Let me just start off by saying that Laura Monster Crusher by Wesley King is one of the best Red Maple books from this year that I’ve read so far. I enjoyed how King incorporated both aspects of Laura’s life into the story, fantasy and reality, because I was worried that he was just going to write about the “Monster Crushing” side of her life. I really liked this book’s characters and their varying characteristics, especially the steadfast dedication of Eldon, the quiet persistence of Laura, and the humorous innocence of Tom. I found the plot extremely unpredictable, especially when Laura was betrayed by a trusted family member, and found an enemy to become an acquaintance. I found the narration really good, too, particularly when Laura was being bullied, and her reactions, thoughts, and emotions to it.
However, I found a few flaws in this book, however slight. I felt as if the author’s narration from a girl’s perspective was a bit over-the-top, though that could just be me. Also, I found it strange that the “Monster Crushers” battled with weapons such as swords, arrows, and hammers, but didn’t use firearms. It could’ve just been a matter of the time period the story was set in(?), but I’m skeptical. The first gun was invented in the late 1300s, and if the citizens of Derwin are advanced enough to form underground communities, fancy hammers, and, as quoted from the book, boring machines that “sliced through the (solid) rock like butter”, they should have no problem being advanced enough to manufacture guns, or at least "borrow" some from the Surface World. After all, using firearms is a much more efficient, not to mention effective, way of fighting monsters, which leads me to think that Wesley simply didn’t include this class of weapons, because it would tarnish the whole ‘fantasy’ concept of the story. This is a pretty trivial matter, but I thought that the “Monster Crushers” could use a cooler name, such as the… Behemoth Eradicators? Creature Obliterators? Beast Annihilators? Okay, so my names aren’t much better, either, but you get the idea. Oh, and when I was nearing the final battle at the end of the book, I was thinking, Why is this book so short? What’s going to happen at the end? How are they going to end the war so quickly? My fears were confirmed when this book ENDED IN A CLIFFHANGER.
Well, I guess I’ll be reading the second book, then.
Despite these drawbacks, I still found this a wonderful book. With intrigue, action, adventure, and fantasy, I couldn’t stop reading. This is a story about perseverance, resilience, loyalty, tenacity, and being able to bounce back from ignominy.
At one point in this book, (page 279,) Tom says, “Can you imagine? Being wanted for the one thing I always thought was my biggest weakness? Don’t you know what it’s like?” I found this quote to be very memorable.