슬픈연가 5

슬픈연가 #5

by Ji-Sang Sin, GEO (Illustrator)

해인의 첫 라이브 콘서트가 대성공을 거두었습니다. 그녀의 마음을 아프게 하지 않고 마침내 그녀와 결혼하기 위해 건우는 음악 프로듀서로서의 경력을 포기하고 아버지의 발자취를 따르기로 동의합니다. 하지만 해인은 준규에게 점점 더 매력을 느낀다. 그녀는 과연 준규가 누구인지 알아낼 수 있을까? 그리고 준영/준규는 결혼식을 막을 수 있을까?

Genres: Manga, Manhwa, Romance, Shojo

Paperback

First published January 1, 2006

Reviews

[Sushi (寿司) · Rating 5 out of 5]

La fine del drama e del manga sono totalmente diverse. Nel drama Jun Kyu o Joon Kyu (dipenderà dalla traduzione il manga l'ho letto in italiano e il drama l'ho visto con i subs inglesi) muore dovuto alle complicazioni di un emorragia al fegato dopo che era stato picchiato mi pare e mentre assiste al debutto di Hae In. Non sono al 100% sicura e non ricordo se c'era anche una pugnalata finale. Sono passati moltissimi anni e quindi è difficile ricordare bene.
Nel manga muore dopo che incontrano per caso, lui e Hae In, Keon Woo al tempio dove è sepolta la madre di Keon Woo. Mentre lui e Hae In stanno per andarsene Jun Kyu torna indietro e vede il tipo, o sicario assoldato dal cognato anche se lui ovviamente non sa chi è, che sta per sparare a Keon Woo e poi si vede lui morto dopo il rumore dello sparo. In più qui Jun Kyu si sente male e viene portato in ospedale, prima, ma ha problemi renali e non è stato picchiato.
Vale la pena vedere e leggere entrambi. Il drama sono 20 episodi ed è di un tristezza assoluta più del manga. Ogni puntata è sofferenza pure perchè è sviluppato più lentamentamente del manga.

[✨Sky✨ ♏ · Rating 4 out of 5]

4,5 stars

[Yan · Rating 1 out of 5]

The pacing of this manhwa is honestly all over the place, and at times it feels like a typical Korean melodrama taken to the extreme. I started this story feeling genuinely curious about where it would go, but that curiosity eventually turned into disappointment and frustration because of how the plot unfolded. What frustrated me the most were the characters, especially Hwajung and Haein’s mother. Both of them constantly interfere in Haein and Junyoung’s relationship, making it almost impossible for anything to progress naturally. Hwajung’s obsession with Junyoung goes as far as spreading lies, while Haein’s mother is entirely self-centered, using her daughter as a shield to protect herself and avoid responsibility. Their actions feel manipulative and exhausting to watch. I felt particularly bad for Junyoung. His entire life has been nothing but hardship. From being born as the son of a prostitute, to running away from home, losing his mother, and having his father imprisoned, it feels like tragedy follows him at every turn. While this makes his character sympathetic, it also becomes overwhelming because he’s rarely given any real relief or growth. The story itself has an interesting premise, and the emotional weight is there, but the execution falls short. The uneven pacing, frustrating character decisions, and constant interference prevent the narrative from reaching its full potential. Instead of feeling tragic in a meaningful way, the manhwa often feels unnecessarily stressful and draining.

[Novels and Neckties - Kira Murasaki · Rating 3 out of 5]

I need answers!
I think Kon- Woo was right about love being an egoist. I agree.
I think he was sad but he understood what was going on when Hae-In chose her Jun-Young.
I just wish she would have told him sooner. Really.
Why do ppl not talk to each other in this manhwa? She could have told him openly.
Fair and square. He would habe been heartbroken, maybe furious too, but he would have understood.

That´s why I think Kon- Woo was right when he said, that Hae-In betrayed him.

The end was too tragic and I (the reader) didn´t get a chance to recover from it.
Instead I got a last page where Hae-In has a like 9 year old son.
What happened? Hae-In and Jun-Young confessed their love along a train-rail-road after she wanted to jump in front of a train. - So what happened? They went to his room in his friends apartment and yeah, did it? ... Didn´t we learn that you should not have s*x after a trauma situation?! Because you are bound to do things you wouldn´t do in a normal state of mind.

I want a discussion! I have questions! I need answers!
As much as I was invested in the characters over the course of the whole series, that ending knocked me off completely. Give it 20 more pages or so. PLEASE!

[L · Rating 1 out of 5]

Not mention the ending was pretty annoying.

So he's sick so maybe they are not going to end up after all, then lets better kill him to make it more dramatic. *BANG*

[Fitri Gita · Rating 3 out of 5]

belum dibaca ... tapi klo sama ama yng aq tonton ... berarti ... hikshikshiks ... sedih!

[Nurmalahayati Yusuf · Rating 5 out of 5]

Tissue.. tissue.. tissue...