Studied as a primer for "building the base" while I had been preparing for the Civil Services Exam, this one was a fascinating read. On one hand, it was amazingly comprehensive, with practically entire Indian history, with lots of impressive facts, being captured in a single volume. On the other hand, despite being an effort from some of the greatest historians ever, it was strangely dissatisfying. By that time, i.e. when I was studying the subject, Indian historiography had been changed by so-called secular Marxist historians. As a result, the book was rather jarring when compared with the NCERT textbooks penned by R.S. Sharma, Satish Chandra, and the Penguin volume by Romila Thapar. So much so, that despite reading it from cover-to-cover for my prelims during almost eight months, I didn't study it for the Mains out of fear that the JNU-based Marxist examiners would make a mincemeat of my answers if they are based upon the assertions & findings of this book.
Days have changed. The vice-like grip of Marxists and pseudo-seculars have lessened in these days. Hopefully that would enable more readers to openly savour and appreciate this classic.
Only reason for dropping a star is the lack of updation, as far as this book is concerned. It should have been updated in terms of facts, especially with respect to Harappa Civilization, Bhakti mivement, and the popular basis of freedom struggle along-with its internal contradictions.
Recommended.