What do you think?
Rate this book
The House of Closed Doors #3
The Shadow Palace
For unwed mother Nell Lillington, 1876 Chicago—and her new wealth—offer the promise of longed-for independence. She dreams of a place in society for her daughter Sarah and contentment for her friend Tess. Yet how can she settle in a town where she’s far too likely to run into Martin Rutherford and his glittering, faithless wife, Lucetta? Can she resist her love for Martin for Sarah’s sake?
Martin was doubtless joking when he told Nell that if she got herself mixed up with a murderer for the third time, he’d disown her. But when Martin himself is arrested for murder, Nell’s dreams appear to be swallowed up in the new web of secrets she constructs to help him. Secrets that threaten to alienate Tess, Sarah, and even Martin . . .
The third book in the House of Closed Doors series will take you to a Chicago teeming with opportunistic new Americans, luxury-loving merchant princes and hard-hearted denizens of the underworld.
Martin was doubtless joking when he told Nell that if she got herself mixed up with a murderer for the third time, he’d disown her. But when Martin himself is arrested for murder, Nell’s dreams appear to be swallowed up in the new web of secrets she constructs to help him. Secrets that threaten to alienate Tess, Sarah, and even Martin . . .
The third book in the House of Closed Doors series will take you to a Chicago teeming with opportunistic new Americans, luxury-loving merchant princes and hard-hearted denizens of the underworld.
452 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 29, 2016
1168 people are currently reading
1363 people want to read
About the author
Jane Steen
11 books965 followersDear Reader,
Welcome to my page. Now, I could talk to you about myself in the third person, as if my author-self were someone else, but instead let me give you the Most Important Fact:
I was named after Jane Eyre.
I swear that this decision of my mother's influenced my entire life. I've always felt that I lead only half my existence here (here being wherever I happen to be) while the much more interesting stuff goes on in my head.
It also doomed me to spend most of that head-time in the nineteenth century, hence my books. My aim is to write entertaining fiction that hovers somewhere in the PG range (no graphic sex or nasty stuff unless the plot totally demands it) and is neither dumbed-down nor pretentiously intellectual. In short, it's the type of fiction I like to read when I just need to RELAX.
You can get to know me a lot better by subscribing to my newsletter.
The short biography is that I've lived in England, Belgium, the United States and England. The problem with moving around is that you end up torn between different countries and cultures; the advantage is that you get to speak more languages (my second language is French).
I've had an interestingly varied employment history (editor in a law firm, translating a Belgian aerospace magazine into English and real estate marketing spring to mind, but there were others), and have absorbed more education than is good for me. I'm married to a nice American, and have two adult daughters.
Welcome to my page. Now, I could talk to you about myself in the third person, as if my author-self were someone else, but instead let me give you the Most Important Fact:
I was named after Jane Eyre.
I swear that this decision of my mother's influenced my entire life. I've always felt that I lead only half my existence here (here being wherever I happen to be) while the much more interesting stuff goes on in my head.
It also doomed me to spend most of that head-time in the nineteenth century, hence my books. My aim is to write entertaining fiction that hovers somewhere in the PG range (no graphic sex or nasty stuff unless the plot totally demands it) and is neither dumbed-down nor pretentiously intellectual. In short, it's the type of fiction I like to read when I just need to RELAX.
You can get to know me a lot better by subscribing to my newsletter.
The short biography is that I've lived in England, Belgium, the United States and England. The problem with moving around is that you end up torn between different countries and cultures; the advantage is that you get to speak more languages (my second language is French).
I've had an interestingly varied employment history (editor in a law firm, translating a Belgian aerospace magazine into English and real estate marketing spring to mind, but there were others), and have absorbed more education than is good for me. I'm married to a nice American, and have two adult daughters.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 141 reviews
October 7, 2020
4.5 STARS
A perfect ending to a fantastic series. I thoroughly enjoyed this last installment. It was a little bit slower than the previous book, in my opinion, but that didn't deter from my enjoyment of it. Excellent story-telling. I hated for it all to end. I will look forward to reading more from Jane Steen.
“I hardly know where to begin,” I replied.
“But I’ll tell you one thing. I don’t just think I found a job when I came to Chicago. I think I found a lifetime’s calling.”
A perfect ending to a fantastic series. I thoroughly enjoyed this last installment. It was a little bit slower than the previous book, in my opinion, but that didn't deter from my enjoyment of it. Excellent story-telling. I hated for it all to end. I will look forward to reading more from Jane Steen.
April 4, 2017
This is the third book in a wonderful series.
Nell has moved her household to Chicago in hopes of starting a new life for everyone as a wealthy "widow". While she tries to figure out how she and Martin can be together. However just days after Nell arrives in Chicago Martin's wife is murdered and Martin is arrested for the killing. Nell decides she needs to help Martin so she goes undercover working in the store owned by his ex-wife's family. As Martin struggles to prove his innocence Nell works to create a life for herself and her family. Working under an assumed name Nell moves from selling hats for the competition to working as a seamstress at Rutherfords (Martin's store).
Nell is also stepping out into Chicago society, while hoping to keep Sarah's illegitimacy secret. One misstep can mark them all as social pariah's.
While having dinner one night Tess discovers the waiter is her brother and is able to reconnect with her long lost family, the same family who sent her to the poor farm as a child. Now Tess has to decide how much she wants her long lost relatives in her life.
Will Nell, Tess, Sarah and Martin have a happily ever after?
I received this book for free from the author/narrator/publisher in exchange for my honest review.
Nell has moved her household to Chicago in hopes of starting a new life for everyone as a wealthy "widow". While she tries to figure out how she and Martin can be together. However just days after Nell arrives in Chicago Martin's wife is murdered and Martin is arrested for the killing. Nell decides she needs to help Martin so she goes undercover working in the store owned by his ex-wife's family. As Martin struggles to prove his innocence Nell works to create a life for herself and her family. Working under an assumed name Nell moves from selling hats for the competition to working as a seamstress at Rutherfords (Martin's store).
Nell is also stepping out into Chicago society, while hoping to keep Sarah's illegitimacy secret. One misstep can mark them all as social pariah's.
While having dinner one night Tess discovers the waiter is her brother and is able to reconnect with her long lost family, the same family who sent her to the poor farm as a child. Now Tess has to decide how much she wants her long lost relatives in her life.
Will Nell, Tess, Sarah and Martin have a happily ever after?
I received this book for free from the author/narrator/publisher in exchange for my honest review.
December 26, 2019
Note: I am reviewing the audible audio version of this novel , for which there is no entry on goodreads.
August 5, 2020
In the author notes, Steen mentions that her primary goal is to entertain readers. To that end, she succeeds. It's a light mystery set in the 1870s with plenty of attention to historical details. It's a bit more of a romance than I usually care for, but there's enough else going on in this third book of the series to still provide plenty of entertainment.
Nell, the protagonist, is a bit of a twit, in my opinion. For all her protests about being an independent woman, she's constantly in need of being saved from her silly impulses or impetuous (and often harebrained) choices. For all her propriety, she seems to have no resistance to a pretty male face or flattery. She's quite the clothes horse, so anyone who enjoys detailed description of 1870s high fashion will be happy. I understand why there was so much of it, given Nell's profession, but I sometimes found myself impatient to get through the constant descriptions of fabrics/finery and back to the plot.
In all, a nice light, fast read and pleasant diversion from non-fiction and everything else going on right now.
Nell, the protagonist, is a bit of a twit, in my opinion. For all her protests about being an independent woman, she's constantly in need of being saved from her silly impulses or impetuous (and often harebrained) choices. For all her propriety, she seems to have no resistance to a pretty male face or flattery. She's quite the clothes horse, so anyone who enjoys detailed description of 1870s high fashion will be happy. I understand why there was so much of it, given Nell's profession, but I sometimes found myself impatient to get through the constant descriptions of fabrics/finery and back to the plot.
In all, a nice light, fast read and pleasant diversion from non-fiction and everything else going on right now.
March 10, 2019
Best of the three
This was by far the best of the three books in this series. I still think books one and two could have easlily been combined, but book three had all the action and drama needed to maintain a pleasant pace....and it finally, finally brought the conclusion expected since half way through book one. Satisfyingly worth the wait.
This was by far the best of the three books in this series. I still think books one and two could have easlily been combined, but book three had all the action and drama needed to maintain a pleasant pace....and it finally, finally brought the conclusion expected since half way through book one. Satisfyingly worth the wait.
October 11, 2018
Once you open the first door...
...You can't stop until all have been opened and experienced. Loved the series, and especially the inclusion of terms no longer used in modern times.
Just when one obstacle was dealt with, there often several more thrown in to keep you one edge.
Without giving any spoilers, there was one loose thread at the end in my mind- and it wasn't dangling from a spool or a garment being sewn. Don't you wonder?
...You can't stop until all have been opened and experienced. Loved the series, and especially the inclusion of terms no longer used in modern times.
Just when one obstacle was dealt with, there often several more thrown in to keep you one edge.
Without giving any spoilers, there was one loose thread at the end in my mind- and it wasn't dangling from a spool or a garment being sewn. Don't you wonder?
October 4, 2018
This was the final book in a 3 book series that I hated to actually finish reading. Not because I didn’t enjoy it but rather because I hated it to actually end! What a truly wonderful story! This author made the pages come alive for me. I walked into Nell’s world just like a friend. Read this book. You won’t be sorry.
May 25, 2021
Second read September 23, 2020 - 4 stars
My feelings were that odd mixture of liberty and heaviness that comes when a burden you shoulder cheerfully is lifted from you for a while.
In 1876, Nell moves to Chicago to start a new life with her precocious little girl, Sarah, and the sister of her heart, Tess. We have lots of adventures in this book, some delightful and some difficult, all wrapped up with a lovely happy ending.
What are you going to do while I talk to your mother about boring old figures?” he asked her.
“I’m going to write a dictionary,” said Sarah gravely, holding up my improvised book and only slightly stumbling over the long word. “With illustrations.” Her missing teeth made her lisp the last word charmingly.
I recommend this entire series to folks who love historical fiction. This series is best when you read it the books in order, starting with The House of Closed Doors.
------------------------------------------------
First read August 11, 2018 - 4 stars
My feelings were that odd mixture of liberty and heaviness that comes when a burden you shoulder cheerfully is lifted from you for a while.
In 1876, Nell moves to Chicago to start a new life with her precocious little girl, Sarah, and the sister of her heart, Tess. We have lots of adventures in this book, some delightful and some difficult, all wrapped up with a lovely happy ending.
What are you going to do while I talk to your mother about boring old figures?” he asked her.
“I’m going to write a dictionary,” said Sarah gravely, holding up my improvised book and only slightly stumbling over the long word. “With illustrations.” Her missing teeth made her lisp the last word charmingly.
I recommend this entire series to folks who love historical fiction. This series is best when you read it the books in order, starting with The House of Closed Doors.
------------------------------------------------
First read August 11, 2018 - 4 stars
March 11, 2019
More of an enjoyable read than book #2 but it had it's own frustrations.
Tess was extremely irritating, as were her family. A lot of the irritations came from the miscommunication between the two of them, but then a lot of stories use this as a tool to cause arguments and then resolve them - so a tired formula didn't really help.
Martin was also really annoying. I can't even put my finger on what made him frustrating but he was!
Nell seemed to change a lot from the fiesty independent girl from book 1 to a self centred woman in book 3....so whilst Tess did annoy me with the back and forth and accusatory statements, I could see why she felt that way.
All in I am quite glad the series came to an end here, but I would probably read an offshoot of Sarah's continued story.
Tess was extremely irritating, as were her family. A lot of the irritations came from the miscommunication between the two of them, but then a lot of stories use this as a tool to cause arguments and then resolve them - so a tired formula didn't really help.
Martin was also really annoying. I can't even put my finger on what made him frustrating but he was!
Nell seemed to change a lot from the fiesty independent girl from book 1 to a self centred woman in book 3....so whilst Tess did annoy me with the back and forth and accusatory statements, I could see why she felt that way.
All in I am quite glad the series came to an end here, but I would probably read an offshoot of Sarah's continued story.
July 4, 2017
Goodreads Giveaway Win!
I have got to be honest, I didn't read the first two books within the franchise... BUT that didn't even matter. The story still made sense, and was still an enjoyable read.
I thouroughly enjoyed this book, set in the older times too- something I loved. Each character broight their own zest to the novel, all different, but al enjoyable to read about, to get involved with them and also fall in love with them all. Especially with the main character Nell!
A must read :).
I have got to be honest, I didn't read the first two books within the franchise... BUT that didn't even matter. The story still made sense, and was still an enjoyable read.
I thouroughly enjoyed this book, set in the older times too- something I loved. Each character broight their own zest to the novel, all different, but al enjoyable to read about, to get involved with them and also fall in love with them all. Especially with the main character Nell!
A must read :).
July 5, 2023
After the first 2 books, I was curious what would happen next to Nell and Tess but must say I didn't enjoy this one as much, as there seemed way to many far-fetched and improbable things happening. I don't want to elaborate as it would mean too many spoilers... But it's all a bit too much, really. And curiously I still cannot warm up to Martin - I know he is meant to be the good guy, but somehow his character twists and turns from book to book, he seems to stay quite remote and aloof most of the time and I cannot "see" him half a clearly as Nell and Tess.
March 11, 2024
This is book 3 in the House of Closed Doors series, a set of historical novels set in post Civil War USA/Midwest. The Shadow Palace takes place in 1876-77 and is set in Chicago. Our intrepid heroine, Nell, along with daughter Sarah and best friend Tess, have left Kansas to start a new life with the help of Nell’s longtime friend, Martin. Martin is a successful businessman with a number of clothing stores across the country, but his flagship store is in Chicago. Nell has feelings for Martin, which we have suspected for a long time and which she finally acknowledged in the last book, Eternal Deception, but Martin has married while Nell lived in Kansas, dashing her hopes for a future with him. Nell has to find her place in Chicago society, because even though she is an unmarried mother (claiming to be a widow), she is also wealthy thanks to Martin’s wise investment of her inheritance after her father’s death. Of course, even though I don’t consider this series to be a “cozy mystery” series, there is a mystery to solve. Nell will not be persuaded to stay out of it and let the authorities handle things – and in the process, Nell learns a lot about herself and her love for Tess in particular. I won’t say more – I don’t want to spoil your enjoyment of the twists and turns of the story.
I’ve become quite the fan of Jane Steen’s books – the other series of hers I’ve been reading is the Scott-De Quincy Mysteries, which are set in England in Victorian times. Jane brings the time period and the locales to life – she has lived in Illinois and now lives in her native England – and she studied history so she is knowledgeable of the customs and events of those times and places. Jane is a self published author but you would never know it from the quality of the writing and editing. She has good people working with her to make these books a pleasure to read. Jane’s writing style has almost won me over to the first person voice, although thankfully she writes in past tense, not present. The reader learns about the time and place through the story and through Nell’s eyes. The female characters, especially Nell and Tess, are strong figures, smart, independent and clever, trying to work within the limits placed on women in those times. The Chicago women that Nell meets are also strong, independent characters and add a richness to the story.
Jane does a lot of research before writing her books, and she shares that research in her notes at the end of the book. Be sure to read the notes – and see how she incorporates real life events and people into her stories. I purchased this book directly from the author, allowing her to receive more of the purchase price than if I purchased through an online book store. I’ll be buying the next book in the series, The Jewel Cage, to discover the next adventures in Nell’s life. I hope you’ll give this series a try. You’ll be glad you did!
I’ve become quite the fan of Jane Steen’s books – the other series of hers I’ve been reading is the Scott-De Quincy Mysteries, which are set in England in Victorian times. Jane brings the time period and the locales to life – she has lived in Illinois and now lives in her native England – and she studied history so she is knowledgeable of the customs and events of those times and places. Jane is a self published author but you would never know it from the quality of the writing and editing. She has good people working with her to make these books a pleasure to read. Jane’s writing style has almost won me over to the first person voice, although thankfully she writes in past tense, not present. The reader learns about the time and place through the story and through Nell’s eyes. The female characters, especially Nell and Tess, are strong figures, smart, independent and clever, trying to work within the limits placed on women in those times. The Chicago women that Nell meets are also strong, independent characters and add a richness to the story.
Jane does a lot of research before writing her books, and she shares that research in her notes at the end of the book. Be sure to read the notes – and see how she incorporates real life events and people into her stories. I purchased this book directly from the author, allowing her to receive more of the purchase price than if I purchased through an online book store. I’ll be buying the next book in the series, The Jewel Cage, to discover the next adventures in Nell’s life. I hope you’ll give this series a try. You’ll be glad you did!
March 25, 2018
In this third book in The House of Closed Doors series, Nell makes her way to Chicago with Sarah and Tess in tow. Thanks to the investments Martin has made in her behalf, she is an independent woman, with finances to maintain a comfortable establishment of her own. She longs to see the palatial Rutherford's department store and enjoy the success Martin has so admirably earned, but before she has that chance, 1870s Chicago is rocked with scandal. A grisly murder has taken place among the dresses and draperies of Rutherford's, and the proprietor Martin Rutherford is the chief suspect for the crime.
Determined to find evidence to exonerate Martin, Nell goes undercover as a shop girl, but the long hours take their toll on her family relationships as little Sarah becomes even more disobedient and demanding and Tess begins to doubt the friendship that Nell has for her. Not the least concerning is Martin's own aloofness--for even if he is innocent of the crime, he still feels the weight of responsibility for it, and will that responsibility drive a wedge between him and Nell forever?
Martin's department store is every bit as grand as a palace, but like Nell and Martin's relationship, it is a palace with a shadow on it. Can that shadow ever be erased, or must the whole building be leveled so that something new and whole can be raised from the ashes?
Amidst the high stakes of a murder investigation, this novel still manages to explore the fascinating world of couture fashion as Nell continues to pursue her dressmaking ambitions in the new vistas that Chicago opens up to her. Also intriguing are the mercantile empires developed by enterprising store owners and the cutthroat competition to corner the best share of market.
One of the themes I particularly enjoyed in this novel was the connection between love and responsibility. As she enters Chicago, Nell befriends a young but naive suffragist named Elizabeth Parnell who espouses the Free Love movement. Elizabeth argues that marriage is imprisonment and that true love should be free of restriction. Nell, in a knowledge born of experience, argues that love (and sexual relations) of necessity create restrictions. True love produces responsibility, and at the end of the day, that's not a bad thing.
Nell, who has been seeking her independence from the beginning of the first book, has discovered at last that independence is not the end-all and be-all of life. The dependence that comes from relationship is not a yoke to be cast off but a responsibility to be shouldered, and she has found a man ready to shoulder it with her as an equal partner in the glittering new world of the American MidWest.
Determined to find evidence to exonerate Martin, Nell goes undercover as a shop girl, but the long hours take their toll on her family relationships as little Sarah becomes even more disobedient and demanding and Tess begins to doubt the friendship that Nell has for her. Not the least concerning is Martin's own aloofness--for even if he is innocent of the crime, he still feels the weight of responsibility for it, and will that responsibility drive a wedge between him and Nell forever?
Martin's department store is every bit as grand as a palace, but like Nell and Martin's relationship, it is a palace with a shadow on it. Can that shadow ever be erased, or must the whole building be leveled so that something new and whole can be raised from the ashes?
Amidst the high stakes of a murder investigation, this novel still manages to explore the fascinating world of couture fashion as Nell continues to pursue her dressmaking ambitions in the new vistas that Chicago opens up to her. Also intriguing are the mercantile empires developed by enterprising store owners and the cutthroat competition to corner the best share of market.
One of the themes I particularly enjoyed in this novel was the connection between love and responsibility. As she enters Chicago, Nell befriends a young but naive suffragist named Elizabeth Parnell who espouses the Free Love movement. Elizabeth argues that marriage is imprisonment and that true love should be free of restriction. Nell, in a knowledge born of experience, argues that love (and sexual relations) of necessity create restrictions. True love produces responsibility, and at the end of the day, that's not a bad thing.
Nell, who has been seeking her independence from the beginning of the first book, has discovered at last that independence is not the end-all and be-all of life. The dependence that comes from relationship is not a yoke to be cast off but a responsibility to be shouldered, and she has found a man ready to shoulder it with her as an equal partner in the glittering new world of the American MidWest.
November 25, 2018
Book 3 in the series was a wonderful conclusion to the series, The house of closed doors.
With no hesitation, I can recommend this book to all readers that love a good historical mystery with a touch of romance. Ms Steen's writing simply leaves you wanting for more from her pen.
The characters of Martin, Nell, Sarah and Tess has become mature and easily related to. They became live like in your mind.
The plotline grew from curiosity to maturity over a good time frame that invites you into the lives of Nell, her daughter and their best friend, Tess. Adding more supporting characters it is a well-crafted book that takes you back to the younger years of America and the perceptions of different classes, women and business.
The Feminist movement was alive and well in this book, with Elizabeth doing her part to bring it to the forefront of the story. It was women like her that set the wheel in motion for us, years later to enjoy the life we now live. Free Love was a topic thoroughly explored by the characters thru the hand of the author.
Add murder, an investigation with Pinksters and Nell following heart while entering a new culture and you know you will have a wonderful time.
Thanks for such a wonderful story.
With no hesitation, I can recommend this book to all readers that love a good historical mystery with a touch of romance. Ms Steen's writing simply leaves you wanting for more from her pen.
The characters of Martin, Nell, Sarah and Tess has become mature and easily related to. They became live like in your mind.
The plotline grew from curiosity to maturity over a good time frame that invites you into the lives of Nell, her daughter and their best friend, Tess. Adding more supporting characters it is a well-crafted book that takes you back to the younger years of America and the perceptions of different classes, women and business.
The Feminist movement was alive and well in this book, with Elizabeth doing her part to bring it to the forefront of the story. It was women like her that set the wheel in motion for us, years later to enjoy the life we now live. Free Love was a topic thoroughly explored by the characters thru the hand of the author.
Add murder, an investigation with Pinksters and Nell following heart while entering a new culture and you know you will have a wonderful time.
Thanks for such a wonderful story.
March 11, 2019
I really liked this book. It is more of a mystery story than the previous two books in the series. The plot, based in Chicago in the mid-1870's, is engrossing, and the depiction of the social and economic conditions is interesting. The upstairs / downstairs conditions of the affluent and their servants is fascinating, as is the lifestyle of the department store staff, who are required to live in the store's dormitory under strict rules of behavior. One affluent character is also a feminist and believes in "free love" which is interesting in this age of required conformity to societies rules. The lives of poorer, working class people is also described. And after reading two books about Nellie Lillington, I wanted to find out what happened to her, and it was worth the wait.
My interest is also piqued by the fact that my ancestors began arriving in Chicago around this time, so I want to learn more about the area's history after reading this account.
My interest is also piqued by the fact that my ancestors began arriving in Chicago around this time, so I want to learn more about the area's history after reading this account.
March 15, 2019
Historical fiction —- with a twist
This entire series was delightful. I not usually “into” this genre and the first book in the series I got for free and was hooked. I paid for the next two just to see what happened.
Watching Nell mature so much over the six years, and why she developed the way she did was fascinating. She and the other characters were well thought out and solid people... not cardboard cutouts. The writing was first person and used the vernacular of the time: I had to look up some older words or the unique use of a few. I was shown, not told... and the dress of the time was so intricate and complicated. Made me glad I didn’t have to put up it! The added mysteries and weaving in of the Chicago fire was a bonus. I do wish she had not completely dropped an important character from the first and second books. Her and her family moved and vanished...
I do recommend this series in its entirety!
This entire series was delightful. I not usually “into” this genre and the first book in the series I got for free and was hooked. I paid for the next two just to see what happened.
Watching Nell mature so much over the six years, and why she developed the way she did was fascinating. She and the other characters were well thought out and solid people... not cardboard cutouts. The writing was first person and used the vernacular of the time: I had to look up some older words or the unique use of a few. I was shown, not told... and the dress of the time was so intricate and complicated. Made me glad I didn’t have to put up it! The added mysteries and weaving in of the Chicago fire was a bonus. I do wish she had not completely dropped an important character from the first and second books. Her and her family moved and vanished...
I do recommend this series in its entirety!
October 7, 2020
Well worth reading!
I enjoyed reading each of the three books in this series. Nell had so many struggles! These stories had such a real feel about them. Each book was interesting in it's own way, but book number three was my favorite. I enjoy reading books that have history mingled throughout the chapters, so this one fit the bill. The detail about fashion in the 1700's was so true and factual! I struggled with Nell when she had problems in her teens; I struggled with her in her days at the poor farm; I continued to struggle with her in Kansas as well as after she reached Chicago! I finally got to help her celebrate some accomplishments in Chicago too.
These books were filled with very interesting and complex characters. There was lots of history, some romance, joy, tears and fashion - high fashion. I really did not want this book to end!!
I enjoyed reading each of the three books in this series. Nell had so many struggles! These stories had such a real feel about them. Each book was interesting in it's own way, but book number three was my favorite. I enjoy reading books that have history mingled throughout the chapters, so this one fit the bill. The detail about fashion in the 1700's was so true and factual! I struggled with Nell when she had problems in her teens; I struggled with her in her days at the poor farm; I continued to struggle with her in Kansas as well as after she reached Chicago! I finally got to help her celebrate some accomplishments in Chicago too.
These books were filled with very interesting and complex characters. There was lots of history, some romance, joy, tears and fashion - high fashion. I really did not want this book to end!!
October 8, 2020
The Trilogy of Nelly Lillington
I rarely write book reviews because I am not good with words. But...these 3 books starting with the House of Closed Doors and unfortunately ending with The Shadow Palace were just hauntingly beautiful. I have seen this said in book reviews many times but I really couldn't put the books down. And I was so sad for the story to end. I know you're always supposed to leave them wanting more and you certainly achieved that. I wanted to read the story of Martin and Nell's life together but I guess you have to leave something to the reader's imagination. I was so sorry to reach the end of the story but so glad I read the books. I highly recommend them to anyone no matter what genre of books you normally read. There's something for every one in these books. Keep the works coming!
I rarely write book reviews because I am not good with words. But...these 3 books starting with the House of Closed Doors and unfortunately ending with The Shadow Palace were just hauntingly beautiful. I have seen this said in book reviews many times but I really couldn't put the books down. And I was so sad for the story to end. I know you're always supposed to leave them wanting more and you certainly achieved that. I wanted to read the story of Martin and Nell's life together but I guess you have to leave something to the reader's imagination. I was so sorry to reach the end of the story but so glad I read the books. I highly recommend them to anyone no matter what genre of books you normally read. There's something for every one in these books. Keep the works coming!
February 2, 2021
I am completely engrossed in Nell’s love and adventure
This third book of the telling of Nell’s life is a walk through the world of dreams familiar in the secret desires of nearly every woman. Independence , recognized talents, family bonds, and excitement - satisfaction in the face of distress and unexpected disasters are woven neatly in this believable adventure set in the solid historical backdrop of a new Chicago rising from the ashes of the Great Fire with all its political, moral and avaricious flaws. Historical validity is not cheated but never takes front and center, instead laying the substantial foundation of the overarching changes in America’s implosion and evolving character. A gifted writer, Jane Steen offers a delightful escape into the reality of her character’s lives. On to book four!
This third book of the telling of Nell’s life is a walk through the world of dreams familiar in the secret desires of nearly every woman. Independence , recognized talents, family bonds, and excitement - satisfaction in the face of distress and unexpected disasters are woven neatly in this believable adventure set in the solid historical backdrop of a new Chicago rising from the ashes of the Great Fire with all its political, moral and avaricious flaws. Historical validity is not cheated but never takes front and center, instead laying the substantial foundation of the overarching changes in America’s implosion and evolving character. A gifted writer, Jane Steen offers a delightful escape into the reality of her character’s lives. On to book four!
November 1, 2022
Great
I'm really enjoying Nells story. Man, Nell has been through it! She leaves the seminary to join her friend Martin in Chicago where he has been kind enough to recieve and invest all of her money over the past 5 years. This in turn, has made Nell and her companion Tess very wealthy women. Unfortunately Martin's notoriously unfaithful wife is found murdered and Martin is their only suspect. Nell has known him since childhood and knows without question, that he is innocent and defies everyone ( including Martin) and sets out on a spy mission to find the correct murderer. These stories about Nells life, in a time when women were underestimated, ignored and dismissed and were meant to simply be arm candy for their husband's is both fascinating and disturbing. Thank Goodness we've come as far as we have!
I'm really enjoying Nells story. Man, Nell has been through it! She leaves the seminary to join her friend Martin in Chicago where he has been kind enough to recieve and invest all of her money over the past 5 years. This in turn, has made Nell and her companion Tess very wealthy women. Unfortunately Martin's notoriously unfaithful wife is found murdered and Martin is their only suspect. Nell has known him since childhood and knows without question, that he is innocent and defies everyone ( including Martin) and sets out on a spy mission to find the correct murderer. These stories about Nells life, in a time when women were underestimated, ignored and dismissed and were meant to simply be arm candy for their husband's is both fascinating and disturbing. Thank Goodness we've come as far as we have!
November 11, 2023
An Excellent Story!
I wasn't too sure of what the author was trying to do, when I started her first book in this series, the House of Closed Doors- the main character, Nell Lillington, seemed different, somehow, than most heroines of this genre. But Jane Stern steadily grew in my esteem as Nell grew up and into a fascinating character!
The second book was amazing as well, but this, The Shadow Palace was completely enthralling! I highly recommend it if you are looking for authenticity, entertainment and wonderful characters set in a background of the bustling, vibrant city of late 1800s Chicago!
Now I'm about to dive into the last book, The Jewel Cage... and I can't wait to see what's next for Nell, Sarah, Tess and Martin - not to mention Elizabeth and David,and the subtly foreshadowed Alex Gamborelli. Hurry and catch up with me....
I wasn't too sure of what the author was trying to do, when I started her first book in this series, the House of Closed Doors- the main character, Nell Lillington, seemed different, somehow, than most heroines of this genre. But Jane Stern steadily grew in my esteem as Nell grew up and into a fascinating character!
The second book was amazing as well, but this, The Shadow Palace was completely enthralling! I highly recommend it if you are looking for authenticity, entertainment and wonderful characters set in a background of the bustling, vibrant city of late 1800s Chicago!
Now I'm about to dive into the last book, The Jewel Cage... and I can't wait to see what's next for Nell, Sarah, Tess and Martin - not to mention Elizabeth and David,and the subtly foreshadowed Alex Gamborelli. Hurry and catch up with me....
May 10, 2020
Enjoyable series
This last book of the series is, in every way, as good as the first two books.
The ongoing saga of the young woman who strives to raise a child born out of wedlock in 1870's Midwest takes them to Chicago here. A shocking event transpires to further complicate things.
The entire series is well done with a wealth of interesting characters. My favorite is Tess, born with Down's Syndrome and proving her consistent ability to overcome the obstacles of society.
There are often tongue -in-cheek moments where I found myself laughing aloud. I have read this entire series in five days. Very well written.
I would definitely recommend to readers of historical fiction and romance.
This last book of the series is, in every way, as good as the first two books.
The ongoing saga of the young woman who strives to raise a child born out of wedlock in 1870's Midwest takes them to Chicago here. A shocking event transpires to further complicate things.
The entire series is well done with a wealth of interesting characters. My favorite is Tess, born with Down's Syndrome and proving her consistent ability to overcome the obstacles of society.
There are often tongue -in-cheek moments where I found myself laughing aloud. I have read this entire series in five days. Very well written.
I would definitely recommend to readers of historical fiction and romance.
March 8, 2017
The Shadow Palace
: Jane Steen
The 3rd book in the trilogy, I listened to the first book, but somehow missed book 2. This being said the story jumped ahead to Chicago with Nell trying to make a life for herself and her daughter and dear friend. There is a murder, suspense, and romance on the journey with plenty of twists and turns. I need to go back and listen to book 2.
The narration was well done.The characters were well portrayed. Elizabeth Klett gives a wonderful performance.
"I was voluntarily provided this review copy audiobook at no charge by the author, publisher and/or narrator."
March 7, 2022
More Please
I do adore this author! She's an excellent writer with imagination. I have been reading the Nell books eagerly...no, gobbling them , enjoying Neil's and Tess's and Sarah's adventures. But I do have two niggling criticisms. One being the overly mature way the five-year -old speaks. College level, annoying and distracting. Being a mother , grandmother and great grandmother, I'm familiar with children's speech patterns. The second is Martin's long absences and the rather lame excuses for them. And I won't go into the nonsensical reason for it. For me, he's the least interesting of the characters. But I overlook these in my enjoyment of the stories.
I do adore this author! She's an excellent writer with imagination. I have been reading the Nell books eagerly...no, gobbling them , enjoying Neil's and Tess's and Sarah's adventures. But I do have two niggling criticisms. One being the overly mature way the five-year -old speaks. College level, annoying and distracting. Being a mother , grandmother and great grandmother, I'm familiar with children's speech patterns. The second is Martin's long absences and the rather lame excuses for them. And I won't go into the nonsensical reason for it. For me, he's the least interesting of the characters. But I overlook these in my enjoyment of the stories.
September 15, 2023
The saga of Nell, Sarah, Tess and Martin continues! This installment takes to Chicago and Nell's introduction to Chicago society, Rutherford's & Co and sees her taking her place in the fashion world. Martin is accused of murdering his wife, Nell defends him and aids in uncovering Lucetta's murderer. Again, a fire in Chicago causes trauma and Rutherford's is destroyed. Will this fire strengthen or mean the end of Rutherford's? Will this fire strengthen or cause strife for Nell? Obstacles abound as the reader hopes for a happily ever after.
This series is enthralling and keeps you turning to the next page to see what comes next.
This series is enthralling and keeps you turning to the next page to see what comes next.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 12, 2025
Great Series Continuation
Nell Lillington has left the prairie life of Kansas for the new and exciting city of Chicago and, she hopes, to reconnect with her best male friend and possibly soul mate, Martin Rutherford. With her are her best female friend and companion, Tess O'Dugan, and her 5 year old daughter, Sarah. A few days after her arrival, Nell is shocked to learn that Martin has been arrested for the murder of his wife. Even though he no longer loved her and she was unfaithful, Nell is certain that Martin would never have killed her. However, what can be done to prove his innocence?
Nell Lillington has left the prairie life of Kansas for the new and exciting city of Chicago and, she hopes, to reconnect with her best male friend and possibly soul mate, Martin Rutherford. With her are her best female friend and companion, Tess O'Dugan, and her 5 year old daughter, Sarah. A few days after her arrival, Nell is shocked to learn that Martin has been arrested for the murder of his wife. Even though he no longer loved her and she was unfaithful, Nell is certain that Martin would never have killed her. However, what can be done to prove his innocence?
August 26, 2018
A wonderful trillogy.......
I have waited until I had finished all three books. It's rather hard to
Think the first two as stand alone novels,as they leave you hanging. Completing the third does fully satisfy and complete the story.. The story was very enjoyable,believable and never boring.
Jane brought the people and places to life for me. Jane captured all the suspense perfectly and I found myself drawn it time after
Time.. I thank her for writing so well.I recommend this "House Of Closed Doors" ,I've found a new to me author to read.
I have waited until I had finished all three books. It's rather hard to
Think the first two as stand alone novels,as they leave you hanging. Completing the third does fully satisfy and complete the story.. The story was very enjoyable,believable and never boring.
Jane brought the people and places to life for me. Jane captured all the suspense perfectly and I found myself drawn it time after
Time.. I thank her for writing so well.I recommend this "House Of Closed Doors" ,I've found a new to me author to read.
November 30, 2018
I loved this series so much. After the first book I was so excited to see it was a trilogy because I was NOT ready to part with the characters yet! Jane Steen's writing style is beautiful and it flows so nicely that you dont want to stop. She challenges my vocabulary and I'm grateful for kindles dictionary! This time period is also one that I know very little about; so learning the dynamics between men and women, clothing, business, and religion of the time was extremely enlightening. I found a lot of myself in Nell which probably made it that much more interesting to me. Highly recommended!!
June 18, 2017
The plot was a bit far fetched and the ending contrived yet not as happy as I desired after 3 books! It was too much drama and then not enough of our favorite characters together.
I did enjoy the references to the historical period, things were getting interesting! My Grandmother was a Women's Christian Temperance Union member. Women were fed up but I'm confused and amazed that women chose to ask for the vote AND for prohibition of alcohol. How did they ever find support?
I did enjoy the references to the historical period, things were getting interesting! My Grandmother was a Women's Christian Temperance Union member. Women were fed up but I'm confused and amazed that women chose to ask for the vote AND for prohibition of alcohol. How did they ever find support?
April 7, 2018
I have truly enjoyed the box set of this series and look forward to reading more about Nell’s story. I was sent the box set by the publisher and NetGalley and I probably wouldn’t have read the series if it weren’t for that fact. As I’ve mentioned, I’m not a fan of historical fiction. However, Steen does an amazing job of incorporating mystery and suspense into the genre. I also love how independent the female characters are. I look forward to reading Steen’s newest release soon as well!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 141 reviews