All of these stories were well written, not surprising given the authors. Two stories each by Cather, Perkins and Wharton, and four by Chopin. I’m not sure all work well on audio, at least for me. I find it hard to be invested in heavily character-driven stories, especially those without much dialogue or action. I don’t think this is an issue with the narrator, necessarily. I think it’s more that when you read a story yourself you slow down naturally as needed to absorb what’s happening. Visual memory also plays a part in remembering names, relationships and details when I see the words. But with audio, there’s no visual connection and the story continues whether you’re following it or not. So I’m not sure my reactions to the stories would have been the same if I’d read them, but here they are based on this audio version.
“On The Divide” by Willa Cather - *** enjoyed this though could swear I’ve heard it before. I think I borrowed this collection before and didn’t finish it. It follows a rough man who lives alone, but decides to take a wife, literally when she tries to play him. Great characters, and a nice turn at the end.
“The Garden Lodge” by Willa Cather - * I’ve really enjoyed other works by Cather, but though I listened to this whole story, I barely followed it. Something about unrequited love between a lonely woman and an opera singer who lives in the garden lodge, I think?
“A Point at Issue” by Kate Chopin - ** this one just barely held my attention. Though Chopin does well at making you think you know what’s going to happen and then adding a twist.
“The Story of an Hour” by Kate Chopin - ** barely followed this one, seemed more of a character sketch than a story. Not much plot. By the time I finished the collection, I couldn’t even remember what it was about.
“Desiree's Baby” by Kate Chopin - ***1/2 for this story. I’d probably give the story itself a 4, but the narrator on this audio read the whole thing in a heavy French accent which I found distracting and annoying. It tells the story of a woman in New Orleans who makes an unexpected discovery when her baby is born.
“A Pair of Silk Stockings” by Kate Chopin - ***1/2 a very brief story, about a poor woman who comes into a little money which she plans on spending on her children, until she gets to the store and sees a pair of silk stockings. Character-driven but still engaging, and a nice snapshot of life in a bygone era.
“The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman - ***1/2 I’ve heard this on audio before, and it works well as it’s basically a monologue, being sort of stream-of-consciousness first person of an unbalanced woman locked in a room with yellow wallpaper.
“Three Thanksgivings” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman - **** I liked this story of a resourceful widow determined to keep her house and independence, despite the well-meaning efforts of her children.
“The Pelican” by Edith Wharton - *** it took awhile for me to get into this story, which was, like the others, really more of a character study. Because the audiobook narrator was a woman and it’s first person, I didn’t realize the protagonist is a man until the end, which, given the historic setting, changes the story a bit. It’s the narrator describing a widow who lectures, poorly, for the sake of her son. It’s a bit reminiscent in theme of my favorite Wharton novel, The House of Mirth in that it’s about the dependence of single women on others in society for support. Ultimately, I liked this even if I suspected where it was going before the end. Wharton really is brilliant with characters.
“The Fullness of Life” by Edith Wharton - ** a rather odd story for Wharton, about a woman who dies and experiences the afterlife. There’s a bit of a character-driven twist at the end, but overall I didn’t love this one. Felt contrived to make a single point.