Story: 4 Stars
Narrator: 1 star
I really liked this story. That is the story itself, not so much the narrator. Let’s start with her, shall we?
While the narrator has a very soothing voice, it was too much, in my opinion. Some of the time, she came across as sounding robotic, like I could easily imagine one of those computer programs that can talk. The “smile-in-her-voice” narrating was also annoying. I swear there were many times throughout the story in which she was obviously smiling while reading and it just didn’t make sense given what was going on in the scene. She didn’t really change her voice around that much either. For example, Jennifer and Marianne pretty much sounded the same; so oftentimes, it was hard to follow who was saying what. She also seemed to have issue with keeping the character’s voice the same. Again, there were times when Rob sounded distinctive from his brother, Grant, but then other times, he sounded like one of the female characters. It was very strange.
At this point, having only listened to this one book by this narrator, I can easily imagine her narrating a meditation-type book, not so much an actual story. I wouldn’t recommend her. The only reason I continued with this story (which was hard for me) was that the story itself was very interesting.
I think the biggest issue I had with this story, for me, was that I didn’t feel the author described the house that good. I mean, on the cover is this really big, cool-looking, old house. But the characters don’t really go exploring it, besides the kitchen, living room, grandma’s room, and attic. Even when the walls, furniture, mirrors, windows, etc. are brought up, there isn’t much detail. That was disappointing.
Questions/Comment:
I really can’t stand when people beat around the bush, so to speak. Grant obviously had issues with Jennifer, yet neither of them say anything to the other about what was going on when he didn’t show up for the date. That really annoyed me.
I get that Jennifer was going to end up with Grant from the beginning but still. Grant came across as an ass a good majority of the book, yet Jennifer is still all up in his business, if you know what I mean. I was so hoping that she would end up with Rob and then Marianne could have Grant.
Why was Grant always referring to Jennifer by her full name? Yes, he’s the sheriff but they grew up with each other, they live in the same town… Plus, his brother always referred to her by her last name. Yes, he was working for her but they were friends.
People that say, “s/he’s a horrible person but s/he’s still my mother/father, etc.” and basically allow these family members to continually get away with stuff, specifically treating that one person like garbage need to wake up. And I’m not talking about those who are having personal issues, but those who, in this book, haven’t seen their child/grandchild in over six years and doesn’t even care about them. Just because two people are blood, maybe one born from the other doesn’t justify one to be cruel to the other. Get what I’m saying. So, the fact Jennifer invites her mother to have dinner with them just irked me.
At first, I wasn’t sure who the bad guy was. That’s until Jennifer arrives at his office, then it was pretty obvious. You’d think he would have been a little smoother.
Whatever happened to the guy that tried to kill Jennifer? After his confession to her about having killed her grandmother, which she doesn’t seem to tell anyone else, nothing more is said once he’s caught.
In the end, what exactly was the point of Jennifer having to stay in the house for two years? Given she’d been living with her mother when she was interested in Grant, I guess I don’t understand how her grandmother would have known about him.
I received a free copy of this audiobook in exchange for an honest review.