love the way she is able to draw from his strength and kindness. It's like a rebirth slowly takes place over the course of the novel and Miranda comes out better, stronger and more sure of herself than ever before. Wonderful growth -- both in character and in the relationship that sparks between the Lieutenant and the widow.
Robert is a self-made man who dons the veneer of gentlemanly manners with ease. He's a delicious contradiction of cold steel and passionate heat. And gallantly devoted to easing Miranda's pain. He's half in love with her before he even steps over the threshold of her boarding house -- at least with the impression her enamoured husband has left with him. I think it's fair to call Robert noble. He wouldn't agree since he's of lowly birth and had to scrape for a living until he joined the army. Such a deliciously complicated man and the perfect complement for Miranda.
The suspense is intriguing and it take outsiders to cut through the tangled web of deceit which has trapped more than just Miranda in its sticky mess. Compelling secondary characters -- both purely evil and divinely good -- flesh out this captivating read. Eagerly awaiting book two.
My thanks to Zondervan Publishing and Litfuse Publicity for providing me with a copy of this book.
Gray tackles the difficult subject of depression in The Loyal Heart. Miranda has been victimized and subjected to relentless cruelty for so long that it's taken its toll. She's in a vulnerable place when Robert arrives on her doorstep. I love the way she is able to draw from his strength and kindness. It's like a rebirth slowly takes place over the course of the novel and Miranda comes out better, stronger and more sure of herself than ever before. Wonderful growth -- both in character and in the relationship that sparks between the Lieutenant and the widow.
Robert is a self-made man who dons the veneer of gentlemanly manners with ease. He's a delicious contradiction of cold steel and passionate heat. And gallantly devoted to easing Miranda's pain. He's half in love with her before he even steps over the threshold of her boarding house -- at least with the impression her enamoured husband has left with him. I think it's fair to call Robert noble. He wouldn't agree since he's of lowly birth and had to scrape for a living until he joined the army. Such a deliciously complicated man and the perfect complement for Miranda.
The suspense is intriguing and it take outsiders to cut through the tangled web of deceit which has trapped more than just Miranda in its sticky mess. Compelling secondary characters -- both purely evil and divinely good -- flesh out this captivating read. Eagerly awaiting book two.
My thanks to Zondervan Publishing and Litfuse Publicity for providing me with a copy of this book.
August 16, 2016
The Loyal Heart was an interesting story. I liked the setting of post-Civil War Galveston, Texas. I also enjoyed reading the flashbacks to the prisoner of war camp. I felt as if these flashbacks allowed me to understand Robert Truax and the men he served with.
I was intrigued with the way Miranda Markham’s good name and standing in the town had been completely dissolved with rumors and innuendo. The mystery of who was behind the rumors and threats kept me reading to discover the culprit. Without going into detail because I certainly don’t want to spoil anything in a book for a reader, I have to say that in real life, I am not sure that the even the events at the end of the book could have truly restored Miranda’s good name after so many had believed and spread the rumors.
Parts of the book moved slowly for me, even though I enjoyed the story. The pace did pick up in the latter half of the book and I enjoyed seeing how things came together. This novel contains mystery and a light romance.
I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
I was intrigued with the way Miranda Markham’s good name and standing in the town had been completely dissolved with rumors and innuendo. The mystery of who was behind the rumors and threats kept me reading to discover the culprit. Without going into detail because I certainly don’t want to spoil anything in a book for a reader, I have to say that in real life, I am not sure that the even the events at the end of the book could have truly restored Miranda’s good name after so many had believed and spread the rumors.
Parts of the book moved slowly for me, even though I enjoyed the story. The pace did pick up in the latter half of the book and I enjoyed seeing how things came together. This novel contains mystery and a light romance.
I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
June 29, 2016
Mystery, drama and romance in post-Civil War Texas!
A Civil War widow in serious need of help, finds it and more in the former comrades of her husband in this Reconstruction era tale.
The setting of Galveston Island, Texas, a year following the war's end made an interesting backdrop to the story, with a bit of mystery, suspense, action later on, and a little romance. Filling in the backstory of Miranda and Phillip's marriage, and his time in the prison camp together with his fellow soldiers, gave a good picture of what a remarkable man he had been. The loyalty and honor that his former unit showed in dropping everything to help his widow proved it too. He was an unsung hero and an important character in the story though absent. The bit of intrigue and drama towards the end made this a satisfying read. It seemed to finally snap together and look like Miranda's life might have a hopeful outcome after all she'd endured. Robert was a complex character, being a real hero for her, but still unsure of himself. With the many characters introduced, I hope we will see more of them in the rest of the series.
Recommend for fans of clean, historical fiction with some interjections of faith.
3.5 stars
(Book provided by NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for my honest review.)
A Civil War widow in serious need of help, finds it and more in the former comrades of her husband in this Reconstruction era tale.
The setting of Galveston Island, Texas, a year following the war's end made an interesting backdrop to the story, with a bit of mystery, suspense, action later on, and a little romance. Filling in the backstory of Miranda and Phillip's marriage, and his time in the prison camp together with his fellow soldiers, gave a good picture of what a remarkable man he had been. The loyalty and honor that his former unit showed in dropping everything to help his widow proved it too. He was an unsung hero and an important character in the story though absent. The bit of intrigue and drama towards the end made this a satisfying read. It seemed to finally snap together and look like Miranda's life might have a hopeful outcome after all she'd endured. Robert was a complex character, being a real hero for her, but still unsure of himself. With the many characters introduced, I hope we will see more of them in the rest of the series.
Recommend for fans of clean, historical fiction with some interjections of faith.
3.5 stars
(Book provided by NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for my honest review.)
September 5, 2016
The book slump is a real thing, my friends. And this one in particular feels like it will never come to an end.
From the beginning, I really like Robert. He was very protective of Miranda, and I liked how he would take control of a bad situation and defend her honor.
Eventually, I did start to lose interest. This is mostly due to the fact that this time period and setting don't typically hold my interest, and the main conflict did not intrigue me throughout the novel.
At one point, I felt like Robert started crossing lines with his overwhelming need to always step in, even in situations where he was not asked.
I skimmed the last half of the book because I wanted to know if Miranda got her happy ending.
I'm sad to say this book wasn't a new favorite for me. I have really enjoyed Whispers in the Reading Room by this author, so I do plan to try her books again in the future.
*I received this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review. All opinions stated here are my own.*
From the beginning, I really like Robert. He was very protective of Miranda, and I liked how he would take control of a bad situation and defend her honor.
Eventually, I did start to lose interest. This is mostly due to the fact that this time period and setting don't typically hold my interest, and the main conflict did not intrigue me throughout the novel.
At one point, I felt like Robert started crossing lines with his overwhelming need to always step in, even in situations where he was not asked.
I skimmed the last half of the book because I wanted to know if Miranda got her happy ending.
I'm sad to say this book wasn't a new favorite for me. I have really enjoyed Whispers in the Reading Room by this author, so I do plan to try her books again in the future.
*I received this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review. All opinions stated here are my own.*
August 24, 2016
The Loyal Heart by Shelley Shepard Gray is a Christian historical romance and I loved it. It is set in the aftermath of the American Civil War. Bonds and vows sworn in war time were not easily broken. The novel follows the fortunes of one group of men who pledged loyalty to each other.
No matter who 'wins' the war, the reality is - everyone loses. Husbands, sons, brothers, fathers, friends on both sides perished. War changes people. Peace time can be hard to live through if loved ones are lost. The novel deals with the subject of deep depression and thoughts of suicide. "Perhaps today was not the day to die after all. " War robs people of hope. People mourn the loss of their dreams. "Men and women of strong grit survived instead of giving up." It takes courage and determination to live without ones loved ones.
God is at the heart of the novel. Miranda has faith in God but at her lowest moment cries out "Jesus why? I thought you suffered so much so I wouldn't have to." As Christians we are never promised that bad things and bad times won't happen because they will. "The Lord never promised an easy life, only that He wouldn't forsake her."
Within the novel the past, present and future all interconnect. "The past always treads on our present." Living through war means that one may have bad memories that surface without warning. It is PTSD but was not recognised as such in the 1860's. People need love and help to survive. The future may look uncertain but "the future is already in God's hands" - and that means there is hope.
The novel has the theme of loyalty. There is the loyalty of soldiers and the loyalty of a household. In tough times both support all their members.
There is a blossoming romance, gently unfolding throughout the novel. The reader becomes aware of it before the protagonists.
I thoroughly enjoyed The Loyal Heart. I enjoy all Shelley Shepard Gray's writings and always know that I will be in for a cracking read.
A wonderful story masterfully crafted.
I received this book for free in exchange for a fair and honest review. No monetary compensation was received and all views expressed are my own.
No matter who 'wins' the war, the reality is - everyone loses. Husbands, sons, brothers, fathers, friends on both sides perished. War changes people. Peace time can be hard to live through if loved ones are lost. The novel deals with the subject of deep depression and thoughts of suicide. "Perhaps today was not the day to die after all. " War robs people of hope. People mourn the loss of their dreams. "Men and women of strong grit survived instead of giving up." It takes courage and determination to live without ones loved ones.
God is at the heart of the novel. Miranda has faith in God but at her lowest moment cries out "Jesus why? I thought you suffered so much so I wouldn't have to." As Christians we are never promised that bad things and bad times won't happen because they will. "The Lord never promised an easy life, only that He wouldn't forsake her."
Within the novel the past, present and future all interconnect. "The past always treads on our present." Living through war means that one may have bad memories that surface without warning. It is PTSD but was not recognised as such in the 1860's. People need love and help to survive. The future may look uncertain but "the future is already in God's hands" - and that means there is hope.
The novel has the theme of loyalty. There is the loyalty of soldiers and the loyalty of a household. In tough times both support all their members.
There is a blossoming romance, gently unfolding throughout the novel. The reader becomes aware of it before the protagonists.
I thoroughly enjoyed The Loyal Heart. I enjoy all Shelley Shepard Gray's writings and always know that I will be in for a cracking read.
A wonderful story masterfully crafted.
I received this book for free in exchange for a fair and honest review. No monetary compensation was received and all views expressed are my own.
May 13, 2017
I was excited to read The Loyal Heart, and while I don't really feel like the novel lived up to my excitement, overall, I still liked it and enjoyed the read.
My favorite thing about the novel is the brotherhood between former Confederate soldiers, which the series itself is build on, which is a plus. Robert Truax and his friends and fellow soldiers were captured in course of the Civil War and made a pact to always be there for one another, even after the war is over. The details of their time spent as prisoners of war is saddening and compelling, setting the groundwork for the friendship that would carry them through imprisonment and beyond.
I also loved the aspect of chivalry that is present throughout the novel. It's refreshing to have a male lead that's a bit rough around the edges but still determined to do the right thing. I also love the other men, Devin Monroe and Ethan Kelly. I was hoping that Ethan's story was next, but alas, it's one of the men that are not featured in this book, Thomas Baker. I do hope we'll see both of them again in future books.
Miranda Markham was not a main character that I connected with strongly, and that lack of emotion did color how I read the story. I actually preferred Belle, her maid, ha! I did appreciate that Miranda dealt with bouts of melancholy, but I didn't care for the way that people tiptoed around her when it was unnecessary to do so. The plot is a bit meandering as well, with mystery being focused on too late into the story. I thought the mysterious letters would be a big part of the story, but once all is found out, it kind of fizzles out rather quickly. I did like how once the men decided to act, they were very decisive with their actions and words.
The Loyal Heart was a quick read, and I like the post-Civil War time period. Although I didn't love this one, I do plan on reading at least the next book in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
My favorite thing about the novel is the brotherhood between former Confederate soldiers, which the series itself is build on, which is a plus. Robert Truax and his friends and fellow soldiers were captured in course of the Civil War and made a pact to always be there for one another, even after the war is over. The details of their time spent as prisoners of war is saddening and compelling, setting the groundwork for the friendship that would carry them through imprisonment and beyond.
I also loved the aspect of chivalry that is present throughout the novel. It's refreshing to have a male lead that's a bit rough around the edges but still determined to do the right thing. I also love the other men, Devin Monroe and Ethan Kelly. I was hoping that Ethan's story was next, but alas, it's one of the men that are not featured in this book, Thomas Baker. I do hope we'll see both of them again in future books.
Miranda Markham was not a main character that I connected with strongly, and that lack of emotion did color how I read the story. I actually preferred Belle, her maid, ha! I did appreciate that Miranda dealt with bouts of melancholy, but I didn't care for the way that people tiptoed around her when it was unnecessary to do so. The plot is a bit meandering as well, with mystery being focused on too late into the story. I thought the mysterious letters would be a big part of the story, but once all is found out, it kind of fizzles out rather quickly. I did like how once the men decided to act, they were very decisive with their actions and words.
The Loyal Heart was a quick read, and I like the post-Civil War time period. Although I didn't love this one, I do plan on reading at least the next book in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel. The opinions expressed in this review are my own.
July 29, 2016
At the beginning, I thought I wouldn't like the book because the characters showed immediate infatuation to each other, and I'm not a huge romance fan. But though they were attracted to each other, it was not the main theme of the book.
What I liked:
There was a lot in this book that I liked. Being a Civil War fan, I enjoyed reading of the aftermath of the CW in people's lives. The flashbacks to Johnson's Island when the men were POW was also intriguing. The hint of mystery with Mrs. Markham's threats, the loyalty and friendship of her servants, the love and loyalty of Phillip's comrades. It was a very interesting and likable story.
What I didn't like.
The main thing that lowers my rating is the Christianity, or lack of it, in the book. God or Jesus weren't mentioned until halfway through the book. And even then, the Lord always seemed and afterthought. "He was going to need to place his complete trust in her and Kern. And the Lord, of course. He sincerely prayed that would be enough."
Gotta get on a soapbox here and say there was more trust in the arm of flesh than in God. Prayer might be a "good idea," but it was never enough. There wasn't really evidence that the characters were believers. I got the impression that they stood up for themselves and fought in their own strength just fine, only turning to God when they thought they needed a little extra help. There wasn't a personal relationship between man and God.
So, as a story, I enjoyed it. The writing style was fantastic, plot line intriguing, but the spiritual aspect found wanting.
*I received this book in exchange of my honest review from LitFuse*
What I liked:
There was a lot in this book that I liked. Being a Civil War fan, I enjoyed reading of the aftermath of the CW in people's lives. The flashbacks to Johnson's Island when the men were POW was also intriguing. The hint of mystery with Mrs. Markham's threats, the loyalty and friendship of her servants, the love and loyalty of Phillip's comrades. It was a very interesting and likable story.
What I didn't like.
The main thing that lowers my rating is the Christianity, or lack of it, in the book. God or Jesus weren't mentioned until halfway through the book. And even then, the Lord always seemed and afterthought. "He was going to need to place his complete trust in her and Kern. And the Lord, of course. He sincerely prayed that would be enough."
Gotta get on a soapbox here and say there was more trust in the arm of flesh than in God. Prayer might be a "good idea," but it was never enough. There wasn't really evidence that the characters were believers. I got the impression that they stood up for themselves and fought in their own strength just fine, only turning to God when they thought they needed a little extra help. There wasn't a personal relationship between man and God.
So, as a story, I enjoyed it. The writing style was fantastic, plot line intriguing, but the spiritual aspect found wanting.
*I received this book in exchange of my honest review from LitFuse*
July 2, 2016
Miranda Markham is having a rough time, and has seriously considered taking her life, she can’t take it any more, but who is sending the letters that are pulling her down. She also has to deal with her late husbands, Lieutenant Phillip Markham a Confederate Officer in the Civil War, Mother and Sister. They are angry and nasty women, but do they have a right, the house they want back was built by Phillips father, and has always been their home.
There is some help on the horizon for Miranda when Robert Truax, a Second Lieutenant, and friend of Phillips. Unknown to Miranda the men Phillip served with made a pack to help each other families if the unimaginable happened. So when word reaches the men Robert is sent to look into the situation, and you will not believe how a southern city of Galveston, Texas is treating a war hero’s widow!
Will help come in time to save Miranda and her beloved help that run her boarding house with her? Who is so evil to want to take her home, when she has actually made the ultimate sacrifice? Answers are here and you are going to be surprised why this is happening, or maybe not, but once that first page is turned you will not want to put it down.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Zondervan, and was not required to give a positive review.
There is some help on the horizon for Miranda when Robert Truax, a Second Lieutenant, and friend of Phillips. Unknown to Miranda the men Phillip served with made a pack to help each other families if the unimaginable happened. So when word reaches the men Robert is sent to look into the situation, and you will not believe how a southern city of Galveston, Texas is treating a war hero’s widow!
Will help come in time to save Miranda and her beloved help that run her boarding house with her? Who is so evil to want to take her home, when she has actually made the ultimate sacrifice? Answers are here and you are going to be surprised why this is happening, or maybe not, but once that first page is turned you will not want to put it down.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Zondervan, and was not required to give a positive review.
May 3, 2017
by Andrea Renee Cox
I really wanted to like this book, but it annoyed me from beginning to end. There were major inconsistencies, weak and too-convenient backgrounds, men who used their positions of authority as an excuse to be rude and controlling, a couple of random flashbacks that were not grounded in the previous scene, an expletive, and lewd talk. The thing that bothered me the most was the main theme of the story. While being aware of mental health and attempting to fix it is a current-day topic, it was not, as far as I'm aware, something that was broadly known back in the Civil War days. From everything I've learned about that time period, folks with mental health issues were simply sent to asylums and forgotten. This definitely pulled me from the story, because it has been in my lifetime that the mental health issues have come to the forefront of societal awareness. This theme was very out of place for the book's era.
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, authors, and sites like Netgalley, Litfuse Publicity Group, and Blogging for Books. They do not require me to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
I really wanted to like this book, but it annoyed me from beginning to end. There were major inconsistencies, weak and too-convenient backgrounds, men who used their positions of authority as an excuse to be rude and controlling, a couple of random flashbacks that were not grounded in the previous scene, an expletive, and lewd talk. The thing that bothered me the most was the main theme of the story. While being aware of mental health and attempting to fix it is a current-day topic, it was not, as far as I'm aware, something that was broadly known back in the Civil War days. From everything I've learned about that time period, folks with mental health issues were simply sent to asylums and forgotten. This definitely pulled me from the story, because it has been in my lifetime that the mental health issues have come to the forefront of societal awareness. This theme was very out of place for the book's era.
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, authors, and sites like Netgalley, Litfuse Publicity Group, and Blogging for Books. They do not require me to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
May 10, 2017
This book is the first in the Lone Star Hero series by Shelley Shepard Gray. The second installment is called An Uncommon Protector and the expected release date is February 17, 2017. Let me just say that February of next year is a really long time to wait for another installment in a series that started off with such a strong and well-developed story.
I really enjoyed reading this book. I felt there was just the right amount of suspense and romance but I was slightly annoyed with Robert's initial deception when he arrived in Galveston. This is my own personal opinion but his deception really didn't add anything beneficial to the story. I get why he did it but I felt that Miranda would have been open to opening up to a friend of her husbands. Otherwise, I really adored Mr. Robert Truax's character. I felt that he had a strong presence and was genuinely a nice guy.
The characters in this story are really well-developed though I did feel that Bella's story was a bit rushed. Are there plans to expand on her story in a future installment? I hope so because I'm left wondering. Was she a prostitute or was it just her mom? Did I totally read too much into that? I wanted to know more.
I did feel that the book was a little melancholy at times but that's okay! Life is not always pretty and I would assume any woman would feel depressed and angry after losing her husband. Add in rumors and threatening mail and of course that would have been a recipe for disaster for this young lady.
Honestly, every book I've read by Shelley Shepard Gray has been very well written. The characters feel real and as if you can relate to them. I also enjoy her little quirky ability to work in a little suspense in the sweetest of romances. I am absolutely looking forward to book two!
This review was originally posted on A Simply Enchanted Life
July 21, 2016
Shelley Shephard Gray writes Amish fiction under her full name, and historical romance with a touch of suspense as Shelley Gray. I’m not a fan of Amish fiction so haven’t read any of those, but I’ve read several of her previous historical romance novels and been impressed. I watch out for her new Shelley Gray releases, and was pleased to be given the opportunity to review A Loyal Heart.
But I have to say it wasn’t up to the standard I have come to expect from Shelley Gray (or from her publisher, Zondervan). The plot was an excellent combination of romance and suspense, but I was underwhelmed by the plot twist which revealed who was behind the threatening letters widow Miranda Markham had been receiving for the last year, and that meant the novel ended with less than a bang.
I also wasn’t impressed by the editing. There were spelling mistakes, a couple of irritating anachronisms (especially strange, as Gray’s books are usually well researched), and lots of annoying dialogue tags—which perhaps shouldn’t have distracted me, but they did. I was left wondering if I was reading a pre-proofed review copy (which I sometimes do get, but which are usually marked as such). If not, are the spelling and writing errors the fault of the author, or of the editor and publisher?
So while the plot and writing weren't up to the high standard I expect from the author and publisher, the characters were excellent. Miranda Markham blossomed as she got to know Lt Robert Truax, who was a true hero and proved that there is more than being a gentleman than being born into money and influence. I found the growing romance between the two as interesting as the suspense plot, but the romance had a better and more believable resolution.
Thanks to Zondervan and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
But I have to say it wasn’t up to the standard I have come to expect from Shelley Gray (or from her publisher, Zondervan). The plot was an excellent combination of romance and suspense, but I was underwhelmed by the plot twist which revealed who was behind the threatening letters widow Miranda Markham had been receiving for the last year, and that meant the novel ended with less than a bang.
I also wasn’t impressed by the editing. There were spelling mistakes, a couple of irritating anachronisms (especially strange, as Gray’s books are usually well researched), and lots of annoying dialogue tags—which perhaps shouldn’t have distracted me, but they did. I was left wondering if I was reading a pre-proofed review copy (which I sometimes do get, but which are usually marked as such). If not, are the spelling and writing errors the fault of the author, or of the editor and publisher?
So while the plot and writing weren't up to the high standard I expect from the author and publisher, the characters were excellent. Miranda Markham blossomed as she got to know Lt Robert Truax, who was a true hero and proved that there is more than being a gentleman than being born into money and influence. I found the growing romance between the two as interesting as the suspense plot, but the romance had a better and more believable resolution.
Thanks to Zondervan and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.
August 18, 2016
I really enjoyed this book by Shelley Shepard Gray. Not only is it a well done historical romance but it also has just enough suspense to keep you wondering whodunit.
Poor Miranda! Not only is she a struggling war widow, but someone is spreading rumors about Phillip, her dead husband, and threatening her through frequent letters. At one point, she finds herself so low that she wonders if she should keep living. In comes the hero! Robert is an awesome hero. He comes in and immediately starts saving the day - he's fiercely protective, he stands up to her hecklers, and he brings life and hope back to Miranda's life. And he's determined to solve the mystery of who is threatening her and why.
I enjoyed the secondary characters as well, especially the group of Phillip's soldier friends who have made a pact to look out for each other after the war. The introduction of the Captain and the Major was a good addition and I hope the following books continue their stories. :) The loyalty of her servants was great especially considering the town was treating her like an outcast. I was not, however, enamored of the sheriff. I couldn't make up my mind if he was a good guy or not and it seems like he did too little too late. And the revelation of the villain and what he does in the end was, in my opinion, a little anti-climatic.
This is a gentle romance with a steady pace and a thread of suspense. You'll enjoy this post Civil War historical romance that addresses the prejudices and depression many struggled with after the war.
*Thanks to Litfuse for a complimentary copy of this book for review purposes. I was not required to post a positive review and all opinions stated are my own.*
Poor Miranda! Not only is she a struggling war widow, but someone is spreading rumors about Phillip, her dead husband, and threatening her through frequent letters. At one point, she finds herself so low that she wonders if she should keep living. In comes the hero! Robert is an awesome hero. He comes in and immediately starts saving the day - he's fiercely protective, he stands up to her hecklers, and he brings life and hope back to Miranda's life. And he's determined to solve the mystery of who is threatening her and why.
I enjoyed the secondary characters as well, especially the group of Phillip's soldier friends who have made a pact to look out for each other after the war. The introduction of the Captain and the Major was a good addition and I hope the following books continue their stories. :) The loyalty of her servants was great especially considering the town was treating her like an outcast. I was not, however, enamored of the sheriff. I couldn't make up my mind if he was a good guy or not and it seems like he did too little too late. And the revelation of the villain and what he does in the end was, in my opinion, a little anti-climatic.
This is a gentle romance with a steady pace and a thread of suspense. You'll enjoy this post Civil War historical romance that addresses the prejudices and depression many struggled with after the war.
*Thanks to Litfuse for a complimentary copy of this book for review purposes. I was not required to post a positive review and all opinions stated are my own.*
December 19, 2016
I loved that this one was set in Galveston. I got a little history lesson as well as being entertained. I had no idea that the Tremont and the Strand had been a part of the Island that long. Although I'm sure it all had been rebuilt after the storm of 1900 or was it 1906? Whenever it was, I know there was a huge storm that no one knew along this time period. This was also the first book that I had read that was set in the America's during this time period. It was kind of shocking to me that the whole town had turned against the widow Miranda just because of some rumor.
I won't spoil it for any other readers, but it was pretty much obvious who was behind the letters. One reason was apparent, but the other reason was a much deep, darker, creepier one.
I loved that Miranda's war unit soldiers were there for her and helped her to alleviate a lot of her problems. Namely the big one that her husband was a traitor before he was killed in the war. While this book was rife with helpless women, the main ones stood up and held their ground in a time when it was not becoming. That was another source of the rumors that Miranda had to deal with.
I felt this was a very entertaining read. I thoroughly enjoyed it and learned one major basic thing. I would not have wanted to live on Galveston Island during these times. HA!
Huge thanks to Thomas, Nelson, Zondervan for my big box of books. I know you said I didn't have to read them all. However, I have most of them very interest and enjoyable. A big plus when your sending out presents for people you don't know. As usual, I have posted my reviews on all my major sites.
I won't spoil it for any other readers, but it was pretty much obvious who was behind the letters. One reason was apparent, but the other reason was a much deep, darker, creepier one.
I loved that Miranda's war unit soldiers were there for her and helped her to alleviate a lot of her problems. Namely the big one that her husband was a traitor before he was killed in the war. While this book was rife with helpless women, the main ones stood up and held their ground in a time when it was not becoming. That was another source of the rumors that Miranda had to deal with.
I felt this was a very entertaining read. I thoroughly enjoyed it and learned one major basic thing. I would not have wanted to live on Galveston Island during these times. HA!
Huge thanks to Thomas, Nelson, Zondervan for my big box of books. I know you said I didn't have to read them all. However, I have most of them very interest and enjoyable. A big plus when your sending out presents for people you don't know. As usual, I have posted my reviews on all my major sites.
August 25, 2016
*My Thoughts*
If you've been following the multi-talented Shelley Shepard Gray, you know one thing with certainty: She is multi-talented.
From sweet Amish love stories to Edge of your seat suspense, Shelley has never left us hanging.
That being said, I think she found her niche.
I've had the pleasure of reading both Shelley's Amish stories and suspense stories in the past and they were great. But I have to say, this one has been my favorite I think. With each genre, Shelley adds something special, and this one is no exception!
Filled with compassionate and sweet characters, a fantastic storyline, and an a fantastic setting, Shelley captures the spirit of civil war America perfectly!
I can't wait to read book 2!
_______________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give The Loyal Heart by Shelley Shepard Gray...
5 stars!!
_______________________________________________
*I received this book from Litfuse, the publisher and the author in exchange for an honest review, which I have given. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
If you've been following the multi-talented Shelley Shepard Gray, you know one thing with certainty: She is multi-talented.
From sweet Amish love stories to Edge of your seat suspense, Shelley has never left us hanging.
That being said, I think she found her niche.
I've had the pleasure of reading both Shelley's Amish stories and suspense stories in the past and they were great. But I have to say, this one has been my favorite I think. With each genre, Shelley adds something special, and this one is no exception!
Filled with compassionate and sweet characters, a fantastic storyline, and an a fantastic setting, Shelley captures the spirit of civil war America perfectly!
I can't wait to read book 2!
_______________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give The Loyal Heart by Shelley Shepard Gray...
5 stars!!
_______________________________________________
*I received this book from Litfuse, the publisher and the author in exchange for an honest review, which I have given. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
October 26, 2016
This was an enjoyable historical novel set during Reconstruction, with some flashbacks to memories of the Civil War. The pace was slow but steady for the first part of the book, then picked up in the latter half when more things began to happen. There was a lot of telling of the characters' thoughts and feelings, and for some reason I didn't quite connect with them on an emotional level. The theme of unconditional loyalty to one's brothers in arms was well represented, and Robert and his comrades rallied around Miranda to protect her and solve the mystery of her harassment. I wasn't too impressed with Robert's or the sheriff's investigative skills. The story didn't show much of what they did to figure out the problem, and the solving of who was behind the threatening letters came about pretty easily. I was surprised by how simple the conclusion was; I expected it to be more complex.
(Thank you to Zondervan Publishing for a copy of the book; this is my honest review)
(Thank you to Zondervan Publishing for a copy of the book; this is my honest review)
August 19, 2016
I have not read many book by Shelley Gray, but I enjoyed her Chicago series and I love the time period surrounding the Civil War. This is actually my second attempt reading it. My first read, I wasn't impressed. But I was also in a book rut. So I picked it up again and enjoyed it way more. It is very character driven, but an interesting look at post Civil War. Texas. Characters battle the loss of their dreams, fortunes, and future. Some become very bitter and angry and others just try to survive one day at a time. We get a small glimpse of PTSD and the effects of that. I enjoyed this book and am looking forward to the next one!
Thanks to Netgalley and publishers for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
Thanks to Netgalley and publishers for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
July 26, 2016
I just finished reading a book by the well-established but new-to-me author, Shelley Shepard Gray, and honestly, I’m not sure what to think of it... As the first book in the new “Lone Star Hero’s Love Story” collection, “The Loyal Heart” was published by Zondervan in the summer of 2016. Although the storyline was unique and interesting, several other elements just didn’t quite measure up to my standards of well-written Historical Fiction. Let me explain...
As I mentioned before, the plot of “The Loyal Heart” is quite captivating. Told from two primary (and at least one secondary) characters’ points of view, a tale of deception, courage, and unravelled dreams is carefully woven. Although several inappropriate references are made to the activities of less-than-honorable women, that is not the novel’s only flaw. The WAY the tale is told also leaves much to be desired for two glaring reasons....
1) The characters act and converse in a flat, uninspired, and sometimes unnatural manner for their time period. Although the heroine of the story was greatly esteemed by her now-deceased husband, I truly did not notice much in her character that was exemplary. Apart from seeming unrealistic, she also seemed rather selfish.
2) The second annoying factor is the way in which the dialogue was written. One character would make a statement or ask a question, and the second character would then have a lengthy (several paragraphs long) internal process of remembering or otherwise thinking, and THEN make a reply. By that time, I often forgot what the initial comment was! Perhaps some readers wouldn’t mind this technique, but I did.
In the end, if you are looking for an interesting story set in the aftermath of the Civil War and told from the perspective of the South, I do recommend this book. Apart from that, however, I can’t say too much in its favor... Poorly developed characters, a difficult and bumpy writing style, and several unseemly and dark references mar this Historical Fiction novel enough that I do not intend to read it again. But what will you decide? Does a compelling story that captures your interest warrant reading the entire novel, even if it is annoying and lackluster? Or is it the writing style and character development that truly make a novel worth your time?
I received this book free from the publisher through the BookLook Bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
As I mentioned before, the plot of “The Loyal Heart” is quite captivating. Told from two primary (and at least one secondary) characters’ points of view, a tale of deception, courage, and unravelled dreams is carefully woven. Although several inappropriate references are made to the activities of less-than-honorable women, that is not the novel’s only flaw. The WAY the tale is told also leaves much to be desired for two glaring reasons....
1) The characters act and converse in a flat, uninspired, and sometimes unnatural manner for their time period. Although the heroine of the story was greatly esteemed by her now-deceased husband, I truly did not notice much in her character that was exemplary. Apart from seeming unrealistic, she also seemed rather selfish.
2) The second annoying factor is the way in which the dialogue was written. One character would make a statement or ask a question, and the second character would then have a lengthy (several paragraphs long) internal process of remembering or otherwise thinking, and THEN make a reply. By that time, I often forgot what the initial comment was! Perhaps some readers wouldn’t mind this technique, but I did.
In the end, if you are looking for an interesting story set in the aftermath of the Civil War and told from the perspective of the South, I do recommend this book. Apart from that, however, I can’t say too much in its favor... Poorly developed characters, a difficult and bumpy writing style, and several unseemly and dark references mar this Historical Fiction novel enough that I do not intend to read it again. But what will you decide? Does a compelling story that captures your interest warrant reading the entire novel, even if it is annoying and lackluster? Or is it the writing style and character development that truly make a novel worth your time?
I received this book free from the publisher through the BookLook Bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
September 1, 2016
Fantastic! The Loyal Heart by Shelley Shepard Gray is a fabulous story of life, promises, loyalty and dreams. What can easily be a morbid tale (it does take place during and right after the Civil War), in the hands of Shelley gave way to the honor of life and loyalty, among friends, compatriots and fellow human beings.
So rich with details and character developments, I am shocked by how I fell in step with The Loyal Heart, and just kept turning the pages. I guess I really shouldn't be. Shelley have never failed me once, with all the novels I've read of hers. The Loyal Heart is no different. I am instantly drawn by the promise set forth early by the unit, as well as the follow-through that is the basis of this first book in the series. Lieutenant Robert Truax was the skeptical one, yet he's our first protagonist in this series, having to protect his comrade, Phillip Markham's wife, Miranda. What ensues are a series of "unfortunate events" that showed the heinous side of human nature. Plus there is a mystery to solve with more than one budding romance to root for. The arrival of Robert and Phillip's other comrades gives strength to the pact and the meaning of loyalty.
What I find so endearing about The Loyal Heart are the encouragement and inspiration for the good of people and God's grace, from the get go. Captain Devin's motivation to the unit on the first page, to the last page (which I won't share - in case of spoilers), we see the goodness of these people, and what it can mean for others. With emotions on high, touching on topics as PTSD, not only in the sense of soldiers, but all who suffered, and depression, there's much more than a little romance in The Loyal Heart. The depth of what it means in the title and in each of the soldier in Captain Devin's unit, grant readers a story worth reminiscing, not to mention some great characters to root for! I just love this bottom quote!
This review first appeared on Just Commonly Blog.
NOTE: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. For my review policy, please see my Disclosure page.
So rich with details and character developments, I am shocked by how I fell in step with The Loyal Heart, and just kept turning the pages. I guess I really shouldn't be. Shelley have never failed me once, with all the novels I've read of hers. The Loyal Heart is no different. I am instantly drawn by the promise set forth early by the unit, as well as the follow-through that is the basis of this first book in the series. Lieutenant Robert Truax was the skeptical one, yet he's our first protagonist in this series, having to protect his comrade, Phillip Markham's wife, Miranda. What ensues are a series of "unfortunate events" that showed the heinous side of human nature. Plus there is a mystery to solve with more than one budding romance to root for. The arrival of Robert and Phillip's other comrades gives strength to the pact and the meaning of loyalty.
What I find so endearing about The Loyal Heart are the encouragement and inspiration for the good of people and God's grace, from the get go. Captain Devin's motivation to the unit on the first page, to the last page (which I won't share - in case of spoilers), we see the goodness of these people, and what it can mean for others. With emotions on high, touching on topics as PTSD, not only in the sense of soldiers, but all who suffered, and depression, there's much more than a little romance in The Loyal Heart. The depth of what it means in the title and in each of the soldier in Captain Devin's unit, grant readers a story worth reminiscing, not to mention some great characters to root for! I just love this bottom quote!
This review first appeared on Just Commonly Blog.
NOTE: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. For my review policy, please see my Disclosure page.
August 20, 2016
Shelley Shepard Gray is a very talented author. Her Amish fiction books are some of my favorites in the genre. When it comes to her historical fiction books, it's a bit hit or miss for me. The Loyal Heart had such promise, but it fell short of the mark. I love stories that are centered around the Civil War and Reconstruction, so it didn't disappoint in that aspect, but most of the characters and the plot just didn't work for me.
First off, the good! Miranda was fantastic. Rarely do you find characters in Christian romance that battle demons like depression, suicide, PTSD, etc. Even though romance readers come to expect a happily ever after, I liked that Miranda *spoiler alert* got hers in this book, but not without some serious internal battles and soul searching. For me, however, she was the highlight of The Loyal Heart. I was a little confused with Robert and Jess Kern's roles in Miranda's life. Just why were those two men, as well as a few other of Phillip Markham's army comrades so invested in her life? I realize that they had each made promises to stick by each other and their families after the war, but they were all a little obsessive when it came to Miranda. I also didn't know what to think of some of these men! If they are supposed to be "heroes" in stories to come, something better take place for me to trust these guys more -- especially the sheriff, Mr. Kern. He is a wee bit shady for a lawman.
All in all, The Loyal Heart was just an "OK" read for me. The few characters whose moral compasses were in a gray area and a sluggish plot made this my least favorite novel by Gray. If you're a fan of her historical novels, this could be a story worth reading on a lazy Sunday. At just over 300 pages, it's a quick read.
~ My Rating: 2.5 out of 5 stars ~
*I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.*
First off, the good! Miranda was fantastic. Rarely do you find characters in Christian romance that battle demons like depression, suicide, PTSD, etc. Even though romance readers come to expect a happily ever after, I liked that Miranda *spoiler alert* got hers in this book, but not without some serious internal battles and soul searching. For me, however, she was the highlight of The Loyal Heart. I was a little confused with Robert and Jess Kern's roles in Miranda's life. Just why were those two men, as well as a few other of Phillip Markham's army comrades so invested in her life? I realize that they had each made promises to stick by each other and their families after the war, but they were all a little obsessive when it came to Miranda. I also didn't know what to think of some of these men! If they are supposed to be "heroes" in stories to come, something better take place for me to trust these guys more -- especially the sheriff, Mr. Kern. He is a wee bit shady for a lawman.
All in all, The Loyal Heart was just an "OK" read for me. The few characters whose moral compasses were in a gray area and a sluggish plot made this my least favorite novel by Gray. If you're a fan of her historical novels, this could be a story worth reading on a lazy Sunday. At just over 300 pages, it's a quick read.
~ My Rating: 2.5 out of 5 stars ~
*I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.*
July 9, 2016
"The Loyal Heart" is historical fiction. One part was set in 1865 in a POW camp on Johnson's Island, Ohio. These scenes had a vivid setting, good character development, and helped set up later motives. The main story occurred in 1867 in Texas. Except for the clothing and some comments to remind us of the time period, the main story could have happened after any war. Some words, phrases, and even behavior were a bit modern for the actual time.
As for the romance, much of the book focused on how much Phillip had loved Miranda and developed their romance story. Robert was in love with Miranda before he even met her because he longed for a love like Phillip's. Miranda felt so alone that Robert's willingness to stand up for her (even though it didn't help her reputation) made him seem like her savior. By the end of the book, they still hardly know the other person yet are certain they love each other.
The book sounded like it had mystery/suspense: Robert needs to track down who started the false rumors and stop them. In the book, once he finally started this task, it took one short scene (10 pages long) to reveal the who and why. The answer wasn't surprising as there were only a few possible candidates. But there was some suspense during their attempt to capture the miscreant.
In the main story, each character spent a lot of time thinking, mainly about the past. A person would ask a question, the next few paragraphs would be thinking, and then the scene continued. One time the thinking lasted four pages before the question was answered. This really slowed the flow of the action and made the story drag for me.
The Christian element was basically references to prayer. There was no sex or bad language.
I received this book as a review copy from the publisher through BookLook.
As for the romance, much of the book focused on how much Phillip had loved Miranda and developed their romance story. Robert was in love with Miranda before he even met her because he longed for a love like Phillip's. Miranda felt so alone that Robert's willingness to stand up for her (even though it didn't help her reputation) made him seem like her savior. By the end of the book, they still hardly know the other person yet are certain they love each other.
The book sounded like it had mystery/suspense: Robert needs to track down who started the false rumors and stop them. In the book, once he finally started this task, it took one short scene (10 pages long) to reveal the who and why. The answer wasn't surprising as there were only a few possible candidates. But there was some suspense during their attempt to capture the miscreant.
In the main story, each character spent a lot of time thinking, mainly about the past. A person would ask a question, the next few paragraphs would be thinking, and then the scene continued. One time the thinking lasted four pages before the question was answered. This really slowed the flow of the action and made the story drag for me.
The Christian element was basically references to prayer. There was no sex or bad language.
I received this book as a review copy from the publisher through BookLook.
August 3, 2016
I didn't like this book for verious different reasons. This author has written much better books than this.
To me, I felt like it kept going in circles and centering on Miranda who was hated by the whole town. I thought in different ways this town was two-faced. You can't go tormenting this woman and then do a 100 degree turn around because they found out Phillip was this big hero. I mean it's just plain wrong and stupid.
I didn't like this book because everytime a woman is in trouble you have to have a man save you. They portray miranda as this helpless character who always has to have someone look out for her. Too me, that is just plain selfish. I can understand the grieving but this a little too much!!!
I'm sorry but this is how I feel about this book. I received a copy of this book from Bethany House publishers in exchange for an honest review. these are my own words
I did like the cover of the book and there were several scenes in the book I did like however like the servants banning together to help Mirada out.
I love Shellys Amish books and I'm looking forward to the last book in the Amish series that she has out now
I simply just did not enjoy this book. What's crazy about it I usually love stories that involves the civil war
To me, I felt like it kept going in circles and centering on Miranda who was hated by the whole town. I thought in different ways this town was two-faced. You can't go tormenting this woman and then do a 100 degree turn around because they found out Phillip was this big hero. I mean it's just plain wrong and stupid.
I didn't like this book because everytime a woman is in trouble you have to have a man save you. They portray miranda as this helpless character who always has to have someone look out for her. Too me, that is just plain selfish. I can understand the grieving but this a little too much!!!
I'm sorry but this is how I feel about this book. I received a copy of this book from Bethany House publishers in exchange for an honest review. these are my own words
I did like the cover of the book and there were several scenes in the book I did like however like the servants banning together to help Mirada out.
I love Shellys Amish books and I'm looking forward to the last book in the Amish series that she has out now
I simply just did not enjoy this book. What's crazy about it I usually love stories that involves the civil war
August 13, 2016
Good read. I really liked parts of this book, while others I wish were a little different! There's a great mystery hidden within that will continue (I hope) through the series. Many questions come up as you read about these characters and only some are answered! So of coarse I MUST go on! :D There were definite lulls in the pace however. Sometimes I wished some scenes were shorter or not quite as well described and detailed. And there was one time when I felt it was repeating a scene a little.... However the characters are highly interesting and the sub characters are even more so! I can't wait for some of their stories and to see what happens with them! Especially since I'm still not sure where one characters loyalty truly lies! ;)
Songs: "Tell Your Heart to Beat Again" by Danny Gokey and "Press On" by Mandisa
Songs etc. May be changed and/or added in the future. ~ASC
Psalm 51:10
~ASC
*I requested and received this book as a member of Litfuse for the purpose of reviewing it. This in no way affected my opinion and the above are my true thoughts and feelings about The Loyal Heart. ~ASC
http://litfusegroup.com/author/sgray
Songs: "Tell Your Heart to Beat Again" by Danny Gokey and "Press On" by Mandisa
Songs etc. May be changed and/or added in the future. ~ASC
Psalm 51:10
~ASC
*I requested and received this book as a member of Litfuse for the purpose of reviewing it. This in no way affected my opinion and the above are my true thoughts and feelings about The Loyal Heart. ~ASC
http://litfusegroup.com/author/sgray
August 23, 2016
Readers will be thrilled with Shelley Shepard Gray’s book one in the Lone Star Hero Series, The Loyal Heart. A beautifully written novel that is full of historic incites, loveable characters, and a love story that includes a passion and fierce loyalty not only to love but to protect. A huge fan of historical fiction, I immediately fell in love with this delightful story and its characters. Shelley’s research of the historical background of the story also shines through, bringing this novel to life. I would recommend this story to readers that enjoy books written by Shelley Shepard Gray, as well as fans of historical romance.
Series: Lone Star Hero
Genre: historical, romance, Christian
Publisher: Zondervan
Publication date: July 12, 2016
Number of pages: 320
Content Rating: PG
Book Rating: 5 stars
Other books in the series:
2-An Uncommon Protector (coming February 2017)
A review copy of this book was provided by LitFuse.
Series: Lone Star Hero
Genre: historical, romance, Christian
Publisher: Zondervan
Publication date: July 12, 2016
Number of pages: 320
Content Rating: PG
Book Rating: 5 stars
Other books in the series:
2-An Uncommon Protector (coming February 2017)
A review copy of this book was provided by LitFuse.
July 22, 2016
Post Civil-War, romance, mystery, and more is what you will find in Shelley Shepard Gray's newest release, The Loyal Heart. Miranda, the heroine of this story, lost her husband Phillip in a prison camp. Her mother and sister are trying to take her home away from her. Her mother and sister are pretty mean and nasty and if I were Miranda I would have removed them from my life completely. Enter Second Lieutenant and Confederate Officer Robert, who is trying to help Miranda in any possible way. Robert also happens to be an old friend and comrade of her late husband Phillip. It's going around town that Phillip was not a hero, but a traitor to his country. Can Miranda and Robert clear Phillip's name or will his reputation and name be forever tarnished. The Loyal Heart is the perfect book for fans of Historical Romance.
September 22, 2016
A bit of mystery, peril, a widow in need and men of honor, along with an interesting secondary cast of characters. This romance is lovely and heart-felt and I loved every minute of this story, surprisingly even the POW camp flash-back scenes. What stood out most for me, though, was how well Miranda's depression was portrayed, along with the way the story highlighted the continued importance of reputation in the post-Civil War Reconstruction years.
I am so looking forward to An Uncommon Protector, the second Lone Star Hero's Love Story, in early 2017 and I highly recommend The Loyal Heart for those who enjoy a story of regained hope, faith, and love.
This review refers to a free review copy received from Thomas Nelson and Zondervan's Fiction Guild. All opinions expressed are my own. My full, unedited review can be read at http://wp.me/p5Tcfi-1AE
I am so looking forward to An Uncommon Protector, the second Lone Star Hero's Love Story, in early 2017 and I highly recommend The Loyal Heart for those who enjoy a story of regained hope, faith, and love.
This review refers to a free review copy received from Thomas Nelson and Zondervan's Fiction Guild. All opinions expressed are my own. My full, unedited review can be read at http://wp.me/p5Tcfi-1AE
August 15, 2016
The Loyal Heart by Shelley Shepard Gray is book is A Lone Star Hero’s Love Story. Shelley Shepard Gray sure does know how to capture your heart with the story that she writes pulling you into the story hook, line and sinker. This is a wonderful historical fiction book that will leave you yearning for the next book in the series. There is always something happening so there is never a dull moment. Be sure to order your copy of The Loyal Heart today. 5 stars! I received a copy of this book for my honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 224 reviews