Gwen Frostic, Wing-borne (Presscraft Paper, 1967)
When I was in high school back in the mid-eighties, a friend of mine discovered some small, thin, blank-spined books in the poetry section of our local Walden's and, being the impetuous sort, bought one of them. They were by some cat who called himself Javan. Said friend, thinking he'd discovered some sort of long-lost treasure, immediately got on the horn to me and convinced me I needed one, too. So I bought one that he hadn't already bought, and we devoured these things like devil's food cake.
It's twenty-five years later, and I know a lot more about poetry than I did then, as well as a lot more about logic. (Who finds little-known gems in a mall bookstore? No one, that's who, because mall bookstore managers have no autonomy at all in what they order.) Javan (whom I now believe to be the wife of late mystery novelist William X. Kienzle, though this has never been officially confirmed) was one of the legions of Rod McKuen wannabes whose tripe flooded the market back in the day when McKuen was still a marketable name. Why am I telling you all this? Because I had it all come rushing back while reading the work of Gwen Frostic. I wish I'd remembered it before.
I spent years hearing praises sung about Frostic, and especially about Wing-borne. I cannot remember where I heard any of this, but my notes say “multiple award-winning book that made a huge splash on publication and then faded into obscurity.” Is any of that true? I've no idea. In any case, I have since discovered that Frostic owned Presscraft Papers until her death in 2001; Wing-borne was self-published way before self-published was cool. And it has that same godawful Rod McKuen/Susan Polis Schutz/Javan thing going for it, where you take whatever your obsession happens to be, write something about it, chop that something up into little lines, and proclaim it “poetry” despite it really being prose.
“From the soil of the earth the sun brings
forth life----seeds sprout---and tiny plants
rise to reach the light...... .
The countless leaves upon each tree---the
leaves of every flower------each blade of grass
sometime---somehow will turn that the sun will
shine upon it---and-thereby make the one
connecting link between the sun and all the life on
earth.........”
...yeah. (And with all the dashes and dots.) There's no rational defense for calling that poetry. It's barely coherent prose. If you need to scratch a Rod McKuen-style itch and have exhausted all the other horrendous poets of this ilk (and have sampled Helen Steiner Rice, whose poetry is somewhat different, yet mines this same vein of OMGHIDEOUS), then give Gwen Frostic a try. Else, save what brain cells you devote to poetry, which will surely commit suicide if you attempt this. (half)