What do you think?
Rate this book


400 pages, Paperback
First published June 5, 2018
I stumbled upon Duskfall through reddit and boy o’ boy, it was such a fun and refreshing read! Dark Immolation was a tossup for me. I thought Dark Immolation’s atmosphere and story was in the opposite direction of what had attracted me to give Duskfall a try: a mysterious stranger in a quest to find his forgotten identity, his supernatural powers, justice for those he loved, and survive the dangers of it all. It was full of action and intrigue and there was never a dull moment.
Dark Immolation took the story in the opposite direction. Knot lost his wife (or what he assumed without much effort on his part), his powers and most importantly his direction in life. The premise for Dark Immolation is that Knot has to start over again but this time, his journey is abysmally boring because he doesn’t have a clear purpose nor a strong drive to find his own strength (again, I might add).
Then there’s the other (or should I say supporting) main characters: Jane and Cinzia. I had never really liked those two. In fact, I thought them to be enormously annoying and frustrating to read due to their silly religious arguments and ideals. Let’s be honest, I’m here to read a fantasy adventure, not a theological preaching about Cantos (Christianity is the analogy to it). And let’s not forget the other original main character from Duskfall, Knot’s wife, Winter. She’s still in her path of addiction and self-destruction. There’s not much to say about her in the last book except for her joining the crazy club.
So finally, here’s the third book: Blood Requiem. Now these days, as a reader I don’t have much free time for reading and along with a huge backlog of books to read, if I don’t find a book interesting by the 30% mark, I’m done. Time is precious and my tolerance level is low. But, I had really liked reading the Chaos Queen series and despite my hang-ups from Dark Immolation, Blood Requiem was this year’s anticipation for me.
Let’s just say, without much major spoilers, Blood Requiem seems to be in the same direction as Dark Immolation. I’m sorely disappointed. I don’t care much for this type of plot mechanic: Let’s make Knot weak again so he can go through another boring path to find his own strength (for try number 3!). If this series was Lord of the Rings and in every book, Aragon has to start off weak and discover his own strength and in reverse, he has to rely on the Hobbits to save his butt, I’m sure Sauron has already conquered Middle Earth, and “yawn.”
And then there’s the other characters. There’s not much changed for Winter’s situation. Locodoco club all the way for her. But, Jane and Cinzia has turned up the annoyance level to an all-time high. In the previous book, Jane and Cinizia’s religious plot device was part of the overall plot for the political maneuverings and religious conflicts. Besides that, there’s a bigger and mysterious evil that’s come to threaten the world.
In Blood Requiem, it’s progressed, in my opinion, into full Christian preaching. Cinzia is still in this repetitive mode: “Should I have faith or not have faith?” Hasn’t this already been resolved in the last book? But anyways, if a religious zealot has so much recurring doubts, she’s obviously in the wrong profession as a priest. More to the point, this book focuses less on the decisions, actions, and consequences of Jane and Cinizia’s religious struggles and decisions against the political atmosphere but more on the spiritual and theological beliefs. It’s become more of “Let’s have faith even though we’re making dumb decisions.” Ex: Oh, there’s a conflict they can’t solve? Tada! Faith to the rescue. Or, they need to make a smart decision on how to proceed? No need. Faith will fix it.
Then, there’s also the supernatural or magical part of the story. From a covert and magical organization in book one, to some nonsense devil and archangel concept in book three. From the last book, we know the evil that attacked their world was from Azael (I hope I’m right from my hazy memory). And now we’re introduced to more demons (or whatever they are) in the beginning of the book: Luceraf, Hade, Samann and etc. Clearly some mix of biblical, Greco-Roman and Germanic pagan ideas here. But more to the point, it’s a parody of the Christian (Cantos) vs. Pagans concept.
Sadly to say, by about a third of the book, I’ve lost interest. What initially attracted me to read Duskfall is completely gone by this book. I don’t find Knot interesting. I am, as always, annoyed by Jane and Cinizia. Winter is forever a dull read. And the supernatural turned religious preaching is a major turn off.
Don’t get me wrong. The writing style is fabulous to read. There’s great talent there. But personally, I don’t find it fun anymore in my limited reading time. (But to be honest, I’m just damned tired of Knot’s Ping-Pong cycle).