I have been wanting to read the novelization of Rogue One: A Star Wars Story forever. Not only do I always enjoy reading novelizations for the theatrically released star wars movies to see what was added, but response to Alexander Freed’s take on the first Star Wars spinoff film has been largely positive. Also, as soon as I got out of the movie, I felt like it was the perfect movie for a novelization.
Just for a warning, this review contains SPOILERS for both the movie and the novelization. So I’d give the novelization a read before you read this, because its absolutely incredible.
THE MOVIE: Normally I would give a quick synopsis of the story, but because this is an adaption of another story, I take this time to talk about the source material: the 2016 movie directed by Gareth Edwards.
I'm not that big fan of the film. Yes, that Darth Vader scene was awesome. Yes, the third act was spectacular. But most of the rest left much to be desired. And in terms of the new movies, I found The Last Jedi and even The Force Awakens to be far better.
I'll start with the good real quick. I like the story alot. It's a compelling prequel on how the rebels got the death star plans. Through that we get to see lots of different points of view in the galaxy, particularly the idea that not everybody in the rebellion was what you would call a good person.
Some people connected with the characters and really loved them, others found them completely flat and bland. I'm somewhere in between. On the one hand, the movie's portrayal of Jyn was a bit weak. To this day, I'm left completely unconvinced that Jyn would so quickly be willing to lead the team to scariff after the rebels killed her father. Yes, K2SO and Chirrut Imwe were fun, but they didn't leave much of an impact beyond that. I didn't get very emotional for any of the main cast when they were killed off.
On the other hand, Cassian Andor is seriously underrated. He was by far the best written character and Diego Luna gave the best performance in the film.
Now for the problems: yes, I think the bor gullet scene is stupid too. Yes, the cameos from R2 and 3PO as well as Pondo Baba and Dr. Evazaan were forced. But lets get to my other problems. First, Forrest Whitaker's performance was pretty goofy. He's a great actor (as proven by Denis Villeneuve's "Arrival") and he can be fantastic in the role (Rebels proved that), but with this movie, something didn't translate well, and when he was trying to be intimidating, I just sort of cringed.
But the biggest problem? Director Krennic. Ben Mendelson did the best he could with the role, but the character himself was without a doubt the lamest villain from any Star Wars movie. At least Ziro the Hutt nearly doomed the republic's war effort in the god awful clone wars movie. Heck, even General Grievous killed a jedi master in a deleted scene. Krennic was just there to be pushed around by Tarkin (who shouldn't have been in the movie), and Vader. He wasn't even able to kill Cassian Andor!
While the movie is in the middle for my Star Wars film ranking (those have been done to death so I’m NOT going to do it here), Rogue One’s novelization is right up there with Revenge of the Sith as not just one of the best Star Wars movie novelizations, but one of the greatest Star Wars books I have ever read. It takes the story, that was already pretty good, and makes it quite powerful. It takes the action scenes which were already pretty fun but makes them truly intense. And most importantly, it takes the characters, which was one of the movie’s weaker elements, and makes them interesting, memorable, and relatable.
Alexander Freed does an amazing job with the material from the movie and turns it into truly something special with this book. There’s a multitude of extra lines of dialogue and extra moments and flashbacks, and they were integrated into the story perfectly.
While Jyn Erso was a flat character with rather awkward development in the film, she is a wonderful protagonist in this book. Whenever Freed has the chance, he will take moments to dive into Jyn Erso’s past and it really helped me understand her motivations. I also enjoyed the metaphor with the cave to explore her psyche. The movie was lacking a connection between the little girl Jyn we see at the opening of the movie and the adult Jyn we see for most of the film, but the cave in her mind really helps connect the two Jyns as well as provide an interesting way to show how she feels in all the situations she sees herself put into.
I also like how Freed handles Director Krennic, in that he pretty much just portrayed Krennic as another cog in the imperial system. And I think it works better this way because Freed didn’t have to try to make him a big bad threat and instead just fleshing him out to make him a more interesting character. It also worked well as part of the payoff for reading James Luceno’s Catalyst. Speaking of payoffs from Catalyst, Galen Erso is also pretty well done and so is the opening sequence of the book. I also like the added bits with Krennic and Galen leaving Lah’mu that shows Krennic trying to give Galen his condolences, because he knows he can’t get Galen to do the work he needs him to do by treating him terribly.
Bodhi Rook is another highlight of this novel. While he got his uplifting moments during the battle of Scariff before he was killed off, he’s such an endearing character in this novelization. I like the way that the book went into his past to show why he ended up defecting in the first place, and I like how Freed eschewed the cliché of “one big tragedy or atrocity” and instead it was just eventually off instinct. The book also does a good job making you feel for Bodhi as he risks everything to help the rebels only to be treated horribly by Saw’s rebels.
Speaking of Saw’s people, they were yet another well done aspect of the book. Not only was the relationship between Jyn and Saw Gererra fleshed out in the novel, that Bor Gullet scene was actually GOOD in this book. Not only did the scene work well in creeping me out and making me cringe in the RIGHT way (in the movie I just found the scene to be dumb), but Freed also throws in Bodhi’s inner thoughts during the ordeal to help flesh out his character, and then does a far better job than the movie in clearing up Bodhi’s transition from being a raving insane person to being a normal function person.
Chirrut and Baze are also fleshed out well, especially with Baze where the book provides insights into his past and goes inside his head to really elevate him from just being the guy with a big gun.
The efforts gone to characterize K-2SO, were fantastic, to the point where I was truly shaken after he died. His death scene is one of the most memorable and powerful moments I have found in a Star Wars novel.
The film had an exciting third act with the battle of Scarif, but the novelization elevates it from being a fun battle with lots of visual splendor to something that was truly intense with characters you deeply care about. Every death scene has a sense of poignancy to it that was often absent for me in the film. The action sequences themselves are also more intense as Freed keeps the focus tightly on the characters. In the movie, it sometimes felt like I was just waiting for the third act to happen because that was the good part of the movie. In the book, however, it was well deserved buildup from a first two thirds I was already invested in.
There’s also just many moments that were added in or fleshed out to in a magnificent way.
I love how the Death Star’s destruction of Jedha City was done here. It always confused me why they kept saying they destroyed Jedha in the movie even though they just took out the city and the planet was mostly intact otherwise. It also deemphasizes the moment in A New Hope when Alderaan is destroyed. But the book continually emphasized that it was just Jedha city and hence it made more sense. I also loved those couple POV scenes where it showed various citizens right before they died in the wake of the Death Star’s first test, particularly when Freed describes the final moments of that tiny girl that Jyn rescued in the city during the shootout between the stormtroopers and Saw’s rebels.
I also really loved how Freed wrote the scene with Jyn beating the crap out of those troopers with those truncheons. In the film that scene was a bit silly but in the book Freed makes sense of it by describing how Jyn strikes them, as well as an extra bit where a trooper hits her with the butt of a rifle. This increases the sense of pain in the scene as well.
That’s another thing I really liked about this book- there’s an increased sense of PAIN, especially when regarding Jyn Erso’s character. It makes Jyn a more relatable protagonist, and hence a more interesting one.
I also found the scene where the Rogue One team got together before going to Scarif had a nice touch, where Freed added a sense of melancholy and improvisation to it- the scene made the team truly feel like it earned the name “Rogue One” as it has this interesting feeling of the group haphazardly coming together, so it’s all the more uplifting to actually see them succeed in stealing the death star plans. Finally, I really loved the extra moments and scenes on Scarif particularly with Bodhi and Tonc that gave the soldiers and extra sense of camaraderie, making me feel even more for them when they eventually went down.
Even that scene with the hammerhead ship is made ten times more effective. Freed took a scene that, while creative, was largely there for fanservice for those that watched Star Wars Rebels and played Knights of the Old Republic, and used it to create a pretty effective scene that wonderfully fleshed out the character of Admiral Raddus.
One last thing, and it’s how the Vader massacre scene was handled. It got me giddy and excited when I last watched the movie but I really like how Freed wrote the scene from Vader’s POV, making it more interesting as well as making better sense of how he was ultimately unable to retrieve the data tape from fleeing rebels.
If I had to nitpick this book, I can give you a couple things. The first would be concerning Pau, the lizard man that went with the rebels on Scarif, as well as Bistan the space monkey. They didn’t get a spotlight and it was a touch disappointing because they were cool. I would have also liked to see the whole thing where you see C-3PO and R2-D2 on Scarif cleared up because it still feels far fetched with how they made it onto the Tantive IV afterwards.
Also, the cave metaphor with Jyn Erso could have been tied into the final moments with Jyn a little better.
But that’s it. I can’t really find anything else wrong with this book.
THE CONCLUSION: What an amazing book this turned out to be. Not only is it one of the best of the novelizations, it is also one of the best novels in the new canon. I desperately want to pick up Rebel Rising as well as the Guardians of the Whills book that came out. I liked the story that the movie told, but I LOVED the version that the book told.
THE RANKING: With a total of 9 novelizations for Star Wars films, here they are from worst to best!
9. The Force Awakens, by Alan Dean Foster
It adds a couple of interesting bits of information with Snoke and Starkiller base, but other than that it actually takes away from what made the movie great, resulting in an awful reading experience.
8. The Empire Strikes Back, by Donald F. Glut
Literally the script of the movie written in novel form. The very definition of surface level and a complete waste of time if you want to read the book for more insight on the film.
7. A New Hope, by George Lucas (Alan Dean Foster ghost wrote it though)
Another novelization that is largely the screenplay of the movie with some added words so it can be read as a novel. However, a couple extra scenes in the beginning with Luke on Tatooine elevates this one a touch above the Empire Strikes Back novelization.
6. Return of the Jedi, by James Kahn
The first half is a chore to get through as it is is pretty dull and Chewie and R2 are given painfully choppy dialogue. The second half is great as a read on it's own though if again, you didn't necessarily come to get more insight on the film. You do get some hints of a novelization though with a really funny added scene between Darth Vader and an imperial officer, and one or two extra sentences of detail with the fight between Luke and the Rancor and the battle of Endor that makes more sense out of the Ewoks beating the empire.
5. The Phantom Menace, by Terry Brooks
This one is neck and neck with Return of the Jedi. The characters of Qui-Gon Jinn and Anakin Skywalker were done a million times better, but Jar Jar comes off as even more annoying and Obi Wan is straight up unlikeable. I like how Anakin truly feels like a 9-year-old boy in this book and the book makes better sense with Qui-Gonn, especially why he would drag Jar Jar along. The extra scenes with Anakin are also pretty well done.
4. Attack of the Clones, by R.A Salvatore
The story is still a mess with little going on and the action could have been done better, but the work that was put into the characters is truly fantastic. Anakin and Padme's love story was particularly well handled, where I was suprised that they had (gasp!) chemistry even with just about every lame line from the movie being kept in.
3. The Clone Wars, by Karen Traviss
A truly awful movie that was turned into a really intense and really powerful war novel. Despite how well Traviss handled the story, the characters, and especially the action, her constant bashing of the Republic and the Jedi got incredibly irritating and prevented the book from being a true masterpiece.
2. Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, by Alexander Freed
Alexander Freed's handling of the Rogue One material was incredibly impressive. The characters were wonderfully fleshed out and the story was made twice as impactful. The Battle of Scarif was also amazingly done. In short, it made the problematic elements of the film fantastic and the stuff that was already good in the movie even better. This is not the last time I'll be reading it.
1. Revenge of the Sith, by Matthew Stover
This masterpiece still remains on top for me. The book is absolutely brilliant, from the way it tightly weaves all the elements of the movie together to the way it powerfully handles the character of Anakin Skywalker. It also does a phenomenal job with all the background players from Obi Wan to Padme, from Palpatine to Mace Windu and Yoda. I have picked up and read this book more times than I can count and I'll look forward to the many more times I'll pick it up again.