What do you think?
Rate this book
The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection
Join the journey as one word etched in Latin on an ancient bronze bottle travels through the centuries to reach five young women who are struggling to maintain their faith in God and love. An Irish princess, a Scottish story weaver, a Post-Colonial nurse, a cotton mill worker, and a maid who nearly drowned each receive a message from the bottle just when they need their hope restored. But will the bottle also bring them each to a man whose love will endure?
446 pages, Paperback
First published March 1, 2017
29 people are currently reading
892 people want to read
About the author
Joanne Bischof
19 books1,295 followersAn ECPA Christy Award winner and an ACFW Carol Award winner, Joanne Bischof DeWitt writes deeply layered fiction that tugs at the reader’s heartstrings. Joanne’s 2016 novel, THE LADY AND THE LIONHEART, received an extraordinary 5 Star TOP PICK! from Romantic Times Book Reviews among other critical acclaim.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 95 reviews
February 5, 2017
This book really, really impressed me! 5 romantic stories spanning the centuries and the stories are connected through one bottle. Spero,Latin word meaning Hope,carved into the neck of the bottle.
The stories take place in North of Ireland,Scotland,New York,Georgia and California. I loved that the stories took place in a wide variety of settings and time periods in history. It was especially interested to me to read about the Vikings in Ireland and the story taking place in Scotland. I will be looking to read more books by authors Heather Day Gilbert ( I want to read more of her Norse tales, I was fascinated) and Amanda Dykes ( both of these authors are new to me and their stories caught my attention.) Maureen Lang I have read before and her books are always interesting. Jocelyn Green, I loved reading her Civil War series and it was excellent to see another short story here about it. Joanne Bischoff, I have read her books and they are not to miss.
All the women in these stories posses integrity,strength and faith.
I highly recommend this story collection to lovers of Romantic Historical fiction.
Expected publication: March 1st 2017 by Barbour Books
Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Books for providing me with a copy of the book . I have given my honest opinion here.
The stories take place in North of Ireland,Scotland,New York,Georgia and California. I loved that the stories took place in a wide variety of settings and time periods in history. It was especially interested to me to read about the Vikings in Ireland and the story taking place in Scotland. I will be looking to read more books by authors Heather Day Gilbert ( I want to read more of her Norse tales, I was fascinated) and Amanda Dykes ( both of these authors are new to me and their stories caught my attention.) Maureen Lang I have read before and her books are always interesting. Jocelyn Green, I loved reading her Civil War series and it was excellent to see another short story here about it. Joanne Bischoff, I have read her books and they are not to miss.
All the women in these stories posses integrity,strength and faith.
I highly recommend this story collection to lovers of Romantic Historical fiction.
Expected publication: March 1st 2017 by Barbour Books
Thank you to NetGalley and Barbour Books for providing me with a copy of the book . I have given my honest opinion here.
April 3, 2017
I rarely read novellas nor collections as I'm not a fan of them. However, my dear friend Beth knew I very much enjoyed reading novels by two of the authors from the collection and offered to send me her extra copy. I am so thankful she did! I do not think I'd have read the collection otherwise and what a loss that would have been.
What I loved about this collection (yes, me saying love and collection in the same sentence) was the use of the bottle with a message and its thread of hope from Prologue to Epilogue. The bottle was introduced into stories in unique ways with the history known at times and others not, which rings so true. Even the super short Prologue and Epilogue added value to the collection. I enjoyed each and every story and its characters in all five novellas. Four of the five novellas included rich historical detail about the geography and time period.
I treasured the time I spent in the pages of this collection. I highly recommend The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection to readers of historical fiction. Nicely done.
My gratitude to my friend Beth for sending me a copy of this collection to enjoy. Thank you my friend.
What I loved about this collection (yes, me saying love and collection in the same sentence) was the use of the bottle with a message and its thread of hope from Prologue to Epilogue. The bottle was introduced into stories in unique ways with the history known at times and others not, which rings so true. Even the super short Prologue and Epilogue added value to the collection. I enjoyed each and every story and its characters in all five novellas. Four of the five novellas included rich historical detail about the geography and time period.
I treasured the time I spent in the pages of this collection. I highly recommend The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection to readers of historical fiction. Nicely done.
My gratitude to my friend Beth for sending me a copy of this collection to enjoy. Thank you my friend.
April 26, 2018
The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection was very good. I loved how all five of the stories connected via the bottle. It was interesting to see each author's different way of using the bottle. I really liked all the stories and I don't think I can pick a favorite. They were all unique in their own way and I recommend this collection if you enjoy historical romances.
*I received a complimentary eBook copy of this book for my honest review. As always, all thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.*
*I received a complimentary eBook copy of this book for my honest review. As always, all thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.*
March 20, 2017
Full review on Faithfully Bookish http://wp.me/p7ngfE-Fr
I am digging deep to create a review worthy of the experience held between the covers of this book. The prologue and epilogue are powerful mini-stories in their own right yet the journey of the bottle weaves them and the five stories together into one inspiring adventure. This book consistently summoned blissful sighs, book hugs, and happy tears which eventually evolved into a blubbering book hangover at the end. I will be telling everyone about this book and the timeless message etched on that bottle! Bravo, ladies! BRAVO!
I requested the opportunity to read and review this title through the authors and NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own.
I am digging deep to create a review worthy of the experience held between the covers of this book. The prologue and epilogue are powerful mini-stories in their own right yet the journey of the bottle weaves them and the five stories together into one inspiring adventure. This book consistently summoned blissful sighs, book hugs, and happy tears which eventually evolved into a blubbering book hangover at the end. I will be telling everyone about this book and the timeless message etched on that bottle! Bravo, ladies! BRAVO!
I requested the opportunity to read and review this title through the authors and NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own.
December 13, 2016
Prologue (834 AD) and The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert ~ 1170 Ireland
A Song in the Night by Amanda Dykes ~ 1715 Scotland
The Forgotten Hope by Maureen Lang ~ 1798 New York
A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green ~ 1864 Georgia
The Swelling Sea and Epilogue by Joanne Bischoff ~ 1890 California
My Review
Who hasn’t dreamed of finding a message in a bottle? Two summers ago my son fished a bottle with a message enclosed out of Salem Harbor in Massachusetts. The sender had written her contact information inside and after calling we learned the bottle had not traveled far. This was not the case for the bottle in The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection, which traverses continents and centuries with it’s secrets carried inside.
A bronze bottle forged in a monastery connects the 5 novellas of this collection. Interestingly, it never passes directly from the characters of one story to the next and each time the bottle finds a new owner, the contents inside are different — suited to the receiver. Regardless of what was inside, the bottle always brings with it SPERO (hope). Therefore in addition to the object itself, a common theme links the novellas.
I believe the stories with the most interesting settings and tidbits of history were those set in Ireland, New York, and Georgia. In The Distant Tide, Vikings invade Ireland on a mission of vengeance, but when their leader is captured, the kindness of an Irish princess leads Ari Thorvaldsson to reconsider everything. My familiarity with Gilbert’s previous Norse tale God’s Daughter, helped me to understand the warrior nature of Vikings as well as to explain how Christianity could have grown in Ari’s homeland. Set in New York during the late 1700’s, Lang’s character Abigail intrigued me with her desire to marry a man who would allow her to continue practicing medicine. Through her ministrations to her patients, readers get a fascinating look at medical procedures and superstitions we find laughable by todays standards. Finally, Green’s novella showcased the plight of Southern mill workers who were displaced in droves under the order of General Sherman. Green’s hospital scenes were reminiscent of those in her book Widow of Gettysburg (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️).
In conclusion, all 5 authors did comparably well creating/maintaining romantic tension. I was pleasantly surprised by Maureen Lang, who has earned herself a new reader. My favorite secondary characters Eugenia Bettredge and Ronan came from Dykes (also a new author for me) and Gilbert respectively. Overall, The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection was a good read with some stories possessing more depth and intrigue than others.
With thanks to Barbour Publishing for offering a review copy through Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
A Song in the Night by Amanda Dykes ~ 1715 Scotland
The Forgotten Hope by Maureen Lang ~ 1798 New York
A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green ~ 1864 Georgia
The Swelling Sea and Epilogue by Joanne Bischoff ~ 1890 California
My Review
Who hasn’t dreamed of finding a message in a bottle? Two summers ago my son fished a bottle with a message enclosed out of Salem Harbor in Massachusetts. The sender had written her contact information inside and after calling we learned the bottle had not traveled far. This was not the case for the bottle in The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection, which traverses continents and centuries with it’s secrets carried inside.
A bronze bottle forged in a monastery connects the 5 novellas of this collection. Interestingly, it never passes directly from the characters of one story to the next and each time the bottle finds a new owner, the contents inside are different — suited to the receiver. Regardless of what was inside, the bottle always brings with it SPERO (hope). Therefore in addition to the object itself, a common theme links the novellas.
I believe the stories with the most interesting settings and tidbits of history were those set in Ireland, New York, and Georgia. In The Distant Tide, Vikings invade Ireland on a mission of vengeance, but when their leader is captured, the kindness of an Irish princess leads Ari Thorvaldsson to reconsider everything. My familiarity with Gilbert’s previous Norse tale God’s Daughter, helped me to understand the warrior nature of Vikings as well as to explain how Christianity could have grown in Ari’s homeland. Set in New York during the late 1700’s, Lang’s character Abigail intrigued me with her desire to marry a man who would allow her to continue practicing medicine. Through her ministrations to her patients, readers get a fascinating look at medical procedures and superstitions we find laughable by todays standards. Finally, Green’s novella showcased the plight of Southern mill workers who were displaced in droves under the order of General Sherman. Green’s hospital scenes were reminiscent of those in her book Widow of Gettysburg (⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️).
In conclusion, all 5 authors did comparably well creating/maintaining romantic tension. I was pleasantly surprised by Maureen Lang, who has earned herself a new reader. My favorite secondary characters Eugenia Bettredge and Ronan came from Dykes (also a new author for me) and Gilbert respectively. Overall, The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection was a good read with some stories possessing more depth and intrigue than others.
With thanks to Barbour Publishing for offering a review copy through Netgalley. All opinions are my own.
March 6, 2017
Five wows.....didn't want this one to end. I love the way each story was connected and how the prologue drew you end and had you sitting on the edge of your seat to see...what next....where is the bottle going to turn up next.
The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert finds us in Ireland with a Princess and Vikings. This is exceptionally well written and takes you on a beautiful journey of mistaken identification and setting wrongs to right.
A Song In The Night by Amanda Dykes weaves a lovely tale in Scotland. You can hear the bagpipes in this vivid tale.
The Forgotten Hope by Maureen Lang is a story that takes place in the midst of a yellow fever outbreak in New York. Descriptive words make you feel like you are there.
A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green is exceptional, as you can expect from this gifted author. This tale takes place during the Civil War and has you riveted to your seat. I found this story to be breathtaking.
The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof takes place on Coronado Island in California. Two classes collide in this story of unexpected love. You want to know the stories that shape these characters and can't read fast enough.
The epilogue is present day and left me in tears.
Each story has believable characters searching for Hope that they find in a Bottle that restores their Faith. I loved the Faith that is shown in each tale and how love can stretch across cultures, classes, and distance. Jeremiah 29:11 comes to mind for me...that God had a plan for these characters and if we but HOPE it finds us.
Exceptional book that should be on your must read list.
I received a complimentary copy. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert finds us in Ireland with a Princess and Vikings. This is exceptionally well written and takes you on a beautiful journey of mistaken identification and setting wrongs to right.
A Song In The Night by Amanda Dykes weaves a lovely tale in Scotland. You can hear the bagpipes in this vivid tale.
The Forgotten Hope by Maureen Lang is a story that takes place in the midst of a yellow fever outbreak in New York. Descriptive words make you feel like you are there.
A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green is exceptional, as you can expect from this gifted author. This tale takes place during the Civil War and has you riveted to your seat. I found this story to be breathtaking.
The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof takes place on Coronado Island in California. Two classes collide in this story of unexpected love. You want to know the stories that shape these characters and can't read fast enough.
The epilogue is present day and left me in tears.
Each story has believable characters searching for Hope that they find in a Bottle that restores their Faith. I loved the Faith that is shown in each tale and how love can stretch across cultures, classes, and distance. Jeremiah 29:11 comes to mind for me...that God had a plan for these characters and if we but HOPE it finds us.
Exceptional book that should be on your must read list.
I received a complimentary copy. The honest review and opinions are my own and were not required.
March 21, 2017
I was so impressed by this novella collection, in a way that I rarely am with novellas. This is a stellar group of authors, and while one was new to me, I knew I was in good hands because of the authors included here. I think what impressed me most was that, while romance plays a huge role in all of the stories, there is also a plethora of engaging historical details and plots that stand on their own. None of the stories fall back on insta-love, rather the romance grows organically as each plot progresses.
In the book’s prologue, Gilbert skillfully introduces readers to the special bottle that will accompany them throughout this group of stories. From its humble beginning in an Irish monastery, the bottle travels through the centuries and crosses continents, encouraging it’s bearers with a message of “spero,” that is, hope. In her story, “The Distant Tide,” a Viking clashes with an Irish princess in a quest of vengeance, but hope can reconcile them all. Ari Thorvaldsson is no stranger to Christianity, but has never opened himself to it. Britta’s kindness and acceptance of him, despite their differences, brings him a perspective that he’s never considered – one of healing and hope. I am unabashedly a huge fan of Heather Day Gilbert, especially her Viking stories. She portrays them realistically without falling back on stereotypes, and this story is no exception.
In “A Song in the Night,” Amanda Dykes takes readers to 1715 Scotland, placing them firmly in the precarious, traitorous interaction of Scottish clans. Meg is ready to sacrifice her future happiness for her clan, but before she can, rivalry between her clan and another leads to tragic results. Picking up the broken pieces of her life, Meg finds a new home with a traveling group, one that travels Scotland selling pearls. Despite her shadowed past, she is content, until a ghost from the past appears, with news that all was not lost of that terrible day two years past. Meg’s courage and willingness to sacrifice are admirable, and her fears feel genuine. If she can get past the pain of reconciling with her past, hope is within reach. I was utterly charmed by Meg’s storytelling and Duncan’s pipe playing. There is a whimsical quality to this serious story, which I think fit well in the Scottish setting. I have loved Dyke’s previous novella and short story, and this story has just reinforced that feeling.
“The Forgotten Hope” takes the bottle and its message to 1798 New York, a time when medical work is one left to men. Abigail, however, is determined to find a husband who will accept her work in medicine. Calvin is a jaded physician, interested in healing patients, but not very interested in restoring his own broken spirit. Maureen Lang touches on a time when the Revolutionary War is not a distant memory, but rather something that still tinged people’s lives with sadness. It’s not a time period that seems to be touched on often, so I really appreciated the authenticity that those details offered. The medical practices of the time are equally fascinating and somewhat appalling with what we know today. Abigail’s character highlights how women had little say in what was considered appropriate, and even though nurses played an integral role, decisions were to be left to men. While a lot of the issues between Abigail and Calvin arise from lack of communication, it feels realistic to the times and makes their understanding much more satisfying. Maureen Lang is a new-to-me author, but certainly one that I am more interested in reading after this novella.
Next the bottle travels to Civial War era Georgia, where Jocelyn Green introduces readers to the displacement of Southern mill workers by order of General Sherman in “A River Between Us.” Cora Mae chooses to become a nurse for the Confederate Army in order to stay in Georgia, with hopes of returning to her ailing mother sooner rather than later. She unexpectedly finds a kindred spirit in Ethan, a Confederate soldier, but of course, circumstances easily come between them. The authenticity of Cora Mae’s character and the intense details of a battlefield hospital captivated me. Usually authors can really mishandle a southern accent, but in this case, it feels authentic and not overdone. The bravery of the doctor’s, soldiers as well as those nursing them is highlighted by the added details of the battlefield and its aftermath.
In the final story, “The Swelling Sea,” by Joanne Bischof readers will find themselves on the coast of California, at a posh resort, crossing between the classes with Jonah, a wealthy law student, and Rosie, a resort maid with a mysterious past. The beauty of the shoreline, as well as the coastal flora and fauna drew me into this story, but even more catching was the emotional depth of the characters, who despite their different worlds, find they aren’t so very different after all. Rosie’s whimsical child-like nature and Jonah’s eagerness to accomplish his goals endeared them both to me. Something about their relationship just really captured my heart – it’s one of those unfathomable connections that I sometimes just have to a character. Bischof writes about character’s difficulties with sensitivity and excels at creating characters that are easy to love. I love the idea that sometimes life’s mysteries are unsolvable, yet even so we are not without hope.
The prologue brings readers back to the present day, tying all of the stories together, with an authentic yet subtle nod to each story. This is a quality collection, one that I feel sure I will revisit again one day. Typically, there is one or more that don’t dazzle me, but with the Message in a Bottle Collection, I couldn’t find a bad story. I think even those who are not typically drawn to novellas or collections of them will find something to savor here. Fans of romantic historical fiction will not be disappointed!
I received a complimentary copy of this book, which I chose to review. This review is my honest opinion.
In the book’s prologue, Gilbert skillfully introduces readers to the special bottle that will accompany them throughout this group of stories. From its humble beginning in an Irish monastery, the bottle travels through the centuries and crosses continents, encouraging it’s bearers with a message of “spero,” that is, hope. In her story, “The Distant Tide,” a Viking clashes with an Irish princess in a quest of vengeance, but hope can reconcile them all. Ari Thorvaldsson is no stranger to Christianity, but has never opened himself to it. Britta’s kindness and acceptance of him, despite their differences, brings him a perspective that he’s never considered – one of healing and hope. I am unabashedly a huge fan of Heather Day Gilbert, especially her Viking stories. She portrays them realistically without falling back on stereotypes, and this story is no exception.
In “A Song in the Night,” Amanda Dykes takes readers to 1715 Scotland, placing them firmly in the precarious, traitorous interaction of Scottish clans. Meg is ready to sacrifice her future happiness for her clan, but before she can, rivalry between her clan and another leads to tragic results. Picking up the broken pieces of her life, Meg finds a new home with a traveling group, one that travels Scotland selling pearls. Despite her shadowed past, she is content, until a ghost from the past appears, with news that all was not lost of that terrible day two years past. Meg’s courage and willingness to sacrifice are admirable, and her fears feel genuine. If she can get past the pain of reconciling with her past, hope is within reach. I was utterly charmed by Meg’s storytelling and Duncan’s pipe playing. There is a whimsical quality to this serious story, which I think fit well in the Scottish setting. I have loved Dyke’s previous novella and short story, and this story has just reinforced that feeling.
“The Forgotten Hope” takes the bottle and its message to 1798 New York, a time when medical work is one left to men. Abigail, however, is determined to find a husband who will accept her work in medicine. Calvin is a jaded physician, interested in healing patients, but not very interested in restoring his own broken spirit. Maureen Lang touches on a time when the Revolutionary War is not a distant memory, but rather something that still tinged people’s lives with sadness. It’s not a time period that seems to be touched on often, so I really appreciated the authenticity that those details offered. The medical practices of the time are equally fascinating and somewhat appalling with what we know today. Abigail’s character highlights how women had little say in what was considered appropriate, and even though nurses played an integral role, decisions were to be left to men. While a lot of the issues between Abigail and Calvin arise from lack of communication, it feels realistic to the times and makes their understanding much more satisfying. Maureen Lang is a new-to-me author, but certainly one that I am more interested in reading after this novella.
Next the bottle travels to Civial War era Georgia, where Jocelyn Green introduces readers to the displacement of Southern mill workers by order of General Sherman in “A River Between Us.” Cora Mae chooses to become a nurse for the Confederate Army in order to stay in Georgia, with hopes of returning to her ailing mother sooner rather than later. She unexpectedly finds a kindred spirit in Ethan, a Confederate soldier, but of course, circumstances easily come between them. The authenticity of Cora Mae’s character and the intense details of a battlefield hospital captivated me. Usually authors can really mishandle a southern accent, but in this case, it feels authentic and not overdone. The bravery of the doctor’s, soldiers as well as those nursing them is highlighted by the added details of the battlefield and its aftermath.
In the final story, “The Swelling Sea,” by Joanne Bischof readers will find themselves on the coast of California, at a posh resort, crossing between the classes with Jonah, a wealthy law student, and Rosie, a resort maid with a mysterious past. The beauty of the shoreline, as well as the coastal flora and fauna drew me into this story, but even more catching was the emotional depth of the characters, who despite their different worlds, find they aren’t so very different after all. Rosie’s whimsical child-like nature and Jonah’s eagerness to accomplish his goals endeared them both to me. Something about their relationship just really captured my heart – it’s one of those unfathomable connections that I sometimes just have to a character. Bischof writes about character’s difficulties with sensitivity and excels at creating characters that are easy to love. I love the idea that sometimes life’s mysteries are unsolvable, yet even so we are not without hope.
The prologue brings readers back to the present day, tying all of the stories together, with an authentic yet subtle nod to each story. This is a quality collection, one that I feel sure I will revisit again one day. Typically, there is one or more that don’t dazzle me, but with the Message in a Bottle Collection, I couldn’t find a bad story. I think even those who are not typically drawn to novellas or collections of them will find something to savor here. Fans of romantic historical fiction will not be disappointed!
I received a complimentary copy of this book, which I chose to review. This review is my honest opinion.
March 14, 2017
"Dum Spiro Spero. While I breathe, I hope."
An ancient bottle inscribed with a solitary legacy, travels across continents and generations to deliver a divine message of hope; the kind of hope that does not disappoint, that inspires courage, that instills confidence, that passionately entwines the most unlikely of souls into a covenant of love that mirrors the "ancient of days".
Each and every one of these stories is uniquely different and yet perfectly part of a whole; creating absolute pleasure within its pages and utter satisfaction for its readers.
I received a copy of this book from the authors. The opinions stated are entirely my own.
An ancient bottle inscribed with a solitary legacy, travels across continents and generations to deliver a divine message of hope; the kind of hope that does not disappoint, that inspires courage, that instills confidence, that passionately entwines the most unlikely of souls into a covenant of love that mirrors the "ancient of days".
Each and every one of these stories is uniquely different and yet perfectly part of a whole; creating absolute pleasure within its pages and utter satisfaction for its readers.
I received a copy of this book from the authors. The opinions stated are entirely my own.
March 21, 2017
I do not read novella collections very often, but this is a MUST READ!
Each author has managed to write a short story with lovely character development and a plot that does not feel rushed. I found the premise of a bottle finding it way through the centuries to bring the message of Hope to the right person at the right time to be intriguing. Each author has provided a story, rich in historical detail that is rarely found in shorter stories. I would be hard-pressed to pick a favorite because each appealed/ touched me in different ways. The bottle travels from 9th and 12th centuries Ireland, Georgian Scotland, post- revolutionary war New York, Civil War era Georgia and finally the California coast of the Gilded Age.
Each of the heroes and heroines display strength of character as they face the challenges life brings to them. Yet God manages to bring the bottle with its message of hope at the right time. While each novella tells the tale of love in the adversity of war or sickness, it is the realization that strength and hope can be found by trusting in God that gives each story depth of meaning. This is not a forced theme, but is masterfully woven to link each story together.
I do not wonder how the bottle manages to travel between the centuries. It is left to the reader to imagine the lives the bottle has touched and the individual messages of hope, whether in the words of scripture or a well-loved hymn, that traversed in the ancient vessel.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Each author has managed to write a short story with lovely character development and a plot that does not feel rushed. I found the premise of a bottle finding it way through the centuries to bring the message of Hope to the right person at the right time to be intriguing. Each author has provided a story, rich in historical detail that is rarely found in shorter stories. I would be hard-pressed to pick a favorite because each appealed/ touched me in different ways. The bottle travels from 9th and 12th centuries Ireland, Georgian Scotland, post- revolutionary war New York, Civil War era Georgia and finally the California coast of the Gilded Age.
Each of the heroes and heroines display strength of character as they face the challenges life brings to them. Yet God manages to bring the bottle with its message of hope at the right time. While each novella tells the tale of love in the adversity of war or sickness, it is the realization that strength and hope can be found by trusting in God that gives each story depth of meaning. This is not a forced theme, but is masterfully woven to link each story together.
I do not wonder how the bottle manages to travel between the centuries. It is left to the reader to imagine the lives the bottle has touched and the individual messages of hope, whether in the words of scripture or a well-loved hymn, that traversed in the ancient vessel.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
October 13, 2020
This is a great novella collection. It has strong authors & stories over 5 time periods I enjoy reading. I would give most of the novellas 5 stars ⭐️! :
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert
A Song in the Night by Amanda Dykes
A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green
I enjoyed reading the shorter stories & was deeply
moved & impressed by the stories written by Dykes & Green.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert
A Song in the Night by Amanda Dykes
A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green
I enjoyed reading the shorter stories & was deeply
moved & impressed by the stories written by Dykes & Green.
November 7, 2017
As someone who is not generally inclined to pick up novella collections, I am so glad I made an exception for this one! Having read three out of the five contributing authors before, I was fairly certain I would enjoy the collection, but it ended up exceeding even that expectation.
The collection begins with a prologue set in a monastery in Northern Ireland in AD 834. A monk, desperate for the Living Word to endure as they are attacked by Vikings, prays: “Please, Father...If we perish, may hope yet live.” A bronze vessel and the single parchment he manages to secure inside are that legacy of hope, and the five novellas that follow trace a small part that bronze vessel’s journey through the centuries, closing with an epilogue in modern-day California.
For me, the most attractive part of this series was the different settings, each so vividly brought to life. If I was pressed to nominate a favourite, I would still have to give two: A Song in the Night by Amanda Dykes, and The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof.
Amanda Dykes was one of the new-to-me authors in this collection, and not only did I love the Scottish setting (my own ancestry and a setting not frequently seen in Christian fiction), but I fell in love with her writing and her characters. As an extra bonus, the original performance of Handel’s Water Music features in the story! My music- and story-loving hearts united!
Joanne Bischof’s heroine, Rosie, is one of the sweetest heroines I have come across—a young woman who nearly drowned at the age of ten and still exhibits certain mannerisms that are considered childlike. Couple that with Joanne Bischof’s beautifully sensitive writing and you have a captivating story.
But I would only single those ones out if I was REALLY pressed to nominate a favourite, because this is truly a stellar collection. Even if you are not normally a novella reader, I highly recommend this series. If you are a novella reader, put this one at the top of your list. You’re in for a real treat!
The collection begins with a prologue set in a monastery in Northern Ireland in AD 834. A monk, desperate for the Living Word to endure as they are attacked by Vikings, prays: “Please, Father...If we perish, may hope yet live.” A bronze vessel and the single parchment he manages to secure inside are that legacy of hope, and the five novellas that follow trace a small part that bronze vessel’s journey through the centuries, closing with an epilogue in modern-day California.
For me, the most attractive part of this series was the different settings, each so vividly brought to life. If I was pressed to nominate a favourite, I would still have to give two: A Song in the Night by Amanda Dykes, and The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof.
Amanda Dykes was one of the new-to-me authors in this collection, and not only did I love the Scottish setting (my own ancestry and a setting not frequently seen in Christian fiction), but I fell in love with her writing and her characters. As an extra bonus, the original performance of Handel’s Water Music features in the story! My music- and story-loving hearts united!
Joanne Bischof’s heroine, Rosie, is one of the sweetest heroines I have come across—a young woman who nearly drowned at the age of ten and still exhibits certain mannerisms that are considered childlike. Couple that with Joanne Bischof’s beautifully sensitive writing and you have a captivating story.
But I would only single those ones out if I was REALLY pressed to nominate a favourite, because this is truly a stellar collection. Even if you are not normally a novella reader, I highly recommend this series. If you are a novella reader, put this one at the top of your list. You’re in for a real treat!
September 16, 2024
A wonderful collection of stories spanning centuries, with a thread of hope, faith and love connecting them. I enjoyed them all! It was an interesting mix of history and characters from all walks of life. The message of hope is one we all need to hear and hang onto as trials come and go. The last story and wrap up with the connection to the Irish monastery and Vikings from the beginning, nicely tied them all together with the thread of hope.
Recommend! 4.5 stars
(An ebook was provided by NetGalley and the publisher. This review is my honest, unsolicited opinion.)
Recommend! 4.5 stars
(An ebook was provided by NetGalley and the publisher. This review is my honest, unsolicited opinion.)
March 9, 2017
I enjoyed this novella collection so much! With an overarching theme of hope, each story drew me in and captured my heart as I watched various characters learn to embrace hope regardless of circumstances.
I loved that these stories were all set in different time periods, with characters and situations that varied with each novella. Yet, even still, that theme of hope was woven through each story by way of a bronze bottle as it traveled through history.
I enjoyed every single novella in this book. The prologue and epilogue both started and ended the collection nicely. I truly loved the variety in the different novellas! The fact that the stories covered such a wide range of history, from Viking times to late 1800’s America, made for a very enjoyable experience.
If you enjoy historical fiction, I definitely recommend The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
I loved that these stories were all set in different time periods, with characters and situations that varied with each novella. Yet, even still, that theme of hope was woven through each story by way of a bronze bottle as it traveled through history.
I enjoyed every single novella in this book. The prologue and epilogue both started and ended the collection nicely. I truly loved the variety in the different novellas! The fact that the stories covered such a wide range of history, from Viking times to late 1800’s America, made for a very enjoyable experience.
If you enjoy historical fiction, I definitely recommend The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
February 27, 2017
The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection: Hope Reaches Across the Centuries Through One Single Bottle, Inspiring Five Romances is a wonderful collection. This collection includes the following stories:
Prologue by Heather Day Gilbert
The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert
A Song in the Night by Amanda Dykes
The Forgotten Hope by Maureen Lang
A River between Us by Jocelyn Green
The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof
Epilogue by Joanne Bischof
I enjoyed all of these sweet stories. There were a wide variety of settings and time periods in history. From 1170-1890 and in Ireland, Scotland, New York, Georgia, and California. If U had to choose a favorite of the five, I would definitely go with Joanne Bischof's The Swelling Sea. She is a favorite author of mine and this story is just another reason why.
Highly recommended.
5 plus stars.
Prologue by Heather Day Gilbert
The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert
A Song in the Night by Amanda Dykes
The Forgotten Hope by Maureen Lang
A River between Us by Jocelyn Green
The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof
Epilogue by Joanne Bischof
I enjoyed all of these sweet stories. There were a wide variety of settings and time periods in history. From 1170-1890 and in Ireland, Scotland, New York, Georgia, and California. If U had to choose a favorite of the five, I would definitely go with Joanne Bischof's The Swelling Sea. She is a favorite author of mine and this story is just another reason why.
Highly recommended.
5 plus stars.
March 21, 2017
I enjoy reading novellas, though I avoided them for a long time because I hadn’t read any good ones up to that point. I was under the impression that the characters were thin, the plots too simplistic, and the writing unable to sustain longer work. This is one collection that definitely defies each of these myths proving that good authors shine regardless of length and a novella is simply a way for readers to try new authors without committing to a longer length work.
The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert
This is the first story I have read by Gilbert, and I am thoroughly impressed. This novella engaged my emotions with surprising force; my eyes teared up at one point and it wasn’t over a character death, either! The spiritual content is solid and portrayed in a moving, thoughtful way while the romance is realistic and a little bittersweet. Despite the shorter length, this one is a winner!
A Song in the Night by Amanda Dukes
This novella transported me to another time and culture with its heartwrenching prose. Love and loss, and carrying on after the unthinkable happens is the main thrust of this story; the punch comes from the twist, which I should have suspected but never saw coming. I love the way the romance survives the impossible, no-win situation it is formed in, a gorgeous picture of how God can take the ashes of our lives and create beauty we never see coming.
The Forgotten Hope by Maureen Lang
Perhaps of all the novellas, this one most speaks to the hope we all need when we fear the worst. And fear drives many of the motivations for these characters, whether it’s caring too much and then losing the loved one or fearing for the loved ones we will one day leave behind. There is also a great pull and tug theme in this story. Who will Abigail choose to be? Daughter or wife? A woman who loves or a doctor? And why can’t she be allowed to be all of them?
A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green
Green is the only author I have previously read, but the strength of her work alone was enough to make me want to read the whole collection. I absolutely love the interplay between love and duty and the seemingly impossible situation the hero and heroine find themselves in. The characters go through much in this novella and I finished feeling as satisfied as if I had read a standard length book—there is that much packed in. The writing is deep and descriptive, leaving me feel as if I could see and smell and hear the battles raging around them.
The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof
The final novella in this book is a poignant story about knowing who you are and choosing to let go of that which you cannot control. Hope is found in the water in this novella, first through the bottle found on the beach, then through the waves themselves as both the hero and heroine learn that they aren't alone, despite the scars each of them carry from the past.
Beginning with the prologue and finishing in the final pages, I am amazed at how these novellas all tie together into a cohesive whole despite their differing locations and time periods; the message in the bottle, or the message OF the bottle, really does tie it all together without it seeming like a stretch for it to do so. I highly recommend this collection to fans of historical romance regardless of time period—it has a little something for everyone and the overarching themes of hope and faith are woven beautifully together to create a fantastic book.
I received a free copy of this book from the authors and publisher, but no compensation for this review. I was not required to write a favorable one and the opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
The Distant Tide by Heather Day Gilbert
This is the first story I have read by Gilbert, and I am thoroughly impressed. This novella engaged my emotions with surprising force; my eyes teared up at one point and it wasn’t over a character death, either! The spiritual content is solid and portrayed in a moving, thoughtful way while the romance is realistic and a little bittersweet. Despite the shorter length, this one is a winner!
A Song in the Night by Amanda Dukes
This novella transported me to another time and culture with its heartwrenching prose. Love and loss, and carrying on after the unthinkable happens is the main thrust of this story; the punch comes from the twist, which I should have suspected but never saw coming. I love the way the romance survives the impossible, no-win situation it is formed in, a gorgeous picture of how God can take the ashes of our lives and create beauty we never see coming.
The Forgotten Hope by Maureen Lang
Perhaps of all the novellas, this one most speaks to the hope we all need when we fear the worst. And fear drives many of the motivations for these characters, whether it’s caring too much and then losing the loved one or fearing for the loved ones we will one day leave behind. There is also a great pull and tug theme in this story. Who will Abigail choose to be? Daughter or wife? A woman who loves or a doctor? And why can’t she be allowed to be all of them?
A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green
Green is the only author I have previously read, but the strength of her work alone was enough to make me want to read the whole collection. I absolutely love the interplay between love and duty and the seemingly impossible situation the hero and heroine find themselves in. The characters go through much in this novella and I finished feeling as satisfied as if I had read a standard length book—there is that much packed in. The writing is deep and descriptive, leaving me feel as if I could see and smell and hear the battles raging around them.
The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof
The final novella in this book is a poignant story about knowing who you are and choosing to let go of that which you cannot control. Hope is found in the water in this novella, first through the bottle found on the beach, then through the waves themselves as both the hero and heroine learn that they aren't alone, despite the scars each of them carry from the past.
Beginning with the prologue and finishing in the final pages, I am amazed at how these novellas all tie together into a cohesive whole despite their differing locations and time periods; the message in the bottle, or the message OF the bottle, really does tie it all together without it seeming like a stretch for it to do so. I highly recommend this collection to fans of historical romance regardless of time period—it has a little something for everyone and the overarching themes of hope and faith are woven beautifully together to create a fantastic book.
I received a free copy of this book from the authors and publisher, but no compensation for this review. I was not required to write a favorable one and the opinions expressed are both honest and my own.
March 6, 2017
I was absolutely enthralled with this book for so very many reasons! The five highly talented Christian authors who corroborated on this collection brilliantly combined their efforts to tell the story of a ancient bottle from the Ballyfir Monastery in the North of Ireland in 834AD that was tossed into the sea by a monk who gave his life so that The Living Word would endure. Through each authors' imagination I was immersed in stories of true faith and inspiration that engaged every single one of my emotions and embraced my joy of reading by taking me to places that I had never traveled to through my books before. To Ireland amongst revenge seeking Vikings, to Scotland's shores amid feuding clans, to New York City after the American Revolution, the Civil War and then to present day California. Each story has interesting and inspiring characters who act selflessly time and again to change their fate while teaching me about the true meaning of faith and the strength that faith employs. My favorite story, by far, was A River Between Us by Jocelyn Green because I have always been fascinated by the history of the Civil War though I never could have anticipated how harrowing the lives of her characters could become. With every page of this collection I was engrossed in these stories featuring everyday people in extraordinary circumstances who find love and the empowerment of hope. It's a journey that I will never forget. I read a complimentary copy of this book and all opinions expressed in my voluntary review are completely my own.
March 3, 2017
Having just finish the novella collection, Message in a Bottle, I can honestly say that I enjoyed the stories within. Each story, while different from the rest, pivoted about one central object: an ancient bottle containing a message of hope. Lighthearted, uplifting, and full of an array of time periods, plots, and characters, this book proved to be very entertaining.
Being a history buff, I greatly appreciated being able to span 5 historical eras within one book. The fact that each era centered on one object - the message in the bottle - knit together these stories in such an enticing way. While some of the stories stood out to me more than others, they were all a delight to read and their authors possessed a writing skill that captivated me. Charming, lovely, and full of encouragement, this set of stories will be sure to fill your heart with hope.
I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for my opinion.
Being a history buff, I greatly appreciated being able to span 5 historical eras within one book. The fact that each era centered on one object - the message in the bottle - knit together these stories in such an enticing way. While some of the stories stood out to me more than others, they were all a delight to read and their authors possessed a writing skill that captivated me. Charming, lovely, and full of encouragement, this set of stories will be sure to fill your heart with hope.
I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for my opinion.
February 21, 2017
Across centuries, miles, and oceans, one bottle spreads the truth of the one word etched into it.
A Viking intent on revenge and an Irish princess who longs to change the world discover that love knows no barriers. Neither the past nor language barriers can dim the promise of Spero.
After tragedy strikes, a Scottish Laird’s daughter and the clan piper, who kept his promise to always watch, are reunited.
While one woman is torn between her heart’s desire to help her father and societal expectations, she meets a doctor determined to remain detached from anyone after too much loss.
A confederate mill worker and a union soldier discover love is greater even than the war that separates them.
And a college student set on making a childhood dream reality who meets a hotel maid who is missing vital piece of her childhood memory.
The bottle finds its way into each of their lives when they need a reminder of the message. The power of Spero is intended for everyone and given freely to anyone who believes. Because hope is timeless and limitless.
I love these romance collections because it gives me a glimpse into authors I’ve not read yet, and I usually find another or two to add to my list. The Message in a Bottle collection is no exception to this. While each story is set in a different time and written by a different author, the message flows throughout the story seamlessly and in a beautiful way to keep the promise of hope flowing through present-day.
Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including Netgalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
A Viking intent on revenge and an Irish princess who longs to change the world discover that love knows no barriers. Neither the past nor language barriers can dim the promise of Spero.
After tragedy strikes, a Scottish Laird’s daughter and the clan piper, who kept his promise to always watch, are reunited.
While one woman is torn between her heart’s desire to help her father and societal expectations, she meets a doctor determined to remain detached from anyone after too much loss.
A confederate mill worker and a union soldier discover love is greater even than the war that separates them.
And a college student set on making a childhood dream reality who meets a hotel maid who is missing vital piece of her childhood memory.
The bottle finds its way into each of their lives when they need a reminder of the message. The power of Spero is intended for everyone and given freely to anyone who believes. Because hope is timeless and limitless.
I love these romance collections because it gives me a glimpse into authors I’ve not read yet, and I usually find another or two to add to my list. The Message in a Bottle collection is no exception to this. While each story is set in a different time and written by a different author, the message flows throughout the story seamlessly and in a beautiful way to keep the promise of hope flowing through present-day.
Disclosure statement:
I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including Netgalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
December 20, 2016
I loved this collection of stories by some of my favorite authors! The way they all weaved their tales using the same bottle for inspiration made me eager to keep reading so I could see how the stories all fit together. They were all beautiful stories of hope. I would definitely recommend this book to friends.
February 4, 2017
A few years ago there was the big tsunami in Japan and even to this date we can still find items washing ashore on the Pacific Coast beaches. I've walked those beaches and thought, what would it be like?
Have you ever found something and wondered where it has been and what stories it could tell?
Well, this collection of stories deals with that idea.
Found, is a bottle.....a very simple bottle with a very special message. "SPERO"...."HOPE."
Within this collection of stories there is the presence of the bottle. Each author connects with the other stories in such a way that it feels like we're following this bottle on it's journey to bring hope to anyone who needs it!
I loved how the stories cover a large span of time and different places. Each author uses colorful word pictures to bring the stories to life.
There is sadness, healing, suspense, humor, sweet moments of romance and wonderful examples of God's redeeming love and hope.
I highly recommend this book set. You won't be disappointed!
Have you ever found something and wondered where it has been and what stories it could tell?
Well, this collection of stories deals with that idea.
Found, is a bottle.....a very simple bottle with a very special message. "SPERO"...."HOPE."
Within this collection of stories there is the presence of the bottle. Each author connects with the other stories in such a way that it feels like we're following this bottle on it's journey to bring hope to anyone who needs it!
I loved how the stories cover a large span of time and different places. Each author uses colorful word pictures to bring the stories to life.
There is sadness, healing, suspense, humor, sweet moments of romance and wonderful examples of God's redeeming love and hope.
I highly recommend this book set. You won't be disappointed!
February 13, 2017
I thoroughly enjoyed this collection of timeless short stories from an fantastic group of talented authors. Each of the stories tied together nicely with their own unique story surrounding a priceless bottle and the messages it contains. You begin the journey in Ireland in 834 AD and travel thru time and historical events ending in the present day.
I’ve read many various story collections and often times you find maybe two stories in the collection that you enjoy; however with this one I enjoyed each of the stories. Often times I’d wish the story would continue. I’d recommend this book to anyone looking for a travel thru history with sweet stories of love and gentle reminders of God’s ever present love and watch-care of each of his children.
I’ve read many various story collections and often times you find maybe two stories in the collection that you enjoy; however with this one I enjoyed each of the stories. Often times I’d wish the story would continue. I’d recommend this book to anyone looking for a travel thru history with sweet stories of love and gentle reminders of God’s ever present love and watch-care of each of his children.
February 14, 2017
Message in a Bottle Romance Collection, written by Heather Day Gilbert, Amanda Dykes, Maureen Lang, Jocelyn Green and Joanne Bischof.
This collection is a book of love and HOPE spanning in time from 1170 with The Distant Tide. Gilbert takes us to Ireland...an Irish Princess finds herself in the midst of war...where could hope be found with a Viking raiding the castle?! Then we go to 1717, A Song in the Night, and Dykes takes us to Scotland! I love Scottish stories! Here's a quote I grabbed from this book by Duncan, "There is a difference between fleeing"...."and flying." Loved this! Can Meg find the hope she needs?! We then find ourselves in New York in 1798 in The Forgotten Hope. Lang introduces us a to a doctors family...namely a woman doctor and her father who wants her to stop doctoring and find herself a husband. Is there any hope she can find happiness giving up helping the sick to take care of a husband?! Next, we're into 1864 with Jocelyn Green's A River Between Us in Roswell, Georgia. This is such a moving story...South to North to South in the midst of war and uncertainty...where to find hope?! Then we finish off the book on Coronado Island, California in The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof. This was a challenged young woman and man both with their own medical issues...hope?!
Most of these books I found that hope that was depicted within the stories and the message in the bottle! They were well written and most compelling to keep those pages turning.
This book would be great for teen and up. Inspirational, romantic and full of hope! Recommended!
I received this book from Netgalley. All thoughts and comments are honest and my own.
4.5 stars.
This collection is a book of love and HOPE spanning in time from 1170 with The Distant Tide. Gilbert takes us to Ireland...an Irish Princess finds herself in the midst of war...where could hope be found with a Viking raiding the castle?! Then we go to 1717, A Song in the Night, and Dykes takes us to Scotland! I love Scottish stories! Here's a quote I grabbed from this book by Duncan, "There is a difference between fleeing"...."and flying." Loved this! Can Meg find the hope she needs?! We then find ourselves in New York in 1798 in The Forgotten Hope. Lang introduces us a to a doctors family...namely a woman doctor and her father who wants her to stop doctoring and find herself a husband. Is there any hope she can find happiness giving up helping the sick to take care of a husband?! Next, we're into 1864 with Jocelyn Green's A River Between Us in Roswell, Georgia. This is such a moving story...South to North to South in the midst of war and uncertainty...where to find hope?! Then we finish off the book on Coronado Island, California in The Swelling Sea by Joanne Bischof. This was a challenged young woman and man both with their own medical issues...hope?!
Most of these books I found that hope that was depicted within the stories and the message in the bottle! They were well written and most compelling to keep those pages turning.
This book would be great for teen and up. Inspirational, romantic and full of hope! Recommended!
I received this book from Netgalley. All thoughts and comments are honest and my own.
4.5 stars.
April 6, 2017
I had highly anticipated this collection since it contained novellas by two inspirational authors whom I've followed for several years now, and it did not disappoint! Historical novels are my second favorite (behind mystery novels), and this book features several settings that are near and dear to my heart as well as some less familiar. Each character's story is tied loosely together by the theme of Hope introduced through an ancient bronze bottle.
Over the past several years, I've discovered that reading novella collections is one of the best ways to introduce myself to new authors and new settings. The shorter story lengths also fit well into my busy lifestyle.
I highly recommend this particular collection for its beauty both in story and in message. The book itself features a gorgeous cover and textured-edge pages. The love stories are graciously presented and appropriate for a variety of ages. I believe that The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection would be a very good choice to gift to your favorite bookworm.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest opinion.
Over the past several years, I've discovered that reading novella collections is one of the best ways to introduce myself to new authors and new settings. The shorter story lengths also fit well into my busy lifestyle.
I highly recommend this particular collection for its beauty both in story and in message. The book itself features a gorgeous cover and textured-edge pages. The love stories are graciously presented and appropriate for a variety of ages. I believe that The Message in a Bottle Romance Collection would be a very good choice to gift to your favorite bookworm.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest opinion.
April 15, 2017
Oh my gosh I loved this book! I give it 10 stars. I read a lot, and I put this on my top ten list for keepers.
It opens in Ancient Ireland with a Monk under attack - trying to save manuscripts, putting a message in a bottle. Beginning in Ireland is a great way in itself to hook me - then each tale is so very well written. They all have a strong Christian message and although they share the same bottle with a message (added to along the way), each is unique with journey of its own. I would love to read a continuing story of each one (authors please!! and please let me know when you do). There is a big gap between the timelines and we don’t know how the bottle got from person to person. It’s not a short read so you’re given lots to get lost in. This was one that I did not want to end!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the Barbour Publishing - Netgalley book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
It opens in Ancient Ireland with a Monk under attack - trying to save manuscripts, putting a message in a bottle. Beginning in Ireland is a great way in itself to hook me - then each tale is so very well written. They all have a strong Christian message and although they share the same bottle with a message (added to along the way), each is unique with journey of its own. I would love to read a continuing story of each one (authors please!! and please let me know when you do). There is a big gap between the timelines and we don’t know how the bottle got from person to person. It’s not a short read so you’re given lots to get lost in. This was one that I did not want to end!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from the Barbour Publishing - Netgalley book review bloggers program. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
March 20, 2017
This was an enchanting collection of novellas! I love how the 5 authors worked together to create 5 stories that were entirely independent of each other, and yet also inextricably linked. The variety of time periods and settings kept each story fresh and fascinating. You wouldn't think a brass bottle would be a very good cornerstone for a collection of stories... but it is. The way that a bottle travels from medieval Ireland to late 1800s California (making multiple stops along the way) while bringing hope to those in its path makes for an interesting and unique plot device.
I've tried to decide which of the novellas I loved most (and it's hard because they're all so unique), but I think I may have to go with A Song in the Night. (There's just something about stories set in the Highlands!) I really enjoyed reading these novellas and would absolutely recommend this book! If I have one complaint, it's that all of the stories were resolved rather abruptly, but I suppose that's the way it has to be when a story is only around 100 pages (or less).
I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review.
I've tried to decide which of the novellas I loved most (and it's hard because they're all so unique), but I think I may have to go with A Song in the Night. (There's just something about stories set in the Highlands!) I really enjoyed reading these novellas and would absolutely recommend this book! If I have one complaint, it's that all of the stories were resolved rather abruptly, but I suppose that's the way it has to be when a story is only around 100 pages (or less).
I received a copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review.
October 24, 2017
by Andrea Renee Cox
Overall, this was an enjoyable collection of stories. I found that the bottle was inconsistent from story to story. I thought it was supposed to have been carried down from generation to generation, but it didn't appear that way once I dove into the novellas.
I've lost my notes on the first story (that notebook ran out, and I'm not sure what happened to it), but here are my thoughts on the others:
A Song in the Night
This might have been my first book by Amanda Dykes, but after seeing the complexity, faith, and hope she masterfully stitched together, I am certain it won't be my last. I liked that Scotland and bagpipes were featured. That added a fun flair to this story. The characters were well developed and easy to root for. One tiny thing that tugged my attention from the story line for a few moments was the use of the modern slang term "cuppa." This detail didn't detract from the richness of this story.
The Forgotten Hope
Though I appreciated Cal's desire for serious rather than frivolous conversation, he often came across as rude, which did not make for an enjoyable leading man. As for the leading lady, I was disappointed that she became a flirt when she had begun as a smart, serious young woman. The last couple of chapters were more enjoyable, but by that point, I already had lost interest in the characters' journeys.
A River Between Us
Only the second Civil War-era book I've enjoyed (just not my era, I guess), this book was an emotional journey worth taking. I adored June, and characterization was a strong point in this story. The gruesome war surgeries were realistically portrayed (caution advised for those who easily pass out or get squeamish). There were plenty of high tension and twists in the plot. Though I enjoyed this one, there were a few drawbacks for me, which included: profanity, alcohol, and a joke about a chaplain drinking alcohol.
The Swelling Sea
As always, Joanne Bischof shared a story of hope wrapped up in flawed characters a person can root for. Rosie was amazing, particularly for her innocence. What a refreshing character! The only things that interrupted my experience were a few clunky sentence fragments and a sudden flashback that unnecessarily detracted from the climax of the story. Those things don't change how delightful this sweet romance was.
I wish I could find my notes for that first story! I remember enjoying that one, but the details are escaping me now.
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, authors, and sites like Netgalley, Litfuse Publicity Group, and Blogging for Books. They do not require me to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
Overall, this was an enjoyable collection of stories. I found that the bottle was inconsistent from story to story. I thought it was supposed to have been carried down from generation to generation, but it didn't appear that way once I dove into the novellas.
I've lost my notes on the first story (that notebook ran out, and I'm not sure what happened to it), but here are my thoughts on the others:
A Song in the Night
This might have been my first book by Amanda Dykes, but after seeing the complexity, faith, and hope she masterfully stitched together, I am certain it won't be my last. I liked that Scotland and bagpipes were featured. That added a fun flair to this story. The characters were well developed and easy to root for. One tiny thing that tugged my attention from the story line for a few moments was the use of the modern slang term "cuppa." This detail didn't detract from the richness of this story.
The Forgotten Hope
Though I appreciated Cal's desire for serious rather than frivolous conversation, he often came across as rude, which did not make for an enjoyable leading man. As for the leading lady, I was disappointed that she became a flirt when she had begun as a smart, serious young woman. The last couple of chapters were more enjoyable, but by that point, I already had lost interest in the characters' journeys.
A River Between Us
Only the second Civil War-era book I've enjoyed (just not my era, I guess), this book was an emotional journey worth taking. I adored June, and characterization was a strong point in this story. The gruesome war surgeries were realistically portrayed (caution advised for those who easily pass out or get squeamish). There were plenty of high tension and twists in the plot. Though I enjoyed this one, there were a few drawbacks for me, which included: profanity, alcohol, and a joke about a chaplain drinking alcohol.
The Swelling Sea
As always, Joanne Bischof shared a story of hope wrapped up in flawed characters a person can root for. Rosie was amazing, particularly for her innocence. What a refreshing character! The only things that interrupted my experience were a few clunky sentence fragments and a sudden flashback that unnecessarily detracted from the climax of the story. Those things don't change how delightful this sweet romance was.
I wish I could find my notes for that first story! I remember enjoying that one, but the details are escaping me now.
I receive complimentary books from publishers, publicists, authors, and sites like Netgalley, Litfuse Publicity Group, and Blogging for Books. They do not require me to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
December 25, 2016
The Message in a Bottle collection was a wonderful collection of novellas written by five great authors. Each story is not connected to each other. The bottle travels through generations bringing hope to different couples which brings about love. The stories in this book are fraught with danger, war, adventure, strength, endurance, romance, excitement, and most importantly Spero - Hope!
I did have two favorite stories in this collection, which personally touched my life.
There where a few quotes I found quite impacting. Here a couple I really enjoyed:
Real love is not so easily tossed aside.”
-Heather Day Gilbert
“It’s that getting up again and pressing onward. It’s that swell that always follows. Always.” -Joanne Bischof
The only thing I missed and was confused about, was what happened to the contents of the bottle when it traveled through the generations. What happened to them? I'm assuming they were lost throughout the years. I was also curious how the bottle ended up in the hands of the person who had it before it was given to another person.
Despite these questions, this book was well-worth the five stars! All the authors did an amazing job writing this collection. I'm sure it was not easy keeping everything straight!
Disclaimer:
I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, in Netgalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.
I did have two favorite stories in this collection, which personally touched my life.
There where a few quotes I found quite impacting. Here a couple I really enjoyed:
Real love is not so easily tossed aside.”
-Heather Day Gilbert
“It’s that getting up again and pressing onward. It’s that swell that always follows. Always.” -Joanne Bischof
The only thing I missed and was confused about, was what happened to the contents of the bottle when it traveled through the generations. What happened to them? I'm assuming they were lost throughout the years. I was also curious how the bottle ended up in the hands of the person who had it before it was given to another person.
Despite these questions, this book was well-worth the five stars! All the authors did an amazing job writing this collection. I'm sure it was not easy keeping everything straight!
Disclaimer:
I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, in Netgalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.
April 2, 2017
I adore these kinds of collections because they are quicker reads. The ones with stories that tie together are just fabulous! This whole collection is now one of my favorites - come on, who wouldn't love a message in a bottle with a twist! I won't go into each story - but just need to say that from the very first page (and that was the prologue!) I was sucked into the drama and danger and couldn't wait to see where the bottle would end up and how it was used. The ending was beautiful and so satisfying! Each talented author put their heart into the stories and you feel that as you read them. There wasn't a slow one in the bunch - each one snagged my attention immediately and kept me turning pages.
Here is a snippet of my feelings on the first story:
The Distant Tide
The gritty detail in this story sucked me in and made me wish I was there watching the interactions between all the characters. I can just picture Ari and feel his struggle with his emotions and fight his feelings. Britta is a beautifully strong yet gentle character who knows she wants to follow God’s calling! Lovely details and emotions in this moving tale!
All in all you will not be one bit sorry for making this a bookshelf keeper! I am so happy these women got together for such a unique and intriguing story line. Very gifted writers and lovely merging of details.
Here is a snippet of my feelings on the first story:
The Distant Tide
The gritty detail in this story sucked me in and made me wish I was there watching the interactions between all the characters. I can just picture Ari and feel his struggle with his emotions and fight his feelings. Britta is a beautifully strong yet gentle character who knows she wants to follow God’s calling! Lovely details and emotions in this moving tale!
All in all you will not be one bit sorry for making this a bookshelf keeper! I am so happy these women got together for such a unique and intriguing story line. Very gifted writers and lovely merging of details.
April 2, 2017
Five talented authors have created beautifully crafted and original novellas of diverse characters and time frames. They share the quest for hope in difficult times. The lives of the characters in each of the books contained in The Message in a Bottle are complex and diverse. Each tale is told from the perspective of different time periods throughout the book. Well researched and creative, each story holds secrets and questions regarding their respective positions.
The commonality that each tale holds is the discovery of a bronze bottle, beaten and scarred, engraved with the Latin word meaning "hope." As diverse as these novellas are, there are common basic needs that rises to the surface.
I thoroughly enjoyed each of these novellas that make up the entirety of The Message in a Bottle. There are a couple of stories that really impressed me and touched my heart in different ways, but the complete book is very impressive and worth reading. I highly recommend this interesting and mystifying book.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book as a gift, and was not required to write a positive review. All expressed opinions are my own.
The commonality that each tale holds is the discovery of a bronze bottle, beaten and scarred, engraved with the Latin word meaning "hope." As diverse as these novellas are, there are common basic needs that rises to the surface.
I thoroughly enjoyed each of these novellas that make up the entirety of The Message in a Bottle. There are a couple of stories that really impressed me and touched my heart in different ways, but the complete book is very impressive and worth reading. I highly recommend this interesting and mystifying book.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book as a gift, and was not required to write a positive review. All expressed opinions are my own.
February 2, 2021
I'm not always the biggest fan of novella collections, they often seem too short, too spacey, or too quickly written. But this collection had me pleasantly surprised. I was familiar with some of the authors which is why I was interested in the collection, but now they're all going to be on my "to-read" list.
Each novella is set in a completely different time period (and location!) than the others, but they all have one common little thread, the bottle. While this is woven in more strongly in some novellas than others, it's still there. This was a fun theme that I enjoyed through each work. At the end of each novella I ached for that story to continue, the characters and plots were that good!!
If you're a history fan, a romance fan, or just a fan of shorter stories, this is a great book to check out! Enjoy.
** I received this book from the authors. All my opinions are my own.
Each novella is set in a completely different time period (and location!) than the others, but they all have one common little thread, the bottle. While this is woven in more strongly in some novellas than others, it's still there. This was a fun theme that I enjoyed through each work. At the end of each novella I ached for that story to continue, the characters and plots were that good!!
If you're a history fan, a romance fan, or just a fan of shorter stories, this is a great book to check out! Enjoy.
** I received this book from the authors. All my opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 95 reviews